Warning over ‘reputational risk' damage from Church abuse scandals
Safeguarding failures on abuse could make it more difficult for the body managing the Church of England's investment fund to attract and keep staff, a new report has warned.
High-profile cases such as that of serial abuser John Smyth and the subsequent Makin Review which prompted the resignation of Justin Welby as Archbishop of Canterbury, are said to 'undermine public confidence' in how seriously safeguarding is taken.
The annual report from the Church Commissioners for England – which manages the Church's investment portfolio – described their reputational risk as currently being 'at an elevated level'.
The Makin review, the commissioners said, 'gave rise to serious questions about safeguarding practice in the Church of England'.
The commissioners' report, published on Monday, added: 'This case and other safeguarding failures undermine public confidence in the assertions made by the Church, including the Church Commissioners, about the importance of, and priority given to, safeguarding.
'The potential reputational impacts could be far-reaching; for example, they may in turn make it more difficult for us to attract and retain staff.'
The warning came as Church Commissioners announced they would be investing more than £1.6 billion towards the work of the Church from 2026 to 2028.
Bishop of London Dame Sarah Mullally said the 36% rise on the previous three-year period was 'the biggest injection of funding towards the work of the Church of England in our history, and we are very grateful for that'.
The money will go towards various areas including clergy pay, church repairs and net zero plans.
Some £30 million is being allocated towards the cost of national safeguarding work, including moves towards greater independence in how safeguarding is dealt with.
Some £150 million towards the costs of the new national redress scheme for survivors of Church abuse had already been announced.
In his foreword to the report, Archbishop of York Stephen Cottrell acknowledged the 'challenging year' the Church had faced.
The commissioners noted there was also an element of reputational risk around the Church's work on dealing with its past links to slavery, saying such work had already 'attracted significant attention, comment and, in some cases, criticism'.
Their latest report warned: 'Further reaction (including negative comment) to this programme of work is expected when the intended new Fund for Healing, Repair and Justice is launched, making investments andissuing grants.'
The Church announced in January 2023 its work to address historic links to slavery, with a funding programme for investment, research and engagement to 'address past wrongs' but the initial £100 million investment fund was branded too small and slow.
An independent oversight group later said commissioners had 'embraced a target of £1 billion for a broader healing, repair and justice initiative with the fund at its centre'.
Elsewhere, some of the overall £1.6 billion investment announced on Monday is to go towards clergy pay rises of almost 11%.
The Church said the National Minimum Stipend (NMS) and the National Stipend Benchmark (NSB) will both rise by 10.7% from April, bring them to £33,350 and £34,950 respectively.
Dame Sarah said the latest investment will 'value and affirm our clergy who give their lives in the service of Christ through the Church'.
She said: 'I hope these carefully costed plans will provide a step-change in support to clergy right the way through from those following a call to ordination to those who have retired.
'It is vital also that we learn the lessons of our recent past and do everything we can to be a safer church for everyone.
'While no amount of money can ever erase the harm done by perpetrators of abuse, these spending plans will support the vital work of safeguarding in the Church and underpin the new National Redress scheme.'
To aid the Church's ambition to be 'net zero' by 2030, the commissioners said have earmarked up to £190 million up to 2031 for projects including decarbonising cathedrals, churches, church halls, schools andhouses.
The report admits it is 'unlikely that cathedrals will achieve net zero carbon by 2030 without some form of carbon offset, but we are working with the community to help reduce emissions as much as possible'.
The commissioners add that the latest investment will go towards preventing 'a 'cliff-edge' after the 2030 target date set by Synod, enabling work to limit carbon emissions to continue to receive support'.
Meanwhile, the report noted dozens of repair projects had been funded by commissioners to the value of £1.3 million last year, with a rise in instances of Church ceilings which appeared to have been damaged through lack of ventilation when the buildings were closed during the Covid-19 lockdowns.
It said there had been 'an increase in the numbers of failed lath and plaster ceilings due to weakened plaster' which it said was 'likely to have been exacerbated by condensation forming due to the lack of ventilation when churches were closed for prolonged periods during the pandemic'.
First Church Estates Commissioner, Alan Smith, said: 'This distribution of £1.6 billion represents the highest distribution in the Church's history – and we celebrate all those who have made it possible across the entire community of the Church, in particular the investments team, clergy and parishes.
'In stewarding these resources, we must be humble and vigilant, as the times ahead promise both great opportunities and challenges.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
38 minutes ago
- The Sun
Woman dies and nine injured in horror M4 crash as motorway shut ‘for most the day' with cops launching urgent hunt
A WOMAN has died in a car crash that hospitalised nine other people last night. The fatal crash happened on the M4 between junctions 16 and 17, just before 11.30pm last night. 1 A womanin her 40s sadly died at the scene, and another woman in her 70s was seriously injured Five other people in the car had minor injuries. There were also three people travelling in the second car who were hurt and were taken to hospital with minor injuries. Wiltshire Police's Serious Collision Team are at the scene carrying out an investigation into what happened. The motorway is likely to be closed westbound for most of the day, likely causing disruption for a large number of people. Cops received reports that a white vehicle may have been involved and left the scene. Any witnesses to the collision or anyone who may have dashcam footage are asked to contact the serious collision investigation team on 01225 694597, quoting log number 399.
BBC News
41 minutes ago
- BBC News
Highland-wide holiday lets control zone proposed by councillors
A Highland-wide control zone to limit Airbnb-style lets has been suggested as a way of tackling a shortage of homes across the proposing the move said 7,011 short-term let licences had been granted across the Highlands, but only four lets are not banned in control areas, but operators need planning permission as well as a short-term lets councillors said the powers could be used where there was local demand for them. Highland Council officials said control area status for the whole of the Highlands would require research and, if it was introduced, could mean additional costs and workload for its planning department. The idea of Highland-wide status has been suggested by Inverness councillors Michael Gregson and Duncan a paper going to next week's meeting of the full council, they said the region needed more than 24,000 homes over the next 10 added: "The private long-term rental market has shrunk disastrously: estate agents are withdrawing from letting out properties because of the shortage of properties available. "Even taking into account the efforts of Highland Council and the Housing Associations, there is a shortage of affordable housing."The councillors said the local authority should first ask the Scottish government to revisit its original plan to have an overprovision policy within short-term lets said if that was not possible, then to seek approval for Highland control area their response, officials said there would be financial implications for the local authority around both suggestions from the also said there could be potential challenges to Highland-wide of Edinburgh Council had to amend its licensing scheme following a court ruling. The whole of the City of Edinburgh Council area was designated Scotland's first short-term let control area in September 2022.A law requiring operators to have a licence came into force across Scotland in October the following Council's first control zone was approved in December 2023 and covers Badenoch and who supported its introduction said it was needed because workers and local young people had difficulties finding affordable the Association of Scotland's Self-Caterers (ASSC) said at the time that targeting legitimate small businesses to address longstanding housing issues showed "a muddled sense of priorities".
BBC News
41 minutes ago
- BBC News
Life Factory contractors angry over unpaid work 'worth thousands'
Contractors who worked on a £2.89m government-funded renovation project have said it is "disgusting" they have not been paid for all their to create a community space at The Life Factory in Glastonbury paused in 2024 after Somerset Council had concerns about its progress and stopped releasing funds to Red Brick Building Centre, which was responsible for the BBC understands about 15 creditors are awaiting payment, including one who claimed he is owed about £380,000. He described the impact as "catastrophic".Somerset Council said the situation was "regrettable", while the Red Brick Building board said it had been liaising with creditors to "work out what to do". Keith Jackson is director at TML Building Services, which was contracted by Beckery Construction Company (BCC), a subsidiary of Red Brick, to carry out structural works at The Life told the BBC he had not been paid since January 2024 and claims he is owed about £380,000 for work, including removing the floor and roof."We never knew the project was in trouble until a halt was called," he said."Why can't we be paid for the work we've done? Why should we suffer for other people's incompetence?"He said the situation had a "terrible effect" on his company."We haven't got any finances," he explained. "We've got several jobs we could go to, but we don't have the money to go. "We owe other subcontractors a considerable amount of money, but also it's taken our future away." Funding to develop the community and learning space was awarded to Red Brick Building Centre, a social enterprise, under the Glastonbury Town West Audit Partnership (Swap) is looking into what went wrong. In a report, it said it had "no assurance" sound governance or financial controls were in place at Red Brick Building or Somerset also found "no evidence" of a plan to deliver the project "within budget, scope and on time".The report said BCC was set up to keep costs down, but confused the relationship between parties which lead to a communication breakdown, poor governance and a lack of also found standard HR procedures were not followed at BCC, including around sub-contractor recruitment and timesheet records. 'Huge strain' J&E Construction SouthWest was also contracted by BCC to renew the internal floors and roof structure of The Life director Tom Popham claimed he is owed a significant sum in unpaid invoices. He said the situation put a "huge strain" on him, but a loyal client base and his other business meant he was able to pay his contractors and suppliers. However, he said the company is now facing "slow growth"."We haven't got the money in the bank that we used to," he added. He described the council's decision not to release more funds as "disgusting". "I have lost all faith in Somerset Council," he said."I do think they [the council] should settle up if we can prove what we've done." Somerset Council said: "It is deeply regrettable this is having an impact on local contractors with legitimate claims, but we are not contractually responsible for any payments to them."It added the Swap report confirmed the council's concerns about the project and made it "clear" it "cannot release further payments".In a previous statement the council's chief executive Duncan Sharkey said the authority accepted its monitoring of the project "could have been strengthened". A new board started operating at Red Brick at the end of 2023 and its chair Indra Donfrancesco said it is "heartbreaking" contractors have not been paid."There hasn't been a day in this last year where we haven't been trying to work out with them what to do," she added."It is absolutely devastating on every level."A statement from the new Red Brick board said the previous leadership set up BCC in 2022 to manage the scheme and appointed a full-time project manager. It claimed there were "serious" procedural and reporting "failures" and said: "In hindsight, both Red Brick and Somerset Council lacked the capacity to provide proper oversight".Ms Donfrancesco said the previous Red Brick board should have had more of a "financial forecast" of where money was going, what the project would look like and the contractors involved. John Capper, one of two former directors of BCC, said in a statement that Red Brick's board signed the funding agreement and so responsibility lies with said the project manager, who was also a BCC director and full-time employee of Red Brick, was "managerially responsible" for the project's delivery and the "reporting and adherence" to procedures."He reported on a regular basis to the Red Brick board as overseers of the project," Mr Capper said that, during his time as a director, "no concerns" were raised by the council or Red Brick board regarding the issues in the Swap report."However, I did raise my own concerns with the Red Brick board and the Somerset Council officer, which is the reason why I left," he Poizer, the other BCC director and the project manager, declined to comment until the audit process is complete. What now? Ms Donfrancesco said the new board will work with the council to try to find a way to satisfy the funding agreement."Should an alternative viable plan for regenerating the derelict building come to fruition over the coming months, the remaining funds could still be released," she audit work continues. A Swap report found a considerable sum is due to be paid to contractors and creditors, but said the amount was unconfirmed as some costs could be ineligible and some invoices are in a recent council meeting, auditors described the work as complex and could not give a timeline as to when it will be complete.
