PTI questions PBS figures
ISLAMABAD: The Opposition Leader in National Assembly Omar Ayub on Friday severely criticised the government, accusing it of relying on what he called 'outdated and unreliable' statistical data – warning that such practices were eroding evidence-based policymaking and stalling economic progress.
Talking to journalists following a meeting with World Bank officials and a briefing by Commerce Ministry on tariff-related issues, he expressed serious concerns over the credibility of figures published by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS), citing glaring inconsistencies.
Referring to the recently released Economic Survey of Pakistan, he described many of the indicators as 'absurd,' claiming the figures were 'fudged, fabricated, and misleading.'
PTI warns oil reserves may run out in 10-12 days
He took particular aim at the livestock data, which he said epitomised the flawed nature of PBS reporting. 'The way PBS claims to collect data on the increase in livestock numbers defies logic,' he remarked. 'It lays bare the absurdity of the data driving our national economic policies.'
During the Commerce Ministry's briefing, he said that the opposition MPs grilled officials over the reliability of the statistics underpinning country's trade policies. He argued that obsolete metrics were distorting sectoral analysis, especially in agriculture, where livestock accounts for 64 per cent of data. This, he said, grossly skewed the broader economic picture.
'Our regional competitors are racing ahead with real-time data and modern analytics, but we're still stuck in the past. A 21st-century economy cannot run on 20th-century statistics,' he regretted.
He went on to claim that tariff mechanisms had been better managed under the previous Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) government – a point he said was implicitly acknowledged by some current officials during the briefing.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
6 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Weekly inflation in Pakistan up 0.27%
ISLAMABAD: The Sensitive Price Index (SPI)-based inflation for the week ended June 19, 2025 registered an increase of 0.27 per cent owing to an escalation in the prices of liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) 14.86 per cent, potatoes 3.75 per cent, diesel 3.10 per cent, gur 2.25 per cent, chicken 2.17 per cent, sugar 2.13 per cent, petrol 1.88 per cent, mustard oil 1.12 per cent, powdered milk 0.97 per cent, rice basmati broken 0.84 per cent, cooked daal 0.68 per cent, and tea prepared 0.39 per cent. The SPI data released here on Friday by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) on year-on-year (YoY) depicted a decrease of 2.06 owing to decrease in the prices of onions 63.22 per cent, tomatoes 56.11 per cent, electricity charges for Q1 41.63 per cent, garlic 32.58 per cent, maash 19.09 per cent, potatoes 17.97per cent, tea Lipton 17.93 per cent, wheat flour 14.16 per cent, chicken six per cent, masoor 5.87 per cent, rice IRRI-6/9 witnessed a reduction of 4.47per cent and chilies powder 3.86 per cent. Weekly SPI up by 0.02pc While on YoY major increase was observed in the prices of ladies sandal 55.62 per cent, moong 28.90 per cent, sugar 26.19 per cent, powdered milk 25.93 per cent, LPG 21.77 per cent eggs 17.90 per cent, beef 15.74 per cent, vegetable ghee 2.5kg 13 per cent, vegetable ghee 1kg 12.73 per cent), bananas 12.47 per cent, gur 10.85 per cent, firewood 10.80per cent and cooked daal 10.64 per cent. On the other hand, a decrease is observed in the prices of eggs (9.53 per cent), tomatoes (5.62 per cent), garlic (1.03 per cent), pulse gram (0.35 per cent), vegetable ghee 2.5kg (0.17 per cent), cooking oil 5 litre (0.03 per cent) and bananas and firewood (0.01 per cent) each. During the week, out of 51 items, prices of 23 (45.10 per cent) items increased, eight (15.69 per cent) items decreased and 20 (39.21 per cent) items remained stable. The SPI for the lowest consumption group with monthly income up to Rs17,732 witnessed an increase of 0.05 per cent and was recorded at 299.50 points from previous week's 299.40 points. The SPI for consumption groups of Rs17,732 to 22,888 with an increase of 0.05 per cent was recorded at 295.36 against previous week's calculation of 295.20, the SPI for the income group Rs22,889-29,517 with an increase of 0.10per cent was recorded at 320.05 points against previous week's recording of 319.72 points, the SPI for the income group Rs29,518-44,175 with an increase of 0.13 per cent was recorded at 310.88 points against previous week's reading of 310.47 and SPI for the monthly income group above Rs44,175 recorded an increase of 0.42 per cent from 313.60points to 312.29. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
6 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan budget for 2025-26 to consolidate economic gains, NA told
ISLAMABAD: Amid criticism from opposition lawmakers, Minister of State for Finance Bilal Azhar Kayani on Friday said that the budget is aimed at further consolidating economic gains, providing relief to the people, and continuing the reform process. He said the reforms would also extend to tax fraud investigations, with new safeguards to prevent arbitrary arrests. Under the new policy, arrests during investigations would only occur in cases of sales tax fraud exceeding Rs50 million, and only after approval from a three-member Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) panel. The opposition lawmakers; however, sharply criticised the budget, saying it lacked vision and heavily favoured the handful elite. They decried the increase in allocations to the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP), which rose from Rs592 billion to Rs716 billion, arguing it came at the expense of education, whose allocation remains comparatively low. PTI says 'federal budget favours elite, ignores masses' The opposition also slammed what they termed a symbolic 10 percent salary raise for government employees and a seven percent hike in pensions for retired government employees. They noted the budget failed to increase the minimum wage, allegedly due to pressure from industrialists. The Finance Ministry did announce some tax relief for salaried individuals, a promise previously made by Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif. But opposition members ridiculed the tax relief for those earning above Rs1.2 million annually, calling it a 'cruel joke.' At the outset of the session, Federal Minister for Finance Muhammad Aurangzeb laid four Statutory Regulatory Orders (SROs) before the House, issued under the Customs Act and Income Tax Ordinance. He confirmed to the speaker that he would conclude the budget debate on Monday. Several lawmakers belonging to both opposition and treasury participated in the ongoing debate on the Finance Bill for 2025-26, voicing a wide range of concerns and suggestions. Pakistan People's Party (PPP) MNA Nafeesa Shah called for greater support to the agriculture sector. Saba Talpur echoed this sentiment, urging the government to cut prices of seeds, fertilisers, and pesticides to support farmers. Junaid Akbar Khan of PTI said the budget had nothing for the people and called attention to sacrifices made by Khyber Pakhtunkhwa in the war on terror. Agha Rafiullah of PPP demanded that the government review proposed family pension reforms and remove limitations affecting spouses and disabled children. Sahibzada Hamid Raza of SIC criticised the apparent neglect of health and education sectors in the budget. Minister for Religious Affairs Muhammad Yousaf described the budget as balanced and praised the government's handling of Hajj arrangements, noting that over 115,000 Pakistani pilgrims participated this year. Saudi Arabia awarded Pakistan for its management, and planning for next year's pilgrimage has already begun, he added. Qaiser Ahmed Sheikh, Minister for the Board of Investment, said macroeconomic indicators were improving, with inflation falling and remittances rising. He urged all political parties to agree on a Charter of Economy to attract investors. Minister for Public Affairs Rana Mubashir Iqbal said Rs250 billion had been allocated for Balochistan, including Rs100 billion for road infrastructure and further allocations for dams, agriculture, energy, education, and health. Minister of State for Religious Affairs and Interfaith Harmony Kesoo Mal Kheal Das stressed that no new taxes had been imposed on agriculture and reaffirmed the government's commitment to completing the Sukkur-Karachi motorway. Murtaza Mahmud lauded the government's steps toward economic stability, while Pullain Baloch called for tax relief for the public. Law Minister Azam Nazeer Tarar reiterated Pakistan's stance against Israeli aggression – whether in Gaza, Lebanon, Iran, or elsewhere – stating that the country will continue to oppose and condemn such actions. Other lawmakers who took part in the debate included Fayyaz Hussain, Azimuddin Zahid, Shaharyar Khan Mahar, Osama Sarwar, Noor Alam, Farah Naz and Zulfiqar Ali, Zahra Wadood. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
8 hours ago
- Business Recorder
PTI counsel says no time violation in 15-day window for independents
ISLAMABAD: The counsel of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) asserted that there is no violation of time-line in the majority judgment by granting 15 days to the 41 independents to join the PTI. The judgment of eight judges in reserved seats has straight way declared that 39 independents, out of 80, were PTI candidates, while for 41 candidates laid down the mechanism for their joining the PTI. Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail and the ex-CJP Qazi Faez also ruled that 39 independents, who in their nomination paper mentioned PTI, are the PTI MNAs. Justice Yahya Afridi also had similar view. Salman Akram Raja, representing the PTI, said that 11 judges had accepted the reality that injustice was caused to the PTI candidates in the general elections 2024. Defending the majority judgment, he argued that 15 days were given to 41 candidates to inform that on February 8, 2024 of which party they were member, and not to join a political party, adding the majority judgment did not give relief to the PTI, but to the people of Pakistan. An 11-member Constitutional Bench, headed by Justice Aminuddin Khan, on Friday, heard the review petitions of Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), Pakistan Peoples' Party (PPP) and the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP). The proceeding was live-streamed on SC's YouTube channel. During the proceeding, Justice Musarrat Hilali questioned why did Hamid Raza, who is chairman of Sunni Ittehad Council (SIC), contested election as an independent candidate. Raja clarified that Hamid Raza in his nomination form instead of independent wrote the PTI-SIC alliance. Justice Mandokhail asked Raja that if his argument is accepted then 11 judges' judgment was wrong, and review should have been filed by the SIC rather than the ECP, the PML-N and the PPP. He said the Court cannot compel anyone to join such and such political party. Justice Hilali also questioned whether voting is the fundamental rights? Her objection was that after birth a person does not have voting right automatically, rather he had to wait till the age of 18 years. Justice Baqar Ali Najafi said right of vote is subject to the law and a person can cast vote after attaining the age of 18, and he/she polls vote only when there are elections in his/her constituency. Justice Najafi observed that there had been constitution deviation and the fundamental rights were violated in the past as well. He inquired from Raja what deviation did he see in the last elections, adding if the elections were non transparent and fair then why not the entire process of general elections 2024 declared null and void. Raja responded that instead of striking down the elections the Court laid down the mechanism to rectify the wrongs committed. He submitted that in the past whenever the constitutional scheme was violated or deviated the apex court played its role to bring the situation back to normal, adding if the matter is of general public and the fundamental rights then it can invoke the jurisdiction under Article 184(3) and Article 187 of the constitution, and under these provisions it has much greater and wider power. Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar did not agree with him and said the High Court under Article 199 has greater power than the Supreme Court as it has power of habeas corpus and quo warran to. Raja also contended that there was no issue that the election symbol was taken, but the worst thing happened was that the PTI was derecognised, the candidates were told that if they would write PTI in their nomination forms then those would not be accepted and forced them to write independent in the nomination papers. The violation was committed by the ECP under Article 51 of the constitution that a party was not recognised and its candidates were not allowed to contest election on PTI ticket. These things completely destroyed the sanctity of the elections, he added. The PTI lawyer argued that the reason for joining the SIC was that they had the precedent of Balochistan Awami Party (BAP), which neither contested elections nor had any seat in the Assemblies despite that reserved seats were allocated to it. Earlier, Raja argued that review petitions could be filed if some facts or provisions of law are overlooked, while the erroneous judgment is no ground for review. Similarly, no technical aspect comes in the way to challenge the judgment in review jurisdiction. He contended that a party has to establish that the fact or provision of law was overlooked. The case is adjourned until Monday (June 23). Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
