Expert insights on Enoch Godongwana's upcoming budget speech in South Africa
Experts have mixed feelings as Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana prepares to deliver his third expected budget speech on Wednesday.
Image: Pixabay
As South Africa braces for Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana's third budget speech on Wednesday, a wave of expert opinions reveals a landscape marked by both cautious optimism and pronounced concerns.
With rising economic pressures and a growing budget deficit, Godongwana faces the complex task of generating revenue without curbing growth.
Old Mutual chief economist Johann Els highlighted the anticipated revenue shortfall following the scrapping of a planned Value Added Tax (VAT) increase.
Els estimated a loss of around R13.5 billion for the current year, with an alarming three-year total that could reach approximately R75bn.
'This will have to be made up for; Treasury will have to revise their gross domestic product (GDP) growth forecast downwards; they have it at 1.9% for 2025, but most forecasts have GDP around 1.5%,' he said.
The ramifications of this budget speech extend beyond just lost tax revenue. Els said the budget speech was more than just a VAT increase that needed to be made up for.
'It is crucial that the government sticks to the deficit targets that they set in the first two budgets. Investors and rating agencies would not like it if the government tries to make up for the loss in revenue by borrowing more.
It is crucial that they stick to the budget deficit target of 4.6% for this year, easing lower over the next few years to -3.5%. The primary surplus target of +0.9% rising to +2% over the next three years should be maintained. Crucially, the debt-to-GDP ratio peaking this year at 76.2% should be maintained. I think there needs to be significant expenditure cuts in this budget.'
Professor Raymond Parsons, an economist at the North-West University (NWU) Business School, choed the sentiment that this budget could provide a much-needed opportunity.
'The third budget stands a good chance of being a successful one. It should benefit from the robust debate around the VAT controversy, which identified new options on both the spending and revenue of the budget to better 'balance the books'. The credibility of the budget will depend upon its ability to do two key things,' he said.
Parsons added that the government needed to stick close to its original goal of a debt-to-GDP ratio of 76.2%, and second, strongly reflect what is now needed to meet the Government of National Unity's commitment to a 3% job-rich GDP growth target in the medium term.
Neil Roets, CEO of Debt Rescue, welcome the confirmation that VAT will remain at 15%, sparing families from yet another blow, but said they remained concerned about the possibility of proposed increases in fuel levies and sin taxes.
Roets said that equally troubling was the persistent budget deficit.
'The possibility of turning to 'stealth' measures such as bracket creep or frozen medical aid credits only shifts the burden onto consumers. We urge Minister Godongwana to prioritise spending efficiency rather than add to household strain,' he said.
Benay Sager, Executive Head of DebtBusters, said that their expectation was spending cuts across the different departments as there just was not enough money to go around.
'We expect tax brackets to remain as they have been, and as a result of bracket creep, there will be more money coming in. We also expect additional taxes to be announced on things like, potentially, crypto and crypto trading and so on,' he said.
Casey Sprake, economist at Anchor Capital, said that the central challenge of the third iteration of Budget 2025 liesd in how effectively the government responded to several mounting fiscal pressures.
Sprake added that to offset the negative fiscal impacts, the government is likely to dial back some of the new spending introduced in the previous two Budget 2025 updates.
'In particular, increased allocations for frontline services are expected to be trimmed. However, Treasury is likely to protect infrastructure spending, positioning it as central to efforts aimed at boosting long-term economic growth,' Sprake said.
Weekend Argus
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
11 hours ago
- The Herald
Store account add-ons, ‘lack of due care' car claims among top disputes for consumers
The life division of the NFO finalised 5,977 cases in 2024. The total amount recovered was R202.8m. Denise Gabriels, lead ombud: life division, said funeral benefits remained the product most complained about, accounting for 45% of complaints. The most common causes for complaints were claims being declined; at 56%; followed by poor service or administration, at 34%. Of the five life insurance companies that received the most complaints: 628 formal cases were opened against Old Mutual Life Assurance Company, representing 18% of all complaints opened; Liberty Group Limited had 399 formal cases opened, representing 11%; Hollard Life Insurance Company had 259 cases, representing 7%; Metropolitan Life had 216 cases; and Sanlam Life Insurance Ltd had 188 cases opened. Credit The credit division of the NFO successfully closed 2,040 cases, achieving positive outcomes for complainants in 49% of cases. This resulted in financial redress totalling R2.35m. The highest number of cases were opened with: the Retail Credit Solutions (RCS) Group, which had the highest number of cases opened, totalling 243, representing 17% of all cases opened; Opco 365 had 133 cases opened, representing 9% of all cases opened; Edcon Limited had 126 cases opened, 9% of all cases opened; and DMC Debt Management had 121 cases opened, 9% of all cases opened. Findings in favour of complainants totalled 44%. Howard Gabriels, lead ombud: credit division, said two matters that stood out with a number of retailers for their systemic impact during the reporting period were: value-added services (VAS); and minimum payment calculations. 'A serious concern emerged regarding the application of payments on credit accounts where VAS charges (such as airtime or insurance add-ons) were not considered in determining the minimum monthly payments,' he said.
The Herald
2 days ago
- The Herald
Godongwana proposes full public funding for political parties
Finance minister Enoch Godongwana is proposing political parties be fully funded by public money, arguing reliance on private donors undermines accountability. Speaking at the Electoral Commission of SA's (IEC) inaugural symposium on political funding on Thursday, he said: 'In my view, political parties must be fully publicly funded. Political funding for political parties from the public purse carries with it obligations — there's going to be accountability and transparency. The auditor-general must be able to audit for that accountability.' Godongwana said there is need for a funding regime that ensures stability, transparency and participation. However, he cautioned that economic challenges and reduced revenue collection could limit the creation of a common public funding pool. 'Between the 2011/12 financial year to date, we've only given R3bn to political parties,' a figure he cited to highlight underfunding of parties. He also questioned the IEC's role in overseeing political funding, asking, 'Are we not putting the IEC in a position of a conflict?' Listen to the minister:
Eyewitness News
2 days ago
- Eyewitness News
Godongwana thinks political parties should be wholly funded from national fiscus
CAPE TOWN - Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana is of the view that political parties should be wholly funded from the national fiscus and not have to accept private donations. Speaking to the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC)'s political funding conference in Durban on Thursday, Godongwana said it's unacceptable that some political parties don't submit annual audited financial statements. Godongwana's own political party, the African National Congress (ANC), was among those fined by the Electoral Court last year for falling foul of the law in this regard. The finance minister questioned whether the IEC was the appropriate body to keep political parties in check over their finances, saying it puts the institution at risk of accusations of bias and a lack of independence. "I'm from the ANC. When they do it to us, we say they've been captured. When they do it to another party, they say Ramaphosa has sent them." With a court challenge still pending over plans to double the annual private funding limit to R30 million, while also raising the threshold for declaring donations to R200,000, Godongwana said he hoped the matter was settled before next year's local government elections. He said that the conference should consider the implications of political parties purely being funded by the state. "That raises the question: What is the optimal level of funding and what is the criteria for that? We complain that departments are inefficient. Should we fund political parties for inefficiencies as well?" Godongwana also hinted that if the revenue allowed, more money could be set aside to fund next year's local government election, in addition to the R1.4 billion already allocated in this year's budget.
