IBC's weak spot: Slow, difficult recovery from dubious pre-bankruptcy deals
New Delhi: Companies on the brink of collapse tend to do certain transactions that benefit the promoters or close partners but are detrimental to the organization and its creditors. While such 'dubious transactions' can later be set aside during bankruptcy proceedings by tribunals, getting the money back is proving an uphill task.
Data from regulator Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) reviewed by Mint showed that in FY25, just ₹1,322 crore or a tenth of the amount involved in 'avoidance transactions' disposed of by tribunals were recovered. And overall, just 12% of the ₹65,650 crore worth voidable deals executed by promoters and management of 368 companies–and where tribunals have given their verdict–were recovered, according to IBBI.
Such deals could include paying off a friendly creditor just before bankruptcy proceedings while ignoring others, moving assets to related parties or hiding them, selling assets for less than they're worth, or taking loans on unfair or excessive terms.
Also read | A series of court orders changed bankruptcy rules. Now, the govt is amending the law
'There is often misconduct by earlier management pre-insolvency and it might be a reason for the insolvency in some cases," said Dhananjay Kumar, partner (head-insolvency and restructuring) at law firm Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas. 'Recovery of such amounts is a fundamental function of a law like IBC (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code)," added Kumar.
Other challenges pointed out by Kumar include lack of data to challenge these transactions, lack of funds with resolution professionals, and slow movement in National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT).
The matter assumes significance because money recovered from dubious transactions adds to the pool of resources available for a corporate restructure plan. According to IBBI's estimates, on a conservative scale, a decision on avoidance transactions by tribunals would add recovery to creditors by at least 10%.
Yogendra Aldak, partner at Lakshmikumaran and Sridharan Attorneys, said the high amounts being flagged as avoidance transactions highlight an alarming trend of promoters deliberately using such transactions 'to deprive a company of its resources for self-serving purposes leading to a snowball effect during times of stress".
Read this | Scrapping a key bankruptcy rule may yield faster liquidation, better recovery
Further, Aldak said IBC has not been designed as a debt-recovery machine and, instead, prioritises resolution of distressed companies. So, to avoid delays in rescuing businesses, taking decisions on avoidance transactions has been kept independent of corporate debt resolution.
However, this makes it hard to recover money from avoidance transactions. For example, only deals made within two years before the insolvency process can be reviewed, which means many questionable transactions are never examined, Aldak explained. Another problem, he said, is tracking the money, as it is often moved through shell companies or hidden in other countries, making recovery even harder.
Anisha Jhunjhunwala, senior consultant-IBC at NPV Insolvency Professionals Pvt. Ltd, said that despite clear evidence, enforcing clawbacks from avoidance transactions is a lengthy legal battle, with promoters delaying proceedings through litigation, and tracing diverted assets is complex, especially when routed through layers of related entities or parked overseas.
Also read | NCLT member crunch slows down bankruptcy resolution
'The high quantum of flagged transactions reflects serious lapses and, in some cases, wilful misconduct by promoters, particularly during the twilight period before insolvency," said Jhunjhunwala. 'It shows that promoters, anticipating distress, often prioritize asset stripping over stakeholder interest, highlighting the need for stricter pre-insolvency oversight and faster adjudication timelines."
The fact that it often takes considerable time for a bankruptcy petition by a creditor to be admitted in a tribunal only allows more time for such unscrupulous activities to take place.
Till the end of March 2025, close to 1,200 bankrupt enterprises have been restructured under IBC and their creditors got the chance to recover ₹3.89 trillion or about a third of their admitted claims. This is in addition to proceeds from companies liquidated and the recoveries made by lenders who struck settlement deals with corporate borrowers before tribunals initiated insolvency proceedings.
And read | Bankruptcy resolution professionals face creditor fury as cases reach courts
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
34 minutes ago
- Mint
Japan's BeyondNext plans $50 million India fund to back deeptech, AI, semiconductor startups
Japanese venture capital firm BeyondNext Ventures, which focuses on deeptech and deep science startups, plans to raise a $50 million fund to back more Indian ventures, a top company executive said. The firm's rationale is threefold: investing in companies with a strong go-to-market focus, investing in Indians across the world, and bringing these businesses to Japan, where larger conglomerates can act as distribution partners. 'We think of India as a place where there are enormous tailwinds and tonnes of young entrepreneurs," Jay Krishnan, head of India investments at BeyondNext Ventures, told Mint in an interview. 'We want to enable those tailwinds, both from a policy and risk conversion side, and bring them to Japan." BeyondNext entered India in 2019, when it backed 14 startups using capital from its $100 million second fund. 'Back then, the idea was to get a taste, get some exposure. Now, we've decided to go full hog in India," Krishnan said. Also Read | How AI is transforming the role of venture capital for startups Japanese VCs are looking more closely at the Indian startup ecosystem. Clean energy startup Aerem raised about $12 million from Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation earlier this year. In November last year, Sumitomo's Asia fund was part of a $35 million funding round in mortgage-tech startup Easy. In July last year, mobility manufacturer Suzuki launched its first India-focused ₹340 crore fund to tap startups working in agriculture, financial inclusion, supply chain and mobility. BeyondNext is fundraising at the moment and will set aside 50% of the fund for 20 to 25 investments in the first five years of the 10-year fund. In the next five years, it will deploy the remaining capital for winners from the India portfolio, reserving $1 million for a pre-Series A cheque and another $1 million for follow-on investments. Bullish on semiconductors The firm will enter companies at the pre-seed stage and is offering cheques that start at $250,000 and go up to $2 million. 'We don't want to do Series A for these startups – we'd rather make them discoverable and visible to investors who come in at that stage," said Krishnan. Also Read | India's venture capital firms are finding that leaner might be better For the India-focused fund, BeyondNext said it is very bullish on the semiconductor industry, specifically startups that are able to disrupt the value chain in the sector. Additionally, the firm is evaluating startups in biotech, space and artificial intelligence. 'We're also eager about anything that has a local/contextualised play where the market is big enough that once they crack India, they can go anywhere," Krishnan said. The firm plans to bring its Japanese deeptech playbook to India. BeyondNext runs an incubation programme called BRAVE, where it matches scientists and researchers with ideas that could become startups with business-facing talent. The programme has yielded 52 ventures, according to BeyondNext's website. Also Read | End of FOMO: Venture capital firms turn cautious over AI startup hype; demand models with clear returns and impact 'We prefer two or three founders where the shortcomings of one are mitigated by someone else," said Krishnan. Some of BeyondNext's previous investments in India include GigIndia, which was acquired by PhonePe in 2022, medical crowdfunding platform ImpactGuru, daycare surgery aggregator Medfin, and low-code digital therapeutics SaaS platform Wellthy Therapeutics.
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
Queen's University Belfast appoints Professor M Satish Kumar first Dean of India campus
Queen's University Belfast (QUB) has announced the appointment of Professor M Satish Kumar as the first Dean of its upcoming international campus in Gujarat International Finance Tec-City (GIFT City), India. Prof Kumar will assume his role in July 2025 and will be based in GIFT City, where he will provide academic leadership across disciplines as the university prepares to launch its India campus. The GIFT City campus is expected to welcome its first cohort of students in early 2026. As the first UK Russell Group university to establish a presence in GIFT City, QUB's expansion is part of a broader strategy to enhance global engagement and foster long-term partnerships with Indian academic institutions, industry stakeholders, and government bodies. According to a statement from the university, Prof Kumar has been associated with QUB for over 25 years, having served in the School of Natural and Built Environment. He also led Queen's Academy India and held the position of Director of Internationalisation, where he contributed to strengthening the university's outreach and collaborations in South Asia. He has previously held visiting professorships at Banaras Hindu University in Varanasi, Jawaharlal Nehru University in New Delhi, and the University of Calcutta in Kolkata. The GIFT City campus will begin with a portfolio of five postgraduate programmes aligned with the demands of the Indian economy. These programmes are being designed to cater to sector-specific skills and will form the core academic offering during the initial phase of operations. QUB will announce the names of academic staff responsible for programme delivery in the coming months. Queen's University Belfast's expansion into India reflects a broader trend in transnational education, with increasing academic and institutional collaborations between the UK and India. The establishment of the GIFT City campus aligns with national policies encouraging international branch campuses and is expected to contribute to both educational and economic development in the region.
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Is lifestyle inflation fuelling debt among India's middle class?
The paycheque is bigger, but the wallet feels thinner. Across urban India, many salaried professionals are earning more than they did five years ago, yet they're still anxious at the end of each month, juggling EMIs, credit card bills, and shrinking culprit isn't just stagnant salaries or rising costs. It's what personal finance experts call lifestyle inflation—the quiet, creeping habit of spending more as you earn it's starting to show up in debt IS LIFESTYLE INFLATION? Lifestyle inflation refers to the tendency to increase spending in line with income growth. A salary hike often triggers upgrades: a bigger house, a newer car, fancier gadgets, or more frequent eating out. But these expenses can quickly outpace actual earning power if not kept in check.'It's a major concern,' says Abhishek Kumar, SEBI-registered investment advisor and founder of SahajMoney. 'Even professionals earning substantial salaries are left with limited disposable income. As their income grows, so do their expenses, often faster than the income itself.'Over time, this pattern erodes financial flexibility. A higher salary that once promised upward mobility ends up funding short-term gratification and long-term liabilities.A SALARY HIKE, FOLLOWED BY AN EMIWith every job switch or annual raise, many professionals slide into bigger EMIs and costlier routines. But when those income jumps are modest, the math doesn't hold. 'High earners are increasingly falling into what I call the 'new middle class.' They earn well but feel stretched every month,' says Now, Pay Later (BNPL) schemes, no-cost EMIs, and credit card offers make it easier than ever to overspend. 'These products change behaviour. They make expensive purchases seem affordable by breaking them into smaller chunks, but the cumulative burden strains monthly budgets,' he often creeps in gradually until repayments consume a third or more of someone's WARNING SIGNSThe red flags of lifestyle overextension often go unnoticed. 'Living paycheck to paycheck despite a good salary, relying on credit for groceries or bills, dipping into savings for everyday needs—these are all warning signs,' Kumar use of short-term loans, missing credit card due dates, and falling credit scores are also markers that someone is living beyond their patterns are no longer rare. Personal loan growth among salaried urban professionals is at a record high, and delinquencies in BNPL accounts have been rising SOCIAL MEDIA TRENDSThe psychological triggers behind lifestyle inflation are just as strong as the financial ones. 'FOMO is real,' Kumar notes. 'Social media creates the impression that everyone else is doing better. That pressure pushes people to upgrade faster than they can afford.'A curated life on Instagram or an aspirational reel can influence everything from vacation plans to restaurant bills. But these comparisons often come at a financial SAVINGSadvertisementPerhaps the most damaging effect of lifestyle inflation is what it crowds out: long-term savings. 'When people spend more on lifestyle, they invest less for the future. And those early years are critical for building wealth,' Kumar out on compounding in your 20s or early 30s can delay financial goals by years. A few indulgences now might mean postponing retirement or taking on more risk restraint doesn't mean austerity, but balance is key. 'Start with the 50-30-20 rule. Allocate 50 percent to needs, 30 to wants, and 20 to savings and investments. It helps you stay grounded,' Kumar also recommends automating investments, limiting EMIs to essential purchases, and using a 24-hour pause before big-ticket buys. 'Clarity is crucial. It's not just about what you earn, but how you make that income work for your life goals.'Because income alone doesn't build wealth. Discipline does.
