‘Doesn't actually help': University responds to Albo's HECS cuts

Campus vibes or couch convenience?
A new report highlights the growing divide in preferences for university learning formats between younger and older Australians, with mature-age students gravitating towards online study while Gen Z remains attached to traditional campus experiences.
The national survey commissioned by the University of New England (UNE) and run by Year13 – a digital platform that helps school leavers – examined the motivations, barriers, and preferences of more than 1,000 Australians considering university study.
Young vs mature: A stage-of-life divide
The study found a sharp divide between how younger and more mature age students preferred to study.
Will Stubley, co-founder of Year13, said younger students in their early 20s are drawn to the communal and social aspects of campus life.
'The research shows Gen Zs really want to head into uni and be in class while Millennials and Gen Xs aren't nearly as keen,' Mr Stubley told news.com.au
'It's a stage of life divide, where most students in their early 20s with more freedom on their side want to be learning with other students, meeting people and having fun around campus like uni is famous for.
'But going into class quickly loses favour for students in their late 20s and 30s when priorities shift from pub lunches between classes with their mates to their career and family, meaning university study needs to fit in around those central pillars of their life and not the other way around,' Mr Stubley said.
This shift is reflected in the survey results, where more than 64 per cent of respondents overall, and more than 70 per cent of those aged 25–54, expressed a preference for online learning.
For mature students such as James O'Hanlon, 40, who is currently pursuing a PhD in creative practice at UNE, online study is not just a preference but a necessity.
'Changing economies and employment landscapes has meant that I've had to be flexible and take my career in new directions,' Mr O'Hanlon said.
When the opportunity came to formalise his decision with postgraduate study Mr O'Hanlon figured he'd try something new, but with kids of his own and work to contend with flexibility in study became a deciding factor.
'Flexibility and ability to learn at my own pace in my own time are a necessity when coming back as a mature aged student,' he said.
Motivations and outcomes
The survey found that motivations for returning to study vary significantly with age. While younger mature-age students (25–44) often seek career progression or change, older learners (45+) are motivated by personal fulfilment and a chance to re-engage with education.
'These aren't school leavers,' Mr Stubley said. 'They're experienced adults making calculated decisions. They're asking: What will this cost me? How will it fit into my life? And what's the return?'
'People want to study, but they're pragmatic,' Mr Stubley said. 'Universities need to do a better job of showing how courses fit into real lives and what outcomes students can expect.'
Financial barriers loom large
The survey also highlighted significant barriers to higher education, with cost standing out as the most cited obstacle. More than half of respondents (52 per cent) said financial concerns hindered their decision to study, and 42 per cent worried about accumulating student debt. Other barriers included full-time work commitments (29 per cent) and family responsibilities (22 per cent).
'Taking study seriously necessarily means other things have to step aside, such as full time employment,' Mr O'Hanlon added.
'The only way to make this work as a mature aged student with kids is often through scholarships or other financial support.'
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese ran on the election promise of wiping 20 per cent off student HECS and HELP loans.
However, UNE's executive director of future students Dr Neil Durrant said that debt forgiveness is not the same as 'changing the funding structures which allows students to not have that much debt in the first place.'
'I think clearly those things will be helpful to the students, the prospect of having less debt in the future or this messaging around the government's concern about the debts that students have … ,' Dr Durrant said.
'[However] it doesn't actually help universities with the cost of providing education,' he said.
'So when you're looking at the kinds of cohorts of students that UNE is particularly expert in providing education to, they generally tend to be students that have a higher touch as far as support and that's more costly to teach those kinds of students. 

'So changing the HECS model doesn't actually help universities provide the kind of quality education that we would be looking to provide.'
Universities respond to changing demands
Dr Durrant said the findings of the report justifies the university's longstanding focus on mature-age and online learners, with a huge 85 per cent of UNE students studying online.
'This research validates what we're hearing from our students every day,' he said.
'They want a high-quality university education that works with their lives, not against them.'
However, online study poses its own challenges, particularly around maintaining motivation and engagement. Dr Durrant emphasised the importance of creating a robust digital experience that supports interaction and connection.
'There's a little bit of a catch 22 here with mature age students preferring online study where they've also expressed difficulties with online study in terms of staying motivated in terms of making sure that they had the intrinsic motivation to keep going with online study,' he said.
'And so I think what that signals for universities for us is this clarion call to make sure that the online experience that we provide is really high quality. 

'It's not a simple matter of just taking what you do in the classroom face-to-face and then somehow magicing that up into something online. It's actually having a really strong focus on what it means for students to study online and how we keep students engaged and motivated.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

SBS Australia

34 minutes ago

• SBS Australia

Midday News Bulletin 22 June 2025

Listen to Australian and world news, and follow trending topics with SBS News Podcasts . TRANSCRIPT The US bombs nuclear sites in Iran 16 billion passwords exposed in a series of data breaches in the NRL, the Storm beat the Rabbitohs by one point Donald Trump says the United States has completed what he calls a "very successful attack" on nuclear sites in Iran. Earlier, US media outlets reported B-2 bomber aircraft had been moved from the US mainland to the Pacific island of Guam. In a statement on social media, Mr Trump says all US planes are safely on their way home after completing a mission to attack three nuclear sites in Iran, including a full payload of bombs at the primary site of Fordow. He ended the message, saying: "now is the time for peace". Meanwhile, Nationals Party leader David Littleproud says the US's actions show the conflict is escalating - and he urged Australians to seek safety. Speaking before the confirmation of US targeting Iran's nuclear sites, Mr Littleproud says the reports of the deployment of multiple B2 bomber aircraft shows the increasing danger. He told Channel Nine, Australians in the region should heed the warnings. "What we need to understand is that this is now a significant escalation in what's happening in the Middle East. This is a serious situation and Australians need to understand they are in harm's way and they need to cooperate with the government if they want to get out of there. And we would encourage them to get out there as quickly as they can." Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has accused Russian President Vladimir Putin of being uninterested in peace and acting like the authoritarian ruler of Iran, calling him Ayatollah Putin. His comments came after Mr Putin said that in his view, the whole of Ukraine was ours - warning that advancing Russian forces could take the Ukrainian city of Sumy. Mr Zelenskyy says Ukrainian troops are holding back the Russian army in the region. And he says the comments from Mr Putin at St Petersburg Economic Forum, which ended on Friday ((local time)), make clear his intentions. "Russia wants to wage war. Even brandishing some threats. This means the pressure the world is applying isn't hurting them enough yet, or they are trying very hard to keep up appearances. Well, the Russian economy is already crumbling. We will support this process even more. Ayatollah Putin can look at his friends in Iran to see where such regimes end up, and how far into decay they drive their countries." Australian workers can look forward to more money in retirement, under an increase to the superannuation guarantee that would add tens of thousands of dollars to the average super account. From July 1, employers' minimum required contribution to employees' superannuation accounts will rise from 11.5 per cent to 12 per cent. It's the latest and last in a series of incremental increases from nine per cent over more than a decade since they were legislated by the Rudd-Gillard Labor government in 2012. The Association of Superannuation Funds Australia, says the latest increase would see a 30-year-old on an annual salary of $60,000-a-year accrue an extra $20,000 in super by retirement. It would add about $300 each year to the superannuation of a worker on a $60,000 salary, or $500 for someone on annual salary of $100,000. Researchers say that 16 billion login credentials have been exposed, giving cybercriminals unprecedented access to accounts consumers use each day. The researchers at cybersecurity outlet Cybernews have discovered 30 exposed datasets that each contain a vast amount of login records covering a range of popular platforms - including Google, Facebook and Apple. The team says the data set covers multiple data breaches and most certainly includes duplicates in the data, making it impossible to know just how many people have been exposed. Cybersecurity expert David Taxer told CBS affiliate, K-H-O-U television station in Houston, it is one of the largest data breaches ever seen. "What they're really looking for is hey, does this guy work for so and so company? Does he have access? Is this password the same? Can we get onto his PC? It is not completely verified (the size of the data set). It does look like it is a concerted effort." Experts are urging users to change passwords frequently - and to add multi-factor authentication to their accounts. In the NRL, the Rabbitohs came up one-point short against the Storm in Sydney. The Storm moved to extra time, sealing victory with a 25-24 win - moving into third spot on the ladder. Latrell Mitchell had done his utmost to help South Sydney upset their visitors, including kicking to Tyrone Munro for the try that levelled the scores with only four minutes to play. Storm coach Craig Bellamy says it was a close game. "You have got to give Souths a lot of credit for coming back. It would have been easy to say: this is going to be too hard tonight. But they just kept hanging in there. And with 10 minutes to go - it looked like they were going to win the game. So, I think we were really fortunate to get out of it at the end. Yeah, there are some things we'll need to do this week to be a bit better next week. Just in those moments when it really matters, I think that it was what we struggled with tonight."

News.com.au

3 hours ago

• News.com.au

The truth about Melbourne, Sydney ‘exodus'

In the years since the pandemic first began to unfold, the perception of Melbourne and Victoria more broadly in the nation's collective imagination has changed dramatically. Prior to the pandemic Victoria had the fastest rate of population growth in the nation in both nominal and per capita terms, while the state's economy was one of the fastest growing of any in the nation. Yet despite Victoria's relative economic strength prior to the pandemic, today the perception of Melbourne and Victoria could scarcely be more different. But is that reputation deserved? Or is Victoria experiencing a hangover of pandemic era perceptions that are no longer reflective of reality, years after the pandemic drew to a close. In an attempt to provide a concrete answer to this question, we'll be looking at three quantifiable metrics, comparing today's Victoria not only with the other states and territories, but also with where Victoria was at the eve of the pandemic. Housing In recent years Victoria has often made headlines for an exodus of property investors. Weaker than average growth in housing prices, a lowering of the land tax threshold and higher land taxes have all been put forward as reasons for investors exiting the market. For the sake of argument, we will assume that the rental bond data used to underpin claims of an exodus is correct, despite the extremely high likelihood of seeing the number of rentals in Victoria revised upward. If there has been an exodus of property investors from Melbourne, no real downside is being realised relative to other states and territories. As of the latest data from property data firm SQM Research, Melbourne has the highest rental vacancy rate of any the nation's capital cities and in relative terms has a vacancy rate 83 per cent higher than the average rate of the nation's other capital cities and 42 per cent higher than the national average. This not what you would expect to see if an exodus of property investors was negatively impacting Melbourne's renters. In recent years, an increasingly widespread perception of a mass exodus from Melbourne has developed, arguably as a response to the state's more protracted and more severe lockdowns than the national average. It is correct that population flows in and out of Melbourne have shifted since the pandemic. During the 2021-22 financial year, 24,450 people left Melbourne in net terms as a result of domestic migration. However, the largest loss of residents to domestic migration of any city during 2021-22 was experienced by Sydney, where 49,800 people exited the harbour side city in net terms. Fast forward to the latest data from the ABS which covers up to the end of the last financial year, Melbourne saw a loss of 7580 residents to net internal migration. Meanwhile, Sydney saw a significantly larger exodus of residents to domestic migration, with 41,100 exiting during 2023-24. While Melbourne has certainly seen a major shift from the pre-pandemic norm of domestically driven population inflows, the outflows it is now experiencing are a fraction of what became the norm in Sydney over a decade ago. The labour market When it comes to the labour market Victoria's performance is significantly less impressive. But first some good news, Victoria's unemployment rate is 0.47 percentage points lower than it was at the end of 2019 (4.85 per cent then vs. 4.37 per cent today). The bad news is that despite the strong improvement in the labour market compared with pre- pandemic, its improvement is the weakest of the nation's five most populous states. As of the latest data from the ABS, Victoria also has the highest unemployment of the five most populous states, with 4.37 per cent of the labour force out of work compared the best performing state, Queensland where 3.69 per cent are unemployed. While things are not going as well for Victoria compared with the other states on this metric, there is a silver lining. Since January, the unemployment rate in Victoria has reduced by 0.3 percentage points, even while the unemployment rate in New South Wales and South Australia has increased. The takeaway While Melbourne has seen domestic migration turn negative since the onset of the pandemic, claims of a mass exodus are overstated, at least when put into context with Sydney, which saw 5.4x residents exit to elsewhere in Australia in 2023-24. On the other hand, the news from the labour market is more mixed, unemployment in Victoria is significantly lower than where it was prior to the pandemic, but is 0.31 percentage points higher than the national average. Meanwhile, the best news for Victoria stem from its housing market, where it holds the title of highest rental vacancy rate in the nation and simultaneously the lowest cost house rents of any major city. Victoria certainly faces challenges on the road ahead, most notably from its state budget, as the Allan government attempts to get the state on a more sustainable fiscal path after facing a particularly damaging period during the pandemic. Ultimately, despite its other challenges, Victoria is not facing the problems claimed to the degree that is often perceived and in some important ways Victoria is excelling to a degree unseen in the rest of the nation's large states.

ABC News

5 hours ago

• ABC News

Victorian Liberal leader Brad Battin says party infighting is over as focus shifts to 2026 election

Victorian opposition leader Brad Battin has conceded some Liberal Party MPs have focused more on internal rivalries than voters, but has said his team will be unified heading into the election in 2026. Mr Battin described the party's decision to provide former leader John Pesutto a $1.55 million loan to avoid bankruptcy, a policy he supported, as a "line in the sand" that signalled a renewed focus on winning government. The long-running fight between Mr Pesutto and fellow Liberal MP Moira Deeming, who successfully sued her former leader for defamation, has divided the party. It became a proxy battle in a broader ideological struggle for control of the party. In an interview with the ABC, Mr Battin said he was speaking to every MP individually following the decision to provide Mr Pesutto a financial lifeline, stressing the need for unity. "You've been elected as a local member of parliament. You've got the self-discipline to get there. You just need now to put that into team unity." Asked whether MPs who failed to be team players would face consequences, Mr Battin said voters would ultimately decide. "The consequences are, you lose the election. It's a pretty simple consequence." The Coalition has not won a Victorian election since 2010 and has been crippled by infighting. A common criticism is that too many MPs are focused more on getting to parliament rather than winning government. "I think there's always an element of that, because it's been publicly perceived as that,'' Mr Battin said. The Berwick MP said it was incumbent on MPs to reflect on why they were elected. "What things did you want to see change in the state? And can you do it from opposition? If the answer is yes … then you're probably in the wrong job." Mr Battin challenged Mr Pesutto's leadership six months ago after his supporters undermined Mr Pesutto's position, but Mr Battin reiterated throughout the interview that his team was now united. He hinted that the frontbench team could change but would not say if Mr Pesutto or Ms Deeming would be included in a revamped shadow cabinet. Ms Deeming had proposed an alternative to the party loaning Mr Pesutto money, including delaying his court order debt if her preselection was guaranteed. Mr Battin declined to comment on that or complaints to the state's anti-corruption watchdog, citing legal advice not to speak publicly on the matter. While expressing confidence in the team he would take to the election, Mr Battin said some MPs would need to reflect on their future. "People have to make decisions about time served in parliament, if they want to stay or not,'' he said. The Coalition must add 16 seats at next year's November election to win office. The task is big, but after three terms of Labor, there is a genuine chance for the Liberals, Mr Battin believed. "We've got one chance coming up in about 16 months. It's our opportunity to ensure we prove to Victorians we're ready." He said the party would now focus on policy, with internal disputes hopefully behind him. Mr Battin admitted the long-running conflict between Mr Pesutto and Ms Deeming took a toll on him, including sleepless nights. "It takes a physical and mental challenge on you … but it's resolved my drive. I know what I need to do to win at the next election." He doesn't regret how he handled the matter, stressing that it was a dispute between two individuals. Some MPs criticised Mr Battin for a lack of leadership in failing to resolve the crisis sooner, while others were angered by his decision to support the loan to Mr Pesutto, highlighting the party's ongoing divisions. "I know what I need to do to win at the next election. I need to get the right policy settings, have the right processes with my team, ensure we're a united front, and send a message to Victoria that we're ready to govern."