Same-sex parenting rights under scrutiny in Ohio Supreme Court case set for oral argument this month
The Gavel outside the Supreme Court of the State of Ohio. (Photo by Graham Stokes for Ohio Capital Journal. Republish photo only with original article.)
A case regarding parental rights in a same-sex relationship will be heard by the Ohio Supreme Court this month. It could test not only Ohio law but the federal Supreme Court decision on same-sex marriage.
The state's highest court will hold oral arguments in a case appealed from the First District Court of Appeals to decide the parental rights of a woman who was in a relationship with the children's mother when the child was born. But the woman was never married to the mother, and does not have adoptive rights to the children.
Priya Shahani and Carmen Edmonds were in a relationship for more than a decade, and had thoughts of getting married. But the bulk of their relationship occurred before the 2015 U.S. Supreme Court decision Obergefell v. Hodges, an Ohio-based case that legalized same-sex marriage nationwide.
Edmonds argues the couple travelled to Boston with plans to get married, but decided against it, due to the fact that Ohio would not recognize the marriage at that time. The state also does not recognize common-law marriages.
During the course of the relationship, Shahani had three children using a sperm donor that court documents say was chosen because he matched Edmonds' nationality.
Shahani and Edmonds sought to legally dissolve their relationship after 11 years, an agreement that included scheduled parenting time for Edmonds, but the children still held hyphenated names.
It wasn't until after Shahani removed the hyphenate from the children's names and filed to terminate their shared-custody agreement that the case started. Edmonds argued that the couple's 'marriage-like relationship' gave her rights to the children.
A lower court awarded Edmonds 'companionship time,' but otherwise effectively ruled against both women. It refused to terminate the shared custody agreement while also not allowing a 'parentage' decree for Edmonds.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
When both went to the First District Court of Appeals for answers, Edmonds brought up the Obergefell case legalizing same-sex marriage.
Edmonds argued that under that decision, parental rights statutes apply in this case as they would for married couples. The appellate court said the trial court needed to hold a hearing to decide whether the couple would have been married if the same-sex marriage decision had been in place.
Ohio law only recognizes parents if they are married, have a biological connection, or have legally adopted the child, something that requires marriage in the case of the 'second parent.'
The ACLU of Ohio said state parentage laws, combined with the Obergefell decision, 'provide a pathway for Ms. Edmonds and other non-biological, non-adoptive, same-sex parents who were unable to have their marriages legally recognized in the state of Ohio during the course of their relationship to establish legal parentage and confer the accompanying rights and responsibilities of parenthood.'
Shahani, noted that she made 'the major child-related decisions' including expenses and medical needs. She told the supreme court that giving Edmonds parental rights goes against both state law and the Obergefell decision, even if state statutes were looked at with gender-neutral language.
'This case is about whether Ohio's courts can reinvent history as a mechanism for seizing a fit parent's constitutionally protected rights,' attorneys for Shahani wrote in an October brief to the court.
In a state where common-law marriage isn't recognized, the attorneys said the state constitution, as well as the U.S. Constitution, doesn't allow state courts to 'manufacture an unlicensed marriage into existence.'
'The foundation upon which a 'would have been married' standard rests is a hypothetical injury that the individual may have been denied a marriage license if they had applied for one, or the state may not have recognized a marriage had there been an out-of-state marriage,' attorneys told the state supreme court.
Shahani refutes Edmonds' claim that the two travelled to Boston to get married, then changed their minds. But even if that were true, the legal result should be no different, she argues.
'Even in Ms. Edmonds's version of events, she would not have been married to Ms. Shahani when the insemination occurred, and therefore would not have parental rights,' court documents stated, citing a state statute regarding artificial insemination of a married woman.
The law, effective as of March 2001, specifies a woman 'and her husband' must sign a written consent to the insemination for the 'non-spousal artificial insemination' to occur.
The case was mentioned as one of the 'state oral arguments to watch' this month by the Brennan Center for Justice at NYU. The center identifies 'prominent or interesting state court cases,' which this month include the Ohio parental rights case, along with a challenge to Wyoming's abortion ban, an appeal to New York City's greenhouse gas emissions caps, the process of electing appellate judges in Arizona and voter power over zoning changes in an area of Georgia where descendants of slaves have historically taken up residence.
Oral arguments in the case will be heard on April 22 by the Ohio Supreme Court.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Buckeye Community School hosts graduation for 180 students from around Marion
The Buckeye Community School in Marion graduated 180 students June 3. Buckeye Community is a charter school with the mission of helping students thrive in a nontraditional high school, according to the school, which provides an alternative experience using individual tutoring, while not relying on online curriculums. Bryanna Large, a graduate from Buckeye Community School-Marion, spoke during the ceremony about how instructors motivated students to keep coming in and the personal relationships she made. "This journey was about healing," Large said, according to a news release. "About fighting through my past trauma, abuse, and hardships. Learning how to believe in myself when it felt like the world forgot about my worth and finding my reason to keep going. Alex Russell, another student speaker, described what led him to the Buckeye Community School-Marion. "I haven't always had the best attendance at school," Russell said. "In fact, I might have the record for the number of withdrawals, but I never gave up and was committed to finishing high school. There were lots of ups and downs along the way, but I managed, with the help of my teachers and family, to keep going and turn in my exams. It wasn't always easy, but I did it." While the graduation ceremony is held annually, students can graduate from the Buckeye Community School whenever they completed degree requirements. Students who finish early are welcomed back to celebrate their accomplishments. This article originally appeared on Marion Star: Buckeye Community School Marion hosts graduation ceremony
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Parties and proclamations: Juneteenth across the diaspora
Hello and welcome to The Long Wave. I'm Adria R Walker, a Mississippi-based race and equity reporter for the Guardian US, and I'm excited to be taking over this week. I've been working on a story about the ways Black American communities have celebrated – in many cases, for centuries – the formal end of slavery, which is variously called Emancipation Day, Freedom Day, Jubilee Day and, perhaps most famously, Juneteenth. My article will be published on 19 June, Juneteenth, a federal holiday that was enshrined into law four years ago. In doing this reporting, I've learned a lot about the holiday that I grew up celebrating. For this week's edition of the newsletter, I'll guide you through what Emancipation Day can look like in the US and its legacy. In 1863, President Abraham Lincoln signed the emancipation proclamation, which abolished slavery in the states that had seceded during the civil war, though slavery was abolished nationwide when the 13th amendment was ratified on 6 December 1865. News of the proclamation spread varyingly. Some southern enslavers attempted to outrun the order and the Union soldiers who brought news of it, moving the people they had enslaved farther and farther west until the army caught up with them. In Galveston, Texas, it was not until 19 June 1865 that people who were enslaved found out about the declaration. News of that freedom was enshrined in Juneteenth, celebrated annually by Galvestonians and nearby Houstonians. While Juneteenth has become the most famous emancipation celebration, it is far from the only one. I had the idea for the story a couple of years ago, on 8 May 2023, when I became curious about how communities across the south celebrated emancipation historically and in the present day. On that day, the Mississippi Civil Rights Museum, one of the Two Mississippi Museums in Jackson, my home town, had shared a newspaper clipping on Instagram about a historic Emancipation Day celebration on 8 May. The 8 May celebrations, which are still observed by the Mississippi School of Mathematics and Science and the local community, began in 1865, when Union soldiers arrived in Columbus to inform the enslaved people that they were free. Elsewhere, 8 August commemmorates the day the former president Andrew Johnson manumitted (freed) the people he had enslaved – the emancipation proclamation had not applied to Tennessee or West Virginia. William Isom, the director of Black in Appalachia, tells me that Samuel Johnson, a formerly enslaved person, is credited with the spread of 8 August celebrations. In Florida, the day is celebrated on 20 May, honouring that date in 1865 when Union troops read and enforced the emancipation proclamation at the end of the civil war. In Gallia County, Ohio, they have marked 22 September 1862, the day on which Lincoln drafted the emancipation proclamationsince 1863 – making it one of the longest-running emancipation celebrations in the country, Isom says. Some communities have celebrated 1 January since 1863, when Lincoln signed the proclamation, while others celebrate 31 December, or Watch Night, when enslaved and freed Black Americans gathered to hear news of the emancipation proclamation. Watch Night is still observed in Black communities across the south, including in the Carolinas, where Gullah Geechee people observe Freedom's Eve, and elsewhere. As a child, I attended Watch Night services at church in Mississippi, though I didn't appreciate the significance at the time. Whenever and wherever slavery was abolished, formerly enslaved people observed and celebrated the day – this is consistent across the African diaspora. I knew about Emancipation Day festivities in the Caribbean and in Canada, for example, though they are different from those in the US, but I didn't know such celebrations extended to the northern US. In Massachusetts, Emancipation Day, also known as Quock Walker Day, is on 8 July. Quock Walker, born in 1753, sued for and won his freedom in 1781. His case is considered to have helped abolish slavery in Massachusetts. In New York State, the Fifth of July was first celebrated in 1827, an event first held the day after full emancipation was achieved there. After the British empire ended slavery in 1838, many areas in the north began to observe 1 August. In Washington DC, on 16 April, people commemorate the anniversary of the 1862 signing of the District of Columbia Compensated Emancipation Act, which abolished slavery and freed about 3,000 people in the capital. Under the act, former enslavers were compensated for the people they had enslaved, a common practice during efforts to end slavery around the world. However, the people who had been enslaved did not receive compensation. I vaguely remember attending my first Juneteenth celebration as a little girl. Farish Street, a historic Black district in Jackson, was abuzz with people. Despite it being the middle of summer in Mississippi, the heat didn't stop folks from coming out to eat, dance and socialise. The state is relatively close to Texas – it is about a six-hour drive from Jackson to Houston – so we have quite a bit of cultural overlap. It made sense that we would share holidays. Like many other cultural traditions, Juneteenth spread across the country with the arrival of southern people during the great migration. In the decades since, Juneteenth has been catapulted from a local or regional event to a national and international one – last year, for example, I was invited to attend a Juneteenth event in Toronto, Canada. Other emancipation commemorations travelled, too. The 8 August celebrations, for example, moved throughout Appalachia, through coal country and into urban metropolises such as Chicago, Indianapolis and Detroit. Historically, the holiday included celebratory aspects – eating traditional foods, hosting libations, singing, dancing and playing baseball – but also a tangible push for change. Celebrants would gather to find family members from whom they had been separated during slavery, attend lectures and advocate for education, and practise harnessing their political power – something that was particularly relevant in the reconstruction days. For Isom, Juneteenth can become a day that the entire country comes together to celebrate freedom, while communities' specific emancipation celebrations can be hyper-local and hyper-specific. 'Even in [places] where there's not necessarily many Black folks at all, they're having the Juneteenth events,' he says. 'And so the local celebrations – like for here, 8 August or 22 September – that's where I feel like communities can showcase and celebrate their own cultures and traditions around Emancipation Day. We need both.' To receive the complete version of The Long Wave in your inbox every Wednesday, please subscribe here.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Ohio Lottery Mega Millions, Pick 3 Midday winning numbers for June 20, 2025
The Ohio Lottery offers multiple draw games for those aiming to win big. Here's a look at June 20, 2025, results for each game: Mega Millions drawings take place every week on Tuesday and Friday at 11 p.m. 26-49-58-61-63, Mega Ball: 09 Check Mega Millions payouts and previous drawings here. Drawings are held daily, seven days a week, at 12:29 p.m. and 7:29 p.m., except Saturday evening. Midday: 2-7-0 Evening: 8-9-9 Check Pick 3 payouts and previous drawings here. Drawings are held daily, seven days a week, at 12:29 p.m. and 7:29 p.m., except Saturday evening. Midday: 6-6-3-5 Evening: 9-8-4-6 Check Pick 4 payouts and previous drawings here. Drawings are held daily, seven days a week, at 12:29 p.m. and 7:29 p.m., except Saturday evening. Midday: 3-7-2-2-0 Evening: 8-9-2-5-0 Check Pick 5 payouts and previous drawings here. Drawings are held daily, seven days a week, at approximately 7:05 p.m. 18-27-34-37-39 Check Rolling Cash 5 payouts and previous drawings here. Drawings are held daily, seven days a week, at approximately 10:35 p.m. 05-09-31-33-45, Lucky Ball: 08 Feeling lucky? Explore the latest lottery news & results Winning lottery numbers are sponsored by Jackpocket, the official digital lottery courier of the USA TODAY Network. Tickets can be purchased in person at gas stations, convenience stores and grocery stores. Some airport terminals may also sell lottery tickets. You can also order tickets online through Jackpocket, the official digital lottery courier of the USA TODAY Network, in these U.S. states and territories: Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Idaho, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Montana, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Oregon, Puerto Rico, Washington D.C., and West Virginia. The Jackpocket app allows you to pick your lottery game and numbers, place your order, see your ticket and collect your winnings all using your phone or home computer. Jackpocket is the official digital lottery courier of the USA TODAY Network. Gannett may earn revenue for audience referrals to Jackpocket services. GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1-800-GAMBLER, Call 877-8-HOPENY/text HOPENY (467369) (NY). 18+ (19+ in NE, 21+ in AZ). Physically present where Jackpocket operates. Jackpocket is not affiliated with any State Lottery. Eligibility Restrictions apply. Void where prohibited. Terms: This results page was generated automatically using information from TinBu and a template written and reviewed by an Enquirer digital news director. You can send feedback using this form. This article originally appeared on Cincinnati Enquirer: Ohio Lottery Mega Millions, Pick 3 Midday winning numbers for June 20, 2025
