Expert Commentary: NZ Privacy Commissioner Provides Clarity For Retailers On Facial Recognition Technology

Press Release – Optic Security Group
Finding published yesterday by NZ Privacy Commissioner on supermarket facial recognition trial places retailers on notice, says FRT technology risk expert.
Nicholas Dynon is Brand Strategy & Innovation Director at Optic Security Group. He is a certified security risk professional and counter terrorism practitioner.
'The inquiry report found that the live facial recognition technology (FRT) model trialed by Foodstuffs North Island Limited (FSNI) in 25 of its supermarkets complied with New Zealand's Privacy Act. While the Privacy Commissioner assessed the level of privacy intrusion as high due to every shopper's face data being collected, the privacy safeguards in the trial reduced it to an acceptable level.
'The outcome has been met with strong and immediate political support, with Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith lauding the result as 'great news' and stating that he now expects the Ministerial Advisory Group for Victims of Retail Crime to 'continue to look at this technology as an option to be used more widely'.
'The outcome also provides some much-needed clarity for retailers – and other organisations – who have held back on considering FRT as a potential solution to their security issues due to the fear of ending up on the wrong side of privacy legislation. But it's not a green light.
'The Privacy Commissioner has highlighted several changes that FSNI needs to make in order to make its trial permanent or to expand it to more stores. The Office of the Privacy Commissioner (OPC) has also set out nine key expectations for organisations that are considering using FRT.
'Compliant FRT deployment is about more than just the technology itself. Factors such as identifying and assessing the specific purpose for which you want to use FRT, maintaining watchlists, protecting the system from misuse and information breach, communications to customers, staffing and training, customer interventions, incident response, managing enquiries and complaints, and maintaining and monitoring the system, are all critical to compliance – and they involve significant research, planning, testing, and careful implementation.
'At the same time, retailers should be aware that the results of an OPC survey published just weeks ago demonstrate that many New Zealanders are not supportive of the use of FRT in retail stores.
'The survey of over 1,200 New Zealanders found that 41% of respondents are 'concerned' or 'very concerned' about the use of facial recognition technology (FRT) in retail stores to identify individuals. A total of 25% are neutral on the topic, 31% are either not so concerned or not concerned at all, and 3% are unsure. 49% of Maori respondents indicated concern over FRT in retail.
'For retailers considering FRT, this means not only ensuring all the privacy legislation boxes are ticked but also taking a step back and asking whether FRT is the most appropriate solution to your security problem.
'Inappropriate FRT deployment exposes an organisation not only to legal risk but also to significant reputational risk. Engaging with trusted experts to understand the privacy dimensions and factors influencing social licence to operate this emerging technology are critical.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Scoop

an hour ago

• Scoop

Flood Of Interest To Invest In New Zealand

Minister for Economic Growth Hon Erica Stanford Minister of Immigration The Government is attracting new migrants to bring their capital, experience and skills to New Zealand with a flood of formal interest in the new 'golden' visa. Since only April – less than three months – Immigration New Zealand (INZ) has received 189 applications for the Active Investor Plus visa, significantly more than the 116 applications received over more than two-and-a-half years under previous settings, Economic Growth Minister Nicola Willis says. 'New applications under the scheme represent a potential $845 million of new investment in New Zealand business.' "Attracting investment to New Zealand is crucial to the country's economic growth. It means Kiwi businesses can expand, hire and grow – and that means more opportunities for New Zealanders. 'Investor migrants are clearly attracted to New Zealand's growing reputation as a safe, pro-business, high-potential economy. In a world where countries compete for dollars and talent, it's great to see New Zealand's growth prospects being recognised.' 'New investors don't just bring their dollars to our shores, they also bring skills, knowledge and experience that will drive future economic development. It's a win-win.' Immigration Minister Erica Stanford says the interest shows investors hear the call loud and clear: New Zealand is open for business. 'We welcome your capital, your knowledge, and your contribution to New Zealand's economic growth,' Ms Stanford says. 'We're seeing strong momentum from global investors, particularly across Asia and North America. This reflects our growing reputation as a stable, forward-looking destination for investment and innovation. 'These are smart, flexible and nuanced immigration solutions to help stimulate economic growth.' On April 1 the Government changed the Active Investor Plus visa to a simple two-pronged system: the Growth category and the Balanced category. Other changes included expanding the scope of acceptable investments and removing potential barriers to investment, such as the English language requirement. As at 23 June, 100 applications had been approved in principle, and of those, seven had transferred and invested their funds in New Zealand and had been granted a resident visa. Five of those were invested in the Growth category and two under the Balanced category, totalling a total minimum investment of $45 million. The Growth category for this Visa focuses on higher-risk investments, including managed funds and direct investments in New Zealand businesses. It will require a minimum investment of NZD $5 million for a minimum period of 3 years. The Balance category focuses on mixed investments, with the ability to choose ones that are lower risk. There will be a minimum investment of NZD $10 million over 5 years.

1News

2 hours ago

• 1News

Another bank cuts home loan interest rates

ASB has cut four fixed home lending rates in the latest round of interest rate drops hitting the market. The cuts target some of the bank's most popular mortgage terms, with the six-month rate dropping 16 basis points from 5.45% to 5.29%. One-year fixed rates fell six basis points to 4.89%, three-year rates dropped six basis points to 5.09%, and four-year terms were reduced 10 basis points to 5.49%. The bank also cut some term deposit rates by between five and 20 basis points. The six-month and one-year fixed home loan offerings are now largely in line with the other major banks. ADVERTISEMENT ASB personal banking executive general manager Adam Boyd said the reductions would help existing borrowers and first-home buyers. "We know there are many New Zealanders looking to refix their mortgage or take on the significant title of homeowner this year, and we're pleased to support them with lower rates," he said in a media release. ASB Bank (file image). (Source: 1News) "Those considering our 12-month fixed home loan will be paying 2.50% less interest than they would have been 18 months ago. "On a loan of $500,000, this reduction in interest translates to an extra $12,500 a year, which will make a real difference to many households across the country." The rate cuts come as banks compete for mortgage business amid a turbulent economy. BNZ last week lowered several of its fixed rates alongside other banks earlier this month. ADVERTISEMENT It cut its fixed six-month rate from 5.35% to 5.29%. Its one-year fixed rate was also lowered from 4.95% to 4.89%. A low equity interest rate premium also applies to those with less than 20% equity. The official cash rate was also cut to 3.25% last month, the lowest rate since October 2022. The Reserve Bank's Monetary Policy Committee will next meet on July 9.

Scoop

2 hours ago

• Scoop

Ario Encourages Government To Embrace Safer Streets And Smarter E-scooters

Press Release – Ario Ario offers the worlds safest, most innovative, and technologically advanced e-scooter. Currently operating in Christchurch, they have ambitious plans to bring its game-changing e-scooter to other cities across the country. Ario, a world leader in e-scooter innovation and design, welcomes the announcement that the Government is progressing a comprehensive reform of New Zealand's land transport rules. 'We're long-time advocates for rules that keep pace with the technology they're meant to regulate,' says Adam Rossetto, Ario's General Manager for New Zealand and Australia. 'This is a critical opportunity for the Government to make sure New Zealand has an efficient regulatory system that prioritises public safety and embraces innovation, especially in emerging transport sectors like ours.' Ario offers the world's safest, most innovative, and technologically advanced e-scooter. Currently operating in Christchurch, they have ambitious plans to bring its game-changing e-scooter to other cities across the country so communities can experience safer rides and benefit from its full suite of features such as pedestrian detection, helmet unlock-to-ride technology, and its remote parking technology. 'We're particularly excited about the changes that will allow e-scooters in cycle lanes. We wrote to the Minister of Transport about this last year, and are thrilled that it's now on the horizon,' says Mr Rosetto. Ario's remote parking system uses onboard cameras and sensors to safely reposition improperly parked scooters. This technology achieved an unparalleled 99.3% parking compliance rate (the highest in NZ) and resolved non-compliant parking incidents in an average of just 8 minutes, outperforming the industry standard of 90 minutes. Before its deactivation, 99% of all parking issues were proactively resolved by Ario's system, not by public complaints. Ario is hopeful the reforms will also improve central decision-making and help ensure New Zealand's micromobility sector does not remain stagnant. 'We're optimistic that the updated rules will allow the reactivation of our remote re-parking technology. It's disappointing that the status quo prevents New Zealanders from benefiting from the safety and accessibility improvements that should be already available to them.' Ario looks forward to engaging with the upcoming consultations, and to making the case for improved regulations that can keep up with the industry's progress without putting the brakes on technological development.