Giant Structure in Deep Space Challenges Our Understanding of The Universe
A colossal structure in the distant Universe is defying our understanding of how the Universe evolved.
In light that has traveled for 6.9 billion years to reach us, astronomers have found a giant, almost perfect ring of galaxies, some 1.3 billion light-years in diameter. It doesn't match any known structure or formation mechanism.
The Big Ring, as the structure has been named, could mean that we need to amend the standard model of cosmology.
The discovery, led by astronomer Alexia Lopez of the University of Central Lancashire, was presented at the 243rd meeting of the American Astronomical Society in 2024, and has been published in the Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics.
It's the second giant structure discovered by Lopez and her colleagues. The first, called the Giant Arc, is actually in the same part of the sky, at the same distance away. When the arc's discovery was announced in 2021, it puzzled astronomers. The Big Ring only deepens the mystery.
"Neither of these two ultra-large structures is easy to explain in our current understanding of the universe," Lopez said in January 2024.
"And their ultra-large sizes, distinctive shapes, and cosmological proximity must surely be telling us something important – but what exactly?"
The most immediate link seems to be with something called a Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO). These are giant, circular arrangements of galaxies found all throughout space. They're actually spheres, the fossils of acoustic waves that propagated through the early Universe, and then froze when space became so diffuse acoustic waves could no longer travel.
The Big Ring is not a BAO. BAOs are all a fixed size of around 1 billion light-years in diameter. And thorough inspection of the Big Ring shows that it is more like a corkscrew shape that is aligned in such a way that it looks like a ring.
Which leaves the very unanswered question: What the heck is it? And what does it mean for the Cosmological Principle, which states that, in all directions, any given patch of space should look pretty much the same as all other patches of space?
"We expect matter to be evenly distributed everywhere in space when we view the universe on a large scale, so there should be no noticeable irregularities above a certain size," Lopez explained.
"Cosmologists calculate the current theoretical size limit of structures to be 1.2 billion light-years, yet both of these structures are much larger – the Giant Arc is almost three times bigger and the Big Ring's circumference is comparable to the Giant Arc's length."
But the size is just one of the problems. The other is what it means for cosmology, the study of the evolution of the Universe. The current model is the one that currently fits the best with what we observe, but there are some features that are challenging to explain under its framework.
There are other models that have been put forward to address these features. Under one such model, Roger Penrose's conformal cyclic cosmology, in which the Universe goes through endless Big Bang expansion cycles, ring structures are expected – although it's worth noting that conformal cyclic cosmology has significant problems of its own.
Another possibility is that the structures are a type of topological defect in the fabric of space-time known as cosmic strings. These are thought to be like proton-wide wrinkles that emerged in the early Universe as space-time stretched, then froze into place.
We've not found much physical evidence of cosmic strings, but the theoretical evidence is pretty promising.
At the moment, nobody knows for sure what the Big Ring and the Giant Arc signify. They could just be chance arrangements of galaxies twirling across the sky, although the likelihood of that seems pretty small.
The best hope would be to find more such arrangements of galaxies, scattered throughout the Universe, hiding in plain sight.
"From current cosmological theories we didn't think structures on this scale were possible," Lopez said.
"We could expect maybe one exceedingly large structure in all our observable Universe. Yet, the Big Ring and the Giant Arc are two huge structures and are even cosmological neighbors, which is extraordinarily fascinating."
The findings are reported in the Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics.
An earlier version of this article was published in January 2024.
Magnetar 'Starquakes' Could Forge Gold in Space, Scientists Discover
Depictions of Milky Way's River of Stars Found in Ancient Egyptian Art
Dawn's Second Look Reveals Vesta Could Be Part of a Lost World
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
a day ago
- New York Times
Vera Rubin's Legacy Lives On in a Troubled Scientific Landscape
In January, the American Astronomical Society hosted a panel to discuss how the Vera C. Rubin Observatory would transform scientific studies of dark matter, dark energy and the faintest corners of the cosmos. All six panelists, each holding a leadership role related to the observatory, were women. The message, intentional or not, was clear: The legacy of the astronomer Vera C. Rubin, for whom the observatory was named, was not just the way her work revolutionized scientists' understanding of the universe. It was also the way Dr. Rubin charted a path for women and other historically underrepresented groups in science to do the same. 'The universe is universal,' Sandrine Thomas, the deputy director of construction at the observatory, said at the panel. The telescope is now poised to begin the widest, deepest scan of the southern sky in an altered political climate, one in which American science is facing sharp cuts to funding, research project cancellations and rollbacks of programs related to diversity, equity and inclusion, or D.E.I. Astronomers worry about what that means for the future of the observatory, which is funded by the U.S. Department of Energy and the National Science Foundation and was renamed in 2019 near the end of the first Trump administration for Dr. Rubin. 'She was the ultimate role model for women in astronomy in the generation after her,' said Jacqueline Mitton, an astronomer based in England and an author of a biography of Dr. Rubin. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
'Elio': Toronto Oscar winner Domee Shi explains why title character has an eye patch
Oscar winner Domee Shi drew inspiration from her own mother for her 2018 animated short film Bao, crafted a love letter to Toronto with one of the best fictional boy bands with Turning Red in 2022, and now takes on sci-fi with the movie Elio (currently in theatres). For Shi, it was exciting to get to play with the genre as one of the film's directors. "This was my first time directing a sci-fi movie, but I've always loved sci-fi as a genre. Some of my favourite movies are sci-fi movies, like Alien, Gravity," Shi told Yahoo Canada in Toronto. "It was so great to be able to pay homage to all of my favourite movies." "I love that in our movie we can use space as a symbol of aspiration, of wish fulfillment, instead of a scary space or a threatening space. It's a space that welcomes and accepts our main character." Unlike what we see in most movies, the main character Elio Solis (voiced by Yonas Kibreab) wants to be abducted by aliens. As an orphaned child, he lives with his aunt Olga (voiced by Zoe Saldaña), who works in the military as a major in the U.S. Air Force tasked with scanning for space debris. Olga had dreams of pursing the astronaut space program, but those plans had to be put aside when she became Elio's legal guardian. Elio is an 11-year-old boy who just doesn't feel like he belongs, which makes him long for a life in space with the aliens. As we see early on in the movie, as Elio tries to craft a device to communicate with aliens, things don't go as planned and he ends up injuring his eye, requiring him to wear and eye patch until he's healed. The eye patch was something that was quickly embraced by many, even when we didn't know exactly why he was wearing one. "I love that people have embraced Eliot's eye patch," Shi said. "The original idea came from the original director, Adrian Molina, just this idea that a characteristic that Elio could be othered for is something that he can be celebrated for, that could make him look actually really cool once he's in space." "Once he is in space and he has the eye patch and the cape, he looks like ... a cool space pirate, but it's so amazing that kids and audiences have embraced that eye patch." Elio's attempt at alien abduction pays off when he's beamed up to the Communiverse, an organization with representatives from each galaxy, like a sci-fi version of the United Nations, but it's all a misunderstanding. The aliens think that Elio is the leader of Earth. But he doesn't want to go home just yet, so Elio goes along with it and does not tell them he's actually just a kid who loves space. It's in the Communiverse that Elio leans into what Pixar does best, creating really interesting animated characters, some that are more visually frightening and some that are the most adorable little bundles of joy you've ever seen. "One of the things I loved about directing a sci-fi movie ... is that you can take these familiar tropes ... and kind of turn them on their head and twist them in a surprising way," Shi said. "So introducing a really scary looking toothy worm with no eyes, you're like, oh my gosh ... is Elio going to be eaten? And then twisting it and being like, oh no, it's actually a really cute kid. It's actually this lonely, weird, cute boy who could be Elio's first friend." At the heart of Elio is a story of loneliness, a universal theme set to resonate with many who see the movie. "Me and [co-director Madeline Sharafian], when we started on this project, ... it was our idea to kind of make Elio obsessed with getting abducted by aliens, obsessed with going into space and living with aliens, but we had to understand why," Shi explained. "We had to understand the emotion driving that and we realized it had to be loneliness." "When Elio gets abducted, when that beam hits him and he's whooping for joy, audiences have to be whooping with him. ... We had to introduce him in a way that made audiences really empathize and understand why he doesn't feel like he belongs on Earth. And that means introducing him as this recently orphaned kid who's thrust upon his aunt who's still struggling with trying to figure out how to balance her career and being a new mom. It's a fine balance too. We don't want to start the movie off in too much of a sad way." And what's impressive about Elio is that it's able to present its message in a way that can speak to both children and adults. Even Shi admitted that it's a difficult element to achieve. "It is really hard. It's hard work, but that's kind of the bar that we set for ourselves at Pixar, is to tell these stories that are for kids and for adults," Shi said. "Even when really wacky, goofy, cartoony aliens are on screen and it is a fun, wacky adventure, there is an emotional through line." "We're really honest with each other. At Pixar, we show our work to each other all the time. These movies take four to five years to make because we're constantly putting up the movie multiple times. We have screenings. We invite members of the crew, members of the studio to watch it, to send in notes. People are very honest, because everyone cares so much about what they do at Pixar and wanting to make stories that resonate with people."
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
'Elio': Toronto Oscar winner Domee Shi explains why title character has an eye patch
Oscar winner Domee Shi drew inspiration from her own mother for her 2018 animated short film Bao, crafted a love letter to Toronto with one of the best fictional boy bands with Turning Red in 2022, and now takes on sci-fi with the movie Elio (currently in theatres). For Shi, it was exciting to get to play with the genre as one of the film's directors. "This was my first time directing a sci-fi movie, but I've always loved sci-fi as a genre. Some of my favourite movies are sci-fi movies, like Alien, Gravity," Shi told Yahoo Canada in Toronto. "It was so great to be able to pay homage to all of my favourite movies." "I love that in our movie we can use space as a symbol of aspiration, of wish fulfillment, instead of a scary space or a threatening space. It's a space that welcomes and accepts our main character." Unlike what we see in most movies, the main character Elio Solis (voiced by Yonas Kibreab) wants to be abducted by aliens. As an orphaned child, he lives with his aunt Olga (voiced by Zoe Saldaña), who works in the military as a major in the U.S. Air Force tasked with scanning for space debris. Olga had dreams of pursing the astronaut space program, but those plans had to be put aside when she became Elio's legal guardian. Elio is an 11-year-old boy who just doesn't feel like he belongs, which makes him long for a life in space with the aliens. As we see early on in the movie, as Elio tries to craft a device to communicate with aliens, things don't go as planned and he ends up injuring his eye, requiring him to wear and eye patch until he's healed. The eye patch was something that was quickly embraced by many, even when we didn't know exactly why he was wearing one. "I love that people have embraced Eliot's eye patch," Shi said. "The original idea came from the original director, Adrian Molina, just this idea that a characteristic that Elio could be othered for is something that he can be celebrated for, that could make him look actually really cool once he's in space." "Once he is in space and he has the eye patch and the cape, he looks like ... a cool space pirate, but it's so amazing that kids and audiences have embraced that eye patch." Elio's attempt at alien abduction pays off when he's beamed up to the Communiverse, an organization with representatives from each galaxy, like a sci-fi version of the United Nations, but it's all a misunderstanding. The aliens think that Elio is the leader of Earth. But he doesn't want to go home just yet, so Elio goes along with it and does not tell them he's actually just a kid who loves space. It's in the Communiverse that Elio leans into what Pixar does best, creating really interesting animated characters, some that are more visually frightening and some that are the most adorable little bundles of joy you've ever seen. "One of the things I loved about directing a sci-fi movie ... is that you can take these familiar tropes ... and kind of turn them on their head and twist them in a surprising way," Shi said. "So introducing a really scary looking toothy worm with no eyes, you're like, oh my gosh ... is Elio going to be eaten? And then twisting it and being like, oh no, it's actually a really cute kid. It's actually this lonely, weird, cute boy who could be Elio's first friend." At the heart of Elio is a story of loneliness, a universal theme set to resonate with many who see the movie. "Me and [co-director Madeline Sharafian], when we started on this project, ... it was our idea to kind of make Elio obsessed with getting abducted by aliens, obsessed with going into space and living with aliens, but we had to understand why," Shi explained. "We had to understand the emotion driving that and we realized it had to be loneliness." "When Elio gets abducted, when that beam hits him and he's whooping for joy, audiences have to be whooping with him. ... We had to introduce him in a way that made audiences really empathize and understand why he doesn't feel like he belongs on Earth. And that means introducing him as this recently orphaned kid who's thrust upon his aunt who's still struggling with trying to figure out how to balance her career and being a new mom. It's a fine balance too. We don't want to start the movie off in too much of a sad way." And what's impressive about Elio is that it's able to present its message in a way that can speak to both children and adults. Even Shi admitted that it's a difficult element to achieve. "It is really hard. It's hard work, but that's kind of the bar that we set for ourselves at Pixar, is to tell these stories that are for kids and for adults," Shi said. "Even when really wacky, goofy, cartoony aliens are on screen and it is a fun, wacky adventure, there is an emotional through line." "We're really honest with each other. At Pixar, we show our work to each other all the time. These movies take four to five years to make because we're constantly putting up the movie multiple times. We have screenings. We invite members of the crew, members of the studio to watch it, to send in notes. People are very honest, because everyone cares so much about what they do at Pixar and wanting to make stories that resonate with people."
