GDP figure based on old data
Listen to article
Pakistan's Chief Statistician Dr Naeemuz Zafar said Thursday that the 2.7% economic growth estimate for this fiscal year is based on a 15-year-old livestock survey and assumes full utilisation of the Rs1.1 trillion development budget.
While responding to questions about the controversy over this year's economic growth figure along with Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal, Dr Zafar claimed that there would be no major downward revision in the 2.7% figure for the outgoing fiscal year.
Iqbal also proposed a new formula for resource distribution under the National Finance Commission (NFC), moving away from the current population-centric model.
The Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS)'s chief statistician called objections to the 2.7% growth rate "unfortunate" and said if a committee is formed to investigate, the PBS is ready to appear.
The government claims a 2.7% GDP growth this year, which independent economists have disputed, estimating it to be closer to 2%. A major objection concerns the 4.8% livestock sector growth.
The livestock sector's 4.8% growth was based on a survey conducted back in 2010, admitted Dr Zafar, adding that there was no deviation from the standard methodology.
When asked how the agriculture sector showed 0.6% growth despite a 14% output decline in major crops, Dr Zafar said the growth was driven by livestock, forestry and minor crops.
The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth figure has been worked out in a transparent manner by following a methodology endorsed by the United Nations and the international financial institutions, he said.
He also confirmed a new agriculture and livestock census has been completed but awaits the planning minister's approval due to his budget commitments.
He added that the Household Integrated Economic Survey, Labour Force Survey, and agriculture census would be ready by October for the next National Accounts Committee (NAC) meeting.
Leader of the Opposition Omar Ayub Khan raised the disputed GDP issue during the National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance meeting held on Thursday.
In a statement, the statistician also stated PBS used the full Rs1.1 trillion federal Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP) figure for GDP calculationshighlighting a glaring methodological flaw.
However, Finance Secretary Imdad Ullah Bosal told the same committee that against the Rs1.1 trillion PSDP allocation, only Rs662 billion had been spent so far. He added that by June-end, spending would remain below the revised Rs967 billion figure.
When asked whether the GDP would be drastically revised in the next NAC meeting, Dr Zafar again said no major revision was expected.
Speaking at the meeting, the planning minister said the country was on a path to steady economic recovery with a goal of sustainable economic growth.
Iqbal added that Pakistan continues to face structural problems of fiscal constraints. Due to limited space, next year's federal PSDP will be just 0.8% of GDPdown from 2.6% seven years ago.
The planning minister noted that the federal government's Rs11 trillion net revenues were barely enough to cover defence and debt servicing.
"With limited tax contributions, people cannot hope for international standard facilities," said Iqbal.
He also called for reforming the NFC award by shifting away from the predominantly population-based distribution formula with broader indicators like education and forestation. Iqbal is the second federal minister after the finance minister to propose a shift in the NFC criteria this week.
Currently, 82% of total resources are allocated based on population, which Iqbal argued incentivises population growth, harming national interests.
He said the Planning Commission would recommend shifting to a broader formula that rewards education and forest preservation.
Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, he added, has decided to constitute a Pakistan Population Council, comprising provincial chief ministers, to design strategies for population control.
Pakistan's annual population growth rate stands at 2.6% — nearly equal to this year's GDP growth rate.
Responding to a question whether the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) took him into confidence before imposing taxes on the digital economy, Iqbal said these were levied with the intent to create a level playing field for conventional retailers.
Commenting on the upcoming PSDP, Iqbal said Rs230 billion had been allocated for Balochistan projects from the Rs1 trillion envelope. Despite limited resources, the government would invest more in water reservoirs.
He said Diamer Basha Dam with 6 million acre-feet capacity and Mohmand Dam with 1 million acre-feet would be completed by 2030 to mitigate water shortages caused by potential Indian efforts to block Pakistan's share of water.
Iqbal added that construction of Diamer Basha Dam would be advanced by two years with increased investment, aiming for completion by 2030 in response to regional water developments.
Due to budget constraints, funding for the Higher Education Commission (HEC) has been reduced to Rs39.5 billion. Iqbal suggested provinces should bear the responsibility of funding universities.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
35 minutes ago
- Business Recorder
PTI questions PBS figures
ISLAMABAD: The Opposition Leader in National Assembly Omar Ayub on Friday severely criticised the government, accusing it of relying on what he called 'outdated and unreliable' statistical data – warning that such practices were eroding evidence-based policymaking and stalling economic progress. Talking to journalists following a meeting with World Bank officials and a briefing by Commerce Ministry on tariff-related issues, he expressed serious concerns over the credibility of figures published by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS), citing glaring inconsistencies. Referring to the recently released Economic Survey of Pakistan, he described many of the indicators as 'absurd,' claiming the figures were 'fudged, fabricated, and misleading.' PTI warns oil reserves may run out in 10-12 days He took particular aim at the livestock data, which he said epitomised the flawed nature of PBS reporting. 'The way PBS claims to collect data on the increase in livestock numbers defies logic,' he remarked. 'It lays bare the absurdity of the data driving our national economic policies.' During the Commerce Ministry's briefing, he said that the opposition MPs grilled officials over the reliability of the statistics underpinning country's trade policies. He argued that obsolete metrics were distorting sectoral analysis, especially in agriculture, where livestock accounts for 64 per cent of data. This, he said, grossly skewed the broader economic picture. 'Our regional competitors are racing ahead with real-time data and modern analytics, but we're still stuck in the past. A 21st-century economy cannot run on 20th-century statistics,' he regretted. He went on to claim that tariff mechanisms had been better managed under the previous Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) government – a point he said was implicitly acknowledged by some current officials during the briefing. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
35 minutes ago
- Business Recorder
SPI-based inflation up 0.27pc
ISLAMABAD: The Sensitive Price Index (SPI)-based inflation for the week ended June 19, 2025 registered an increase of 0.27 per cent owing to an escalation in the prices of liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) 14.86 per cent, potatoes 3.75 per cent, diesel 3.10 per cent, gur 2.25 per cent, chicken 2.17 per cent, sugar 2.13 per cent, petrol 1.88 per cent, mustard oil 1.12 per cent, powdered milk 0.97 per cent, rice basmati broken 0.84 per cent, cooked daal 0.68 per cent, and tea prepared 0.39 per cent. The SPI data released here on Friday by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) on year-on-year (YoY) depicted a decrease of 2.06 owing to decrease in the prices of onions 63.22 per cent, tomatoes 56.11 per cent, electricity charges for Q1 41.63 per cent, garlic 32.58 per cent, maash 19.09 per cent, potatoes 17.97per cent, tea Lipton 17.93 per cent, wheat flour 14.16 per cent, chicken six per cent, masoor 5.87 per cent, rice IRRI-6/9 witnessed a reduction of 4.47per cent and chilies powder 3.86 per cent. Weekly SPI up by 0.02pc While on YoY major increase was observed in the prices of ladies sandal 55.62 per cent, moong 28.90 per cent, sugar 26.19 per cent, powdered milk 25.93 per cent, LPG 21.77 per cent eggs 17.90 per cent, beef 15.74 per cent, vegetable ghee 2.5kg 13 per cent, vegetable ghee 1kg 12.73 per cent), bananas 12.47 per cent, gur 10.85 per cent, firewood 10.80per cent and cooked daal 10.64 per cent. On the other hand, a decrease is observed in the prices of eggs (9.53 per cent), tomatoes (5.62 per cent), garlic (1.03 per cent), pulse gram (0.35 per cent), vegetable ghee 2.5kg (0.17 per cent), cooking oil 5 litre (0.03 per cent) and bananas and firewood (0.01 per cent) each. During the week, out of 51 items, prices of 23 (45.10 per cent) items increased, eight (15.69 per cent) items decreased and 20 (39.21 per cent) items remained stable. The SPI for the lowest consumption group with monthly income up to Rs17,732 witnessed an increase of 0.05 per cent and was recorded at 299.50 points from previous week's 299.40 points. The SPI for consumption groups of Rs17,732 to 22,888 with an increase of 0.05 per cent was recorded at 295.36 against previous week's calculation of 295.20, the SPI for the income group Rs22,889-29,517 with an increase of 0.10per cent was recorded at 320.05 points against previous week's recording of 319.72 points, the SPI for the income group Rs29,518-44,175 with an increase of 0.13 per cent was recorded at 310.88 points against previous week's reading of 310.47 and SPI for the monthly income group above Rs44,175 recorded an increase of 0.42 per cent from 313.60points to 312.29. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
43 minutes ago
- Express Tribune
Fuel and food items lift SPI by 0.27%
The Sensitive Price Indicator for week ending July 14 showed an increase of 16.13 per cent compared to the same week last year. PHOTO: FILE Listen to article The Sensitive Price Indicator (SPI) for the week ended June 19, 2025 recorded an increase of 0.27% compared to the previous week, driven by higher prices of key food and energy items, according to data released by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS). Notable weekly increases were seen in liquefied petroleum gas (LPG, up 14.86%), potatoes (3.75%), diesel (3.10%), gur (2.25%), chicken (2.17%), sugar (2.13%), petrol (1.88%), mustard oil (1.12%), powdered milk (0.97%), broken Basmati rice (0.84%), cooked daal (0.68%) and prepared tea (0.39%). Conversely, prices declined for eggs (-9.53%), tomatoes (-5.62%), garlic (-1.03%), pulse gram (-0.35%), 2.5kg vegetable ghee (-0.17%), five-litre cooking oil (-0.03%) and bananas and firewood (-0.01% each). Out of 51 essential items monitored across 50 markets in 17 cities, prices of 23 items rose, eight fell and 20 remained unchanged. On a year-on-year (YoY) basis, the SPI showed a decrease of 2.06%, with major drops in prices of onions (-63.22%), tomatoes (-56.11%), electricity charges for Q1 (-41.63%), garlic (-32.58%), pulse mash (-19.09%) and potatoes (-17.97%). However, significant annual increases were recorded in ladies' sandals (+55.62%), pulse moong (+28.90%), sugar (+26.19%), powdered milk (+25.93%) and LPG (+21.77%). The weekly SPI serves as a key tool to gauge short-term price movements in essential commodities and to monitor inflationary trends across the country. The SPI has shown mixed trends in recent weeks, with slight fluctuations influenced by petroleum price revisions and market demand dynamics. After experiencing declines earlier in May, the SPI has been gradually inching upwards since late May, indicating renewed inflationary pressures in both food and energy segments, according to data compiled by Optimus Capital Management. Market observers suggest that the coming weeks may witness further volatility depending on global commodity prices and domestic supply conditions. The Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) noted that inflation was expected to trend up and stabilise in the target range during FY26. JS Global Research Head Muhammad Waqas Ghani noted that following a 3.5% YoY increase in May 2025, the monthly Consumer Price Index (CPI) was expected to stand at 3.1% in June. The base effect is now fading, signalling a return to normalised price trends. This will take the FY25 average to 4.6%, down from the FY24 average of 23.9%. Food inflation for June 2025 is expected to rise 2.8% on a YoY basis, which was 0.97% last year, owing to the dissipation of base effect. Nevertheless, price decreases in certain food items are likely to lead to a month-on-month (MoM) decline in food inflation. Housing, gas and electricity segment is projected to post a 4% YoY decline in June, primarily due to a reduction in electricity tariffs. Core inflation is expected to clock in around 8.5% YoY in June 2025. It is pertinent to note that core inflation, which excludes food and energy items, has remained around 9-10% for the past many months. Urban core inflation was registered at 7.3% in May while rural core inflation was reported at 8.8%.
