NRI bought a Hyderabad flat for Rs 64 lakh in 2010. Now has a Rs 1.8 crore regret. Shares lessons
For many NRIs, buying property in India feels like a natural step—financially prudent, emotionally satisfying, and culturally rooted. But when the numbers are finally crunched, the results can often be sobering. One NRI couple's experience with a Hyderabad flat they bought in 2010 offers a clear example of how real estate investments, especially from abroad, can underdeliver over time. Despite making what looked like a smart move back then, the couple now admits it cost them far more in missed opportunities, currency losses, and peace of mind.
In 2010, an NRI couple made what they believed was a sound investment—a Rs 64 lakh 3BHK apartment in Hyderabad's Nanakramguda area. The idea was simple: put money into a growing city, wait for appreciation, and enjoy some rental income. Fifteen years later, the property was sold for Rs 90 lakh. But when they looked at the bigger picture, especially in U.S. dollar terms, they were left with a disappointing return. The story was shared on the subreddit, rupeestories.
A Seemingly Profitable Exit on Paper
The couple had purchased the flat in the Mantri Celestia complex and paid the builder Rs 59.34 lakh over nine years through staggered EMIs. An additional Rs 5 lakh was spent on woodwork and repairs. Possession was delayed until 2019, and they finally sold the apartment in 2024 for Rs 90 lakh.
After deducting realtor fees and capital gains tax, they were left with Rs 84.9 lakh in hand. On paper, that appeared to be a profit of nearly Rs 21 lakh. Add to this Rs 7.2 lakh in post-tax net rental income from 2019–2024, and the overall gain stood at about Rs 28.9 lakh in INR.
The Dollar Math Tells a Different Story
When converted to dollars, however, the picture turned grim. Due to rupee depreciation—from around Rs 45/$ in 2010 to roughly Rs 85/$ in 2024—their total returns shrank dramatically. Their original Rs 64.34 lakh investment was around $111,740 in dollar terms. After 15 years, they walked away with only about $120,000 (including rent and sale proceeds), making the actual profit roughly $8,500. That's a 0.5% annualised return in USD.
Had the same amount been invested steadily in an S&P 500 index fund like SPY over the same period, the couple calculated they could have accumulated over $330,000. Instead, they ended up with just $120,000—an opportunity cost of over $210,000 (approx. Rs 1.8 crore). The regret wasn't just about the missed money, but also the lost time and mental energy that went into maintaining the flat, dealing with tenants, chasing rent, handling repairs, and navigating taxes and paperwork from abroad.
Low Rental Yield and Liquidity Challenges
Over five years, the flat earned Rs 12 lakh in rent, which after taxes and maintenance, dropped to Rs 7.2 lakh. That translated to a gross rental yield of around 2.25%, far below the 3.5%–5% net yield many experts believe NRIs should target to make real estate in India worthwhile.
On top of that, the flat did not appreciate as expected. Despite being located in a much-hyped "IT corridor," Nanakramguda didn't develop into the next Hitech City as projected. Liquidity too was an issue—the flat didn't sell quickly, highlighting the difficulty in offloading Indian real estate when you truly need funds.
Key Takeaways from a Costly Lesson
Reflecting on the entire experience, the NRI investor laid out some hard-earned lessons:
Currency risk significantly impacts NRI investments. A decent return in INR may translate to poor growth in USD.
Opportunity cost is often overlooked. U.S. index funds can quietly outperform Indian real estate in the long run.
Liquidity and yield are more important than speculative capital gains.
Buying based on hype rather than fundamentals can lead to underwhelming outcomes.
Detailed, USD-adjusted math should always be run before buying property in India.
Gurgaon Manager's Warning
This story isn't unique. A Gurgaon-based manager recently shared a similar experience on social media. Someone he knew had bought a 3BHK apartment in a Tier II city for Rs 70 lakh in 2022. Two years later, they managed to sell it for just Rs 75 lakh. Once taxes and transaction costs were considered, the net gain was almost negligible.
In fact, as the manager pointed out, a simple fixed deposit in a bank over the same period would have offered better returns—without the stress of property upkeep, paperwork, or market uncertainty.
The Hyderabad flat story is one of many emerging from NRIs and domestic investors alike. These accounts reinforce a common theme: Indian real estate, while emotionally appealing and once seen as a 'safe' investment, doesn't always deliver strong returns—especially after adjusting for currency risk, taxes, and missed alternative gains.
Whether in Tier I metros or smaller towns, real estate investments need sharper scrutiny today. As the NRI investor candidly put it: this isn't about being anti-property—it's about being pro-math.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
19 minutes ago
- News18
Did ICICI Bank Try To Acquire HDFC? What Deepak Parekh Reveals
Last Updated: 'I remember you talking to me said ICICI started HDFC. 'Why don't you come back home?' That was your offer,' Parekh said in interaction with Ex-ICICI CEO Chanda Kochhar. ICICI Bank once tried to merge housing finance firm HDFC with itself before its reverse merger with its own banking arm, HDFC Bank former chairman Deepak Parekh has revealed. In a YouTube video, Parekh, in an interaction with ICICI Bank former MD & CEO Chanda Kochhar, said, 'I remember you talking to me once…you said that ICICI started HDFC. 'Why don't you come back home?' That was your offer." However, Parekh said he declined the offer, saying 'it won't be fair or proper with our name and the bank and all". He also said the HDFC Bank-HDFC reverse merger, which was completed in July 2023, was primarily driven by regulatory pressure. 'The RBI supported us and they pushed us into it to some extent and they helped us…there were no concessions, no relief, no time, nothing but they helped us to go through the process and get the approval," Parekh said. On the reverse merger, Parekh called it 'a sad day and a happy day". He added, 'It's good for the institution. It's good for the country to have large banks. Look at how large Chinese banks are. We have to be bigger, larger in India." Describing the merger as good for the institution, he said, it is good for the country to have large banks. Indian banks must grow through acquisitions to become stronger in future, he added. HDFC Ltd, the parent entity of HDFC Bank, merged with its banking subsidiary to create the country's biggest private sector lender. The merger became effective from July 1, 2023. With the reverse merger, the 44-year-old institution HDFC Ltd faded into memory lane. Interestingly, the creation of HDFC Ltd was financially supported by erstwhile ICICI Ltd, the parent entity of ICICI Bank. The Reserve Bank of India had classified large NBFCs like HDFC, which then held assets exceeding Rs 5 lakh crore, as systemically important — well above the Rs 50,000-crore threshold. (With Inputs from PTI) First Published:
Time of India
20 minutes ago
- Time of India
Investors brace for oil price spike, rush to havens after US bombs Iran nuclear sites
Investors warned that U.S. airstrikes on Iranian nuclear sites could jolt global markets when they reopen, with oil prices likely to surge and a rush toward safe-haven assets such as the dollar expected. The attack, announced by President Donald Trump, deepens U.S. involvement in the Middle East conflict, raising concerns about inflation and economic uncertainty. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Oil prices, inflation Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Dollar woes A U.S. attack on Iranian nuclear sites on Saturday could lead to a knee-jerk reaction in global markets when they reopen, sending oil prices higher and triggering a rush to safety, investors said, as they assessed how the latest escalation of tensions would ripple through the global attack, which was announced by President Donald Trump on social media site Truth Social, deepens U.S. involvement in the Middle East conflict. That was the question going into the weekend, when investors were mulling a host of different market scenarios. In the immediate aftermath of the announcement, they expected the U.S. involvement was likely to cause a selloff in equities and a possible bid for the dollar and other safe-haven assets when trading begins, but also said much uncertainty about the course of the conflict Trump called the attack "successful", few details were known. He was expected to address the nation later on Saturday."I think the markets are going to be initially alarmed, and I think oil will open higher," said Mark Spindel, chief investment officer at Potomac River Capital."We don't have any damage assessment and that will take some time. Even though he has described this as 'done', we're engaged. What comes next?" Spindel said. "I think the uncertainty is going to blanket the markets, as now Americans everywhere are going to be exposed. It's going to raise uncertainty and volatility, particularly in oil," he however, said there was time to digest the news before markets open and said he was making arrangements to talk to other market participants.A key concern for markets would center around the potential impact of the developments in the Middle East on oil prices and thus on inflation. A rise in inflation could dampen consumer confidence and lessen the chance of near-term interest rate cuts."This adds a complicated new layer of risk that we'll have to consider and pay attention to," said Jack Ablin, chief investment officer of Cresset Capital. "This is definitely going to have an impact on energy prices and potentially on inflation as well."While global benchmark Brent crude futures have risen as much as 18% since June 10, hitting a near five-month high of $79.04 on Thursday, the S&P 500 has been little changed, following an initial drop when Israel launched its attacks on Iran on June the U.S. attack on Saturday, analysts at Oxford Economics modeled three scenarios, including a de-escalation of the conflict, a complete shutdown in Iranian oil production and a closure of the Strait of Hormuz, "each with increasingly large impacts on global oil prices."In the most severe case, global oil prices jump to around $130 per barrel, driving U.S. inflation near 6% by the end of this year, Oxford said in the note. "Although the price shock inevitably dampens consumer spending because of the hit to real incomes, the scale of the rise in inflation and concerns about the potential for second-round inflation effects likely ruin any chance of rate cuts in the U.S. this year," Oxford said in the note, which was published before the U.S. strikes. In comments after the announcement on Saturday, Jamie Cox, managing partner at Harris Financial Group, agreed oil prices would likely spike on the initial news. But Cox said he expected prices to likely level in a few days as the attacks could lead Iran to seek a peace deal with Israel and the United States."With this demonstration of force and total annihilation of its nuclear capabilities, they've lost all of their leverage and will likely hit the escape button to a peace deal," Cox said. Economists warn that a dramatic rise in oil prices could damage a global economy already strained by Trump's any pullback in equities might be fleeting, history suggests. During past prominent instances of Middle East tensions coming to a boil, including the 2003 Iraq invasion and the 2019 attacks on Saudi oil facilities, stocks initially languished but soon recovered to trade higher in the months average, the S&P 500 slipped 0.3% in the three weeks following the start of conflict, but was 2.3% higher on average two months following the conflict, according to data from Wedbush Securities and CapIQ escalation in the conflict could have mixed implications for the U.S. dollar, which has tumbled this year amid worries over diminished U.S. the event of U.S. direct engagement in the Iran-Israel war, the dollar could initially benefit from a safety bid, analysts said."Do we see a flight to safety? That would signal yields going lower and the dollar getting stronger," said Steve Sosnick, chief market strategist at IBKR in Greenwich, Connecticut. "It's hard to imagine stocks not reacting negatively and the question is how much. It will depend on Iranian reaction and whether oil prices spike."
Hans India
28 minutes ago
- Hans India
Varsity launches innovative ‘industry inside the campus' initiative
Belagavi: In a pioneering step towards integrating industry with academics, Visvesvaraya Technological University (VTU), Belagavi, has launched a novel initiative titled 'Industry Inside the Campus'. This move comes on the heels of the university making headlines for declaring exam results within an hour—yet another testament to its push towards student-centric reforms. To implement this new concept, VTU has established the Visvesvaraya Research and Innovation Foundation (VRIF) on its main campus, opening up space for companies in drone technology, software development, electric vehicles, IoT, PCB manufacturing, AR/VR, and more. These companies are now operational on campus, with full-fledged training for final-year engineering students set to begin from August. Speaking to this reporter , VTU Vice-Chancellor Prof. S. Vidyashankar said, 'Students now gain hands-on experience and practical exposure within the campus. We've established rapid innovation centres such as the Schneider Acceleration Centre, Proteus, Cadence, and an Electrical Vehicle Lab to bridge the skill gap. Through VRIF, we aim to create not just employees but future employers.' One of the key players in the initiative is Saras Aerospace, a startup established in 2022, specializing in carbon fiber drones and airframe production. Co-founder Brijesh Kumar Koparde noted, 'Thanks to VTU, we operate from within the campus. We train students not only in drone technology but also in equipment used for drone testing. We've delivered over 200 drones across the country, including to the Indian Army, Navy, and Air Force. Our product range includes drones valued between RS1.5 lakh and RS 30 lakh.'Currently, nearly 90 students are undergoing hands-on training with Saras Aerospace. Rajat Hanshate, a final-year engineering student, shared, 'I've developed an Unmanned Ground Vehicle during my internship here. From 3D modeling to integrating sensors and cameras, everything was facilitated. I gained immense exposure to the practical aspects of drone-making for both defence and agriculture.' Another student, Swastik Hegde, emphasized the value of his training, 'I've been interning here for two months. I've learned PCB design and IoT sensor integration. I even worked on a Retractor Landing Gear project. I'm truly grateful to VTU for creating such platforms.' The 'Industry Inside the Campus' initiative is expected to benefit at least 2,500 students in the coming academic year. The university hopes this integrated industry-academia ecosystem will not only make graduates job-ready but also empower them to become entrepreneurs. 'This is not just about employment, it's about entrepreneurship,' reiterated Prof. Vidyashankar.
