SC order on retrospective environmental clearances a step forward but gaps remain: Experts
NEW DELHI: Policy experts on Saturday welcomed the Supreme Court's decision barring the government from granting retrospective environmental clearances but warned that loopholes in environmental laws still exist, and citizens must stay alert to protect their constitutional rights.
In a landmark ruling on Friday, the apex court said the government cannot grant retrospective environmental clearances in the future. The court made it clear that projects started without mandatory prior environmental clearance cannot be legalised later. It added that violators who knowingly ignored the law cannot be protected.
The judgement came in response to petitions filed by the NGO Vanashakti and others, challenging two government office memorandums issued in July 2021 and January 2022 which had created a system to grant environmental clearance to projects that began operations without prior approval under the Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2006.
Stalin D, Director of Vanashakti, told PTI that citizens must now ensure the court's directions are followed. "The judgement clearly says the government cannot try and provide a safe haven for violators. So, we have to ensure that our constitutional framework is not violated in any way."
"One more very pertinent thing in that order is that the people who violated this are not illiterate persons. They are educated, well connected, rich people who knew that they were engaging in a violation, which needs to stop now," he said.
Prakriti Srivastava, a retired Indian Forest Service officer, said while it is a good order, knowing the history of environment ministry and project proponents, they will find a way around. She said post-facto approvals mean the damage is already done before clearance is granted.
"Will these stop and the ministry obey the SC orders? Let's wait and watch Though knowing the record of MoEFCC, they give two hoots for SC orders and may blatantly disregard them," she added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
32 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Vijay Deverakonda booked under SC/ST Act over his remarks about tribal people during Retro pre-release event
Actor Vijay Deverakonda has found himself in trouble as a case has been registered against him under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act for his remarks about tribal people during the pre-release event of Retro. The police confirmed the development to PTI on Sunday. Vijay Deverakonda faces trouble as police registers case against him for remarks against tribal people.(PTI) Case registered against Vijay Deverakonda Police stated that although the remarks, which likened the recent terror attack in Pahalgam to tribal conflicts from 500 years ago, were made in April, a case under the SC/ST Act was registered against the actor on 17 June following a complaint. "The actor made comments in April. However, based on a complaint, a case under the SC/ST Act was booked against him on 17 June,' a police official told PTI. The complaint was lodged by Nenavath Ashok Kumar Naik, also known as Ashok Rathod, who serves as the State President of the Joint Action Committee of Tribal Communities. He alleged that during the pre-release event of the film Retro, which stars actor Surya, the actor made statements that hurt the sentiments of tribal communities and caused serious offence. Rathod further claimed that the actor's comparison of tribal people to Pakistani terrorists was racially insensitive. What Vijay Deverakonda had said During the pre-release event of Surya's film Retro, Vijay addressed the Pahalgam terror attack and said, 'The solution to what is happening in Kashmir is also to educate them (terrorists) and ensure they don't get brainwashed. What will they achieve? Kashmir belongs to India, and Kashmiris are ours. India doesn't even need to attack Pakistan because Pakistanis themselves are fed up with their government and will attack them if this continues. Asalu 500 years back tribals kokkutunnatu, veelu buddi lekunda, minimum common sense lekunda chese panulu.' (They behave like tribals did 500 years ago, fighting without common sense). After facing backlash on social media for his comments, the actor expressed regret. He took to X and wrote, "It has come to my attention that a remark I made during the Retro audio launch event has caused concern among some members of the public. I wish to sincerely clarify: there was absolutely no intention to hurt or target any community, especially our Scheduled Tribes, who I deeply respect and consider an integral part of our country." The actor clarified that his intention was to promote unity, emphasising that India is one, its people are one, and the nation must progress together. He expressed disbelief at the idea that, while advocating for national solidarity, he would deliberately target or discriminate against any community, all of whom he considers part of his larger family. He concluded, "If any part of my message was misunderstood or hurtful, I express my sincere regret. My only aim was to speak of peace, progress, and togetherness. I remain committed to using my platform to uplift and unify — never to divide. Vijay Deverakonda."
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Vijay Deverakonda booked under SC/ST act for remarks against tribal communities
A case has been registered against popular actor Vijay Deverakonda under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act for allegedly making remarks about tribal communities during a movie pre-release event. The complaint was lodged with the police, and an official confirmed that a case was registered on June 17. The actor allegedly made these controversial remarks at an event held in April this year. Comments compared tribal wars with terror attack According to the police, Vijay Deverakonda compared the recent terror attack in Pahalgam to ancient tribal wars from five hundred years ago. This statement was quickly broadcast online and increased widespread criticism. According to PTI, the actor's words were seen as highly insensitive and aggressive by many people within the tribal community, indicating action from the authorities. The police confirmed the matter to the media and said that an investigation was currently going on. State tribal committee leader files complaint against Vijay Deverakonda The complaint was filed by Nenavath Ashok Kumar Naik, also known as Ashok Rathod, the State President of the Joint Action Committee of Tribal Communities. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 2025 Top Trending Local Enterprise Accounting Software [Click Here] Accounting ERP Click Here Undo In the complaint, Rathod accused the actor of hurting the feelings of the tribal people and making derogatory comparison by aligning his struggles with Pakistani terrorists. The complaint alleged that such remarks were charged racially and the scheduled tribes were depth, strict action was called against the actor. Vijay Deverakonda clarifies intent, expresses regret as investigation continues On May 3, in an attempt to clarify the situation, Vijay Deverakonda posted a statement on X (Twitter) expressing his respect for all communities, especially the Scheduled Tribes. He stated that he never intended to target or hurt any group. 'If any part of my message was misunderstood or hurtful, I sincerely regret it. My only aim was to speak about peace, progress, and togetherness. I remain committed to using my platform to unite, not divide,' the actor stated. The case is now being investigated further by authorities.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Evening news wrap: PM Modi calls for de-escalation in call with Iran's President; Tehran vows to continue nuclear push after US strikes; & more
PM Modi urged peace in a call with Iran's president after US airstrikes hit Iranian nuclear sites. Iran condemned the US strikes as a 'savage assault' and vowed to continue its nuclear programme. Meanwhile, an Air India flight was diverted to Riyadh following a bomb threat but landed safely and cleared checks. Here are the top 5 stories that made headlines today: PM Modi urges de-escalation in call with Iranian president after US bombs nuclear sites. Prime Minister Narendra Modi spoke with Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian on Sunday after US airstrikes on Iran's nuclear facilities. Modi stressed the need for 'immediate de-escalation, dialogue and diplomacy' as tensions in the Middle East entered the tenth day. The 45-minute call came after the US bombed key nuclear sites at Fordow, Natanz, and Isfahan, escalating tensions in the region. Read full story. Tehran slams Washington for 'savage assault' and refuses to halt nuclear programme. Iran on Sunday condemned the US bombing of its nuclear sites as a 'savage assault', vowing to continue its nuclear programme despite the attacks. US President Donald Trump confirmed the strikes were carried out using B-2 stealth bombers on three facilities. Iran's atomic energy agency confirmed the strikes, but did not detail the extent of the damage. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Run Your Business Like a Pro - Top Trending Accounting Software (Check Now) Accounting ERP Click Here Undo Read full story. Bomb threat diverts Air India flight to Riyadh An Air India flight from Birmingham to Delhi was diverted to Riyadh on Saturday after a bomb threat, according to an airline spokesperson. The plane, Flight AI114 landed safely and underwent full security checks. This incident follows a series of aviation troubles, including a technical snag that grounded an IndiGo flight on Friday. Authorities are on high alert, and passenger safety remains a top priority. Read full story. Indore property dealer held in Shillong murder case Silom James, a property dealer from Indore, was arrested late Saturday in connection with the murder of Raja Raghuwanshi in Shillong. Police say James removed cash, a pistol, and jewellery from a flat used by the victim and his associate Sonam. CCTV footage shows James retrieving a bag from the flat and later installing cameras allegedly to cover his tracks. Read full story. Actor Vijay Devarakonda booked under SC/ST Act, over alleged anti-tribal comments Actor Vijay Devarakonda has been booked under the SC/ST Act for allegedly making offensive comments about tribal communities during a film event in April. The complaint, filed by Ashok Rathod of the Joint Action Committee of Tribal Communities, claims the remarks were made at a promotional event for the film Retro. The case was formally registered on June 17. Read full story.
