UK court convicts duo of felling historic tree

An English court found two men guilty on Friday of the "deliberate and mindless" felling of one of the UK's most iconic trees, an incident that sparked national outrage.
A jury at Newcastle Crown Court found former friends Daniel Graham, 39, and Adam Carruthers, 32, guilty of criminal damage for the 2023 felling of the tree at Sycamore Gap.
It had stood for nearly 200 years next to Hadrian's Wall, a UNESCO World Heritage site in northern England. The tree was so striking it featured in the 1991 Hollywood film Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves.
They were convicted after around five hours of deliberation on two counts of criminal damage: to the sycamore and to the Roman wall, which was damaged when the tree fell on it.
Prosecutors had told the court that the two men used a chainsaw to cut down the tree. It was, they said, "an act of deliberate and mindless criminal damage", which they filmed on Graham's phone and shared with others.
Speaking after the conviction, Northumbria Police's Kevin Waring said: "We often hear references made to mindless acts of vandalism, but that term has never been more relevant than today.
"At no point have the two men given an explanation for why they targeted the tree — and there never could be a justifiable one," he added.
Graham has "been in custody for his own protection after an episode in December", his lawyer Chris Knox told court on Friday.
Gale Gilchrist, from the Crown Prosecution Service North, said that "in just under three minutes, Graham and Carruthers ended its (the tree's) historic legacy in a deliberate and mindless act of destruction.
"We hope our community can take some measure of comfort in seeing those responsible convicted today," she added.
The pair were jointly charged with causing £622,191 ($832,?821) of criminal damage to the tree and £1,144 of damage to Hadrian's Wall, an ancient Roman fortification stretching from northwest to northeast England.
The two men have been remanded in custody - Carruthers for his own protection. They will be sentenced on July 15.
The sycamore was a symbol of northeast England and a key attraction photographed by millions of visitors over the years, winning the Woodland Trust's Tree of the Year in 2016. Efforts are underway to see if it can be regrown from its stump or seeds.
The National Trust, which owns the wall and the tree, said it has grown 49 saplings from the sycamore's seeds, which will be planted this winter at sites across the UK. AFP

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Business Recorder

2 hours ago

• Business Recorder

Ensure translation of evidence into Urdu simultaneously: LHC

LAHORE: The Lahore High Court (LHC) remarked that Urdu had been declared as the language of subordinate courts since 2015 but the same has not been implemented in Punjab till now. The court said the Supreme Court on September 8, 2015, had directed the government to implement Urdu as an official language but unfortunately no significant steps have been taken and up-till now evidence is being recorded in English in sessions courts. The court directed all the sessions' judges, additional sessions' judges, as well as, judges of special courts to ensure translation of the evidence of a witness recorded in English into Urdu simultaneously. The court passed this order in murder reference of Irfan alias Pomi after noting that the translation of the prosecution evidence and the statements of the accused have been made by the reader of the court after recording the whole evidence. The court said that law is very much clear on the point that the evidence should be taken down in the language of witnesses by the magistrate or judge himself or be recorded in his presence, hearing and superintendence. However, the translation of the evidence of a witness recorded in English should be translated into Urdu simultaneously at the same sitting, as well as, in the presence of witnesses, accused and the presiding officer, the court added. The court said this is necessary as if any ambiguity in the evidence recorded in English comes on the surface, the same can be removed in the light of translation of evidence in Urdu. The court said normally the witnesses during the trial depose in Urdu and the presiding officer, while transcribing the same in English, dictates to his stenographer and hence Urdu transcript of such deposition is not prepared. The court said this practice diminishes the very purpose of preparing and keeping Urdu translation of evidence recorded by the presiding officer in English. The court; therefore, directed the registrar to send copies of this judgment to all the sessions judges and judges of special courts, as well as, the secretary, ministry of law and justice Islamabad and the secretary ministry of law and parliamentary affairs Punjab for compliance. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025

Express Tribune

6 days ago

• Express Tribune

Same old dreams

Listen to article I've learned not to trust people. Diplomats, men with shining armors, ministers of the sovereign and those on their chrome horses, as soon as you see either, run away. If you see them all together, your mother's curse continues to haunt you. Should've been a better son/daughter. As Ronald Reagan put it "The most terrifying words in the English Language are: I am from the Government and I am here to help." You want to know who really rules over you? Try and see those who you cannot criticise. Those who can't stand criticism are probably the ones who run the game and call the shots. But now you know who runs the party. The ruler who throws the party and declares himself to be the DJ too. Speaking about the DJ, the government has recently directed all guest houses to have their guests registered mandatorily on what they call the 'Hotel Eye Software'. This software registers details of visitors. Such as name, date of birth and other personal credentials. It is said that this measure aims at curbing terrorism and illegal activities. By keeping an eye out on the identity of visitors, the government can now, maybe, anticipate who will engage in not so favourable activities. Here comes unsolicited advice from a man who doesn't know any better. Perpetrators do not stay at guesthouses or hotels. They have safe houses which tend to be off the radar. That was my one cent. The second cent is, we need Parliament Eye Software too. Where we as citizens keep an eye out on who is attending parliamentary sessions and see who is indulging in illegal activities. I reckon we're all prudent enough to fathom where most illegal activities happen. Yes, you guessed it right! The good old wax museum. While we're at it, let's also have a Court House Eye Software. After all, the citizens pay taxes, right? They have all the right to know who enters and exits court houses too. Imagine the scope of this 'eye software' and places we can deploy it in. Now that my views have been laid down and that too quite eloquently, let me clarify my position. The government shouldn't expect to crack down on terrorist activities by surveilling who sleeps where. At most, you'll end up cracking down on bad marriages. Your own house isn't in order (ask the Sunni Ittehad Council, they'll have something to say), why ruin someone else's? In other news, Zahir Jaffer is being sent to the gallows. I don't know when though. Maybe he'll spend the rest of his life on death row. But, despite such overwhelming evidence, it took more than 4 years for him to be sentenced. Need I say more? Unpopular opinion but I still think someone needs to get information out of Zahir Jaffer as to why he did what he did. There is no better way of learning homicidal behaviour than to speak with and study the perpetrator. Some MRIs, some CT scans and who knows, we might be able to build a blueprint of intervention programmes moving forward. There is wisdom with psychopaths and we need to extract that wisdom to ensure we protect our communities and our people in the future. Zahir Jaffer wasn't the first and he is most definitely not the last and for us to learn from our mistakes, we need to treat this man as a subject of a study. Nothing will justify what he did but we might learn about the workings of an Islamabadi psychopath's brain. Islamabadi just makes it sound more pretentious. What on God green's earth has gone wrong with the justice system in Islamabad? Judicial officers cannot seem to come to one page regarding how to run the system. The other day the paper said some judicial officer conceded to rifts within the system. What about the people who want justice and are not concerned with rifts? Fun fact, 172,000 people (skilled labour) have already left the country since January 2025.

Express Tribune

13-06-2025

• Express Tribune

Migrants flee N Ireland unrest

Fireworks thrown at Riot Police illuminate the road during a third night of anti-immigration demonstrations in Ballymena, Northern Ireland. Photo: AFP Foreign nationals hid in wardrobes and attics to escape a wave of unrest which has rocked a Northern Ireland town, police said Thursday, calling for the protests to end and warning rioters they would face arrest. "Stop this violence," said Northern Ireland police chief Jon Boutcher. "We will come after you. We will arrest you. We will prosecute you successfully." He was speaking after three nights of unrest in the town of Ballymena, some 30 miles (48 kilometres) northwest of Belfast. The clashes erupted on Monday night after two teenagers were arrested for the alleged attempted rape of a young girl at the weekend. Police have not confirmed the ethnicity of the teenagers, who remain in custody and had asked for a Romanian interpreter in court. After another barrage of petrol bombs, bricks and bottles, the crowds eventually dispersed late Wednesday without a repeat of the chaotic scenes seen on Monday and Tuesday when houses and businesses in areas where Romanian families live were torched. A total of 13 people have now been arrested, and 41 police officers injured, though most of the injuries are not severe. Three teenage boys aged 15, 17 and 18 were due to appear in court on Thursday having been charged with rioting, said police. Boutcher described the riots as "wanton, disgraceful criminal behaviour that is absolutely race motivated", speaking at a news conference Thursday. Police had helped evacuate foreign national families hiding in attics and wardrobes in their homes "even though they had done nothing wrong", he said. "They are not criminals. They contribute positively to society here and are well integrated," he added. Clonavon Road, where most of the riots happened in a neighbourhood known for having a large population of eastern Europeans, was almost deserted on Thursday. Many of the houses were damaged, and British, English or Northern Irish flags hung from most windows, AFP reporters saw. Some had signs saying they were Filipino residents.