Joshlin Smith case: A landmark trial in South Africa's fight against human trafficking
In powerful closing arguments on Tuesday, Senior State Advocate Zelda Swanepoel described the Joshlin Smith case as unlike any South Africa has seen before, a heartbreaking story where the victim's voice has not been heard.
The six-year-old girl went missing from her Middelpos home in Saldanha Bay on February 19, 2024.
Her mother, Racquel 'Kelly' Smith, her boyfriend, Jacquen 'Boeta' Appollis, and their friend, Steveno 'Steffie' van Rhyn, were charged with kidnapping and human trafficking.
They have pleaded not guilty.
Former accused Lourentia 'Renz' Lombaard testified that Kelly sold her daughter to a sangoma for R20 000.
Addressing the Western Cape High Court, Swanepoel explained that in most human trafficking cases, the child is recovered and can testify about what happened. But Joshlin remains missing. Her absence, Swanepoel said, makes this case unprecedented.
'Usually, in a TIP (Trafficking in Persons) case, the most important source of information is the victim,' she told the court. 'In this case, we don't have that.'
Drawing on extensive research and a recent article that she submitted as an authority, Swanepoel said that although South Africa has dealt with child trafficking before, those cases were very different.
In the past, in three matters, undercover police operations intervened before any actual harm occurred. The children were never fully handed over to criminals.
But Joshlin's situation is different.
'This is the first time we are dealing with a case where the child is truly gone,' Swanepoel emphasised. 'That is why this case is so important, not only for justice for Joshlin but also for the development of our law.'
According to the State, the evidence shows that Joshlin was sold in a planned agreement between the accused parties.
Swanepoel described this as 'modern-day slavery', the commodification of a human being for exploitation.
'A person is never supposed to be a commodity,' she argued. 'It sounds bizarre to the reasonable person that a child could be sold. But sadly, that is the reality we are facing.'
Because South African law historically had no crime specifically criminalising the selling of a person, Swanepoel explained that legislation was introduced to close this gap, following international obligations like the Palermo Protocol.
Swanepoel broke down the elements of trafficking as set out in South African law under Section 4(1) of the Prevention and Combating of Trafficking in Persons Act (PACOTIP). She explained that trafficking requires three elements:
The act - what was done,
The means - how it was done, and
The purpose - exploitation.
However, when the victim is a child, as in Joshlin's case, only two elements are required: the act and the purpose. The 'means' such as force or coercion is not necessary to prove, because children are inherently vulnerable.
'Section 11 of our legislation removes the need to prove the means when a child is trafficked,' Swanepoel said, referring the court to previous cases she had prosecuted where this principle was upheld.
Swanepoel urged the court to recognise the gravity of the allegations.
'This is a very important case, not only because of Joshlin, but because it shapes how South Africa protects its most vulnerable.'
The trial continues.
mandilakhe.tshwete@inl.co.za
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
Confronting racism in our schools
It is alleged that an Indian learner told two Black students 'You stupid Black people are so predictable.' Such language is deeply offensive, dehumanising, and has no place in any learning environment. The latest incident of alleged racism at Bryandale Primary School in Bryanston is yet another painful reminder that South African schools still have a long way to go before genuine transformation and inclusion are achieved. It is alleged that an Indian learner told two Black students, 'You stupid Black people are so predictable.' Such language is deeply offensive, dehumanising, and has no place in any learning environment. This incident must be treated with the seriousness it demands, not as a 'playground misunderstanding,' but as a reflection of wider issues of racism and marginalisation that persist in our schools. While many public and private schools proudly promote values of diversity and transformation in their mission statements, these values must go beyond lip service. Transformation is not a passive hope; it requires active, ongoing engagement and institutional introspection. Schools play a critical role in redressing the deep inequalities and marginalisation embedded in our society. They must be proactive in creating safe and affirming environments for all children, not only through symbolic gestures but through deliberate action, anti-racism training, and clear accountability mechanisms.
The South African
7 hours ago
- The South African
Man shot dead after being robbed of backpack in Inanda, KZN
A man was shot dead in Inanda, KZN, on Saturday, 21 June 2025, after being robbed of his backpack. According to Reaction Unit South Africa (RUSA), a motorist reported to the security company after witnessing two men attacking the victim with pipes. The motorist recalled that the suspects quickly fled the scene with the victim's backpack upon noticing him stop. The motorist said that he was unaware that the victim had been shot. Emergency Medical Services (EMS) were summoned to the scene and found the man unresponsive. Paramedics declared him dead after he sustained a gunshot wound to his back that went through his chest. The suspects have not been apprehended yet. Two-night shift employees at a used spare business in Hazelmere, KZN, were attacked by six armed robbers and tied up for 11 hours on Friday, 20 June 2025. The suspects covered the victims' faces and tied them up at gunpoint. RUSA explained, 'Their hands & feet were bound with belts & shoelaces. Used vehicle bumpers & body parts were then stacked on top of the victims & they were found by dayshift staff eleven (11) hours later in the same position.' The suspects stole mag rims, power tools, car body parts and other items worth thousands of rands throughout the night. According to reports, it is alleged that the leader of the gang was a Mozambican National who was an employee at the same company. The foreign national had his face covered up when the robbery was in progress. He was found in possession of the items taken during the robbery and was arrested. Additional items were discovered in various locations at a home near the Hazelmere Dam. The suspect told RUSA that his accomplices had fled the scene and were on the run. Investigations are taking place. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
The South African
9 hours ago
- The South African
'She is still alive': Joslin Smith hope renewed
The National Prosecuting Authority has renewed hope that little Joslin Smith is still alive despite being missing for over a year. The Salanha Bay girl's disappearance has sparked a national, and even international, rescue effort. Her mother, Kelly Smith, and two others – Jacquin 'Boeta' Appollis and Steveno van Rhyn – have since been convicted and sentenced for kidnapping and child trafficking. Speaking in a webinar this week, NPA prosecutor Zelda Swanepoel shared her beliefs about Joslin Smith. Earlier this month, Swapepoel helped the state to convict Joslin's mother, Kelly Smith, the latter's boyfriend, Jacquin 'Boeta' Appollis, and their pal, Steveno van Rhyn. A life sentence for trafficking and kidnapping was handed down by Western Cape High Court judge, Nathan Erasmus. She said of the search for the missing girl: 'We have done a comprehensive search in Saldanha of all the exhibits. 'Everything that was found in all of those dunes, all the bones, all the clothing, was analysed, there were no positive DNA results found on anything. She continued: 'I'm convinced that she is still alive. However, I don't know where she is. I can only hope we find her.' Will Kelly Smith ever reveal where her daughter Joslin is? The Saldanha Bay girl went missing on 19 February 2024. Images via YouTube screenshot: SABC Swanepoel added that Joslin's case was the first prosecution she had worked on where the missing child had not been found. She added that much of the case hung on the state witness Lourentia Lombaard. The NPA was also banking on the possibility that Joslin's mother would testify. 'We were always hopeful during the trial that the accused would come and testify in the main trial. The plan was to destroy their credibility and demonstrate the improbabilities in their versions. Yes, their decision to remain silent, especially Kelly, was very disappointing,' she added. Meanwhile, Joslin's mother Kelly Smith as well as Appollis and van Rhyn have filed their notices this week for leave to appeal their convictions and sentences. The NPA are also awaiting the fate of the state witness Lourentia Lombaard, whose verdict will be announced by Judge Erasmus at an appointed date. A 204 inquiry will determine if Lombaard will be granted indemnity based on her testimony. If the court does find that Lombaard did not testify truthfully, she could face prosecution for perjury and related charges. Lombaard previously stated under oath that Joslin's mother, Kelly Smith, allegedly sold her to a sangoma for R20 000. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 . Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp , Facebook , X, and Bluesky for the latest news.
