Abortion prosecution horror as woman arrested in hospital while still bleeding

A law change aimed at decriminalising abortion in England and Wales was debated in the House of Commons after a string of women have faced prosecution and even jail
Half a dozen women in England and Wales have recently faced prosecution after having an abortion, but after more than a century, this week could see a major change that allows women the right to choose.
MPs debated in the Commons on a law change aimed at decriminalising abortion in England and Wales. While the Abortion Act in 1967 allowed access to abortion, the 1861 law - the Offences Against the Person Act - was not revoked.
‌
It means abortion was illegal, but allowed up to the first 24 weeks of pregnancy, and beyond then if the mother's life is in danger. Recent changes to the law, introduced in lockdown, have meant that women can access pills to terminate pregnancies under 10 weeks at home through the "pills by post" scheme.
‌
In 2022, the most recent available data, more than 250,000 abortions were reported, the highest figure since records began. However in the last five years, abortion providers have reported 100 requests for medical records from police officers in relation to suspected abortion offences, the BBC reports.
Just last month, Nicola Packer, 45, was cleared by a jury after being accused of having an illegal abortion. In November 2020, when she was 26 weeks pregnant, she took an abortion medicine at home during the coronavirus lockdown, Isleworth Crown Court heard. Ms Packer, then 41, took the medications after they were prescribed over the phone due to lockdown restrictions.
She delivered the baby and took her to Chelsea and Westminster Hospital in a backpack the following day. Ms Packer said she hadn't realised how far along she was in her pregnancy, and expressed her "shock" at being pregnant given her age. She told the jury that if she had known she was more than 10 weeks, she wouldn't have gone ahead with the medication.
Ms Packer had spent the night of November 7 in the hospital and had initially said she miscarried naturally. She had told two midwives the next day that she had taken abortion pills through the post, received from Marie Stopes, one of the largest providers of contraception and abortions.
‌
While recovering from surgery for a stillbirth and still bleeding, she was arrested at the hospital by police the same day. Prosecutors had picked apart her sex life during the trial, with it taking her four years to clear her name.
Ms Packer is one of six women to be prosecuted for the crime since the end of 2022 under the Offences Against the Person Act, which, since its introduction in 1861, had only been used three times. In June 2023, a mum-of-three was jailed for more than two years for inducing an abortion after the legal limit.
Carla Foster, 45, who became pregnant in 2019, had moved back in with her estranged partner at the start of lockdown whilst carrying another man's baby. The court heard she had sought to hide her pregnancy, which the judge accepted as "emotional turmoil". Ms Foster had a remote consultation before being prescribed the medication, and said she wasn't sure how far along she was.
‌
Stoke Crown Court heard she was between 32-34 weeks when she took the pills. Judge Mr Justice Edward Pepperall said it was a "tragic" case, adding that the defendant, who later pleaded guilty to administering drugs to procure abortion, was "wracked by guilt" and had suffered depression.
Her 28-month sentencing outraged campaigners, with the British Pregnancy Advisory Service (BPAS) saying it was "appalled" by the sentencing based on "archaic law". In January 2024, Bethany Cox, 22, was found not guilty of carrying out an illegal abortion on herself.
‌
On the eve of her trial, the prosecution dropped the case due to "evidential difficulties". Nicholas Lumley KC, for Ms Cox, said she had given birth in July 2020 at the end of the coronavirus lockdown.
Whilst "in the throes of grief", the young woman, from Stockton, had been interviewed by police and was under police investigation for three years before being charged. Mr Lumley said it was "beyond regrettable" that she had suffered so extensively.
‌
In December last year, Sophie Harvey, 25, and her boyfriend Elliot Benham were given community orders after prosecutors accepted she did not illegally abort their baby. Meanwhile another woman, whose identity was protected, had her case dropped, with a judge saying he was "flabbergasted" to see it in court.
Then there are the women whose names didn't make headlines, including a teenager who was arrested in front of her neighbours after having a late miscarriage, the Guardian reports, and cases of women who have been denied contact with their children whilst being investigated.
Some women and girls who have had terminated pregnancies past the legal cut-off have been vulnerable, including victims of domestic violence. A BPAS spokesperson told The Guardian: 'We're aware of cases where the woman has been investigated, or even imprisoned, and nothing has happened to her abusive partner.'
‌
The harrowing case of Ms Packer put England and Wales' current abortion laws back into the spotlight, with the trial demonstrating "just how outdated and harmful" current abortion law was, according to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. Dr Ranee Thakar, the college's president, said: "As a doctor, I am acutely aware of how vital it is that women can access essential healthcare in a safe and supportive environment.
"Restrictive abortion laws in England and Wales nurture an environment of fear, stigmatisation and criminalisation. Abortion reform is urgently needed, and now is the time for change."
Two Labour MPs, Tonia Antoniazzi and Stella Creasy, tabled rival amendments to the Crime and Policing Bill. The aim was to prevent women from being investigated, prosecuted, or imprisoned for terminating their own pregnancies.
Ms Antoniazzi has argued that the probes are "dehumanising and prolonged and the women forced to endure them are often extraordinarily vulnerable". She added: "The reality is that no woman wakes up 24 weeks pregnant or more and suddenly decides to end their own pregnancy outside a hospital or clinic.
"But some women, in desperate circumstances, make choices that many of us would struggle to understand. What they need is compassion and care, not the threat of criminal prosecution." Meanwhile, Ms Creasy's rival amendment would position abortion access as a human right.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Daily Mirror

an hour ago

• Daily Mirror

Rabies vaccines see surge in demand following tragic death of British gran

Pharmacist Olamide Olokanmi confirmed the rise in numbers of people asking for rabies treatment. His pharmacy in Otley, West Yorkshire, had stocked up on the jab The tragic death of a British gran from rabies has sparked a surge in travellers seeking advice about vaccinations. Yvonne Ford 59, from Barnsley, died in hospital in Sheffield on 11 June after being scratched by the stray dog during a family trip to Morocco in February. Pharmacist Olamide Olokanmi confirmed the rise in numbers of people asking for rabies treatment. His pharmacy in Otley, West Yorkshire, had stocked up on the jab but he was concerned that an increase in demand may lead to a shortage of supply. ‌ "We frequently have supply issues with vaccines, especially when there's a high demand for them, and rabies notoriously seems to be one of them," said Mr Olokanmi. "Year-on-year we always have that problem, so I do foresee that being a problem. There would then be a wait for it to come back in or we'd have to go to another manufacturer which then drives up the price of the vaccine." ‌ It currently costs up to £330 for a three-dose rabies vaccine. Mrs Ford's death from the virus was the first in the UK since 2018 when a British man was bitten by a cat in the same African country. Mr Olokanmi has seen a rise in the number of customers seeking advice about whether to get the vaccination before travelling to high-risk regions such as Asia, Africa and Central and South America. Before news of Mrs Ford's death, most people accessing the pharmacy's travel clinic opted not to get the jab, he said. He told the BBC: "We had one lady come in on Wednesday night who is going on holiday to Morocco. She wasn't going to get the vaccine but after hearing what happened to this lady she changed her mind. A young man has also come in who is going to Morocco and we've had a lot of phone calls from people asking about it." The Association of British Travel Agents (ABTA), said its members were directing customers to the UK government travel advice. The travel agents have a duty to give advice about vaccines to holidaymakers when planning and booking their trip. That guidance was repeated for the benefit of their members this week. ‌ Spokesperson Emma Brennan added: "The UK Foreign Office does a lot to raise awareness of checking this advice and we support them in that, and their work with industry." Barnsley NHS Foundation Trust confirmed his wife was diagnosed with rabies. ‌ It is a rare but serious infection that is usually caught from the bite or scratch of infected dogs, bats, raccoons and foxes. Although the risk of getting it while travelling is small, rabies is more common in parts of Asia, Africa and Central and South America. Dr Katherine Russell, of the UK Health Security Agency, said: 'If you are bitten, scratched or licked by an animal in a country where rabies is found, you should wash the wound with plenty of soap and water and seek medical advice without delay in order to get post-exposure treatment to prevent rabies." The UK has been rabies-free since 1922, when the last indigenous non-fatal case was recorded, with the exception of rabies-like viruses in some wild bat species. Omar Zouhri, 58, was the last person to die in the UK from rabies; he was bitten by a rabid cat while in Morocco. Mr Zouhri, from Aylesbury in Buckinghamshire, died in hospital in Oxford on November 4, 2018.

Daily Mail​

an hour ago

• Daily Mail​

EXCLUSIVE England's most depressed streets revealed - so how high are rates in YOUR neighbourhood?

England's depression capitals are today revealed in MailOnline's interactive map of every neighbourhood in the country. Topping the table of 34,000 districts, according to the House of Commons Library's (HoC) figures, comes a suburb of Stockport in Greater Manchester. Nearly one in three GP patients in that particular enclave of Brinnington, located just off the M60, have been diagnosed with depression. At the other end of the scale, just 3.5 per cent of people living in an affluent zone of Knightsbridge, central London, are thought to suffer with the mental illness. Five-story Edwardian homes which sell for north of £1.5million are commonplace in that precinct, just a ten-minute walk from Harrods. Our map, which allows you to zoom into street level, plots the depression prevalence estimates for all 34,000 lower super output areas (LSOA) in England – tiny pockets of the country made up of around 1,000 and 3,000 people. Each LSOA is coloured by how many GP patients aged over 18 have been diagnosed with depression. The darker the shade of red, the higher the rate of sufferers. The figure for the entirety of England stood at around 13 per cent, slightly higher than official estimates. Depression is 'more than simply feeling unhappy or fed up for a few days' and is 'not something you can snap out of', the advice page from the NHS states. Of the ten LSOAs with the highest rates of depression, eight were located in the north of England, specifically in Stockport and the Wirral. The other two were in Plymouth's deprived Budshead community, where locals have bemoaned a rise in anti-social behaviour from children who have 'nothing to do'. Eight of the ten places with the lowest rates of depression were in the local authority of Westminster. Dr Dalia Tsimpida, lecturer in gerontology at the University of Southampton, has been investigating what makes some neighbourhoods mental health hotspots while others remain relatively protected. She said: 'Our research reveals a complex web of environmental and socioeconomic factors that contribute to higher depression rates in certain areas. 'Deprivation is a key driver, accounting for up to 39 per cent of recorded depression levels across England, although this varies dramatically by location.' Her research has identified a previously overlooked factor: noise pollution. Areas with transportation noise exceeding 55 decibels on average in a 24-hour basis show much stronger links between health deprivation, disability, and depression. 'Environmental stressors play a crucial but underappreciated role,' she said. 'While transportation noise doesn't directly cause depression, it significantly amplifies the impact of other risk factors.' Dr Tsimpida added: 'Living in a depression hotspot exposes people to what may be "contagion effects" - both social and environmental. 'We observed that mental health challenges may spread through communities through mechanisms like social isolation, reduced community resources, environmental degradation, and normalised hopelessness.' Studies suggest depression rates can be linked to other factors, such as low income or living alone, according to the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey. The survey, carried out for the NHS, also showed a link between poor physical health and mental knock-on effects. Dr Tsimpida added: 'Areas with lower depression rates – particularly in London and the South East – benefit from multiple protective factors working together. 'These include better economic opportunities, higher-quality housing, more green spaces, lower environmental stressors, and stronger social infrastructure.' What is depression? While it is normal to feel down from time to time, people with depression may feel persistently unhappy for weeks or months on end. Depression can affect anyone at any age and is fairly common - approximately one in ten people are likely to experience it at some point in their life. Depression is a genuine health condition which people cannot just ignore or 'snap out of it'. Symptoms and effects vary, but can include constantly feeling upset or hopeless, or losing interest in things you used to enjoy. It can also cause physical symptoms such as problems sleeping, tiredness, having a low appetite or sex drive, and even feeling physical pain. In extreme cases it can lead to suicidal thoughts. Traumatic events can trigger it, and people with a family history may be more at risk. It is important to see a doctor if you think you or someone you know has depression, as it can be managed with lifestyle changes, therapy or medication. Source: NHS Choices A House of Commons report last year estimated that one in six adults experienced a 'common mental disorder' like depression or anxiety in the previous week. But when it comes to treatment, there is a postcode lottery as waiting times for NHS talking therapies (TTAD). Sufferers in Gloucestershire can be seen in just four days, while others in Southport and Formby have to wait at least 10 weeks. Two-thirds of people experience improvement after TTAD, but this varies in different parts of England and between social groups. Health service figures show a record 8.7million people in England, about 15 per cent of the total population, are now on antidepressants, which can also be given to fight OCD, anxiety and PTSD. Some experts have been concerned about the 'one size fits all' approach to patients suffering from depression. The concerns have mainly focused on the use of a type of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and its libido crushing side-effects. Some users have reported being transformed into 'sexless' zombies even years after they stopped taking the mind-altering pills. Uptake of the pills has soared in recent years despite growing unease among experts about the effectiveness of the drugs in treating depression. Plenty of patients insist they work, however. Psychiatrists urge patients concerned about side effects, or potential consequences, of antidepressants to talk to their medical professional about their options. Earlier this year, one of the UK's most eminent GPs warned thousands of Brits were mistaking the 'normal stresses of life' for mental health problems — and incorrectly diagnosing themselves with psychiatric conditions. Dame Clare Gerada, former president of the Royal College of General Practitioners, told MailOnline in January that Britain has a 'problem' with people 'seeking labels to explain their worries'. Professor Gerada's concerns echo that of former Prime Minister Sir Tony Blair's, who has warned against over-medicalising the 'ups and downs of life'. Sir Tony, who served as PM from 1997 to 2007, said there was a danger of telling too many people going through life's normal challenges that they are suffering a mental health condition. Dr Tsimpida argues that current approaches to tackling depression may be fundamentally flawed because they focus on treating individuals rather than transforming places. She said: 'We need place-based interventions, not just individual treatments. 'Our findings show that traditional randomised controlled trials may miss crucial spatial influences on mental health outcomes.' Based on her research findings, she suggests several priority actions which include noise mitigation strategies, sustained investment in hotspots and integrated approaches to treat all root causes at the same time. She added: 'The key insight from our research is that treating depression effectively requires changing places, not just treating people. Jen Dykxhoorn, a research fellow at University College London's Division of Psychiatry Neighbourhood believes regeneration programmes may be helpful. She said: 'There is some evidence that initiatives like planting trees, removing litter, and improving the physical quality of neighbourhoods can reduce rates of depression.' MailOnline's investigation into the country's depression hotspots was calculated from House of Commons Library data which was compiled from GP practice registers in England as published by NHS Digital. Some apparent variation between areas may be explained by differences in how GPs operate and measure, rather than genuine differences in the prevalence of disease and health conditions. HoC Library's most up to date figures use the 2011 LSOA boundaries which were updated in 2021.

Sky News

9 hours ago

• Sky News

The assisted dying debate has been politics – but not as we know it

The House of Commons is a place defined by confrontation where political battles play out and engage more actively with their constituents. But the atmosphere could not have been more different on Friday, as those on both sides of the assisted dying debate listened respectfully, almost solemnly, to one another in the final hours before the crucial vote. As MPs headed for the division lobbies, the bill's supporters seemed confident but nervous. When the voting was completed and the result imminent, a long and profound silence fell over the House. From the press gallery, it seemed that the entire Commons was holding its breath together, collectively aware of the historic moment we were all about to witness, whatever the outcome. The woman at the centre of this seismic moment, the bill's sponsor Kim Leadbeater, braced herself as the result came in. Many months of pressure and responsibility appeared to be lifted from her shoulders as the win was announced and colleagues gathered to commend her efforts. Throughout the process this been politics but not as we know it, with party divisions put aside and MPs asked to search their own consciences and come to their own conclusions. It has created a more collaborative atmosphere in parliament and encouraged MPs to engage more actively with their constituents. 3:06 In the end there was still anger, frustration and disappointment among those who were against the law change, either on principle or because they believed the legislation was flawed. And of course, politics will go back to being combative and voices in the Commons will be raised once again. But for a brief period, historic change was calmly ushered in. The challenge for the proponents now is to take the legislation through the next phases and deliver it with the same smoothness and determination.