Discount power bills: DMO crackdown by Labor will crush small energy retailers
The Albanese government's planned overhaul of household electricity price caps could put small energy retailers surviving on razor-thin profit margins out of business.
The electricity industry was reeling at the policy proposal on Wednesday as intermittent coal outages in Victoria this winter stoke wholesale prices, a force that will inevitably be passed through to energy customers.
Federal Energy Minister Chris Bowen confirmed the government would review the Default Market Offer (DMO) – the benchmark power price in NSW, Queensland and South Australia – with a view to stripping out allowances that protect retailer margins.
The idea is to bring the national standard into closer alignment with Victoria's more tightly regulated counterpart, the Victorian Default Offer (VDO), which will rise by less than 1 per cent in 2024–25.
While the move is politically popular amid persistent cost-of-living pressures, it represents a gamble by the re-elected Labor government that could backfire by reducing utility competition as small retailers capitulate under further pressure.
'This is classic Trump-style politics – a distraction tactic,' one senior industry executive said speaking on the condition of anonymity. 'Labor is blaming retailers when even the ACCC acknowledges margins are at historic lows. All this will do is squeeze out smaller operators and reduce competition, with no discernible impact on prices.'
The government's intent to unwind some components of the DMO – including retailer cost allowances – has reignited discussion over the true drivers of rising energy bills. Retailers argue the biggest pressure point is not retail margins, but network charges, which account for about 40 per cent of the DMO and are rising as transmission infrastructure is upgraded to support the transition to renewables.
Network costs are approved by the government and are the fastest growing component of the DMO.
Australian Energy Council chief executive Louisa Kinnear, which represents the country's retailers, said while a review of the DMO was welcome, it must be comprehensive in its scope as far as cost components go.
'Retail competition allowances have already been stripped out of the DMO in the name of affordability. Yet bills are still climbing, and it's not because of retail margins,' Ms Kinnear said. 'Retailers are also required to support customers facing hardship, which often means carrying bad debts. If we want prices that reflect actual costs, all elements of the DMO need to be under scrutiny.'
AGL echoed that sentiment, insisting the review should not lose sight of the role of network costs.
'To reduce energy bills, we need to look at the whole picture. The government and industry are actively working on measures to reduce wholesale electricity costs. At 40 per cent of an average bill, network costs are a big component of bills and are continuing to grow quickly.
'A focus on improving network productivity is essential to keep these costs in check. Retail costs only represent around 10 per cent of an average bill and we need to carefully consider any moves that could lessen competition in the retail market, particularly if smaller retailers were no longer able to operate,' a spokesman for AGL said.
Victoria, meanwhile, is facing a renewed test of its grid reliability as colder temperatures return and EnergyAustralia's Yallourn coal power station operates at just 25 per cent of its capacity.
Yallourn, the state's second largest coal-powered generator, has been crippled by equipment failures, including a collapsed air duct, though the company has not disclosed the cause of outages at two of its four generating units.
The outages and cold weather again leave Victoria with little wriggle room. The country's energy market operators expect sufficient capacity to minimise concerns about blackouts, but prices are forecast to surge.
Households and businesses, however, do not pay wholesale electricity prices.
The disruption is material for EnergyAustralia, which typically uses Yallourn to supply its retail customers and hedge against volatility in wholesale markets. With the coal plant hobbled, the utility is instead relying on more expensive gas peaking plants to meet demand – a margin-eroding outcome that it can only partially mitigate due to benign conditions in the gas market.
Gas prices remain elevated but manageable, buoyed by near-record storage levels. However, continued outages at Yallourn could test those assumptions if winter demand intensifies.
Originally published as Chris Bowen's default market offer crackdown will crush small energy retailers
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
WA Budget 2025-26: Key regional spending revealed, with major investments across the Mid West
The State Government admitted its first post-election Budget was not sexy but delivered the essentials, with millions in extra funding set to be put into a range of regional infrastructure projects. But while the majority of Mid West election funding promises were kept, notably Labor's pledge to fund a Royal Flying Doctor Service base in Geraldton did not crack a mention this time around. In the lead-up to the election, the Cook Government committed $7.5 million towards establishing the long-awaited RFDS facility in the Mid West, but the funding was nowhere to be seen in this year's Budget — prompting frustration from Member for Geraldton Kirrilee Warr who said the service is critical for timely emergency care in the region's remote areas. 'I'm disappointed there appears to be no funding towards an RFDS base here in Geraldton in the State Budget,' Ms Warr said. 'Nearly 2000 patients were retrieved by the service in the Mid West over the past year — more than five people per day. 'I will continue to back important projects across the electorate and will hold this State Government to account to ensure it delivers the funding they promised at the election.' Minister for the Mid West Jackie Jarvis said she had spoken to the RFDS chief executive and said all election promises would eventually be delivered in Geraldton. 'We're working with them again to understand their timelines and to make sure that they have fully costed the project,' she said. 'It has been 105 days since the State election, that election commitment, all election commitments made in Geraldton, will be honoured as part of our four-year term.' But the Mid West did come out a winner with an additional $500m committed to the State's Strategic Industries Fund — supporting key priorities under the Made in WA plan, including fast-tracking of clean energy and major industrial projects — with the Oakajee precinct set to share in the funding. Oakajee remains part of the State Government's plan to create a renewable energy hub in the Mid West with $60m invested in the project so far. So who were the other Budget winners in the Mid West this time around? Here's the Guardian's five-minute guide to what was in it for our region. Business and development: Geraldton's port will benefit from $3.5m for detailed design of Berths 8 and 9, 'supporting future renewable energy exports like wind turbine components'. Meanwhile, $8.9m has been set aside to boost the Exploration Incentive Scheme to drive regional mining jobs. Other investments include $20m to expand the Aboriginal Ranger Program and $8.3m to progress plans to return WA's freight rail network to public ownership. Cost of living support: A second round of the WA Student Assistance Payment will allow households to apply for a $150 payment for each primary aged child or $250 payment for each secondary aged child. This comes as the first round is due to close on July 4. Eligible concession card holders will receive a one-off rebate on their water bills and $25.7m has been pledged to increase the Regional Pensioner Travel Cards by a further $100, to $775. TransWA fares will be halved, including fares for bus services connecting towns in the Mid West in an $18m promise. The reductions will begin from January 1. The Country Week Assistance Program has been given $8m to support regional participant in country week events. Housing: The Mid West is set to benefit from a major injection of funding aimed at tackling housing shortages and supporting essential workers across the region. As part of a $1.1 billion Statewide investment, $400m has been committed to building and upgrading public housing in regional areas, including Geraldton and surrounding towns. The Government will double its Government Regional Officer Housing construction program with $103.8m to build more than 100 homes and acquire land for key workers such as police and teachers. A further $25m will go into the new Regional Housing Support Fund, offering grants up to $5m to unlock housing and land supply — including subdivisions and key worker accommodation. To improve home ownership access, Keystart will also introduce a new low-deposit loan product to help more Mid West residents purchase modular homes. Health: Planning for an expansion of renal services and a radiation oncology service can begin, with $1m apiece put aside for that purpose within this year's Budget. While in Kalbarri a further $1m will go towards upgrading the health centre's air-conditioning system, improving comfort and safety for patients and staff. The Budget also includes $8.2m to attract and retain health workers in regional areas, with the Government touting that families will also benefit from a $12.2m investment in the Virtual Infant Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service Hub for children which will provide specialist care for children and young people via telehealth. Those who need to rely on the Patient Assisted Travel Scheme will see the benefit of a $18.5m to allow the fuel subsidy to be increased from 26¢ cents to 40¢ per kilometre. Communities: Geraldton will see more CCTV installed as part of a $2.3m Statewide rollout to combat antisocial behaviour, while $1m is going to Police and Community Youth Centres to support youth diversion programs in the city. More than $480m per year is set to be spent on police services across regional WA, including 123 stations and nearly 1900 officers and staff, with $14.3m to provide free police academy accommodation for regional recruits. Regional courts will also benefit from $5m in security upgrades. Planning for a new evacuation centre in Kalbarri can begin with $250,000 pledged for the project as well as the Statewide commitment of $6.7m to support DFES's aerial fire response capability, with two strike teams to mitigate the threat of crop fires during the grain harvesting season. Sport: Geraldton's GBSC Sport Park will receive $3m for new toilets and change rooms, including facilities for women, while the Geraldton Netball Association is getting $2.8m to upgrade its Wonthella courts and amenities. The Backroads Gravel Festival will be supported with $450,000 in funding to keep the Mid West cycling event running for the next three years. The Midwest Kart Club in Geraldton will receive $100,000 to improve onsite medical facilities and the Dongara-Irwin Race Club has been allocated $92,000 for infrastructure upgrades. Education: Geraldton Senior High School is set for a $8m windfall for classroom refurbishments, LED lighting and air-conditioning upgrades, while Champion Bay High School will have a new gymnasium after a $23.5m promise. More than $20m will fund the establishment of new regional university study hubs, giving students in the Mid West and other regions greater access to tertiary education. Another $28m has been given to expand the School Breakfast Program to provide free breakfasts five days a week at more than 650 schools, including in the Mid West.
Perth Now
2 hours ago
- Perth Now
Olympics host on debt mission in 'responsible' budget
A cost-of-living cash splash is set to be reeled in as a state government looks at long-term budget repair before hosting an Olympics. Queensland's Liberal National government is vowing to hand down a "responsible" budget on Tuesday after winning the 2024 election, ending Labor's nine-year reign. Treasurer David Janetzki is looking to chip away at Queensland's projected total debt of almost $220 billion ahead of the 2032 Brisbane Games. "It will lay the foundations for a fresh start and it will be delivering for Queensland," he said. The first LNP budget since 2014, when Campbell Newman was in power, is set to look very different from the former Labor government's 2024 budget, which featured a significant cost-of-living cash splash. Queenslanders were treated to $1000 energy rebates and a 20 per cent reduction in car registration costs, along with frozen government fees. Labor initially said total debt would blow out to $172 billion by 2027/28, including projected deficits for two financial years before returning to surplus in 2026/27. However, in Mr Janetzki's mid-year budget update in January, debt expectations rose to exceed $217 billion by 2027/28. It led to S&P Global revising its outlook for Queensland from stable to negative but maintaining its AA+ rating. If the rating is downgraded, it increases the cost of borrowing, making it harder for the government to fund services. Queensland's revenue has also been hit hard by a $2.4 billion reduction of GST revenue in 2025/26 and falling coal royalties. Neither Mr Janetzki nor Premier David Crisafulli would be swayed on whether the debt figure would change in Tuesday's budget, despite a pre-election promise the red line would improve under the LNP. Mr Crisafulli would not confirm if there would be a return to surplus in the government's first term. The premier ruled out any cuts to the public service, promising it would be properly resourced. The government wants to deliver structural support to services in four key areas - health, housing, crime and cost of living. It has already announced almost $150 million to better equip the police force with tasers, tyre deflation devices and body-worn cameras. Families with kids aged five to 17 can claim a $200 voucher to help with sports expenses, costing the government $62.5 million a year for four years. "It will deliver targeted, responsible cost-of-living support for those who need it most," Mr Janetzki said of the budget.
The Age
7 hours ago
- The Age
eSafety boss reveals scale of ‘harmful' videos on YouTube, urges ban for children
Australian children will be banned from YouTube if the Albanese government accepts the advice of its online safety chief, whose research shows four in 10 young teenagers have been exposed to harmful content, such as eating disorder videos, on the platform. YouTube received an exemption from Labor's world-leading social media ban for under-16s after former communications minister Michelle Rowland, now the attorney-general, deemed it had a significant educational purpose. But eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant, in formal advice delivered to new Communications Minister Anika Wells last week, said the carve-out should be removed because children were experiencing harm on the platform. The advice sets Wells up for a fight with Google, the tech giant that owns YouTube, just weeks into her new role or risk a continued fight from other social media giants including TikTok, Meta and Snap, who argue the exemption makes a mockery of the government's plans. It threatens to be controversial among Australian parents because of its popularity among children who use its Kids' platform to watch clips from groups such as the Wiggles. The minister plans to decide on Inman Grant's advice in coming weeks so that the social media ban can be launched by December. Inman Grant noted children would still be able to access YouTube without having an account. The eSafety Commissioner will tell the National Press Club on Tuesday that risks to children of early exposure to social media were becoming clearer in her agency's research, including on YouTube. 'Four in 10 children reported being exposed to harmful content on YouTube.' An Australian survey of 2600 children aged 10 to 15 found that 96 per cent of them used at least one social media platform, and about 70 per cent had encountered harmful content, including exposure to misogynistic or hateful material, violent fight videos and content that promoted eating disorders. Four in 10 children reported being exposed to harmful content on YouTube.
