Latest news with #DYChandrachud
Indian Express
09-06-2025
- Politics
- Indian Express
The diversity of families: Kerala HC does well to back transgender co-parenting
In a reassuring affirmation of dignity and equality, the Kerala High Court has recognised a transgender couple from Kozhikode as the legal 'parents' of their biological child. The transgender man who gave birth in 2023, and his partner, had sought recognition as co-parents without gender-binary labels so that their child's future — especially with regard to identification documents and school admission — is not impeded. While the Court declined to read down the format mentioned in the Registration of Births and Deaths Rules, 1999, saying that this was a 'rare and exceptional' case, it has directed authorities to issue a birth certificate that reflects the gender-neutral term instead of the conventional 'father' and 'mother'. In its observation, the Court emphasised that in certain instances, 'social justice adjudication' must take precedence over an 'adversarial approach'. In doing so, it broadened the legal imagination around family, gender, and parenthood. In August 2022, granting maternity leave to a central government employee who had previously availed it for the care of her step-children, a bench comprising Justices D Y Chandrachud and A S Bopanna had observed that 'atypical' families are equally deserving of legal protections and social welfare benefits. 'The black letter of the law must not be relied upon to disadvantage families which are different from traditional ones,' they had held. The apex court's refusal to extend civil union or joint adoption rights to LGBTQIA+ couples and its deferral of substantive rights to legislative reform — despite acknowledging queer love and lived discrimination — however, has come as a setback after years of progressive milestones, such as the 2014 NALSA verdict recognising the rights of transgender persons and the 2018 Navtej Johar ruling that decriminalised same-sex relations. In such circumstances, the Kerala High Court's verdict offers a template for affirming queer parenthood within the existing legal framework — and places the child at the centre of that empathetic recognition. It asserts that constitutional dignity cannot wait for political consensus. Days after the Kerala HC verdict, the Madras High Court, while ruling on a habeas corpus petition by a woman forcibly estranged from her lesbian partner, upheld her right to 'find a family'. 'The concept of a 'chosen family' is now well-settled and acknowledged in LGBTQIA+ jurisprudence,' the division bench said. In a country grappling with entrenched social prejudices, these affirmations of diversity reflect a welcome judicial sensitivity to the complexities and plurality of lived experience. They validate, with quiet strength, the right to belong — not as a privilege granted conditionally by tradition, but a truth that embraces every identity, even those that challenge convention.
India Today
06-06-2025
- Business
- India Today
DY Chandrachud takes key role in German energy firm vs Russia dispute
In a significant development in the ongoing arbitration between German energy company Wintershall and Russia, former Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud has been designated as the appointing authority under the Energy Charter Treaty, a multilateral pact that works under a framework for cooperation in the energy Chandrachud, who demitted office as the Chief Justice in November 2024, is widely regarded for his contributions to constitutional law and international philosophy of law. His appointment signals the continued involvement of eminent jurists from diverse legal traditions in resolving high-stakes international investment development came following the resignation of Eduardo Siqueiros as the appointing authority on May 22, 2025. The designation of the appointing authority comes under the rules of the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA), which frequently provides administrative support in disputes between investors and states under the Energy Charter Treaty April this year, Wintershall moved the ECT tribunal seeking an anti-suit injunction directed against the Russian court proceedings, in response to which Moscow had asked for a short suspension of arbitration proceedings also offering that the court proceedings in Russia would be of the arbitrators in the case resigned after Russia didn't accommodate his request to terminate its injunction proceedings and ensure that the ECT tribunal and arbitration counsel were immune from prosecution in was followed by another procedural order in May where the truncated ECT tribunal agreed to temporarily suspend arbitration proceedings conditional on termination of Russian injunction proceedings. It was also stated that such proceedings amounted to a breach of the arbitration a May 24 order, the two arbitrators directed that the case resume, and Moscow was ordered to terminate the Russian injunction proceedings immediately and not file proceedings that would jeopardise the arbitration's per December 2023 Russian decrees, Wintershall Dea's stakes in the Yuzhno-Russkoye oil and gas condensate field and the Achimov gas projects were given back to newly-created Russian companies and offered for sale to Gazovyye company had initiated arbitration proceedings against Russia, which had repeatedly protested against such cases, saying they should have been considered only in Russian on one hand, the state has filed a challenge against the two remaining arbitrators, and on the other, Wintershall, in this case, has sought the move of the seat of arbitration from Dubai to per the arbitrator's latest order, the decision regarding seat relocation was deferred until either the reconstitution of the tribunal, or resolution of Russia's challenge against the two arbitrators, whichever is the ECT, the appointing authority plays an important role and has responsibilities, including facilitation of the constitution of the arbitral tribunal, particularly in case of disagreements between DY Chandrachud served as the Chief Justice of India from November 2022 to November 2024 and was succeeded by Justice Sanjiv Khanna, who also retired last Reel
Time of India
31-05-2025
- Politics
- Time of India
‘Constitution has kept India united in crisis': CJI Gavai at Allahabad high court event
NEW DELHI: Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachud on Saturday said the Indian Constitution has played a decisive role in ensuring the country's unity and strength during times of crisis. Speaking at the inauguration of advocate chambers and a multi-level parking facility at the Allahabad high court, CJI B R Gavai underlined the enduring relevance of the Constitution in guiding the nation's progress. 'Whenever there has been a crisis in the country, it has remained united and strong. The credit for this should be given to the Constitution,' Gavai said. He added that India's journey of development after Independence has been possible because of the constitutional framework. Recalling the debates during the framing of the Constitution, Gavai said, 'Some said the Constitution is too federal, some said it's too unitary. But Dr B R Ambedkar clarified that it is neither wholly federal nor wholly unitary, but one that will keep India united and strong in both peace and war.' He noted that the legislature, executive, and judiciary have collectively contributed to bringing social and economic equality in the 75 years since the Constitution came into effect. 'It is our fundamental duty to reach out to the last citizen who needs justice,' he said. Referring to key legal developments, Gavai highlighted the 1973 Supreme Court judgment which ruled that while Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights, it cannot alter the Constitution's basic structure. 'Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles are the two wheels of the golden chariot of the Constitution,' he said. Commending the Allahabad High Court for its role in judicial progress, Gavai praised the judges who vacated 12 bungalows to make way for the new lawyer chambers. 'The bar and the bench are two sides of the same coin. The chariot of justice cannot move forward unless both work together,' he added.
Time of India
30-05-2025
- Business
- Time of India
SC raps Delhi private schools for fee hike without govt nod
The Supreme Court on Thursday pulled up private unaided schools in Delhi for sharply hiking tuition fees without prior government approval, questioning how institutions receiving land at concessional or no cost could unilaterally raise fees. 'If land is allotted free of cost or at a concessional rate, how can you exorbitantly increase fees without the government's nod?' asked a bench comprising Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud (note: original says CJI B R Gavai, but verify with source) and Justice A G Masih, reported The Times of India. The court was hearing a petition filed by the Naya Samaj Parents Association , which challenged two Delhi High Court orders that had permitted such fee hikes by unaided private schools without prior approval from the Directorate of Education (DoE). The petitioner argued that schools were penalising students who couldn't afford the fees, causing distress among students and parents. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 'They Want This Joint Relief Gummy Gone—Here's Why Seniors Love It' Joint Fuel 360 Click Here Undo The SC bench directed the Action Committee Unaided Recognised Private Schools and the Delhi government's education directorate to file their responses within three weeks. The petition contended that the HC orders contradicted previous Supreme Court rulings—particularly the 2004 Modern School case—that mandated schools situated on government-allotted land must obtain prior approval from the DoE before increasing tuition fees. Live Events Quoting the earlier SC verdict, the plea said: 'The quantum of fees to be charged by unaided private schools is subject to regulation by DoE under Section 17(3) of the Delhi School Education Act, 1973.' The court had also emphasised that private schools must not engage in profiteering or commercialisation of education. The current challenge comes amid broader concerns over affordability and transparency in fee structures in Delhi's private school sector. With inputs from ToI
India Today
26-05-2025
- Politics
- India Today
Supreme court agrees to hear plea on NEET PG 2025 exam format
The Supreme Court on Monday agreed to hear a petition challenging the National Board of Examinations' (NBE) decision to conduct the NEET PG 2025 exam in two separate National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test for Postgraduate courses is scheduled for June 15 and will be held in two computer-based shifts across centres in the country. The results are expected by July bench of Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachud, Justice B R Gavai, and Justice Augustine George Masih said the matter would be listed for hearing soon. The lawyer representing the petitioners reminded the court that the matter was supposed to be listed last week, as assured on May 23, but wasn't. 'This is urgent. The admit cards will be issued on June 2,' the lawyer submitted. The Chief Justice responded, 'It will be listed in a day or two.'The petitioners, including one Aditi and others, have argued that holding the exam in two shifts could lead to an unequal playing field due to possible differences in difficulty levels between the two sets of question papers. The plea has asked the court to direct the NBE to hold the exam in a single shift, ensuring fairness and equal opportunity for all on May 5, the Supreme Court had issued notices seeking responses from the NBE, the National Medical Council, and the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare on the a related matter, the top court recently passed a verdict aimed at reforming NEET PG counselling. It ordered authorities to stop seat-blocking practices and directed that raw scores, answer keys, and the formula used for normalisation be made public for greater current petition raises fresh concerns about fairness in the NEET PG exam process, adding pressure on the authorities ahead of the exam outcome of the plea could impact lakhs of medical aspirants preparing to appear for the NEET PG 2025.
