Human Rights Commissioner Says The Cost Of Limiting Gender Rights Under Legislation will be people's lives

Press Release – Human Rights Commission
International Day Against Homophobia, Biphobia, Intersexism & Transphobia (IDAHOBIT) on May 17 is a global day to raise awareness and advocate for the rights of LGBTQIA+people. This year's theme is The power of communities.
A sense of belonging and being part of a community are vital for each of us. Community is where we find support, understanding, and a sense of home.
International Day Against Homophobia, Biphobia, Intersexism & Transphobia (IDAHOBIT) on May 17 is a global day to raise awareness and advocate for the rights of LGBTQIA+people. This year's theme is 'The power of communities'.
'It is a reminder of the importance of connection and collective action when human rights are threatened. Rainbow people are part of every community and like everyone, often identify with more than one,' says Disability Rights Commissioner and Rainbow Rights spokesperson, Prudence Walker.
'Community support and advocacy can help create safe and accepting environments for everyone to live authentically, to be ourselves.'
However, recent developments in Aotearoa and overseas raise concerns about increasing discrimination against some groups.
'Attacks on the rights of trans, non-binary, and intersex people internationally are having ripple effects here in Aotearoa. I don't believe that is who we are as a country. We have data that shows the overwhelming majority of New Zealanders believe that trans people should be protected from discrimination,' says Walker.
'The laws of other countries are not our laws. Those are not our values.' Trans and non-binary people in Aotearoa already experience disproportionately high levels of psychological distress due to discrimination, barriers to healthcare and threats to their safety. Legislation that threatens to limit rights about gender identity can compound this further, and will likely impact cis women, intersex people and children too. There will be particular impacts for Māori, Pasifika and other Indigenous peoples who have always had diverse expressions of gender and sexuality. Te Tiriti o Waitangi affirms the right of tangata whenua to uphold tino rangatiratanga over their sexuality, gender, gender expressions, and sex characteristics.
Equal Employment Opportunities Commissioner and Women's Rights spokesperson, Professor Gail Pacheco, says inclusion of trans women in the definition of 'woman' is not only protected under international human rights standards, but it's crucial for wellbeing.
'All people deserve to have a sense of belonging. The Commission acknowledges and celebrates the diversity of women in Aotearoa and the value and strength that diversity brings to our communities,' says Pacheco.
The date of May 17 marks the anniversary of the World Health Organization's decision in 1990 to declassify homosexuality as a mental illness. 'While we've come so far together since those dark days, even now many people still live in fear of existing as their authentic selves,' says Walker. 'We cannot go back to a time when discrimination against Rainbow people was normalised in legislation and in public attitudes. The cost is people's lives and it's unacceptable.'
'Trans, non-binary, and intersex people are taonga and have existed forever. They will continue to do so with the same rights as others, including to be free from discrimination, violence and abuse,' she adds. 'Communities can use their power to support everyone's sense of identity and belonging, and to speak out against harmful legislation. We owe it to ourselves and to future generations to create a society that values inclusivity, equality, human rights, and lives of dignity for all.'
Notes:
• The Commission published a guide to 'Trans Rights and Human Rights' last year to help transgender people access this information
• More data about trans and non-binary people's experiences can be found in the
Counting Ourselves Health Survey.
• The United Nations treaty body, the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) has made it clear that 'women', as that term is used in CEDAW, includes trans women, and accordingly, all the rights and protections in CEDAW extend to trans women.
• While Te Kāhui Tika Tangata Human Rights Commission can't make findings or decide if the law has been breached, it can help by providing information and support and in some cases can offer a dispute resolution process for complaints.
If someone has experienced unlawful discrimination, they can make a complaint via our website or by contacting us on 0800 496 877 or infoline@tikatangata.org.nz

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Scoop

5 days ago

• Scoop

Israeli Actions In Palestinian Territories Constitute War Crimes, Human Rights Council Hears

17 June 2025 'The goal of the Israeli government is abundantly clear: the destruction of life in Gaza.' That's how Navi Pillay, Chair of the Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, opened her statement to the 59th session of the Council on Tuesday. Calling the war in Gaza 'the most ruthless, prolonged and widespread attack against the Palestinian people since 1948,' Ms. Pillay addressed the findings of the Commission's report, released to the HRC on 6 May. Attacks on educational facilities in Gaza It found that 90 per cent of Gaza's schools and universities have been damaged or destroyed by Israeli attacks – including airstrikes, shelling, burning and controlled demolitions. 'With the loss of education, Palestinians are also losing their source of stability, hope and possibility of a future,' said Ms. Pillay. By not issuing adequate warnings to civilians sheltering inside, these attacks caused extensive casualties, amounting to war crimes, including knowingly launching attacks that caused excessive and disproportionate civilian harm, and the crime against humanity of extermination. The Commission found no military necessity to justify the destruction of schools, concluding that the intent was to restrict long-term Palestinian access to education. Notably, while Israeli forces often claimed they were targeting Hamas operatives allegedly based in schools, the Commission verified only one instance of Hamas using a school for military purposes, compared to the systematic Israeli use of schools as military bases. Education restrictions in the West Bank Ms. Pillay also warned that education in the West Bank remains under threat. Demolition orders, military raids, restrictions, and operations have significantly reduced school days, while settler violence has endangered students and teachers. The Israeli government has either incited or failed to prevent such violence, she said. Attacks on religious and cultural sites In Gaza, Israeli forces have damaged 53 per cent of religious and cultural sites. Many were being used for refuge or worship, causing further civilian casualties, constituting war crimes and, in some cases, the crime against humanity of extermination. This completely avoidable damage 'has a cascading effect and deeply affects intangible cultural elements, such as religious and cultural practices, memories and history, undermining the identity of Palestinians as a people,' said Ms. Pillay. Because Israeli forces should have known where these sites were and planned their assaults accordingly, the Commission found these acts constituted war crimes including intentionally targeting historic and religious sites and widespread destruction without military necessity. Seizure of cultural heritage sites in the West Bank In the West Bank and East Jerusalem, the Commission documented repeated cases of Israeli authorities or settlers seizing cultural heritage sites, displacing Palestinians, excluding non-Jewish history and restricting Palestinian access. The report highlights increasing restrictions and assaults on Palestinians at Haram al-Sharif/Temple Mount, a long-standing flashpoint in East Jerusalem. Ms. Pillay argued that through these actions, 'Israel has been using cultural heritage and settlements as leverage for its unlawful territorial claims in the occupied West Bank, in flagrant defiance of multiple United Nations resolutions and the 2024 advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice (ICJ).' These actions violate international law, including the right to cultural life, freedom of religion, and protection of cultural heritage. Recommendations Ms. Pillay concluded her speech by underscoring that Israel's attacks on education, infrastructure and heritage sites aim to 'erode Palestinians' historical ties to the land and weaken their collective identity, thereby hindering their right to self-determination' and the possibility of a peaceful, sustainable two-State solution. Accordingly, the Commission calls for Israel to end the unlawful occupation and enable Palestinian self-determination; stop attacks and seizures of educational, religious and cultural sites; end the systematic erasure of Palestinian history; and comply fully with international law, including the 2024 ICJ ruling. Sudan's war intensifies amid starvation, rights probe warns Meanwhile in Sudan, heavy fighting continues to escalate as a 'direct result' of the continued flow of arms into the country meaning that the war is far from over, top independent human rights investigators said on Tuesday, ahead of briefing the Human Rights Council. In an update on the emergency in the northeast African nation, the Independent International Fact-Finding Mission for the Sudan highlighted the increased use of heavy weaponry in populated areas - and a sharp rise in sexual violence. 'Many Sudanese are dying from hunger and especially those who have been detained and in detention - they are dying and millions affected,' said Joy Ngozi Ezeilo, Expert Member of the Fact-Finding Mission. 'In terms of international responsibility, we urge all States to respect and enforce the arms embargo of the United Nations Security Council Resolution 1556,' she added. Humanitarian relief continues to be weaponized and hospitals and medical facilities remain under siege, warned the investigators, whose mandate was established by the Council in October 2023. Direct link ' There is a direct link between the flow of arms in Sudan, armed hostilities and the resulting violence amounting to violations of international humanitarian law and human rights violations,' said Mohamed Chande Othman, Chair of the Fact-Finding Mission. ' We know the kind of arms that are being used: heavy artillery, modern warfare, drones and in fact, they have escalated.' Fellow investigator Mona Rishmawi insisted that testimonies gathered pointed to 'both sides' continuing to commit war crimes – a reference to the Sudanese Armed Forces (SAF) and the Rapid Support Forces (RSF) which turned on each other in April 2023, following a breakdown in transition to civilian rule. Around El Fasher, for instance, civilians have been 'assaulted, detained and killed while villages have been attacked, burned and looted' by the RSF. During one RSF attack from 10 to 13 April, more than 100 civilians were reportedly killed, while a SAF bombing in Al Koma killed at least 15 civilians. Now into its third year, the war has killed tens of thousands of civilians so far, displacing over 13 million Sudanese and subjecting many more to sexual violence, looting and the destruction of homes, health facilities, markets and other infrastructure. Crimes against humanity continue, 'particularly in the context of persecution of certain ethnic groups', Ms. Rishmawi insisted. The result of restrictions to aid relief has been to drive famine, 'especially in Darfur', said the investigators, who are respected human rights experts and not UN staff. In their latest update to the Human Rights Council, the investigators documented a sharp rise in sexual and gender-based violence, with women and girls subjected to rape, gang rape, abduction, sexual slavery and forced marriage, mostly in RSF-controlled displacement camps. About UN experts The members of both the Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory and the Fact-Finding Mission for the Sudan receive their mandates from the UN Human Rights Council. They are not UN staff and do not receive payment for their work.

Scoop

13-06-2025

• Scoop

Israeli Attacks On Gaza Schools Could Be Crimes Against Humanity: UN Probe

10 June 2025 The UN Human Rights Council-mandated Independent International Commission of Inquiry (COI) report found that Israeli forces have used airstrikes, shelling, burning, and controlled demolitions to damage or destroy more than 90 per cent of schools and university buildings across Gaza. This destruction in the wake of the 7 October 2023 Hamas-led terror attacks on Israel has made education impossible for over 658,000 children, many of whom have been out of school for nearly two years. 'We are seeing more and more indications that Israel is carrying out a concerted campaign to obliterate Palestinian life in Gaza,' said Navi Pillay, Chair of the Commission. 'Israel's targeting of the educational, cultural and religious life of the Palestinian people will harm the present generations and generations to come, hindering their right to self-determination.' Classroom-turned military base The COI documented cases where Israeli forces seized and used educational institutions as military bases, including the conversion of part of Al-Azhar University's Al-Mughraqa campus into a synagogue for troops. The report also noted one instance where Hamas militants used a school for military purposes. Such conduct is a breach of international humanitarian law, which mandates the distinction between civilian objects and military targets. Targeting of religious sites More than half of Gaza's religious and cultural sites have been damaged or destroyed, including places serving as refuges for civilians – killing hundreds, including women and children. The Commission stated that Israeli forces knew or should have known the cultural significance of these sites and failed to prevent harm. In the occupied West Bank, including East Jerusalem, Israeli authorities appropriated, developed and profited from cultural heritage sites representing Palestinian, Jewish and other cultures, while displacing Palestinian residents. They have also blocked or severely restricted Palestinians from accessing the sites. 'Attacks on cultural and religious sites have deeply impacted intangible culture, such as religious and cultural practices, memories and history,' said Ms. Pillay. 'The targeting and destruction of heritage sites, the limiting of access to those sites in the West Bank and the erasure of their heterogenic history erode Palestinians' historical ties to the land and weaken their collective identity.' Recommendations The Commission called on Israel to immediately cease attacks on cultural, religious, and educational institutions and to end the seizure and military use of such facilities. It urged Israel to end its occupation and settlement activities, especially near religious and cultural sites, and to comply fully with International Court of Justice (ICJ) orders. Investigators also urged Palestinian authorities to protect and preserve cultural heritage sites, including those of diverse origins, calling on de facto authorities in Gaza to stop using civilian objects for military purposes. Humanitarian crisis spiralling UN agencies continue to warn of a worsening humanitarian crisis in Gaza. The UN Children's Fund (UNICEF) highlighted the case of a five-year-old malnourished child whose recovery depends on adequate food and sustained care. ' Aid at scale must be allowed into Gaza for children's health and survival,' the agency urged. 'Another day of death traps' Philippe Lazzarini, head of the UN agency assisting Palestine refugees, expressed deep concern over delays and obstacles in aid delivery, urging Israel to allow the UN safe and unhindered access to bring in supplies and distribute it safely. 'This is the only way to avert mass starvation including among one million children,' he said. Mr. Lazzarini warned that casualties and injuries continue to be reported daily at US-backed distribution points managed by Israeli and private security forces – creating in effect, daily death traps. He described the system as humiliating, forcing thousands of hungry and desperate people to walk tens of miles, while excluding the most vulnerable and those living too far from aid centres. Food aid disrupted The UN World Food Programme (WFP) reported that 59 trucks carrying essential wheat flour to northern Gaza were intercepted and offloaded by starving civilians desperate to feed their families. A second convoy of 21 trucks bound for southern Gaza faced a 36-hour delay awaiting clearances. As of 10 June – nearly three weeks after the limited resumption of aid – WFP transported over 700 trucks to the Kerem Shalom crossing, compared to 600-700 trucks of aid transported per day during the ceasefire earlier this year. ' To stave off starvation, stabilize markets and calm desperation, we need to consistently support the entire population with basic food requirements every month,' WFP said. Insecurity and lawlessness in Gaza have also led to trucks being looted, injuring drivers and damaging trucks. WFP called for faster approvals, safe routes and open crossings, as well as an urgent ceasefire, to allow it to reach those in need. 'The food aid brought into Gaza during the ceasefire helped to push back the tide of hunger. We can do this again.'

The Spinoff

11-06-2025

• The Spinoff

Marilyn Waring: Why I convened the people's select committee on pay equity

When it became clear the government had chosen ideology over evidence in its rushed-through changes to the pay equity system, former National MP Marilyn Waring decided to do something about it. I had tuned in to parliament to listen to the Equal Pay Amendment Bill debate on pay equity, and I didn't have to listen for very long to know there was no evidence to back this change in law. I sought to confirm this by going online and finding the parliamentary link to the legislation website. You look for the departmental disclosure statement and click on this link. After the general policy statement and the explanatory note, you get to part two: background material and policy information. (Yes, if they wanted you to find this it would be easier to access.) But you need to know this, because this is where you find out if anything other than ideology informed the changes in legislation. It operates as a mini audit, asking key questions that should have been part of the evidence for the change. In this case, it is a very rewarding quest. The first of the audit questions asks, 'Are there any publicly available inquiry, review or evaluation reports that have informed, or are relevant to, the policy to be given effect by this bill?' The answer is 'Yes', and three pieces of research work are referenced. Two of these are totally opposed to the changes in the bill: a report (by rigorous researchers) for the Human Rights Commission on pay equity and care workers, and a report by Research NZ that monitors social workers and employers before and after their pay equity settlement. Nothing in this report supports the changes, especially the response from employers. The other report was commissioned by Health NZ and the terms of reference were written by Health NZ. The researchers report that 'not enough evidence was received to fully answer the terms of reference'; many documents were not provided, and the wider context of the pay equity system could not be included in the report. This is the sole supporting evidence furnished to support the legislation. No regulatory impact statement was provided by MBIE. There was no analysis of 'the potential for any group of persons to suffer a substantial unavoidable loss of income or wealth', (due to 'ministerial time constraints'), but apparently there was analysis of 'the size of potential costs and benefits'. This is an entertaining 'yes', as for a number of years pay equity found itself listed among the 'unquantifiable fiscal risks' along with natural disasters and Treaty settlements. So … how come we went from an unquantifiable fiscal risk to billions of dollars, and which wizards hiding where (I suspect Treasury) just made up the figures – because they don't add up! The next question in the disclosure statement is about New Zealand's international obligations and whether the bill is consistent with these. Oh dear: it's 2025 and the assessors in MBIE and MFAT looked at International Labour Organisation conventions and trade obligations, but didn't mention the Convention on all Forms of Discrimination against Women, so the answer is wrong. Then there's the mystery of what happened to the attorney general's advice to parliament on whether any provisions of the bill limit any of the rights and freedoms in the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990. The site claims that there was such advice from the Ministry of Justice, so I scurried off to their site to find the Section 7 report – nothing there. How surprising. Next there is the claim that there was no 'external consultation on the policy to be given effect by the bill, or on a draft of this bill'. I seriously doubt this, and we will just wait for some loose lips in the post-budget estimates debates to reveal this. The government did, however, test the policy details with the Public Service Commission (where the pay equity group was disbanded in June 2024), Health NZ, the Ministry of Education and the Treasury. So, the government talked to itself, and what's more, every time they say 'employers', they are talking about themselves. In the absence of evidence for the debate we endured the lazy, specious, headline-grabbing and truly ignorant remarks about the comparators used in pay equity settlement. A comparison between social workers and air traffic controllers was one often quoted. I taught in the four-year Bachelor of Social Work, and the further one to two years for a Master of Social Work, at Massey University. Wherever I look on the web (New Zealand, Australia, UK), the skills and knowledge required for air traffic controllers are concentration, using judgment and making decisions, ability to work well under pressure, excellent verbal communication skills, problem solving, and paying attention to detail. In Aotearoa the qualifications can be gained in less than a year, at much less cost than a four-year social work degree. Understanding what a social work qualification means, I would happily employ a social worker as an air traffic controller but never contemplate the reverse. The minister claimed to be 'progressing this bill under urgency because we have to move quickly to make the changes to the act to ensure that the system is workable and sustainable'. No evidence whatsoever was presented to show the system was unworkable and unsustainable. Fourteen claims had been very well settled. Ideology was the only arbiter for these rubbish claims. I'm a researcher and I like to see evidence for such significant changes that continue to exploit women – an exploitation that has been present for my lifetime. I wondered what device could be used to collect that evidence. I began to call retired women MPs to see if they would join me in a people's select committee. We were set up in five days. The people's select committee is calling for submissions now – the deadline for written submissions is July 31, and oral submissions will begin on August 11. We will uncover and report on the information that should have been before any responsible government before the passage of such legislation, and we will make this available to all in Aotearoa.