Another blow to development
EDITORIAL: To take money out of the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP) and reallocate it as subsidy is not just bad policy — it's a confession. When the Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) surrendered Rs50 billion from the PSDP to the Power Division to meet circular debt targets set by the IMF, it tacitly admitted that long-term development has once again been sacrificed at the altar of short-term survival.
Even worse, this wasn't a contingency. The plan to fund solar tube wells in Balochistan was approved nearly a year ago. That it still wasn't reflected in budget allocations — and now requires a last-minute diversion of core development funding — says all that needs to be said about planning capacity and fiscal governance.
That this comes amid chronic under-utilisation of the PSDP makes the decision all the more indefensible. According to the Planning Commission, just 41 percent of the revised PSDP allocation has been spent in 10 months. The total allocation had already been revised downward — from Rs1.4 trillion to Rs1.1 trillion — yet only Rs448.6 billion was utilised by end-April. Clearly, the problem is not a lack of available funds, but a near-systemic inability to spend them productively.
The gap between funds released and funds utilised is particularly revealing. Of the Rs638 billion authorised for various ministries and divisions, only Rs339 billion has actually been spent. The PSDP release schedule from the Finance Division had allowed for 73 percent of funds to be disbursed by this point in the fiscal year. The fact that actual utilisation is lagging so far behind points to failures in coordination, execution, and oversight.
Worse still is the complete inaction by several ministries. The commerce, communications, and religious affairs divisions, among others, have spent nothing from their PSDP allocations so far. This is not merely inefficiency — it is dereliction. Ministries that cannot spend even a fraction of their budgetary authorisations are not just administratively weak, they are obstructing national development itself.
And yet, one line item has bucked the trend: funds earmarked for parliamentarians. Against a revised allocation of Rs25 billion, a full Rs35 billion has already been spent. In a year where so many ministries failed to move a rupee, development funds for elected officials have not only been fully disbursed, they've overshot the budget. This alone captures how public money continues to be lavished on political priorities at the cost of national ones.
The government has claimed that the Rs50 billion reallocated to the Power Division will help solarise 27,000 tube wells in Balochistan. While the solarisation plan may have merit, the fact that Rs14 billion had already been disbursed under this head shows that it was an established project — yet one that never made it into actual planning frameworks or development allocations. Now, instead of correcting that oversight, the government is plugging the hole by cannibalising PSDP funds, further diminishing the scope of broader development.
All this is happening during a time of rare macroeconomic breathing room. The IMF's recent satisfaction with Pakistan's performance and a relatively low inflation environment had created a small window for consolidating fiscal reform and rebooting growth. Instead, mis-governance is squandering it. For yet another year, PSDP utilisation is likely to fall well short of target—continuing a pattern of underperformance that spans governments and budget cycles.
It is telling that this year, ministries were asked to surrender unspent funds a month earlier than usual. While this may have been intended to enforce discipline, it has instead amplified confusion. Some divisions reportedly cut their development activity prematurely, fearing that delayed paperwork would result in permanent loss of funds. That budget management is still subject to such reactive, uncoordinated decision-making speaks volumes about the institutional fragility of the system.
Pakistan cannot afford to treat development spending as a flexible account. The PSDP is not a slush fund to be redirected when convenient — it is the country's primary lever for building infrastructure, improving services, and fostering long-term growth. But unless budgeted funds are actually spent, and unless they are spent well, none of this matters. Time and again, successive governments have failed to meet development targets not because of economic constraints alone, but due to inefficiency, poor governance, and often outright neglect.
In the end, the numbers speak for themselves. Billions remain unspent, core ministries are dormant, yet parliamentarians are flush with funds. And once again, what passes for planning is little more than posturing. It's not just wasteful — it's unforgivable.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
4 hours ago
- Express Tribune
College excluded from PSDP
Leader of the Opposition in Balochistan Assembly Mir Younas Aziz Zehri Leader of the Opposition in Balochistan Assembly Mir Younas Aziz Zehri staged a walkout from the house in a protest over exclusion of Jhalawan Medical College from Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP). In an address before leaving the session, Mir Younas berated the provincial government for neglecting a project of educational importance. "Despite consistently raising this issue, no corrective measures have been taken. The project director remains in-charge, even though he is clearly unqualified," alleged Zehri, citing mismanagement and inefficiency in the college's administration. Former Chief Minister and National Party leader Dr Malik Baloch echoed these concerns, warning that continued funding lapses and administrative failings could draw the attention of the Pakistan Medical Council (PMC). "If PMC takes notice, the college's accreditation could be at risk — threatening the future of hundreds of medical students," he cautioned. In response, Chief Minister Mir Sarfaraz Bugti assured to review the decision.
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
IMF rejects tax rebate for teachers, researchers: FBR
ISLAMABAD: Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) Chairman Rashid Mahmood Langrial, Saturday, informed the National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance that the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has rejected proposal of the FBR to allow 25 percent tax rebate to teachers and researchers from July 1, 2025. The FBR chairman informed the committee that the FBR has twice approached the fund, but they have not agreed. The IMF wants harmonisation of taxes and not allowed the said tax rebate to teachers/researchers. However, the government can give subsidy from budget if possible. MNA Nafeesa Shah stated that the government can give some kind of special allowance to teachers. Budget FY26: Aurangzeb announces major tax relief for salaried class, solar sector State Minister of Finance Bilal Azhar Kayani regretted that there is no fiscal space available in 2025-26. The National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance approved the revised procedure of arrest in cases of tax fraud as approved by Senate Standing Committee on Finance. The FBR chairman informed the committee that the FBR has its own jails to keep persons involved in tax fraud and it can also use other jails for this purpose. The government has incorporated four major safeguards for allowing arrests on tax frauds in order to avoid misuse of powers. In the first pre-requisite, the minister said that the accused of tax fraud would be arrested where there was a fear of his escape, but it would be done with the approval of three members of the Board, including FBR Member IR (Operations) and FBR Member Legal. The tampering of proof could be the second reason, and the third reason could be tax fraud amounting to Rs50 million. The fourth condition of the arrest, he said, would only be possible if someone received three notices but not bothered to respond. The FBR chairman informed that the relevant clause of income tax exemption to pensioners has been deleted from the Income Tax Ordinance to tax only pensions above Rs10 million. The committee recommended that the withholding tax should be increased from 0.6 per cent to 0.8 per cent on cash withdrawals from banks by non-filers. However, the committee rejected the proposal of Senate Standing Committee on Finance to raise tax rate from 0.6 per cent to 1 percent. On the taxation of salaried individuals, the FBR chairman informed that only one per cent tax would be applicable on salaried individuals where taxable income exceeds Rs600,000 but does not exceed Rs1,200,000. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
a day ago
- Express Tribune
Punjab unveils Rs50b shrimp farming expansion plan
The Punjab government has launched an expansive Rs50 billion plan to scale up shrimp farming across the province, aiming to transform the sector into a major contributor to the local economy and export earnings. Key components of the initiative include the development of a model fish market in Lahore and three state-of-the-art shrimp value chain estates in South Punjab's Muzaffargarh district. According to the Department of Fisheries, a 3,000-acre shrimp farming site will be established in Rakh Ali Wala, Muzaffargarh, with an initial investment of Rs10 billion. Additionally, value chain estates in Head Muhammad Wala, Rakh Ali Wala, and Shahgarh will be developed at a combined cost of Rs40 billion. The Punjab government has earmarked Rs3 billion in the upcoming fiscal budget to initiate these projects. Deputy Director of Fisheries Tayyab Rizwan stated that the value chain estates will be fully integrated, featuring hatcheries, feed mills, and shrimp processing plants. These facilities are expected to not only enhance shrimp production but also generate employment and stimulate seafood exports. In Lahore, the government plans to construct a modern model fish market at a projected cost of Rs10 billion. The facility will include cold storage, value addition units, and a streamlined supply chain network to improve market access for fish and shrimp farmers. An initial budget allocation of Rs848.6 million has been approved to commence construction.
