'Shouldn't do that': James Sicily under fire over post-match act in Hawthorn rooms
AFL fans have moved to defend James Sicily after the Hawthorn captain was criticised by Matthew Lloyd on Monday night. Speaking on 'Footy Classified' on Channel 9, Essendon legend Lloyd highlighted vision of Sicily sitting with his head in his hands after the Hawks' loss to Collingwood last Friday night.
It marked Hawthorn's third loss in a row, and Sicily appeared a shattered man amid a worrying form slump. The vision showed the skipper with his head down and face covered, not interacting with any of his teammates.
Speaking on Monday night, Lloyd said Sicily needed to show stronger leadership than what he did in the rooms after the game. "Last year I thought he stood up really well when they weren't going well after five rounds," Lloyd said. "He came on and did an interview with us and gee he was good. He had a wonderful season last year so it's too soon to question whether he's the right captain.
"But I still feel he's very temperamental, and I don't think at times as a captain he's balanced enough (with his emotions). Even that vision in the rooms. I don't think as a captain you should have your head in your hands after the game."
When suggested to Lloyd that players should be allowed to show emotion, he used James Hird as an example of a captain who never gave away when they were hurting. "You've got to be strong for everyone. You get up and get around everyone else and start talking to others," he said.
"What I loved about James Hird is you would never know what kind of day he was having. Whether he was having a poor day or a good day he was the voice of reason and calmness in the rooms for us."
Taking to social media, fans were quick to question whether that was the right message for Lloyd to be sending considering how times have changed. In the modern landscape, players are being encouraged to show more emotion and not bottle up how they're feeling.
One person wrote: "Not everyone is a robot. Some players actually have emotions!" Another commented: "Imagine attacking a man for sharing his feelings with his mates."
Lloyd also suggested coach Sam Mitchell move Sicily out of the forward line. "He's a surprise forward at times, but he shouldn't be starting there," Lloyd said.
When a team loses games everything gets analysed within an inch of its life. The way the players talk, walk, interact, interview and now how they act 10 mins after a loss and if their head is down or not. If he doesn't show emotion guess what? NO EMOTION! NOT A CAPTAIN!!
— Luke (@Luke5557725) June 2, 2025
Not everyone is a robot.Some players actually have emotions!
— Nev_is_here 🇭🇲😸🇦🇺 (@Nev_or_never) June 2, 2025
Maybe Sis had a headache? Seriously Llody, what do you want Sis to do, walk around with his chest pumped out?
— The Thirsty Hawk (@thethirstyhawk) June 2, 2025
Mitchell launched a stirring defence of Sicily before the Collingwood game amid speculation he's battling groin issues. But Melbourne great Garry Lyon reckons it showed the Hawks have become "unnecessarily edgy."
He said on Fox Footy: 'I thought 'they're getting unnecessarily wound up here' ... to me that was the mindset going in and they got punched in the nose. They're going to get more heat and they'll probably get crankier, but that's not going to do you any good. I did get a mindset they felt like they were under siege. They weren't under siege, it was just good old fashioned critique.'
RELATED:
AFL world rallies around Ollie Wines after difficult development
James Hird calls out Sydney Swans over moment he's 'never seen'
On SEN radio, former West Coast coach Adam Simpson called for Sicily to step up. 'Sicily, as much as you don't want to point the finger at one particular player, I'm not sure if he's feeling sorry for himself or if he's feeling the burden of leadership, I wouldn't know, but you need your leaders to lead now," he said.
'Whether it's on the track, whether it's after the game they get together, or whether it's game day, you need your leaders and that's what they're working through.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Bulldogs forward Jamarra Ugle-Hagan opens up on mental health struggles and hitting ‘rock bottom'
Western Bulldogs Jamarra Ugle-Hagan has opened up about his mental health struggles on the Rip Through It podcast. Western Bulldogs Jamarra Ugle-Hagan has opened up about his mental health struggles on the Rip Through It podcast. Photograph: Morgan Hancock/AAP The Western Bulldogs forward Jamarra Ugle-Hagan has opened up about his mental health struggles for the first time since taking a leave of absence, saying there were times he 'didn't want to leave the house'. The former No 1 draft pick is hoping to make his AFL comeback after recently visiting a health retreat in northern New South Wales. Advertisement Ugle-Hagan has not played this season but rejoined Bulldogs teammates earlier this week for the first time since April. He revealed the extent of his struggles while speaking with former AFL players Mitch Robinson and Rhys Mathieson on their Rip Through It podcast, saying he had battled with suicidal thoughts. 'All the noises actually sent me to a rehab facility for my mental health,' Ugle-Hagan said. 'It got to a point where I had to give my car to a mate, so I couldn't drive – I just didn't trust myself driving. 'There were times when I would think about, to be honest with you, [it is] just not even worth living. Advertisement 'I went through a struggle where I didn't want to leave the house. I hit rock bottom and found basement … suicidal thoughts would come pretty frequently.' Related: Callan Ward turning heartbreak into inspiration sums up all that is wonderful about AFL | Jonathan Horn Ugle-Hagan said he turned to alcohol at the height of his struggles before spending time at the health retreat. 'When you are down, you want to keep finding an upper,' Ugle-Hagan said. 'My upper was probably staying and hanging out with my mates and getting on the piss, and training with them as well. 'But it just had no end goal. I didn't have a game. I didn't have anything. Advertisement 'My mental health wasn't in the right space, so I was struggling, and I found it really tough to even enjoy football.' Ugle-Hagan had been unable to regularly train with the Dogs since late last year. He took part in a light training session at Whitten Oval, but could still be weeks away from a possible comeback at VFL level. The AFL would need to approve Ugle-Hagan's comeback because he has been under the league's mental health plan since taking leave. But Ugle-Hagan, who is contracted to the Bulldogs until the end of next season, said he was focused on resuming his 67-game AFL career. The Bulldogs coach Luke Beveridge last week raised that same prospect. Advertisement 'I want to play footy. I can't wait to play footy,' Ugle-Hagan said. 'I have been watching every single Bulldogs game. I have been supporting them. 'I will go to games at the end of the year. I genuinely want to play one more (game), I want to play some games. 'It's going to be grouse.' Ugle-Hagan maintained his commitment to the Bulldogs after trade speculation linked him with a possible trade to the Sydney Swans, given his time spent in NSW. He led the Bulldogs with a career-best 43 goals in 22 appearances last year, but has not featured at any level since the elimination final defeat to Hawthorn. Advertisement Beveridge has also swatted away suggestions Ugle-Hagan could be on the move, declaring him 'our player'. 'I'm obviously still contracted with the Doggies and I still want to play for them and I want to win a flag,' Ugle-Hagan said. 'It's the Bulldogs until my contract runs out and then hopefully they offer me another one, but we will see how we go. 'They have given me opportunities since day dot, so why can't I get back?' – with Australian Associated Press
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
AFL fans divided over Nick Diacos' tagging treatment as celebration detail emerges
St Kilda's efforts to tag Nick Daicos have been labelled as a 'step too far' with the Collingwood midfielder's maturity highlighted amid the rough tactics. Daicos had to contend with one of his more challenging nights on Saturday after tagger Marcus Windhager got stuck into the Magpies star in Collingwood's 16.12 (108) to 11.8 (74) win. Despite the tactic, Daicos was the best on ground with 30 possessions and his crucial last-term goal left Windhager and his teammates demoralised. And while Daicos emerged with a smile on his face after getting the better of the duel, not all were impressed with the tactics. North Melbourne great David King understood it was the expectations of a tagger to frustrate Daicos and push him into making a mistake. One clip showed Windhager appearing to knee Daicos off the ball. And King felt the AFL might need to step in if it ramps up with the potential of injuring a superstar doing damage to the game. 'This is the sort of stuff that's going on. Little knees to the back of the hamstrings. I think that's too far,' King said on Saturday on Fox Sports. 'Taggers do anything to get under the skin ... just little things that are a step too far. (The knees) are a no-go, I think that's outside the code ... If that's happened 15-20 times, I'd expect a call from the AFL. We've got to look after our star-factor players. The game owes these players some sort of protection.' And it was this sentiment that prompted Collingwood coach Craig McRae to praise his players for stepping in and defending Daicos so he wasn't fighting the battle on his own. "There was always going to be a lot of cameras on it (the tag). The spotlight was on it," he said. "We don't want him to fight the battles, we'll fight them for him. "He didn't need to get caught up in the wrestle of that. As a team, we want to look after him. You'd say his performance was pretty impactful and then the way we looked after Nick, I was more proud than what we have (done) in recent times." But after weeks of suggestions Daicos needed to be tagged, questions are being asked if it was over the top. Although Daicos himself didn't have an issue having praised Windhager after the tussle. "Windhager has done some great jobs this year and I knew coming in would be a tough night," Daicos said to Fox Sports. "It's about how I can open up space for my teammates. I thought I was able to do that. I love playing in the midfield." And it was this tactical adjustment that prompted Rory Sloane to label him as one of the 'smartest' players in the comp. It's not the tagging it's the kneeing him in the legs and the pinching that pisses me off, and shouldn't the tagger at least have to pretend he is looking at the ball? — Garry (@i_hate_dan1) June 21, 2025 Speaking on Channel Nine, Sloane broke down how the tagging on Daicos allowed the Collingwood midfielder to open up space for his teammates. During the stoppages, Daicos was heavily marked. Although Sloane pointed out he was backing off and opening up channels for his teammates to run through. "Most teams don't tag because they feel like it pulls apart their structure. And last night it certainly pulled apart St Kilda's structure, particularly around centre bounce," Sloane said. "He is one of the smartest players in the comp..." Sloane felt Daicos was the stand out performer, especially in the fourth quarter. And while he could have celebrated to taunt Windhager after being tagged the whole game, Sloane felt it showed the young star's maturity to remain calm and walk away from the drama. "I think his whole game was enormous. His ability to stand up late in the last, and finish the goal. Not only celebration afterwards showed his maturity," Sloane said. "Didn't go at Marcus, he just got on with the game." Collingwood remained first on the ladder with 48 points, while St Kilda dropped to 15th. "He's one of the smartest players in the comp."Rory Sloane with the vision of how Nick Daicos used Marcus Windhager's tag to create space for teammates.#9AFLSFS | Watch on Nine & 9Now 🖥️ — Footy on Nine (@FootyonNine) June 22, 2025
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Emerging spearhead revitalising newly-confident Lions
With their final "hoodoo" ticked off and a new spearhead hitting his straps, Brisbane are primed to hit the back end of their premiership defence high on confidence. The Lions claimed their first victory over Geelong in 22 years on Friday night, with second-year key forward Logan Morris kicking five goals in the 14.8 (92) to 6.15 (51) win. It means the reigning premiers (10-1-4) will head into the bye in second place and confident they can again do something special, despite losing key defender Jack Payne to injury. Logan Morris is turning out to be a draft steal ⭐️Relive his five goals against the Cats.#AFLCatsLions — AFL (@AFL) June 20, 2025 When asked if Brisbane were lifting based on their opponents, Fagan said "maybe" as he also reflected on their win over Hawthorn at the MCG and a tough away loss to Adelaide. "Maybe there's a little bit of that in it, but we've got to become better than that," he added. "But still, when we got to the bye last year, we were 13th. We got to the bye this year, we're second. "So plenty of things still to work on, but I think the boys have done a good job to win the flag, weather the storm in the first part of the year. It hasn't been smooth sailing, all the teams come at you. "So I'm pretty pleased with where we're at but it's a hard competition so you've just got to keep going, don't you? Brisbane's first win over the Cats in Geelong since 2003 was massive in the race for the top two. Collingwood (44 points) lead Brisbane (42) and Geelong (40). "It's a huge win for us," defender Jaspa Fletcher told AAP. "Fages brought it up in our meeting this week. It's obviously a bit of a hoodoo that we wanted to tick off. "He was pretty set on it in our meeting. It really fired the boys up. "He's been massive for us over his time here at the club. So I guess this win's for him as well." Young spearhead Morris, 20, now has 30 goals in 14 appearances this year after backing up his five-goal haul against GWS. "I love the fact that he was able to back up a great performance," Fagan said. "I said to him during the week 'mate, you've had a bit of attention this week, plenty of publicity - do you reckon you'll get a kick this week? "I think that was the secret, I said that to him and he wanted to prove me wrong. "He's a good, level-headed young fella, he's an exciting footballer. Twenty years of age, being able to do that sort of work on the field. It's exciting for Brisbane supporters that we found one. "Losing Joey (Daniher) last year was a bit of a blow but Logan's stepping up." Cam Rayner was at his dynamic best, kicking three goals,while Fagan believed small forward Kai Lohmann was finding confidence again. Brandon Starcevich was substituted after shutting down Patrick Dangerfield but Fagan confirmed he'd just been cramping in his second game back from a long lay-off with concussion.
