Harvard speech by Chinese graduate exposes class disillusionment and education gap at home
Controversy surrounding
a speech given by a Chinese Harvard graduate reflects the Chinese public's 'disillusionment' with elite education and 'anger at class rigidity', according to a Chinese academic.
Advertisement
Jiang was the first Chinese woman selected as the student speaker at a Harvard graduation ceremony.
03:40
Absurd, anxious, concerned: Students react to US revoking Chinese student visas
Absurd, anxious, concerned: Students react to US revoking Chinese student visas
While her success was initially praised by the Chinese media,
it soon drew criticism from social media users who questioned whether her 'privileged' family background truly represented the broader Chinese student population.
As the controversy escalates, some academics and commentators have begun to examine how it reflects the Chinese public's growing disillusionment with elite education.
Yuan Changgeng, an anthropologist at Yunnan University who has long studied changes in social attitudes, said that in recent years 'China's social classes have become increasingly rigid and tensions between them have been on the rise'.
Advertisement
He added that within the past two years, few of the 'elites' active on Chinese social media had been held up to public scrutiny without having flaws in their experience or morals exposed.
'People are increasingly recognising that competition in education is ultimately a competition of family finances and social capital [connections and resources],' said Yuan, referring to the fact that children from wealthy families in China often have access to more educational resources, both at home and abroad.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
Tackle discrimination against Pakistanis in Hong Kong at the roots
Feel strongly about these letters, or any other aspects of the news? Share your views by emailing us your Letter to the Editor at letters@ or filling in this Google form . Submissions should not exceed 400 words, and must include your full name and address, plus a phone number for verification The core strength of a global city like Hong Kong lies in multiculturalism. However, the challenges faced by the Pakistani community, highlighted at a forum on May 27, are stark and deeply concerning. Higher unemployment rates, lower-than-average income levels and the highest poverty rate in the city reveal a profound crisis of systemic inequality. While inadequate Chinese language skills and lower educational attainment are often cited, the root cause is deeply entrenched systemic discrimination. From educational segregation and workplace exclusion to social marginalisation, these structural issues demand urgent attention from both government and society to achieve genuine inclusion. Systemic deficiencies in education are particularly pressing. The Audit Commission has highlighted that many Chinese language teachers lack the training needed to educate second-language learners , leading to a persistent lag in Chinese proficiency among students from diverse ethnic backgrounds. Furthermore, schools continue to be segregated, with close to 40 per cent of primary pupils from diverse ethnicities attending schools where over 60 per cent of the student body are from these backgrounds – a concentration that may hinder integration and Chinese language acquisition. The authorities must mandate teacher training, establish a unified curriculum and incentivise the desegregation of schools; otherwise, educational equality will remain an empty promise.
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Hong Kong to keep expanding land bank, but not to offset deficit: Paul Chan
Hong Kong will press on with building up its land bank but adopt a cautious stance on selling the sites, the finance chief has said, rejecting the notion the government is rushing to find and sell parcels to offset the budget deficit Financial Secretary Paul Chan Mo-po also said in a recent interview that the government would address plans to build artificial islands off Lantau waters 'later', despite calls from developers to halt the project immediately. 'We will not stop [creating land] because of property prices and the market; we will keep producing land,' he said. 'Having created the land, we don't need to sell it immediately. It can form part of our land bank. 'The message is that the government has land. But how and when to sell it, we will act according to market conditions. At the moment, it is of utmost importance to manage expectations and confidence … we will put [the land] on the market cautiously. 'Some have suspected that the government hopes to sell land to cover its budget deficit. That's not the case.' Chan revealed a deficit of HK$87.2 billion (US$11.1 billion) in his budget in February and outlined a series of measures to cut public expenditure and raise revenue to address the fiscal challenge.
The Standard
3 hours ago
- The Standard
China says US attack on Iran has damaged its credibility
China's Permanent Representative to the UN, Fu Cong, addresses delegates during a meeting of the United Nations Security Council, following U.S attack on Iran's nuclear sites, at UN headquarters in New York City, U.S., June 22, 2025. (Reuters)
