Concern Stormont MLAs delivering pre-scripted remarks for social media clips

Concern has been expressed that Stormont MLAs are delivering pre-scripted text in the Assembly for a clip on social media.
Stormont Speaker Edwin Poots said he was also concerned that Points of Order are being raised about 'the normal cut and thrust of debate'.
Almost a year and a half since the Northern Ireland Assembly was restored, Mr Poots has written to MLAs about the standards of debate in the chamber.
He also made his points at the start of the plenary session on Tuesday.
Mr Poots, who has been elected to the Assembly for almost three decades, said he has witnessed 'political giants who passionately articulated their own case', but also engaged in debate and 'realised that they had to give as good as they could take'.
'Our standards of debate are often referred to in the context of the first element – the standard of remarks made about other members. However, there has been a decreased focus on the second element – the concept of debate,' he said.
'If the Assembly is to be serious about its scrutiny role, having a strong culture of parliamentary debate is vital.'
Mr Poots said requiring MLAs to take care in their language and have civility in exchanges 'is not intended to, and should not, prevent passionate and robust debate'.
'In my time in the Assembly since 1998, I have been privileged to witness political giants, who passionately articulated their own case, engaging in debate,' he said.
'However, they also realised that they had to give as good as they could take.
'The freedom to challenge and to express different views in debate are core to this Assembly's core functions of exercising scrutiny, holding ministers to account and representing our constituents.
'Proper debate is about both having the opportunity to state your own views and listening, responding to and challenging the views of others.
'Some members increasingly concentrate only on stating their own opinions.
' Technology has created a temptation for members to deliver a pre-scripted text in the Chamber, shortly after which they leave to issue a clip of their speech on social media.
'If debate was only about a series of members reading out pre-scripted thoughts on an issue, without interaction, there would be no need for an Assembly Chamber – we could do it by email.'
He added: 'I am also concerned about the tendency to raise Points of Order with the chair about the normal cut and thrust of debate, rather than challenge those points themselves.'
He went on to say he is expanding the Ten Practical Principles of Debate circulated in 2021 to 'ensure they focus not only on interactions between members, but also on having a strong culture of debate and challenge'.
'When the Assembly has responsibility for making legislation which impacts on people's lives, it is vital that members are able to probe all the arguments before the Assembly takes a decision,' he said.
'It is my role to encourage the conditions for members to be able to exercise effective scrutiny and accountability in the Chamber.
'I therefore ask all members to take the time to reflect on the principles I have set out in the attachment and to adhere to them in debate.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Independent

11 minutes ago

• The Independent

Martin Lewis shares important council tax payment update on live TV

Martin Lewis announced that the government is launching a consultation into council tax payments, which will affect over three million people. The Money Saving Expert founder criticised the current council tax debt collection process as "so rapid and aggressive it would make banks blush". Mr Lewis said that forcing individuals to pay for a year when they cannot afford a month is "destroying lives". The consultation will consider slowing down the debt collection process to allow people more time to pay before further action is taken. Watch the video in full above.

Sky News

12 minutes ago

• Sky News

Eight men arrested near Iranian embassy in London after 'altercation at protest'

Eight men have been arrested near the Iranian embassy in London after a protest turned violent, police have said. Seven men were detained on suspicion of grievous bodily harm just before 10am on Friday. Separately, a man has been arrested on suspicion of breaching an order imposed by police to prevent serious disorder. "Two men were treated for injuries at the scene and have been taken to hospital for further treatment by the London Ambulance Service," said the Metropolitan Police. The Met Police also confirmed their injuries are not believed to be life-threatening. In a statement, police added: "Conditions have since been put in place to prevent serious disorder. This stops protestors from gathering in the area until 13:00pm on Sunday 22 June. "One man has been taken into police custody after he was arrested on suspicion of breaching the above conditions. "Seven other men remain in police custody after being arrested on suspicion of grievous bodily harm." The Met Police, who were called to the incident at 09.53am, confirmed the altercation took place on Prince's Gate, which is where the embassy is located. No further details have been released about the injured men, although the London Ambulance Service (LAS) said they were treated at the scene before one was taken to a major trauma centre and the other to hospital. An LAS spokesperson said: "We sent a number of resources to the scene including ambulance crews, paramedics in fast response cars and our Tactical Response Unit." It is not clear how the violence developed or what the demonstration was about, but initial reports suggested it centred around a protest against the Iranian leadership. The Iranian embassy has previously been the target of protests which have turned violent. In September 2022, demonstrators and police clashed outside the building in Knightsbridge. The protest was focused against the Iranian regime after the death of 22-year-old Mahsa Amini in police custody. The Met Police said five officers were seriously injured and 12 people were arrested in those scuffles. A year later, in September 2023, another rally was held in the same area to mark the first anniversary of Ms Amini's death. A number of national embassies are located on or near Prince's Gate, including those for the UAE, Afghanistan, Ethiopia and Tunisia. Separately, the UK said on Friday it was temporarily withdrawing UK staff from its embassy in Iran due to the ongoing security situation there.

BBC News

15 minutes ago

• BBC News

Assisted dying: One NI MP backs law change in England and Wales

Only one of Northern Ireland's MPs has supported controversial new assisted dying legislation in a key vote in the House of Eastwood, of the Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLP), backed the bill, which would allow terminally ill adults with six months or less to live to get medical assistance to end their own legislation will only apply in England and was voted through the final stage in the commons by 314 to 291 - a majority of 23. The Democratic Unionist Party's (DUP) five MPs voted against the legislation, along with Ulster Unionist MP Robin Swann, Alliance MP Sorcha Eastwood, Traditional Unionist Voice (TUV) leader Jim Allister and Independent MP Alex leader Claire Hanna was absent from Westminster but has abstained in previous MPs narrowly back legalising assisted dying in England and WalesOpposing the legislation, DUP leader Gavin Robinson said it was a not a bill which offered "light or hope or dignity".He added: "It is not a safeguard for the dying, but it is the removable of protections for the vulnerable." 'More comfort' But Eastwood said it was right that people "get the opportunity in a very limited and very protected circumstances to die a in a way which gives them more comfort than we are doing now"."We all know these things are happening, people with lots of money can go to Switzerland," he added."We need to ensure that it is available to more people, and it is important that a legal framework is put around this."Swann said the bill "seriously lacks" any safeguards for those with disabilities."This now means doctors can raise ending a patient's life, no matter how vulnerable the patient is, including those with learning disabilities and doctors only need to be 51% sure the patient is not being coerced," he said the bill was "unsafe" and did not provide safeguards for vulnerable people as he called for more funding for palliative described the vote as a "sad day for our nation"."For the first time since the abolition of capital punishment, the state is set to be involved in facilitating the death of its own citizens," he said. Assisted dying drugs While the legislation will not apply in Northern Ireland, MPs passed an amendment which will allow the lethal drugs used in assisted dying to be manufactured in Northern the amendment, Swann said that, unlike elsewhere in the UK, workers will not be able to decline working on those drugs for personal beliefs."The conscious clause has been extended to England, Scotland and Wales but not to Northern Ireland," he added.A ban on adverts promoting assisted dying will also be extended to Northern Ireland. Sinn Féin's seven MPs do not take their seats in the House of Commons but a spokesperson said the party supported assisted dying under "limited grounds"."Given the sensitivity and complexity of this issue it would be most appropriate that the health minister would bring forward legislation on assisted dying," the spokesperson in a statement the Northern Ireland Department of Health said it had "no plans to bring forward legislation on assisted dying"."In Northern Ireland, assisting or encouraging suicide or killing someone on compassionate grounds remains a criminal offence," the statement said.