Chandigarh's slum demolitions: Urban order or displacement dilemma?
When Chandigarh was envisioned by Le Corbusier and his team in the 1950s, it was meant to embody a vision of organised, humane living—free from the chaotic sprawl of older Indian cities. Yet seventy years later, the city's ongoing issues with informal settlements, and their recent demolition, reveal the persistent gap between idealistic planning and the messy, evolving realities of how cities actually grow.
In recent weeks, Chandigarh witnessed a wave of demolitions targeting slum clusters, particularly in Sector 25 and parts of Dhanas. The drive, undertaken by local authorities following high court orders, displaced hundreds of families. The situation calls for an analytical look—at planning intentions, legal mandates, and the pathways Chandigarh must now consider if it wishes to remain both a model city and a compassionate one.
The planning ethos & its frictions
Chandigarh's original master plan was rooted in ideals of functionality, hierarchy of movement, and clear segregation of spaces based on land use and income group. The city included earmarked zones for economically weaker sections (EWS), with modestly designed homes meant to accommodate essential service providers—those whose labour was indispensable to the functioning of the city.
However, over time, the influx of migrants far outpaced the capacities envisioned in the original blueprint. Many of these migrants arrived in search of construction jobs, domestic work, or informal trade opportunities but found formal housing either unaffordable or entirely unavailable. As a result, informal settlements gradually took shape along the city's margins, often occupying vacant parcels of government land.
The emergence of these settlements highlighted a fundamental mismatch between Chandigarh's rigid, top-down planning model and the dynamic, improvisational nature of real human settlement. Despite repeated attempts at relocation and rehabilitation through schemes like the EWS Housing Plan and the Chandigarh Small Flats Scheme, the cycle of encroachment and eviction continued. The latest demolitions are not a new chapter, but rather a continuation—one shaped by decades of unresolved urban pressures.
Demolitions: Legal frameworks vs human realities
The recent eviction operations were carried out under directives from the Punjab and Haryana high court, which emphasised the need to clear unauthorised constructions from public lands. Authorities justified the action on the grounds of city aesthetics, public safety, and the right to planned development.
From a legal standpoint, the demolitions are consistent with principles of planned urbanism and the safeguarding of government-owned land. Chandigarh's unique status as a Union Territory gives its administration direct accountability to the central government, increasing pressure to comply strictly with judicial directives.
Yet from a human and sociological lens, the situation becomes far more layered. Many of those evicted had lived in these areas for years—sometimes decades—contributing to Chandigarh's labor force and social infrastructure. Voter ID cards, ration cards, and other official documentation had, in many cases, validated their presence and blurred the line between illegal occupation and de facto residence.
While the administration stated that eligible residents would be considered for rehabilitation under existing welfare schemes, ground reports suggest that many were left homeless with little notice. The absence of immediate alternative housing or livelihood options raises difficult questions about the ethics and effectiveness of implementation—especially when legal justification exists but humane execution falters.
A case for inclusive urbanism
As Chandigarh continues to expand its infrastructure and economic ambitions, it must confront a deeper, more existential question: who gets to claim space in the 'City Beautiful'?
There is an urgent need for policy frameworks that recognise informal urbanism not just as a problem to be erased, but as a reality to be understood and integrated. Planned cities may begin with geometry and order, but they endure through the lives that unfold within them.
Future strategies might include in-situ upgrades, development of affordable rental housing, and participatory planning models that center the voices of the marginalised. Chandigarh now has a chance to evolve from blueprint to belonging—a shift that honours both its legacy and its future.
aashna.gakhar@gmail.com
(The writer is a Chandigarh-based architect & interior designer)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
British F-35B Fighter Jet Remains Stranded In Kerala A Week After Emergency Landing. What's Next
A British F-35B Lightning II stealth fighter jet remains stranded at Kerala's Thiruvananthapuram airport, one week after an emergency landing due to low fuel reserves. Part of the UK's Carrier Strike Group, the aircraft had just wrapped up joint Indo-Pacific naval drills with the Indian Navy when it requested urgent clearance to land. While it was successfully refueled by the Indian Air Force, a hydraulic system failure grounded the aircraft during its planned return. Despite a UK Navy maintenance team's efforts, the fifth-generation stealth jet remains non-operational. Now, Lockheed Martin engineers are being dispatched from the US to resolve the issue. If on-site repairs fail, transportation via military cargo plane is being considered. This rare international military incident on Indian soil has drawn global attention — especially involving such a highly classified and advanced jet system.#f35 #uknavy #kerala #f35strandedinkerala #ukfighterjetindia #britishf35kerala #stealthjetfail #defencenews2025 #lockheedmartin #toi #toibharat #bharat #breakingnews #indianews Read More
India Gazette
2 hours ago
- India Gazette
Yoga brings balance, helps deal with stress: Delhi Haj Committee chief
New Delhi [India],June 21 (ANI): Delhi Haj Committee Chairperson Kausar Jahan on Saturday joined 11th International Yoga Day celebrations in the national capital and said the anincient Indian practice helps in mental and physical well-being. She lauded efforts of Prime Minister Narendra Modi in popularising yoga all over the world. 'Due to Prime Minister Modi's efforts, the United Nations declared June 21 as International Yoga Day. Yoga brings balance and helps remove stress. It provides wholistic view for health,' Kausar Jahan told ANI. Prime Minister Narendra Modi led the main national event on the 11th International Yoga Day from Visakhapatnam. He extended warm greetings to people across India and the world on International Yoga Day, highlighting that this year marks the 11th occasion when the world has come together on June 21 to practice yoga collectively. He remarked that the essence of yoga is 'to unite', and it is heartening to see how yoga has united the world. Reflecting on the journey of Yoga over the past decade, PM Modi recalled the moment when India proposed the idea of International Yoga Day at the United Nations. He noted that 175 countries supported the proposal, a rare instance of such wide global unity. He emphasised that the support was not merely for a proposal but represented a collective effort by the world for the greater good of humanity. 'Eleven years on, yoga has become an integral part of the lifestyle of millions across the globe', he added. Meanwhile, 2121 participants held the cobra pose for two minutes and nine seconds while performing yoga in Gujarat's Vadnagar on Saturday and created a Guinness World Record. According to Richard Stunning, official adjudicator at Guinness World Records, a recordfor the most people performing the cobra pose in yoga began on Saturday. 'The Guinness World Records title that starts today is the most people performing the cobra pose in yoga, simultaneously. We set a guideline that everyone had to do it for at least a minute each, and we set a minimum target of 250 participants. Today, they did it for more than a minute, they did it for two minutes and nine seconds, and the total was 2185. We had to discount 64 participants. So the confirmed title is 2121 participants. Given we set a minimum of 250, this is smashing the Guinness World Record. Congratulations to everyone involved, and it's a fantastic achievement', Richard Stunning told ANI. (ANI)
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
No decision on hangar facility for Royal Air Force's stranded F-35
Even as the F-35B fighter jet of the United Kingdom government remained grounded at Thiruvananthapuram International Airport for over a week, there is no clarity on when the fighter jet will depart or when its 'technical glitches' will be fixed. Interestingly, all the details of the fifth-generation stealth fighter jet, including the circumstances that led to the emergency landing, its prolonged stay in Thiruvananthapuram, and the nature of glitches it arguably developed during emergency landing, are protected and not disclosed by any of the agencies. Interestingly, the Indian Air Force (IAF), which facilitated the emergency landing of the aircraft for flight safety reasons and has been providing all necessary support for the rectification and subsequent return of the aircraft, has been maintaining that the combat jet was of the Royal Navy. The Central Industrial Security Force (CISF), which provided the security cover for the jet soon after the emergency landing, was terming it a Royal Navy fighter jet. However, it turns out that the fighter belongs to the Royal Air Force of the United Kingdom, not the Royal Navy. It had to seek an emergency landing due to adverse weather conditions over the Arabian Sea. Work is under way to repair and recover the aircraft to HMS Prince of Wales (the aircraft carrier of the U.K. deployed in the Indian Ocean), with the support of the Indian authorities. Various agencies in India have been maintaining that the jet, operating from HMS Prince of Wales, was undertaking routine flying outside the Indian Air Defence Identification Zone, with Thiruvananthapuram earmarked as the emergency recovery airfield, on the night of June 14. However, the weather turned rough in the Indian Ocean, making it difficult for the fighter jet to land on the aircraft carrier. It then had to request an emergency landing here as it was running on low fuel. However, the U.K. agencies didn't mention anything about the low fuel onboard the aircraft during the time of the emergency landing. Although The Hindu tried to obtain the details of the munitions on the aircraft, both the agencies in India and the U.K. refused to disclose the details. Meanwhile, an expert team from the U.K. is expected to reach here soon to attend to the aircraft, which has been parked on bay number 4 near the domestic terminal. Though a discussion was under way to make use of the hangar facility at the airport, a final decision on this would be taken only after the expert team from the U.K. inspects the aircraft, said sources. Made by the U.S.-based Lockheed Martin and used by key NATO allies, F-35B is one of the most advanced fighter jets in service globally, which is known for its short take-off and vertical landing.
