Auckland City Deserves Club World Cup Spot More Than Bayern, Benfica And Boca
CINCINNATI, OHIO - JUNE 15: Referee Issa Sy tosses the coin with Manuel Neuer of FC Bayern Munich ... More and Mario Ilich of Auckland City during the FIFA Club World Cup 2025 group C match between FC Bayern München and Auckland City FC at TQL Stadium on June 15, 2025 in Cincinnati, Ohio. (Photo by Stuart Franklin - FIFA/FIFA via Getty Images)
Another heavy defeat will be expected for Auckland City when it faces Benfica in its second match of the FIFA Club World Cup on Friday afternoon, which will likely lead to more questions around the New Zealand club's inclusion in the tournament.
Auckland City is the sole representative from the Oceania Football Confederation (OFC), and is the only team in the competition with amateur status.
Its 10-0 loss to German Bundesliga giants Bayern Munich in the opening game of Group C led many to question its presence at the tournament, and whether a team from the OFC deserves a place at this newly expanded Club World Cup.
Auckland City's participation does raise numerous issues from various angles, sporting and economic. These include issues of inequality in a global game, FIFA's claims that the Club World Cup involves the world's best teams, and the organisation of soccer in the Oceania region, where its strongest nation, Australia, moved to the Asian confederation in 2006.
There should be no doubt, though, that Auckland City fully deserves its place at the Club World Cup. It could even be argued that it deserves its palace more than any other team in its group.
CINCINNATI, OHIO - JUNE 15: Jamal Musiala #42 of FC Bayern Munchen talks to Jerson Lagos #17 of ... More Auckland City FC during the FIFA Club World Cup 2025 group C match between FC Bayern Munchen and Auckland City FC at TQL Stadium on June 15, 2025 in Cincinnati, Ohio. (Photo by Joe Robbins/ISI Photos/ISI Photos via Getty Images)
Auckland City, the reigning champion of the New Zealand National League, met the qualifying criteria in the most convincing fashion.
It won all three of the OFC Champions League tournaments played in the qualifying period of 2021 to 2024, and also won the most recent edition for good measure, defeating Hekari United of Papua New Guinea 2-0 in the final in April this year.
This means the club has won the last four consecutive editions of the region's version of the Champions League, and has now won 13 of the 24 editions of Oceania's continental competition.
None of the other teams in Auckland City's group qualified by winning their equivalent competition.
Neither Bayern Munich nor Benfica won the UEFA Champions League in the qualification period, and Boca Juniors has not won the South American version of the Champions League, the Copa Libertadores, since 2007.
Though these teams from Europe and South America are far richer than Auckland City and are made up entirely of professional players, many of whom are or have been among the best in international soccer, none of them qualified for the Club World Cup by winning a trophy. Auckland City did.
Bayern, Benfica, and Boca all qualified via the rankings system, which is used to top up the tournament to 32 teams once all the teams qualifying via the main route of winning their confederation's top club competition have been decided.
The OFC only gets one spot at the Club World Cup, but it's right that it gets a spot, regardless of the level of the team that qualifies.
If such a tournament were to introduce a more artificial qualification method to accommodate all the top teams in the world, it would be heavily biased towards Europe and, to a lesser extent, South America.
As a result, it would lose the 'world' aspect of the competition, which is the whole point of it in the first place.
ORLANDO, FLORIDA - JUNE 19: Head Coach Paul Posa of Auckland City FC speaks during the ... More Training/Press Conference ahead of their FIFA Club World Cup 2025 group match between Auckland City FC and SL Benfica at Inter&Co Stadium on June 19, 2025 in Orlando, Florida. (Photo by)
One-sided results are part of sport and are seen at all levels, including when professional teams play professional teams in the soccer's biggest tournaments. Both Liverpool and Real Madrid have recorded 8-0 wins in the UEFA Champions League's lucrative group stage.
The Copa Libertadores has seen scorelines of 9-0 and 11-2 in group stage matches, while the English Premier League—often held up as the pinnacle of domestic club football—has witnessed three 9-0 scorelines.
There are some potentially negative knock-on effects regionally from Auckland City's participation. The prize money the club will receive, which is huge compared to prize money domestically and in the OFC, could further add to its dominance in New Zealand and Oceania, and skew the balance domestically and regionally.
It also raises awareness of the development and organisation of the game in Oceania, and the fact that New Zealand does have two professional teams—Auckland FC and Wellington Phoenix—but both play in the Australian A-League, and are therefore part of the Asian confederation.
However, the principle of having a Club World Cup qualifier for the region, even if it's only one team, is right and proper. If such a tournament wants to represent the world, then it needs to include the world's teams.
There might be the occasional one-sided result, and the distribution of FIFA's money beyond the participating teams needs to be better to avoid further regional disruption, but starting from a position of inclusivity is the right thing to do.
Auckland City, unlike Bayern, Benfica, and Boca, is the champion of its region and fully deserves its place at the Club World Cup.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
32 minutes ago
- USA Today
Kylian Mbappe will not travel with Real Madrid for next Club World Cup match
PALM BEACH GARDENS, FL — Real Madrid star Kylian Mbappe, who was hospitalized for a stomach flu during the FIFA Club World Cup this week, has yet to return to practice with his team. Mbappe did not participate with his Real Madrid teammates during a training session Saturday, a day before the club's second-group stage match. Real Madrid will face Mexican club Pachuca on Sunday at 3 p.m. ET inside Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte, N.C. Mbappe will not travel with Real Madrid from South Florida for the match, a team spokesman told USA TODAY Sports. The club will return to its training site at The Gardens North County District Park after the Pachuca match. New Real Madrid coach Xabi Alonso will likely address Mbappe's condition during a news conference in Charlotte on Saturday night. Mbappe trained at Real Madrid's hotel Friday, the team announced. Mbappe was released from the hospital Thursday afternoon, and expected to "continue with specific medical treatment and will gradually return to team activity," Real Madrid said in a statement. Mbappe was hospitalized for testing "to treat an acute case of gastroenteritis," the club announced in an earlier statement. Mbappe – who led France to the World Cup title in 2018 and scored a hat trick in their World Cup loss to Lionel Messi and Argentina in 2022 – is the biggest star in the Club World Cup field aside from Messi. He did not play last Wednesday in Real Madrid's 1-1 draw against Al-Hilal in the tournament opener for both clubs. "I don't know if he will be back for the next game. We'll see. He wasn't doing well in the last two days. He's sick," Alonso said after the draw Wednesday, before Mbappé was hospitalized. Alonso said Mbappé was "feeling a bit better, but not fully fit," during a news conference Tuesday, adding Real Madrid would wait until the last minute to decide if he would play against Al-Hilal. Real Madrid's final group-stage match at the Club World Cup is against FC Salzburg (Austria) on Thursday, June 26 at 9 p.m. ET inside Lincoln Financial Field in Philadelphia. FC Salzburg sits atop the Club World Cup Group H standings with three points after beating Pachuca 2-1 last Wednesday. Real Madrid and Al-Hilal each have a point after their draw, while Pachuca has zero points. Mbappe's return could come in the Club World Cup knockout stage, if Real Madrid advances.
Yahoo
34 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Blueprint for defending Caitlin Clark may have been established by Valkyries, coach Natalie Nakase
The Indiana Fever (6-6) get back on the court for a matchup with the Las Vegas Aces on Sunday following an 88-77 loss to the Golden State Valkyries (6-6) on Thursday in San Francisco. Golden State held Caitlin Clark to 11 points on 3-of-14-shooting — including 0-for-5 on 3-pointers, which is only the second time in her early WNBA career that she hasn't a shot from behind the arc. The Fever star had two points at halftime, checked tightly by Tiffany Hayes with Kayla Thornton and Veronica Burton also taking turns defending her. Advertisement Thursday's game matched the lowest point total by Clark this season, which came against the Atlanta Dream on May 22. Perhaps not coincidentally, that was the only other game in which Clark hadn't hit a 3-pointer. However, the 11-point effort was not the lowest-scoring performance by Clark during her WNBA career. Last season, she scored three points in a 104-68 loss to the New York Liberty. But during her rookie campaign, Clark didn't reach double figures in only five of her 40 games. Struggling against the eventual WNBA champions perhaps shouldn't be a surprise. But the Valkyries are an expansion team, so holding Clark to 11 points seems notable. Following the game, Hayes and her teammates credited head coach Natalie Nakase for coming up with the effective game plan against Clark. 'Coach gave us a great gameplan,' Hayes told the San Francisco Chronicle's Marisa Ingemi. 'We knew we had to stay up on her. We knew she's a three-level scorer. I think it was a great team defensive game today, everybody was locked in making sure she didn't get any easy looks.' Advertisement Nakase is in her first year as a head coach after three years as an assistant with the Aces and three years with the Los Angeles Clippers and their G League affiliate. She explained some of the defensive scheme against Clark before and after the game, saying that defenders had to pick Clark up higher on the court since she can knock down 3s from the logo. "She shoots from a logo you can't pick her up at a logo just because, that's a super comfortable shot," Nakase said, via ClutchPoints' Kenzo Fukuda. "It's almost like a layup to her. Need to get her going to her left.' More importantly was to not let Clark get into any sort of rhythm. "We were being disruptive, we know she doesn't like physicality," Nakase said after the game. "And we know she wants to get back to that left stepback. I watched her at Iowa; she loves that left step-back. "So again," she added, "just making sure that she wasn't getting into a rhythm and making sure she was seeing multiple bodies.' Caitlin Clark was held to 11 points against the Golden State Valkyries, facing double-teams, multiple defenders and pressure up the court. (Photo by) (Eakin Howard via Getty Images) Part of combating multiple defenders is to get the ball to her teammates and Clark finished Thursday's game with nine assists. So at least to some extent, she was taking what the Valkyries' defense was giving her. And perhaps the easiest explanation is that the Valkyries have Hayes to defend Clark and other WNBA teams don't. Advertisement However, it's now on Clark and the Fever coaching staff to make adjustments against what Nakase might have established as a blueprint to keep her in check. Acting head coach Austin Kelly, filling in for Stephanie White, indicated what Indiana would have to do to combat double-teams and pressure earlier in the possession. "I think the lack of ball movement allowed them to really beat her up," Kelly told Ingemi. "When we move it, a lot of good things happen, we are able to punch it, we get to our sprays, and it gets back to her. That's when she is going to get the good looks. But they did a good job of being physical and making it tough for her.' Clark's response could be immediately apparent with Sunday's matchup versus the Aces. The Valkyries also return to the court on Sunday, facing the Connecticut Sun (2-11).
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Former Eagles Receiver Given Respect in New Role
Former Eagles Receiver Given Respect in New Role originally appeared on Athlon Sports. At first glance, it's hard to call Olamide Zaccheaus a quality receiver for his work with the Philadelphia Eagles in 2023. Advertisement The former Atlanta Falcon and Washington Commander caught just 10 passes during his lone season in Philadelphia with two touchdowns. Zaccheaus was used more as a blocker overall but was ignored in the passing game. Last year with Washington, Zaccheaus' numbers improved. He recorded over 500 yards receiving in the nation's capital. Now, the veteran has signed a free-agent deal with the Chicago Bears. Zaccheaus won't be an everydown player in Chicago, but that doesn't mean he can't be impactful. Bill Barnwell of ESPN named the Bears receiver one of the best fourth receivers in the league today. "While Zaccheaus might have been something closer to the second or third wide receiver for the Commanders last season, he is expected to slot in behind DJ Moore, Rome Odunze, and rookie second-round pick Luther Burden III in Chicago," Barnwell said. "Don't be surprised if Zaccheaus is on the field more often than you would expect -- coaches love him." Advertisement It's easy for coaches to love what Zaccheaus brings to the table. Organizations love the veteran's blocking abilities. Zaccheaus isn't a player who complains about not getting the ball, either. It's a good reminder of how important a player like Zaccheaus is for teams around the league. And why the Bears came away with one of the better fourth receivers in the league on the open market this offseason. Related: Eagles Legends Shine on ESPN's All-Quarter Century NFL Team Related: Nick Sirianni's Stunning Turnaround Lands Him Among NFL's Top Coaches This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 21, 2025, where it first appeared.
