Penalty imposed by CCP: CAT reserves verdict in a case filed by ICAP
ISLAMABAD: The Competition Appellate Tribunal (CAT) has reserved its verdict in a case filed by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Pakistan (ICAP) against a penalty imposed by the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) over alleged price-fixing.
The case dates back to 2008, when CCP initiated suo motu proceedings against ICAP for issuing a revised Accounting Technical Release 14 (ATR-14). Approved at ICAP's 197th Council meeting on July 25, 2008, the revised ATR-14 set minimum hourly charge-out rates and fixed minimum audit fees for public sector entities.
CCP found this in violation of Section 4(1) of the Competition Ordinance, 2007, which prohibits anti-competitive agreements. The Commission declared ATR-14 null and void, directed ICAP to withdraw it from the Members' Handbook, and publish a withdrawal notice in two newspapers. A fine of Rs. 1 million was also imposed.
ICAP challenged the decision before CAT. Representing ICAP, senior counsel Dr. Farrukh Nasim argued that the institute is a statutory regulator and has the authority to set minimum fees for audit engagements, especially for government institutions. He urged the tribunal to overturn the penalty.
CCP's counsel countered that ICAP, though a regulatory body, cannot fix prices in a competitive market. The Commission termed such practices as collusive price-fixing—strictly prohibited under all modern competition laws.
The tribunal has reserved its judgment. The outcome is likely to impact how professional bodies operate within competitive sectors going forward.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
13 minutes ago
- Business Recorder
PKI urges govt to set up Agri Price Commission, Agri Export Authority
LAHORE: Pakistan Kissan Ittehad (PKI) has urged the government to establish an Agricultural Commodities Price Commission to ensure a transparent pricing mechanism that guarantees farmers at least a 25 percent return on their investment. In addition, PKI also called for the creation of an Agricultural Export Authority to stabilize domestic prices and promote sustainable marketing of surplus produce. PKI President Khalid Mahmood Khokhar made these demands while speaking to journalists the other evening. He also called for the removal of the 18 percent GST on seed cotton, the abolition of GST on tractors and related implements, and the introduction of a uniform electricity tariff of Rs 10 per unit for irrigation tube-wells. 'Without urgent reforms, experts warn that Pakistan's agricultural sector, which remains the backbone of its economy is on an accelerating downward spiral, with far-reaching consequences for food security, economic resilience, and social stability,' he remarked. Reacting to the Punjab budget, he criticized the mere 10.75 percent increase in agriculture allocations, arguing that it reflects either a gross underestimation of the crisis facing the sector or a deliberate attempt to downplay its severity. 'Despite these alarming signals, the Government of Punjab has allocated only Rs 129.8 billion for agriculture in the 2025–26 budget a modest 10.75 percent increase from last year's Rs 117.2 billion. In the face of a multi-trillion-rupee crisis, this nominal increment of Rs 12 billion is widely seen as inadequate and dismissive of the sector's plight,' said PKI President Khalid Mahmood Khokhar. Adding to farmers' concerns is the government's proposal to tax agricultural income; a move many believe demonstrates a profound disconnect from the economic hardships currently faced by the farming community. Applying tax slabs designed for stable corporate businesses to climate-affected farmers struggling with water scarcity could prove disastrous. Such a policy risks deepening rural poverty, discouraging investment, and further destabilizing an already fragile sector, he warned. The affordability crisis among farmers has reached critical levels. A steep decline in fertilizer usage, particularly urea and DAP along with a significant drop in tractor sales, indicates that farmers are unable to invest during the current Kharif season. The prospect of declining cotton yields is increasing, and the potential impact on the upcoming Rabi wheat crop is also cause for concern. If this downward trend continues, it could trigger a dangerous food security emergency. Khokhar pointed out that Pakistan's agricultural sector is in deep crisis, with growth plunging by 5.84 percent over the past year, and major crop production shrinking by more than 13 percent. Agricultural exports have also sharply declined in 2024–25, laying bare the sector's deep structural weaknesses. Maize exports fell by a staggering 86 percent to just USD 58.9 million, while rice exports dropped by 15 percent to USD 3.3 billion. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
an hour ago
- Business Recorder
E-Commerce sector urges govt to revise proposed tax steps
KARACHI: Pakistan's E-Commerce ecosystem has urged the federal government to revise proposed tax and compliance measures announced in Finance Bill 2025-26 and initiate a structured dialogue with stakeholders to co-create practical, growth-friendly tax policies Addressing a press conference here on Friday at Karachi Press Club (KPC), representatives of the Chainstore Association of Pakistan (CAP) and the Pakistan E-Commerce Association (PEA), along with other stakeholders including freelancers, marketplaces, courier services, payment providers, and digital platforms, have urged the government to adopt practical revisions to the proposed tax and compliance measures in the Finance Bill 2025-26. On the occasion, representatives including Muhammad Zeeshan, Shoaib Bhatti, Joint Secretary CAP Bushra, Atta Bin Azad, Mahwish from Payfast, Shoaib Ahmed and others were also present. They informed that Pakistan's e-commerce sector has grown over 35 percent annually in the past five years and currently, over 100,000 micro and small online sellers are active, supporting incomes for more than a million people nationwide. The total market size is estimated at Rs 2.2 trillion or $7.7 billion with some 2 percent share in the national GDP. They said that all stakeholders is supporting fair taxation and documentation, but the proposed measures risk severely disrupting both established and small businesses by putting an extreme compliance burden all at once. 'Their design and immediate implementation will stifle digital entrepreneurship, especially among youth and women,' they added. The coalition appreciates the proposed 5 percent digital presence levy on offshore platforms like Temu and supports improved data reporting requirements of the sector. However, the gains should not be undermined by excessive and impractical tax compliance obligations. They said that Finance Bill introduces multiple taxes and complex procedures across all related businesses, with no stakeholder consultation or phased rollout. Industry leaders warn that this top-down approach mirrors the unsuccessful 'Tajir Dost' scheme, which failed due to impractical design and lack of consultation. 'Blanket 2 percent sales tax withholding, mandatory sales tax registration for all online merchants, complex income tax withholding at six different rates, penalties of up to Rs 500,000 per case on platforms, couriers, and sellers and enforcement from 1st July with no transition period are key concern,' highlighted the representatives. They recommended 2 percent sales tax withholding to non-ATL (unregistered) sellers and income tax registration for small/ home-based sellers instead of complicated sales tax registration and monthly filings. Industry leaders urged the Prime Minister, Finance Minister, Commerce Minister, and Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to pause enforcements and initiate a structured dialogue with stakeholders to co-create practical, growth-friendly tax policies. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
an hour ago
- Business Recorder
Fiscal consolidation and social sector expansion: Punjab govt maintains balanced approach
LAHORE: Despite fiscal challenges and persistent structural rigidities, the Punjab government has maintained a balanced approach between fiscal consolidation and social sector expansion. As per Punjab budget 2025-26 document, the NFC transfers and Provincial Own-Source Receipts for FY 2025–26 are estimated at Rs. 4,890.4 billion, driven by a 10.3% increase in Federal Divisible Pool transfers and a projected 13.3% increase in tax collection by Punjab Revenue Authority, reaching Rs. 340 billion. The province's Own Source Tax Revenue is estimated to grow 11.2%, underpinned by reforms in Urban Immovable Property Tax, Agriculture Income Tax alignment with FBR, and transition to a negative list regime under Punjab Sales Tax on Services Act. Punjab's fiscal framework has also been reinforced through the continuation of Public Financial Management (PFM) reforms. Following the enactment of the Punjab PFM Act, 2022, the province institutionalized several key reforms in FY 2024-25, including elimination of circular commodity debt, introduction of a new pension framework, operationalization of the Cash Management Fund, the Grant-in-Aid Policy, and a Medium-Term Debt Strategy, to name a few. The Parametric Pension reforms are projected to reduce accrued pension liabilities to Rs. 6.385 trillion - down from an otherwise estimated Rs. 11.883 trillion - while the Defined Contribution Scheme now applies to all new entrants, introducing a funded model and easing long-term fiscal pressure, the budget document reveals. It may be added that the Grant-in-Aid Policy enforces ceilings, eligibility criteria, and performance-based disbursements to enhance accountability. The Cash Management Fund allows productive investment of idle balances, supporting non-tax revenue and surplus targets. The Medium-Term Debt Strategy guides prudent borrowing, prioritizes concessional finance, and ensures compliance with debt ceilings under the PFM Act. Collectively, these reforms mark a decisive shift toward fiscal sustainability, transparency, and rules-based public financial management. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
