Early release of hundreds of prisoners to begin in Scotland
The first of up to 390 prisoners are being released early in the latest attempt to ease overcrowding in Scotland's jails.Emergency legislation was passed last year which allows eligible inmates sentenced to less than four years to be freed after 40% of their term, rather than 50%.They will be released in three tranches over a six-week period, starting on Tuesday. Prisoners serving sentences for domestic abuse or sexual offences are excluded.Justice Secretary Angela Constance said the prison population was "too high".
"What we can't have is overcrowded prisons because that is not in the interests of prisoners, staff and ultimately the community, because that means we are not rehabilitating people," Constance said.At the end of last week, there were 8,344 inmates in Scotland's prisons – above the target operating capacity of 8,007.Last summer 477 prisoners were released early in an emergency attempt to ease overcrowding.But 61 ended up back in custody before their original planned release date, according to SPS data, and within two months the overall prison population had again risen above the level at which the releases began. More than 1,700 prisoners were released early in England and Wales last autumn as part of a similar attempt by the UK government to ease overcrowding.
Release 'traumatising' for victims
The charity Victim Support Scotland (VSS) and the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) have jointly urged victims of crime to sign up for a scheme to be notified if they will be affected by a prisoner release.Both organisations say only a small percentage of victims have joined, and VSS is calling for a more proactive approach than the current system which relies on victims to sign up.Kate Wallace, chief executive of VSS, said some victims were "worried for their own and their family's safety when someone's being released from prison."Early releases had also raised anxiety amongst victims of older crimes, she said, sometimes causing renewed trauma.
Lynn Burns' son Sam Johnston was 22 when he was stabbed to death at a house party in Saltcoats, North Ayrshire, in 2013.Stuart McCulloch was convicted of Mr Johnston's murder and sentenced to 13 years and five months in jail. His co-accused Allan Carey was convicted of culpable homicide and jailed for three years.Ms Burns said she only found out that Carey had been released early after he arrived back in their home town."As a victim," she said, "all we want is to feel safe in our communities."Carey's release was "completely traumatising," she explained, adding those feelings had resurfaced on hearing about the latest releases.
'Pressure cooker' Victorian jail
The notorious Barlinnie prison in Glasgow is at the forefront of overcrowding problems.The Victorian jail, which opened in the 1880s, is now at 140% capacity with nearly 1,400 prisoners when it was designed for just 987.The governor, Michael Stoney, has even admitted he would "struggle" to cope as an inmate there.He described Scotland's largest jail as a "pressure cooker" and said the new early release laws were necessary for staff and inmates although he accepted that some of those released early would "inevitably return" as part of a cycle of re-offending."In this prison we do the best we can. We have a real focus on those that are getting released under this scheme," he said."You nudge people forward in terms of life development," said Mr Stoney. A controversial replacement for Barlinnie, HMP Glasgow, is being built at a cost of almost £1bn and due to open in 2028.
Prisoners 'warehoused'
Former prisoner Jordan Robertson is building a new life as an artist after a series of short-term sentences for gang-related crime.He knows well the impact of overcrowding."I've seen the deterioration of the system, because from the first time I was in to the last time I've seen it drastically get worse," he told BBC Scotland News."You're seeing people basically get warehoused because the courts can't deal with the demand."
Mr Robertson described the early release scheme as a "a very short term measure" to solve overcrowding rather than tackle reoffending.He said it was a "quick fix" and rehabilitation was the "long game".
Critics of the early release scheme, on both the left and right of politics, say it is an indictment of the Scottish government's approach to criminal justice.The Scottish Conservatives' justice spokesman Liam Kerr said overcrowding was "a crisis entirely of the SNP's own making," pointing to their "catastrophic failure to build new prisons on time and on budget".Justice reform campaigners are also critical.It is now more than 16 years since the report of the Scottish Prisons Commission, chaired by former Labour first minister Henry McLeish, urged a fresh approach.It argued that while "Scotland imprisons more of its people than many other places in Europe," high levels of incarceration had done little to tackle "real problems with violence, alcohol and drugs".
Ms Burns, whose son was murdered, now helps other victims going through the justice system and she agrees fundamental change is needed.On the one hand, she said, 40% of a sentence might not be enough time to rehabilitate a prisoner. On the other, some prisoners were serving prison terms who should have been sentenced to alternatives.She said some people should be in prison for the safety of the public, but there were other examples in the wider community where more could be done to rehabilitate those who had committed crimes. Ms Burns continued: "How we punish and rehabilitate people should be an issue, and how we care for victims should be as big a priority. And I don't believe it always is."What we've been doing is not working."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
a day ago
- Scottish Sun
Horrifying masks & sordid sex dolls – terrifying swingers' ‘House from HELL' which lay abandoned after grisly murder
MOULDY sex dolls and creepy masks have been uncovered inside a murder mansion dubbed the "house from hell" . Porn magazines and sordid photos were among items discovered at the former brothel in Paignton, Devon, where a man was murdered more than two decades ago. 7 Mouldy sex dolls and creepy masks were discovered in the property Credit: Not known, clear with picture desk 7 Printed images of a blonde girl with groups of men were also uncovered Credit: YouTube 7 The 'murder mansion' was renowned for hosting wild sex parties Credit: YouTube Condemned property 3 Keysfield Road - which was renowned for hosting wild sex parties - was dubbed the "house from hell" by neighbours. Urban explorers found boxes piled high with sordid images of a blonde girl with a group of men at the abandoned Victorian villa. Kayleigh Coulston and Proving Demons were left in shock at their "freaky" discoveries in the house, including a blow-up doll and horrifying masks. At several points in the video, they remark to one another that many of the items are not suitable to be shown on YouTube. In footage posted online, Kayleigh says: "Oh no - it's a sex doll. "I did not think we would find that in here. At least she is deflated! "That is so weird - so freaky. I can just tell we're going to be in for a field day at this place. "Already we've found a DVD cover which obviously I can't film and now we've found a blow-up naughty doll. "I'm trying not to film some of it because I can see on the floor there are a lot of dirty articles. "Unfortunately YouTube will not let me get away with that one." They pull out a variety of porn magazines from piles of rubbish on the floors and tables, including a copy of Loaded's 'Big Sexy Orgy' from 2003. The house - now being turned into 14 flats - was the scene of a gruesome murder in 2000. Inside bizarre abandoned 'love motel' where randy couples bonked on beds shaped like boxing rings & fairground rides Dad-of-three David Maher was killed after he was hit over the head with a monkey wrench by drug dealer Peter Mann in a row over cocaine. Mann later dumped the body at a nearby dairy depot. He was jailed for life. The homeowner Angela Claydon, who was the girlfriend of Mann at the time, was also convicted of trying to cover up the crime and helping the killer flee the country. She was jailed for nine months following the trial in 2002. The house was closed by cops in 2010 following complaints from neighbours about drug-taking, prostitution and anti-social behaviour. Residents reported seeing people urinating and defecating in the grounds outside the house. 7 Dad-of-three David Maher was killed in the property after he was hit over the head with a monkey wrench Credit: YouTube 7 The house - now being turned into 14 flats - was the scene of a gruesome murder Credit: YouTube 7 Urban explorers found boxes piled high with sordid images of girls with groups of men Credit: YouTube It was the first home in Paignton to be the subject of a closure order. On the same day police were set to put a closure order on the building, firefighters had been called to the property after Peter Heron tried to burn the house down. The 43-year-old was jailed for 28 months after he used a blowtorch and had the gas turned on in while other tenants were still inside. In 2017, "rogue landlady" Claydon was also found guilty of allowing the property to be occupied - despite a prohibition order banning people from living there. Newton Abbot Magistrates' Court heard that residents and police officers had seen people on the site. The fire service had entered the property in November 2016 to rescue an occupant, thought to be aged in his 40s, during a fire in which a dog died. The former multiple-occupancy house has been described by local police as "a blot on the landscape". Council planners gave the nod to convert the crime-hit derelict home into flats in 2020. Work is now underway to breathe new life into the sordid site. At a planning meeting, Councillor Barbara Lewis said the property had been the source of problems for residents and the development would improve and regenerate the area. She added: 'All the residents of Keysfield Road will be delighted.'
Glasgow Times
a day ago
- Glasgow Times
Volunteers supporting crime victims praised by Princess Royal
More than 100 volunteers and staff from Victim Support Scotland (VSS) were honoured by her visit at the annual OneVSS Volunteering Festival on June 12. Princess Anne, who is the charity's patron, was there to celebrate Volunteers' Week 2025 and the 40th anniversary of VSS. A group of 12 volunteers had the chance to meet her and discuss their roles as well as challenges faced by victims and witnesses of crime. Read more: 'Mmm yummy': Marti Pellow reveals city's 'best' spot for mac and cheese Man dies on beach after 'taking unwell' Date of first Rangers vs Celtic 2025/26 Scottish Premiership fixture confirmed Numerous awards were given to staff and volunteers in categories such as Volunteer Mentor, Volunteer Impact, New Volunteer, Colleague Support, and Spirit of VSS. They were also commended for their long service, with some having dedicated 28 years as volunteers and 35 years as staff members. The Princess Royal praised the attendees, acknowledging the support they have offered to victims of crime across Scotland for four decades. James Whyte, head of volunteering at VSS, said: "It was a real treat for our volunteers to meet The Princess Royal, and we are incredibly grateful for the support she has shown as our patron and the interest taken in the vital support we provide to people impacted by crime in Scotland. "This festival focused on celebrating the amazing contribution of our volunteers, and the staff who support them every day. "Our volunteers are often supporting people going through the most difficult time in their lives, and at VSS we want to let them know that they are appreciated and valued - not only by the people we support but by the entire organisation." Victim Support Scotland is an independent, volunteer-led charity that provides emotional, practical, and trauma-informed support to individuals and families dealing with the impact of crime in Scotland. Volunteers guide victims and witnesses through the court process, provide emotional support, signpost specialist services, or simply listen to those who feel isolated and unheard in the criminal justice system.
The Herald Scotland
3 days ago
- The Herald Scotland
Death never takes a holiday but you do: 10 best crime books for summer
Ambrose Parry, Canongate, £18.99, Canongate, out now Writers Chris Brookmyre and Dr Marisa Haetzman (Image: Getty Images) Why has STV or BBC Scotland not given us a small screen version of Parry's Raven and Fisher Victorian murder mysteries? Budget - or the lack of it - is, presumably, the boring answer. But this splendid series, now drawing to a close, is tailor-made for a TV adaptation. Set in Edinburgh's medical community in the mid-1800s, this is the fifth and final volume in a series of wonderfully crafted entertainments by husband-and-wife duo Chris Brookmyre and Marisa Haetzman, operating under the Ambrose Parry nom de plume. Victorian virtues turn out to be anything but in this gripping story which takes in photography, pornography and people trafficking. White City Dominic Nolan, Headline, £10.99, July 3 Out in paperback at the start of July, this is crime fiction as historical epic. Inspired by a real-life event - the Eastcastle Street robbery of a Post Office van in London in 1952 - this sweeping novel takes the temperature of the capital in the post-war years, culminating in the Notting Hill riots at the end of the decade. More James Ellroy than Agatha Christie, it's bleak, brutal and often thrilling. It's about cops and robbers - and how close both those sides can be - as well as postwar housing, Rachmanism (Peter Rachman is one of just a number of real-life people who appear in its pages; see also Lady Docker), racism and politics at the margins. Both vivid and visceral, it's a rewarding reminder of just how ambitious crime fiction can be. The Good Liar, Denise Mina, Harvill Secker, £16.99, July 31 Oh, this is also very good. Published at the end of July, Denise Mina's new book is a reminder of just how potent a writer the Glasgow author is. The Good Liar is a standalone novel that is embedded in the worlds of forensic science and the law. Doctor Claudia O'Shiel is a blood spatter expert who becomes involved in the investigation of a brutal double murder in an opulent London townhouse. The chief suspect is a Viscount who's never out of the papers. What follows is a novel about grief (O'Shiel has recently lost her husband), the seductive nature of the British establishment and moral compromise. It's sharp, clear-eyed and clever. Rum Punch, Elmore Leonard, Penguin, £9.99, out now 'Sunday morning, Ordell took Louis to watch the white-power demonstration in downtown Palm Beach. ''Young skinhead Nazis,' Ordell said, 'Look, even little Nazi girls marching down Worth Avenue. You believe it?'' Rum Punch, Elmore Leonard (Image: Penguin) Ah, I'd forgotten what a joy it was to read Elmore Leonard. Since the author's death in 2013 he has slightly slipped out of the public eye, but Penguin has now added him to its Modern Classics Crime and Espionage series. The first three of 14 books - Rum Punch, The Switch and Swag - are out now and they're essential reading. Rum Punch is the source material for Quentin Tarantino's film Jackie Brown, which is fine and all, but the original is better. Leonard is one of the great prose stylists of the late 20th century. And these handsomely designed reissues are a wonderful excuse to become reacquainted with one of crime fiction's true originals. The Cut Richard Armitage, Faber, £18.99, August 28 Richard Armitage (Image: PA) Actor Richard Armitage (The Hobbit, Captain America) made something of a splash with his debut thriller Geneva in 2023. This follow-up is a tricksy, time-switching story about High School rivalries and a teenage murder, jumping between then (the 1990s) and now. At times the result pushes hard against the border of believability, but you do keep reading to find out what really happened in the past and what's going to happen in the present. The Man Who Died Seven Times, Yashuhiko Nishizawa, Pushkin Vertigo, £14.99, August 14 More tricksy, time-switching entertainment. On steroids. In fact Yasuhiko Nishizawa's crime novel - translated by Jesse Kirkwood - qualifies for that Doctor Who description, 'wibbly wobbly timey-wimey'. The man in the title is Hisataro's grandfather. He's dead on the first page and then comes back to life a few pages later. That's because for some reason his grandson regularly relives certain days over and over. And so when his grandad is killed - yes, it's murder - he decides to try and change the course of events. But it proves more difficult than he imagines. This is puzzle fiction for want of a better description. It has no other purpose than to entertain. It succeeds at that. Like a Bullet Andrew Cartmel, Titan Books,£9.99, July 8 Like a Bullet by Andrew Cartmel (Image: Titan Books) This year has been a bumper one for Andrew Cartmel fans. There's already been a new Vinyl Detective book - Underscore, the eighth in this hugely entertaining series. And next month sees the third in his Paperback Sleuth series in which our morally ambivalent heroine Cordelia Stanmer tracks down rare paperbacks and somehow becomes embroiled in the odd spot of murder as a result. In her latest adventure she is tasked with finding copies of a pulp wartime series originally published in the late 1960s and early 1970s. In fine condition, it goes without saying. (Not mint condition. That's for coins, stamps, comics and records.) In doing so she meets dodgy brothers, one-armed ex-military men and an author with a taste for Bettie Page and bondage. It's a brisk amuse-bouche of a book, one that wears its learning lightly. Very moreish. The Diary of Lies, Philip Miller, Polygon, £9.99, August 7 The third Shona Sandison thriller is full of spies, conspiracies, government secrets, the newspaper industry and, inevitably, murder. Plenty, then, for our journalist heroine to get her teeth into. Miller, formerly arts correspondent of this parish, has proven himself a very able crime writer in recent years. Among the many admirers of his last novel, The Hollow Tree, was David Peace, author of the Red Riding Quartet, and The Damned United no less. Murder Takes a Vacation, Laura Lippman, Faber, £9.99, August 14 Mrs Blossom is, as the title implies, going on holiday. A cruise down the Seine. Quite something given that she has never left the United States before. It's just a pity that there has to be a murder at the start of it. Veteran crime writer Laura Lippman has taken a minor character from her Tess Monaghan series and placed her front and centre in this cosy crime story. It works perfectly well enough as such, but, really, what makes this essential is that at heart it is a nuanced and clever character study of a flawed, decent woman in her sixties coming to terms with grief and a growing sense of adventure. Mrs Blossom is a delight to spend time with. Oh, and by the way, you may well come away from this with a newfound interest in the abstract artist Joan Mitchell and the ceramics of American industrial designer Russel Wright. A Particularly Nasty Case, Adam Kay, Orion, £16.99, August 28 Not out until the end of August, former doctor Adam Kay has - as his publisher points out - 'decided to stop writing about saving people's lives and start killing them off instead.' Everyone from Russell T Davies to the aforementioned Chris Brookmyre and Joanna Lumley are raving about this development. Chapter 26 is entitled 'Autopsy-turvy'. How you respond to that may tell you whether you'll like it or not. (It made me smirk.)
