CAS rules in favour of Inter Kashi over ineligible player controversy

The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) has upheld Inter Kashi FC's appeal, reversing a prior decision by the AIFF Appeals Committee and awarding a 3-0 win against Namdhari FC for fielding an ineligible player in I-League 2024-25. This decision is set to impact I-League standings and ISL qualification. read more
Churchill Brothers FC Goa finished with 40 points from 22 games at the end of the 2024-25 I-League season, one more than the second-placed Inter Kashi. Image: AIFF
The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), on Tuesday, June 17, 2025, upheld an against a decision issued on April 18, 2025, by an independent appellate committee.
The CAS further set aside the decision issued by the Appeal Committee and upheld the terms of the decision of the Disciplinary Committee, dated February 24, 2025, which deemed Namdhari FC to have fielded an ineligible player in Match 45 of the I-League 2024-25 (Namdhari FC vs Inter Kashi).
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
The match, as per the terms of the decision of the Disciplinary Committee, was awarded as a 3-0 victory to Inter Kashi.
The AIFF followed the orders and implemented the decision of the Independent Committee, and will now follow the CAS orders and implement its decision.
More from Football
Why Inter Kashi have filed an appeal before CAS
Churchill Brothers had finished with 40 points from 22 games at the end of the season, one more than Inter Kashi, and were set to join the Indian Super League (ISL) – the top division of Indian football – by virtue of being the I-League champion.
Inter Kashi, however, had played a game against Namdhari FC in which their opponents collected a 2-0 win while reportedly fielding an ineligible player. Kashi appealed against Namdhari fielding Brazilian forward Cledson Carvalho da Silva despite picking up four yellow cards prior to the game, which should have resulted in his suspension.
Namdhari thus were docked the three points they had collected following their victory, which were awarded to Kashi. Things, however, started getting complicated for all parties involved after Namdhari appealed against the decision before the Delhi-based governing body, claiming Cledson was fielded as the 'AIFF CMS portal did not show the player was banned for the game".
Thus the 3-0 victory that was awarded to Inter Kashi due to Namdhari FC's 'forfeiture' as a result of fielding an ineligible player was put on hold until the AIFF arrived at a final decision.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Business Standard

6 minutes ago

• Business Standard

ENG vs IND: Bumrah is world's best, extremely hard to face

England opener Ben Duckett has hailed Jasprit Bumrah as the best bowler in the world after the Indian pace ace produced a masterclass under the lights on Day 2 of the first Test at Headingley. Bumrah claimed all three wickets to fall in England's innings, including that of Duckett himself, as the visitors kept pressure on despite a strong English response. Duckett full of praise for Bumrah "Bumrah is extremely difficult to face, especially when he's charging in downhill under the lights and swinging it both ways," Duckett said at stumps on Saturday. "He's got so many variations, be it a bouncer, yorker, slower one, or either swing, and he gives away no cues. You have to be locked in completely to face him." Despite Bumrah's brilliance, England ended the day on 209/3 in reply to India's imposing 471, with Ollie Pope leading the resistance. The right-hander played a composed and courageous knock, reaching an unbeaten 100 to steady England's innings. Duckett, who scored a fluent 62 before falling to Bumrah, was full of praise for Pope's temperament under testing conditions. 'He came in with Bumrah in full flow and didn't flinch. He stayed true to his style. You could see what that century meant to him and everyone in the dressing room. I had goosebumps watching him raise his bat.' There had been murmurs about Pope's place in the 11, despite a recent 171 against Zimbabwe, but Duckett believes those doubts have been firmly laid to rest. "We don't let outside noise creep into the dressing room, but obviously we hear it. Inside, there was never any doubt. A guy who scores 171 a few weeks back deserves his spot. Pope's composure and performance today proves exactly why he's our number three." With England still trailing by 262 runs, Day 3 promises to be a crucial one in the context of this gripping Test battle.

Hindustan Times

13 minutes ago

• Hindustan Times

Sourav Ganguly desires a return to Team India, this time as coach: 'Gautam Gambhir has started off little slow...'

Former India captain Sourav Ganguly isn't ruling out the idea of coaching the Indian men's team. Ganguly, who has worn multiple hats post-retirement, from commentator to BCCI president, said he's 'open' to taking on the role in the future. Sourav Ganguly (L) hasn't ruled out a possibility of reuniting with Team India(PTI/ANI) 'I never really thought about it because I got into different roles,' Ganguly told PTI. 'I finished (competitive cricket) in 2013 and then became Board (BCCI) President. We'll see what the future holds. I'm just 50 (53), so let's see what happens. I'm open to it. We'll see where it goes.' Ganguly, who has been Team Director at Delhi Capitals between 2018-19 and 2022-24, believes his biggest contribution to Indian cricket in administration came in the women's game. 'I got into different roles… but I think my biggest contribution was to promote women's cricket,' he said. While the topic of a future coaching role remains open, Ganguly was firm on another front, politics. 'I am not interested,' he said when asked whether he would consider joining a political party ahead of the 2026 West Bengal assembly elections. Even when asked if he would consider it if promised the post of Chief Minister, Ganguly replied again with a smile: 'I am not interested.' Ganguly on Gambhir The former captain also gave a measured endorsement of Gautam Gambhir, who succeeded Rahul Dravid as head coach earlier this year. 'Gautam (Gambhir) is doing a good job,' Ganguly said. 'He started off a little slow, losing to Australia and New Zealand, but he picked up with the Champions Trophy. This is going to be a big series (vs England).' Ganguly was asked whether Gambhir, his former teammate, is a strong tactician. 'I haven't seen him from very close in this role, but I know he is very passionate. I haven't observed his strategies closely because I haven't worked with him as a coach,' he said. 'He's very straightforward, he sees things clearly, and he's very open about what he feels — about the team, players, people, everything. From the outside, you can tell he's a very transparent person — what you see is what you get.' Ganguly recalled playing alongside Gambhir during their international days. 'He was a great guy with a lot of respect for me and the senior players. Even now, I can see he is extremely passionate about his job.' 'I wish him all the best,' Ganguly added. 'He's just a year into the job, and this will be an important (England) tour. He struggled a bit in Australia, but just like everyone else, he'll learn, he'll grow, and he'll become better.'

News18

19 minutes ago

• News18

Sourav Ganguly Open To Coaching Team India: 'Never Really Thought About It...'

Last Updated: Sourav Ganguly, former Indian cricket captain, is open to coaching the Indian men's team. Arguably, one of India's best-ever captains, Sourav Ganguly, is open to the idea of coaching the Indian men's cricket team. Ganguly, who will turn 53 this July, served as the Team Director of Delhi Capitals from 2018-19 to 2022-24. 'I never really thought about it because I got into different roles," Ganguly was quoted as saying by PTI when asked if he would like to coach the Indian team. 'I finished (competitive cricket) in 2013 and then became Board (BCCI) president," Ganguly noted, highlighting that his biggest contribution in that role was promoting women's cricket. When asked if he could have contributed more by becoming India's coach, Ganguly said: 'We'll see what the future holds. I'm just 50 (53), so let's see what happens. I'm open to it. We'll see where it goes." Ganguly praised incumbent coach Gautam Gambhir, noting his progress since the Champions Trophy victory in Dubai earlier this year. 'Gautam (Gambhir) is doing a good job. He started off a little slow, losing to Australia and New Zealand, but he picked up with the Champions Trophy. This is going to be a big series (vs England)," Ganguly said. When asked about Gambhir's tactical acumen, Ganguly praised his passion and straightforward nature. 'I haven't seen him from very close in this role, but I know he is very passionate. I haven't observed his strategies closely because I haven't worked with him as a coach. 'He's very straightforward, he sees things clearly, and he's very open about what he feels, about the team, players, people, everything. From the outside, you can tell he's a very transparent person – what you see is what you get." Ganguly recalled his playing days, noting Gambhir's respect for senior players. 'I've played with him. He was a great guy with a lot of respect for me and the senior players. Even now, I can see he is extremely passionate about his job." Ganguly also believes Gambhir should be given time to grow as a coach and learn over time. 'I wish him all the best. He's just a year into the job, and this will be an important (England) tour. He struggled a bit in Australia, but just like everyone else, he'll learn, he'll grow, and he'll become better," Ganguly added.