Latest news with #Clonskeagh
Irish Times
3 days ago
- Business
- Irish Times
Challenge to Islamic centre board membership change is strongly disputed, court told
A High Court challenge to a change in membership of the board of the company running the Islamic Cultural Centre of Ireland is being strongly disputed, a judge was told. A dispute over control of the Al Maktoum Foundation CLG, which owns the centre in Clonskeagh, Dublin, reached the court last month when Mr Justice Brian Cregan was told it had arisen out of the alleged unlawful appointment of new directors to the foundation company. The court previously heard the mosque and school at the centre have closed. Dr Abdel Basset Elsayed, a Co Meath-based medical consultant who says he has been a director of the company since 2012, brought the challenge claiming the purported appointments of four new directors were invalid and did not follow the requirements of the company's constitution. READ MORE He sought orders from the court requiring the Companies Registration Office (CRO) rectify its register by removing the allegedly unlawfully appointed members and restraining the new directors from performing any duties or representing themselves as directors of the company. The other directors are notice parties in the case. On Wednesday, when the case returned before the court, Lyndon MacCann SC, for the Al Maktoum Foundation, said Dr Elsayed purports to be a director, but counsel said his side says he is not. Counsel said his instructing solicitors 'have at all times' been the solicitors for the company and he was instructed by people who say they are the directors and they will be resisting Dr Elsayed's applications. [ School closed due to dispute over control of Islamic cultural centre in Dublin, court hears ] Mr MacCann said he wanted time to reply to a new application for an injunction seeking to prevent the company from acting pending determination of the dispute. His side was also disputing that Joseph Sallabi BL, who told the court he has a contract as in-house counsel with the Al Maktoum Foundation, was in fact in-house counsel. They were also saying that, even if they accepted Dr Elsayed was a director, which they say he is not, he had called a board meeting without notice to the other directors, counsel said. Mr MacCann said as a lot of his deponents are based in the United Arab Emirates, he would need at least two weeks to put in a response to the latest application. Mr Justice Cregan said it appeared to be a matter of some urgency as the mosque and school are closed. Mr Sallabi agreed it was a matter of some urgency. The judge adjourned the case to next month.
BreakingNews.ie
3 days ago
- Business
- BreakingNews.ie
Challenge to Islamic centre board strongly disputed, court hears
A High Court challenge to a change in membership of the board of the company running the Islamic Cultural Centre of Ireland is being strongly disputed, a judge has been told. A dispute over control of the Al Maktoum Foundation CLG, which owns the centre in Clonskeagh, Dublin, reached the court last month when Mr Justice Brian Cregan was told it had arisen out of the alleged unlawful appointment of new directors to the foundation company. Advertisement The court previously heard that the mosque and school at the centre have closed. Dr Abdel Basset Elsayed, a Meath-based medical consultant who says he has been a director of the company since 2012, brought the challenge claiming the purported appointments of four new directors was invalid and did not follow the requirements of the company's constitution. He sought orders from the court requiring the Companies Registration Office (CRO) to rectify its register by removing the allegedly unlawfully appointed members and restraining the new directors from performing any duties or representing themselves as directors of the company. The other directors are notice parties in the case. Advertisement On Wednesday, when the case returned before the court, Lyndon MacCann SC, for the Al Maktoum Foundation, said Dr Elsayed purports to be a director, but counsel said his side says he is not. Counsel said his instructing solicitors "have at all times" been the solicitors for the company, and he was instructed by people who say they are the directors, and they will be resisting Dr Elsayed's applications. Mr MacCann said he wanted time to reply to a new application for an injunction seeking to prevent the company from acting pending determination of the dispute. His side was also disputing that Joseph Sallabi BL, who told the court he has a contract as in-house counsel with the Al Maktoum Foundation, was in fact in-house counsel. They were also saying that, even if they accepted Dr Elsayed was a director, which they say he is not, he had called a board meeting without notice to the other directors, counsel said. Advertisement Mr MacCann said as a lot of his deponents are based in the United Arab Emirates, he would need at least two weeks to put in a response to the latest application. Mr Justice Cregan said it appeared to be a matter of some urgency as the mosque and school are closed. Mr Sallabi agreed it was a matter of some urgency. The judge adjourned the case to next month.
Irish Times
4 days ago
- Business
- Irish Times
Locals oppose development plans for Dublin 6 site
River Dodder anglers and local residents are opposing plans by a Bain Capital backed firm to build student housing at the former Smurfit Paper Mills site at Clonskeagh in Dublin 6. In the planning application lodged with Dublin City Council, Bain Capital vehicle, Harley Issuer DAC is seeking planning permission for the 439 bed spaces across five blocks from one storey to part seven storeys along with 16 residential apartments. The Large Scale Residential Development (LRD) – located 1km northnorthwestCD's main campus at Belfield - also includes–the extension and renovation of 14 existing homes at Clonskeagh Road. In an accompanying planning report by consultants, John Spain, it states that 'the scale of the proposed development is considered to integrate appropriately with its surroundings, whilst introducing increased height'. READ MORE [ Irish universities earned more than €830m from student housing since 2015 Opens in new window ] However, in an objection against the scheme, the Dodder Anglers Association, which represents more than 1,300 members, states that it is very concerned the proposals 'could damage the biodiversity of River Dodder green/blue corridor and are in breach with Dublin city councils biodiversity action plan as well as the EU habitats direct and water Framework Directive'. On behalf of the Eglinton Residents Association, Robin Mandal has hit out at what he believes to be 'a proposed gross over-development of this sensitive site'. Mr Mandal said: 'we believe that the proposed development would constitute over-development of the site by virtue of its height, scale, bulk and massing at this sensitive and highly visible and sensitive site on the banks of the River Dodder Mr Mandal contends that the student scheme's 'impact on the biodiversity and flora and fauna of the riparian setting will be profound, obliterating much of value'. Mr Mandal said that the former Smurfit Paper Mills site 'has remained vacant and unused for more than 20 years'. Chairwoman of the Richview Residents Association, Marion Cashman said: 'There have been seven planning applications on this site over 20 years. The number of units proposed ranged from 130 units in 2005 to the now proposed 440 student bedspaces and 30 residences. Ms Cashman said: 'The current proposal is an overdevelopment of the site and would set an undesirable and unacceptable precedent for this sensitive location on the river Dodder and other such sites.' The market for student accommodation provision in south Dublin is a lucrative one with University College Dublin (UCD) generating €42.8 million in 'rental income from student residences on campus' in the 12 months to the end of September last.
Irish Times
04-06-2025
- General
- Irish Times
School closed due to dispute over control of Islamic cultural centre in Dublin, court hears
A school at the Islamic Cultural Centre of Ireland in Clonskeagh, Dublin, has closed as part of a dispute over control of the centre's operations, the High Court heard. Mr Justice Brian Cregan was also told Clonskeagh is the primary place for holding a major annual Muslim festival, Eid al-Adha, which falls on Friday, but is now closed. The mosque at the centre had also closed, the court previously heard. The dispute arises out of the alleged unlawful appointment of new directors to the centre's operating company, the Al Maktoum Foundation CLG. Dr Abdel Basset Elsayed, a Co Meath-based medical consultant, says he has been a director of the foundation company since 2012. He claims the purported appointments of four new directors to the board are invalid and not in accordance with the company's constitution. READ MORE He sought orders from the court requiring the Companies Registration Office to rectify its register by removing the allegedly unlawfully appointed members and restraining the new directors from performing any duties or representing themselves as directors of the company. Barrister Niall Ó hUiginn, for the new directors, who are notice parties in the case, on Wednesday said his clients dispute the claims and contend Dr Elsayed has no legal standing to bring the case as he has been removed as a director. Counsel said Dr Elsayed was purporting to give directions on behalf of the Al Maktoum Foundation. His clients will say Dr Elsayed's removal from his directorship was in accordance with the company's constitution. [ Dublin Islamic cultural centre temporarily closed after gardaí called to altercation Opens in new window ] Counsel said he did not wish to get into the merits of the case at this stage as his side needed time to put in a replying affidavit to Dr Elsayed's claims. Barrister Joseph Sallabi, who told the court he has a contract as in-house counsel with the Al Maktoum Foundation, objected to a three-week adjournment. His side argue a corporate body in Dubai is appointing the directors and they are acting for the company, counsel said. There were 27 teachers in the Clonskeagh school who had collectively resigned and the school has closed. Mr Ó hUiginn objected to Mr Sallabi making claims that had not been put on affidavit and were not part of any orders sought. Mr Justice Cregan told Mr Sallabi he would have to put his new claims on affidavit, and that he would also give the notice parties time to put their position on affidavit. It was an 'unfortunate situation', he said, and Mr Sallabi, if he wanted the school and mosque to be reopened, would have to bring a separate application in that respect. He adjourned the matter to later this month.
Irish Times
28-05-2025
- Business
- Irish Times
Dispute over control of Clonskeagh Islamic centre reaches High Court
A dispute over the alleged unlawful appointment of new directors to a company behind the Islamic Cultural Centre of Ireland has led to the month-long closure of the mosque in Clonskeagh, Dublin, the High Court heard. Mr Justice Brian Cregan on Wednesday said he will likely make orders under company law regarding the appointments if five named new directors of the Al Maktoum Foundation CLG, which owns the cultural centre, do not respond to the lawsuit. The case has been brought by Dr Abdel Basset Elsayed, a Meath-based medical consultant and director of the company since 2012, and secretary since 2022. The Al Maktoum in-house counsel, Joseph Sallabi, told the judge that in August 2023, there were only three directors, one of whom was Dr Elsayed. READ MORE One of the three resigned, and Mirza El Sayegh, the third director, appointed five new directors and took control of the company, he said, adding that this was without Dr Elsayed's knowledge and without board approval. 'The situation is really grave as they have now filed submissions with the Companies Registration Office (CRO) changing the constitution and tampering with the records of the company,' he said. Mr Sallabi said the five directors, who are listed as notice parties in the case against the CRO, are all resident in Dubai but have their places of business in Ireland. He said notice of the proceedings has been served by post on the five: Ahmad Tahlak, Hesham Abdulla Al Quassim, Khalifa Aldaboos, Mohamed Musabeh Dhahi and Zahid Jami, all of Roebuck Road, Clonskeagh. None appeared or had representatives in court. Mr Justice Cregan said notice should also be served to them by email. When the judge pointed out that the issues all appear to have taken place a year ago, Mr Sallabi said they only became aware of them in October. In a sworn statement, Dr Elsayed, who is an applicant in the case alongside the company, said the company received a letter from its auditor confirming only he and Mr El Sayegh were directors after the other resigned last August. The auditor recommended that the board includes at least two directors who are based in Ireland to ensure an adequate governance structure. Last January, Dr Elsayed said, Mr El Sayegh received a directive from the Mohammed Bin Rashed Al Maktoum Humanitarian and Charity Establishment to add four directors to the company. On January 20th, Mr El Sayegh allegedly passed a purported board resolution authorising the appointments of four individuals. [ Inside Dublin Islamic centre: pressure on 'senior official' to step down amid claims over staff links to banned group Opens in new window ] 'The purported resolution was issued without my knowledge, attendance or contribution,' said Dr Elsayed. Between April 19th and June 7th last, he said, Mr El Sayegh submitted forms to the CRO appointing the five new directors. Dr Elsayed claims those appointments are invalid, and did not follow the requirements of the company's constitution. The case alleges the appointments were made 'under instructions from an unrelated Dubai-registered organisation with no corporate ties to the company, except Mr El Sayegh's directorship in both entities'. The applicants seek an order, under section 173 of the Companies Act 2014 and under the court's general jurisdiction, directing the rectification of the CRO register by removing the allegedly unlawfully appointed members. They also seek an order restraining the new directors from performing any duties or representing themselves as directors of the company. The Al Maktoum Foundation was incorporated in 1997 to 'establish a position for the Muslim community within the Irish society that is fair and based on due rights and to work for a more enlightened appreciation for Islam and Muslims in wider society, as well as fostering better community relations and working for the good of society as a whole'.
