STAR TREK: The Trans Trill, Explained

For decades, many Trekkies have considered the Trill alien species on Star Trek to be a trans allegory. How long has this interpretation been popular? And how has the Franchise leaned into this trans representation?
For this week's second Pride Month Trek Tuesday, we're examining the read that connects the trill with trans representation. Star Trek: The Next Generation
The Trill were originally introduced on Star Trek: The Next Generation. In The Next Generation Season 4's 'The Host,' a Trill ambassador visits the U.S.S. Enterprise-D in order to take part in some sensitive negotiations on Peliar Zel II. This Trill symbiont, 'Odan,' was originally joined to a male host (Franc Luz).
The Trill species is comprised of two kinds of life forms. There is the symbiont, a worm-like entity. These long-lived symbionts can inhabit a humanoid 'host' body. Once this has transpired, the 'joined Trill' will possess a new personality. This is the synthesis of the personalities of the symbiont and the host.
RELATED: Geek Girl Authority Crush of the Week: Beverly Crusher
In 'The Host,' Odan's male host and Doctor Beverly Crusher (Gates McFadden) became romantically entangled. However, Odan's earlier host was subsequently killed. In order to preserve the life of the symbiont, Dr. Crusher performed a procedure that transferred Odan from the original host into the body of William T. Riker (Jonathan Frakes). This complicated the romantic relationship between Odan and Crusher. This was because she considered Riker to be akin to a brother to her.
At the conclusion of the episode, the Odan symbiont is transferred to a new host: a woman, Kareel (Nicole Orth-Pallavicini). There is a taboo among the Trill regarding continuing a romantic relationship across different hosts. Nevertheless, Odan was willing to disregard this and continue the romance with Crusher. However, Crusher felt that the repeated changes in hosts were too much, and declined to continue the relationship. This parallels the way that a relationship will sometimes conclude when one partner transitions. Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
After being introduced in The Next Generation's 'The Host,' the Trill played a major part in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. This was thanks to the fact that one of the command crew members was a Trill: Jadzia Dax (Terry Farrell). Sporting a new design (for both the host and the Trill), Jadzia introduced viewers to many facets of the Trill that were not explored in 'The Host.' Among other details, this included the fact that unjoined Trill symbionts swim in cave pools on the planet Trill.
However, one aspect of the Trill that was introduced in The Next Generation was obviously and immediately continued in Deep Space Nine. This was the idea of a Trill symbiont moving from a male host to a female host. This was because Jadzia was a new host for the Dax symbiont. However, the previous host for the Dax symbiont was the late Curzon, a male who was the friend of Benjamin Sisko (Avery Brooks).
RELATED: Star Trek: Tracing the Holodeck's History
In an early Season 1 episode of Deep Space Nine, 'A Man Alone,' Sisko and Jadzia discuss Dax's 'transition.' In that scene, Jadzia notes that sometimes Trill friendships with other species 'don't survive the change.' Sisko says that it will be different for them, but that things are 'uncomfortable' at the moment. Jadzia suggests to Sisko that he learn to 'comfortable with his discomfort.' She continues that 'Time will do the rest.'
Ultimately, Sisko's friendship with Jadzia does survive 'the change.' However, Sisko does continue to use the nickname 'Old Man' when speaking to Jadzia. While misgendering a trans person is not recommended, it's clear that this nickname is a sign of Sisko's affection for Jadzia. A Trans Allegory?
There are many other scenes featuring Jadzia that are held in high regard by those Trekkies who perceive the character as a trans allegory. To cite just one more out of many examples, we can turn to the Deep Space Nine Season 2 episode 'Blood Oath.' In that episode, Jadzia reunites with a friend, Kor the Klingon (John Colicos), whom she knew decades earlier as Curzon.
Initially, Kor refers to Jadzia as 'Curzon, [his] beloved old friend.' However, she corrects him by stating, 'I'm Jadzia now.' Kor immediately amends his statement: 'Jadzia, [his] beloved old friend.' For the rest of the episode, Kor refers to her as 'Jadzia' and uses her correct pronouns. These days, the scene has become something of a popular meme. It is frequently posted as evidence that even Klingons can adapt to a trans person's changing names and pronouns.
RELATED: Geek Girl Authority Crush of the Week: T'Pol
Furthermore, interpreting Jadzia as trans is not something that is a recent development. For proof, check out the Summer 1997 issue of Transgender Tapestry magazine. Jadzia is the featured model for the cover of Transgender Tapestry #76. The cover states: 'Star Trek, Transgender & the Final Frontier: Gene Roddenberry's Bold Journey Where No Trans Had Gone Before.' While the issue was released 28 years ago, the discussion around Jadzia remains unchanged.
Sadly, and in one of the most controversial plot beats of the series, Jadzia is killed in the penultimate season of Deep Space Nine. The Dax symbiont is subsequently transferred to a new host, Ezri (Nicole de Boer). However, it is easy to speculate how any aspect of this transition might have been handled differently, especially if the series were released today. Trans Like Me Photo Cr: Paramount+ © 2021 CBS Interactive. All Rights Reserved.
When it comes to the Trill on The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine, we have a trans allegory. While certain elements of the Trill stories align with the contemporary trans experience, other elements do not. However, the Franchise eventually bridged this gap thanks to Star Trek: Discovery.
In the Discovery Season 3 episode 'Forget Me Not,' we're introduced to Gray Tal (Ian Alexander). Like the other joined Trill in this article, Gray has both a host and a symbiont. However, his story is somewhat complicated. When we first meet Gray, his host body is dead. The Tal symbiont has been transferred to a human, Gray's partner, human Adira Tal (Blu del Barrio). Because Adira is human, they do not join with the symbiont in the same way a Trill host would. However, Adira does continue to see visions of Gray.
RELATED: 5 Star Trek Meme Source Episodes
Eventually, the problem is solved by removing the Tal symbiont from Adira and transferring it to a synthetic 'golem' using the Soong method. This can easily be seen as an allegory for contemporary gender affirming procedures.
However, unlike previous Trill, Gray is also textually trans. This is thanks to the fact that the humanoid Trill host is a trans man. Before joining with the Tal symbiont (and before his death), Gray had already transitioned. While trans allegory is good, making Gray textually trans (while maintaining allegorical elements) allows us to have our replicated cake and eat it too. We Get to the Future Together
Hopefully, the Star Trek Franchise will continue to offer textual trans representation moving forward. As Great Bird of the Galaxy Gene Roddenberry said: 'Star Trek was an attempt to say that humanity will reach maturity and wisdom on the day that it begins not just to tolerate, but take a special delight in differences in ideas and differences in life forms.'
RELATED: Star Trek Episode Trilogy: Revisiting 'Unification'
Roddenberry continued, 'If we cannot learn to actually enjoy those small differences, to take a positive delight in those small differences between our own kind, here on this planet, then we do not deserve to go out into space and meet the diversity that is almost certainly out there.'
These episodes of Star Trek are currently available for streaming on Paramount+.
The Premise and How STAR TREK Fans Created Fanfic as We Know It Avery Kaplan is the author of several books and the Features Editor at Comics Beat. She was honored to serve as a judge for the 2021 Cartoonist Studio Prize Award and the 2021 Prism Awards. She lives in the mountains of Southern California with her partner and a pile of cats, and her favorite place to visit is the cemetery. You can also find her writing on Comics Bookcase, NeoText, Shelfdust, the Mary Sue, StarTrek.com, in many issues of PanelxPanel, and in the margins of the books in her personal library.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

CBS News

37 minutes ago

• CBS News

Rats in Boston may be spreading potentially deadly disease, Tufts University study says

Tufts study says rats in Boston could be spreading potentially deadly disease Tufts study says rats in Boston could be spreading potentially deadly disease Tufts study says rats in Boston could be spreading potentially deadly disease Rats in Boston may be spreading a potentially deadly disease, according to a Tufts University study. The disease is called leptospirosis, which is caused by a bacterium called Leptospira. It is typically found in tropical areas, but a link has been found between rats and leptospirosis in other urban areas. Researchers worked on the study for six years, testing different brown rats from the Boston area, including the Boston Public Garden and Boston Common. They found that most rat populations in Boston carry the disease-causing bacteria, which can infect both humans and animals. Researchers warn that the disease's prevalence is expected to increase with climate change. Leptospirosis is typically spread through direct exposure to urine or a "urine-contaminated environment, which then can serve as an infection source for additional rats and other mammals, including humans," the study says. Leptospirosis can be spread through contact with water, soil, and eating food that has been contaminated with animal urine. The bacteria can survive in both water and soil for months. There are around one million cases of leptospirosis in humans around the world every year, and around 60,000 deaths, according to the CDC. Symptoms of leptospirosis Leptospirosis can be deadly if not treated, causing organ failure, trouble breathing, and death, the CDC says. Symptoms of the disease include: Fever Headache Chills Body aches Rash Diarrhea or vomiting Jaundice Red eyes Seek treatment immediately if you think you may have been infected with leptospirosis. Here are some recommended ways to prevent infection: Avoid contact with potentially infected animals Cover any open wounds, including cuts and scratches Wear waterproof clothing and shoes near floodwater or infected soil Research leptospirosis cases if you intend to go swimming A vaccine for leptospirosis is available in the United States for both cats and dogs. If you are concerned that your pet may have contracted the disease, visit the CDC website for more information.

CBS News

43 minutes ago

• CBS News

Cubs legend Sammy Sosa returns to Wrigley Field after 20-plus-year hiatus

Legendary Cubs slugger Sammy Sosa returned to Wrigley Field for the first time in more than 20 years on Friday before Chicago's afternoon game with the Seattle Mariners. Sosa, who is set to be inducted into the Cubs' team Hall of Fame this year, arrived at the iconic North Side ballpark in a black SUV. He was greeted by owner Tom Ricketts, who embraced him in a hug as he exited the vehicle. Sosa became the face of the Cubs franchise where he played 13 seasons after coming in a trade from the crosstown White Sox in March 1992. A seven-time All-Star, Sosa hit 545 homers in 1,811 games with the Cubs and hit a franchise-record 66 in 1998 when he was named the NL's MVP. Sosa, now 56, played his final game with the Cubs at Wrigley on Oct. 2, 2004, when he homered and had two hits in an 8-6 loss to Atlanta. During his years with the Cubs, Sosa appeared to bulk up drastically and was a headliner in a generation of baseball's biggest names linked to performance-enhancing drugs. The Cubs traded him to Baltimore with cash in February 2005 for three players. Sosa appeared to acknowledge using performance-enhancing drugs in December when he released a statement saying he was sorry for mistakes, without specifying them. "There were times I did whatever I could to recover from injuries in an effort to keep my strength up to perform over 162 games," he said in the statement. "I never broke any laws. But in hindsight, I made mistakes and I apologize." On Friday morning, Sosa posed for photos with rising Cubs star Pete Crow-Armstrong outside the team's clubhouse and a video showed Sosa embracing manager Craig Counsell in his office before the game. "(Sosa) saw the wind blowing out today and planned this trip around a good day to be here," Counsell joked. "He asked to be in the lineup because the wind's blowing out." The Cubs honored Sosa with a video board tribute after the second inning. Sosa waved and bowed to fans from a suite during the presentation. In Thursday's 8-7 loss to Milwaukee, Crow-Armstrong went deep to set a new team record for reaching 20 homers and 20-plus stolen stolen bases the fastest, doing it in 73 games. Sosa had the old mark of 96, set in 1994. Counsell, who faced Sosa as a player, saluted the former slugger for his strength at the plate and long homers, as well as star power. "Probably the best thing, Sammy was a true entertainer," Counsell said. "I think when you're in this long enough, you realize that's part of this. "We're also here to entertain and I think Sammy was great at that."

Forbes

an hour ago

• Forbes

‘Jaws' New 50th Anniversary Release And Documentary Get Better With Age

Hollywood icon Steven Spielberg's Jaws was released 50 years ago today and quickly became the highest grossing movie in cinema history. The filmmaker's career, the summer blockbuster, and our modern obsession with sharks all owe their existence mostly to Jaws, and a new anniversary release (including documentary Jaws @ 50: The Definitive Inside Story) all prove it just gets better with age. American actor Richard Dreyfuss (L) and British actor Robert Shaw (1927 - 1978) hold ropes while ... More leaning off the back of their boat, 'Orca,' in pursuit of the giant Great White shark in a still from the film, 'Jaws,' directed by Steven Spielberg, 1975. (Photo by Universal Pictures/Fotos International/Courtesy of Getty Images) Jaws - Trial By Water Spielberg began shooting in May 1974 on Martha's Vineyard, insisting on real ocean locations for authenticity. The eight-week shoot ballooned to 159 days and the budget soared from $4 million to nearly $10 million. Every day brought new woes, as rough seas wrecked shots, boats drifted into frame, equipment failed, and the mechanical shark seldom worked as intended. There were actually three 'Bruces' built, but saltwater corroded their innards, causing one shark to sink and others to fall apart. 'We never fixed the shark, and it was a total disaster,' Spielberg later admitted of those early trials. Faced with constant delays and a creature that wouldn't cooperate, Spielberg improvised. He and co-writer Carl Gottlieb were rewriting nightly to work around the malfunctioning shark, slashing its screen time and letting imagination fill the gaps. Spielberg's ingenuity under duress helped transform a B-movie creature feature into white-knuckle Hitchcockian suspense. Yet during the shoot, Spielberg felt anything but confident. Morale was low among a crew stuck at sea for months, many far over schedule and far from home. The director himself was anxiety-ridden. He feared he'd be fired at any moment for the budget overruns and delays, so much so that he refused to leave the island even on weekends. 'If I left the island I was certain I would never come back,' he recalled. At one point, Spielberg even suffered what he thought was a heart attack on set. It was actually a full-blown panic attack, brought on by stress (as he reflects now, 'We didn't have words like PTSD then' to describe the toll). When the final scene wrapped, the 27-year-old filmmaker was convinced his career was over. Of course, Spielberg's fears proved unfounded. Instead, Jaws's torturous production forged a filmmaker. The young director's trials by water taught him hard lessons in resourcefulness and resilience. He emerged with a mastery beyond his years – a fact noted even at the time. Despite his youth, Spielberg 'showed a maturity behind the camera that belied his years,' one critic later observed of Jaws. In the decades that followed, Spielberg would never again face such a loss of control on set or such financial jeopardy. Jaws's success granted him creative latitude for life. But he also never forgot the experience, always saying Jaws made him a better director and helped exorcise some personal fears. Spielberg noted that perhaps Jaws was even his own fear of water incarnate. Five decades on, Spielberg participates fondly in 50th anniversary retrospectives, able to laugh about the nightmare shoot that minted his legend. As he says in the Jaws @ 50 documentary, making the film involved 'naive people against nature,' and it taught him 'you're gonna need a bigger boat' in more ways than one. Jaws Births The Blockbuster Before Jaws, the summer months were a Hollywood dead zone typically reserved for B movies or ignored entirely ('why go to the movies when the sun is shining?' as one writer put it). Jaws turned that wisdom on its head. Universal Pictures had boldly decided to market Jaws as a must-see summer event, even delaying its release to June so that 'people were in the water off the summer beach resorts,'producer David Brown noted. They blanketed television with millions of dollars worth of ads – an unprecedented blitz at the time – and plastered the now-famous image of a monstrous shark and swimmer on posters, paperback covers, and merchandise everywhere. Tie-ins ranged from Jaws-themed clothing to beach towels to hilarious toilet-seat covers. Jaws was everywhere before it even opened. The tagline 'See it before you go swimming,' was a dare that became a cultural catchphrase. The strategy worked beyond anyone's expectations. Audiences flocked to cinemas, especially the new multiplexes in shopping malls. Many returned for multiple viewings, bringing friends in tow. An event movie mentality was born. Jaws became the highest-grossing film of all time after a record debut and months atop the box office charts. By the end of that summer, the 'sleepy months' had become prime box-office real estate. As screenwriter Carl Gottlieb later observed, Jaws's release proved that selling a film 'as a phenomenon, as a destination' could yield massive returns. It's a lesson Hollywood would take to heart. Jaws - From Popcorn Hit to Classic On its 10th anniversary in 1985, Jaws was already enshrined as a pop culture icon that spawned imitators and its own lesser sequels, as audiences' appetite for sharks remained strong. Meanwhile, directors like James Cameron and John Landis were citing Jaws as formative, and products from toys to theme-park rides continued to rake in money and prove the films' continued popularity. At 10 years old, Jaws was demonstrating its generational staying power. The 25th anniversary in 2000 saw Jaws celebrated in fan circles and by a new generation of filmmakers. Although initially some critics turned up their noses at the film as low-brow entertainment for the masses, by 2000 Jaws was almost universally lauded and the film frequently landed on 'greatest movies' lists. The 30th anniversary in 2005 brought JawsFest to Martha's Vineyard: a large fan gathering that featured cast reunions, location tours, and panel discussions with Jaws scholars. Hundreds of fans descended on the little island. By the time Jaws's 45th anniversaries rolled around, society was locked down in the Covid pandemic's first year, terror gripping communities worldwide. And once again, Jaws proved its relevance. With indoor cinemas mostly shuttered, drive-in theaters sprang up across the country, and what was the top draw? Jaws, of course, sometimes in double features with Spielberg's Jurassic Park. You can read my own review for the film's 45th anniversary release here. Now, for the 50th anniversary this year, Jaws is getting the full treatment. Martha's Vineyard, forever synonymous with Amity Island, is hosting commemorative screenings, Jaws-themed concerts, and a 'shark in the park' event. The Academy Museum in Los Angeles has opened a special exhibit featuring the last surviving Jaws shark prop (restored to its former glory). Notably, there is the brand-new aforementioned documentary Jaws @ 50: The Definitive Inside Story. And of course, there is a 4K UHD special edition home release of Jaws for the 5oth anniversary, including the documentary, which I'll discuss more below. Jaws And Me Five Decades Later Jaws turns 50 the same summer I turn 55. Jaws is my favorite film, encompassing my feelings as a young wide-eyed child seeing it for the first time at a drive-in (talk about larger than life, especially for a small kid) and then rewatching it endlessly on TV and VHS until the tapes wore out. Much of my early years revolved around my love of comics and films, with Jaws, Taxi Driver, Star Wars, and Superman being among the biggest focuses of my attention and remaining long-lasting favorites and influences. In my teen years, I was more interested in music and other pursuits, and aside from a handful of films – including The Terminator, Aliens, Witness, The Right Stuff, Platoon, Die Hard, and Raising Arizona – mid- and late-1980s cinema is mostly something I rediscovered in college when I went back to see what I'd missed. In those first few years, Jaws represented a grounded realistic portrayal at immense scale, horrifying and thrilling and funny, at once seeming like ordinary everyday life and yet also mythic and consequential. My small mind grasped much of that, even if in simplistic and more limited form. But as I grew up, and as I watched more films and read more comics and spent more time on boats and in life itself, Jaws seemed to grow and take on new relevance. It revealed itself to me in different ways, and in turn helped me also think about its themes and the world in different ways as well. It is one of the films that most made me dream of making my own movies, and its been an immense influence on my own approach to dialogue, pacing, and sequencing when I write screenplays. I personally think of Jaws as primarily a suspense thriller with horror elements, rather than an outright horror movie, but I won't argue with anyone who puts it in the latter category. Interestingly, the extent to which it leans more toward thriller or horror often depends on which themes and perspectives are at the forefront of my mind and interpretations while viewing it, including any subtextual social relevance I bring into the screening. Mark Travers' excellent 50th anniversary piece about Jaws notes the way ambiguity enhances our fear by letting our own minds fill in the horror-blanks, so to speak. This is similar to the same reason I'm a fan of zombie films – they're less about the literal particulars of zombies than whatever the zombies come to represent in the minds of individual and collective viewers. Zombies are a metaphor for whatever terrifies and threatens us, be it pandemics or nuclear war or climate change or civil war, the living dead are an empty slate upon which we write our own nightmares. Jaws is a perfect early example of this, within a more refined context as Travers discusses. And the way the shark is more menacing and more terrifying when we don't see it speaks to a point Robert Patterson's Bruce Wayne makes during his opening narration in Matt Reeves' The Batman when he says that because he could be anywhere, scared villains see him everywhere. Jaws - The Legacy Lives On Half a century after it first made audiences cry and popcorn fly, Jaws remains a powerful force in pop culture. Its legacy is seen every year when summer movie season rolls around. Its DNA is present whenever a filmmaker holds back a monster reveal to build suspense or a blockbuster balances character moments with eye-popping thrills. Its cautionary themes about respecting nature, heeding warnings and science, and finding courage are as relevant as ever. And in the simple act of scaring people out of the water, Jaws achieved a kind of immortality that few works of fiction ever do. Modern viewers are still struck by how Jaws, despite launching an era of big-budget popcorn spectacle, remains a relatively modestly human-scaled thriller at heart. Compared to today's CGI-filled epics, Jaws was a mid-budget film that relied on character, suspense, and primal fear more than flashy effects. When the time for effects did come, the realism and selective use made them all the more impressive and scary. In fact, many argue Hollywood took the wrong lessons from Jaws, that studios focused on 'bigger boat' spectacle rather than what truly made the film great – its tight storytelling and craft. The real keys were suspense, relatable characters, and Spielberg's deft directing. Thus, while Jaws undeniably gave Hollywood a new formula for summer hits, it also stands apart from the very blockbusters it inspired. Jaws would thrive in any era. Indeed, the modern masterpiece Godzilla Minus One from writer-director-VFX Supervisor Takashi Yamazaki is heavily inspired by Jaws. The film reflects the best sort of inspiration from Spielberg's film, including the power of character-driven storytelling, suspense and anticipation, and a brilliant vision from its director. If you want a particularly great 50th anniversary of Jaws, the new 4K UHD edition and the gorgeous Godzilla Minus One/Minus Color make for a perfect pairing. Then watch the anniversary documentary Jaws @ 50 (either on the excellent physical home release, or when it runs on National Geographic/Hulu/Disney+) for insightful and revelatory conversations with cast and crew, including Spielberg's conversations about his own reactions and lingering traumas over the many years and decades after making Jaws. For Spielberg and the cast and crew, it probably seems astonishing that a film made under such duress could endure so powerfully. But perhaps it's precisely those challenges that made Jaws great, the creative solutions and on-the-fly brilliance born from chaos and necessity. Jaws transcended its humble 'summer thriller' origins to become a classic. Despite the great Roger Ebert's own glowing review, many of his contemporaries couldn't all see of its greatness, with many dismissing it as nonsense or mere shock entertainment. But time has vindicated Jaws. Today, it is firmly entrenched as a historic turning point in American cinema, dissected in film courses, and beloved by filmmakers and audiences alike. From its metaphorical depths exploring fear of the unknown and the perils of greed and hubris, to its lasting impact on filmmaking and pop culture, five decades on Jaws remains a timeless masterpiece reflecting changes in Hollywood and society, even as it continues to scare new generations out of the water.