Victoria police pay $90,000 to climate protester who claimed head was slammed into wall, door and ground
A climate protester who alleged their head was repeatedly slammed by members of Victoria police's riot squad in 2019 has reached a settlement with the state.
Timothy Buchanan, 39, alleged their head was slammed into a metal wall, the ground and a glass door that their head was then used to open, during their arrest at a protest at an international mining conference in Melbourne.
Victoria police paid the protester a sum of $90,000 as part of the settlement in the civil case in which Buchanan alleged police misconduct, Guardian Australia has confirmed.
Sign up for the Afternoon Update: Election 2025 email newsletter
The settlement was reached in February, within days of the commencement of a class action trial against Victoria police in the supreme court in relation to alleged excessive use of oleoresin capsicum (OC) spray at the same mining conference.
'Victoria police does not comment on the specifics of civil settlements or settlement amounts,' a spokesperson for the force said.
'The settlement decision had nothing to do with separate legal proceedings relating to OC spray.'
Buchanan, a Wiradjuri person, participated in the protest at the International Mining and Resources Conference (Imarc) held at the Melbourne Convention and Exhibition Centre in October 2019, where police arrested scores of protesters amid hostile scenes.
In their statement of claim filed with the Victorian county court in 2022, Buchanan claimed that during the protest on 29 October 2019, Sgt Nicholas Bolzonello, a member of Victoria police's Public Order Response Team, grabbed them by the shirt and pushed against their chest before they were tackled by five other officers. Bolzonello was not personally sued in the case.
In its defence document filed with the court, the state argued the use of force was not disproportionate due to the threat posed to Bolzonello by Buchanan and to the objective of keeping the area, where an arrest was occurring, 'safe and free from protestors'. The defence argued Bolzonello's actions were in response to Buchanan's, including attempting to pull the police officer towards protesters and breaking free during an attempted arrest.
Buchanan went on to claim that the arresting officers, which did not include Bolzonello, then allegedly tackled and repeatedly slammed their head into the ground.
The state argued Buchanan resisted police members during the arrest. It said the five officers took hold of Buchanan to control their movements and arrest them, and that the protester was taken to the ground to allow the arrest to take place.
The state said it otherwise denied the allegations regarding the arrest.
Buchanan alleged that after their arrest Bolzonello slammed their head into a metal wall multiple times. The state denied the allegation in the defence.
It was alleged Bolzonello subsequently slammed Buchanan's head into a glass door, and then used the pressure on the activist's head to open the door.
The defence argued Buchanan resisted while being escorted from the exhibition centre to a police vehicle by Bolzonello and another police officer.
Bolzonello placed his hand on the protester's head to control their movements and protect himself from their 'continued erratic movements', the state said.
It said Buchanan's resistance increased as police members attempted to open the glass door, including trying to escape the officer's hold on them.
The defence admitted 'one or more parts' of Buchanan's body came into contact with the glass door as the police members and activist were passing through the door as the officers sought to readjust their grip to retain control of Buchanan.
Sign up to Afternoon Update: Election 2025
Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key election campaign stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
'Bolzonello's hold on the plaintiff's head was for the purposes of controlling [their] movement as they moved through the door,' the defence said.
'After they passed through the door the police members placed the plaintiff against the wall so as to control the movements of the plaintiff as [Buchanan] was continuing to resist.'
The claim also alleged that Bolzonello made 'derogatory' comments at Buchanan, including calling them a 'faggot' between the arrest and transfer into the police vehicle. The state denied the allegation.
Buchanan's claim argued the alleged actions of police officers towards them were disproportionate, equated to excessive force and were unlawful.
It alleged officers did not inform the activist of their arrest, constituting false imprisonment, and that the actions of police officers breached their duties under the state's human rights charter.
The state said the arrest was lawful and Buchanan was informed of it at the earliest reasonable opportunity.
The claim said as a result of the alleged actions of officers, Buchanan had suffered psychological injury and aggravation of anxiety and depression. The state denied this.
The claim alleged Bolzonello acted with 'contumelious disregard' for Buchanan's rights as the protester 'had been arrested, restrained and posed no threat of harm or violence' to police officers or members of the public. The state rejected the allegation.
Police dropped charges, including assaulting an emergency worker, against Buchanan, Guardian Australia has confirmed. The protester pleaded guilty to a charge of obstruction in 2022, without a conviction.
Buchanan told Guardian Australia they felt a sense of 'compensation but not justice' after the settlement was reached, in which the state made no admissions.
'I don't want this to happen to people,' Buchanan said.
Buchanan's lawyer, Jeremy King, said Victoria police had an 'unfortunate history with protesters'.
'You've got to remember that free speech and peaceful protests are fundamental to our democratic society,' he said.
'There is no meaningful independent oversight of police in Victoria. The only way you can hold them to account is by bringing civil proceedings. Otherwise, nothing happens and there is no accountability.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
16 hours ago
- The Guardian
‘I think you and I are at war': the Australians suddenly united in grief over the Israel-Iran conflict
When Israel triggered a war last Friday after it sent a wave of airstrikes into Iran, Saina Salemi and Oscar were at work in Melbourne, sitting at arm's length away from each other at their desks. Salemi saw the news headline first. She turned to Oscar and said: 'I think you and I are at war.' 'I thought she was kidding,' Oscar, who asked for his last name to not be used, recalled. 'I didn't understand. And then we went to the news, and it had all started, and my heart just sunk immediately.' Salemi, who is 26, moved to Australia from Tehran when she was 7, and Oscar, who is 24 and from Israel, says for the past week they've shared in a grief that feels unending – but there has been a release in sharing it together. The pair became friends when they started work the same day as each other 18 months ago. Since last week, finding out what is happening overseas and if it is affecting their families has become a shared obsession. While sitting next to each other at work, they keep track of the rolling live coverage. Salemi also watches Persian news sources while Oscar watches the Hebrew channels. 'We're translating documents for each other. We're tracking where the missiles are being hit and seeing if they're close to our family members,' Oscar tells Guardian Australia, both he and Salemi speaking on the phone together from their office. 'If we find out information we want the other to know, we text each other, no matter what time of night it is,' Salemi says. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email Oscar's parents, who were visiting Israel when tensions flared are – for now – stuck there. Salemi's grandparents, aunts, and uncles live in Tehran. Their shared grief has not just been defined by doomscrolling and sharing news about loved ones. Salemi says their focus is on the civilians suffering and the governments 'making the choice' to continue it. 'My people, Palestinians and Israelis are being used as political shields for geopolitical aims,' Salemi says. Oscar says he is also battling a feeling of guilt, despite having no control over what is going on. 'I really care about her family. I feel so guilty, and even though obviously I'm not responsible for the actions of the Israeli government, but nevertheless, it really pains me to just see even more suffering being inflicted.' 'I don't want people to become desensitised to what is happening in the region, and the … scale of pain that is taking place every day. It's getting worse.' By Friday, Israeli strikes on Iran had killed at least 657 people and wounded 2,037 others, according to Washington-based group Human Rights Activists. Of those dead, the group identified 263 civilians and 164 security force personnel. Iran has not given regular death tolls during the conflict and has minimised casualties in the past. In its last update, delivered last Monday, it put the death toll at 224 people and 1,277 wounded. Salemi says she has not heard from her family since the Iranian authorities blocked the internet. 'My auntie woke up in the middle of the night thinking that she was having a heart attack because the initial missile was so close to where she lived,' she says. 'I haven't heard from my family members in 36 hours, and there's a great sense of numbness when you worry that maybe that's the last time you've ever heard from your family members,' she says. Oscar says he sometimes has difficulty reaching his parents by phone to check in on how they are. He struggled with the news that a hospital – where his nan had gotten care once after she had a stroke – had been hit by an Iranian rocket. Salemi says while the bombs are falling from Israel, she also blames the Iranian regime – unpopular among many – for failing to protect its people. She points to there being no bomb shelters for people to turn to and disruptions to internet access that could help in planning escape routes with loved ones. Despite the ruling regime being unpopular, Salemi is frustrated by rhetoric from Israel's president, Benjamin Netanyahu, that Israel could support regime change. 'Regime change in Iran will come internally, at the hands of my own people,' she says. Oscar and Salemi say the war has inflamed the grief they were already feeling for the thousands of people killed by Israeli strikes in Gaza. Oscar said on top of this he is also grieving loved ones that died when Hamas attacked Israel on 7 October. Since Israel and Iran began trading strikes, over 100 people in Gaza have been killed while seeking aid. 'The safety of Israel can't come from anything other than peace – lasting, negotiated peace,' Oscar says. 'I want a serious political solution and a lasting peace.' Asked if there is anything they want the Australian government to do, Salemi says it should focus on getting Australian citizens out of each conflict zone. Australia's foreign minister Penny Wong said on Friday there were about 2,000 Australians and their families in Iran and approximately 1,200 in Israel who wanted to evacuate. 'The security situation is obviously very difficult,' Wong said. ' The airspace remains closed.' Oscar says that last Friday, after Israel first struck Iran, he and Salemi sat on the steps outside their work together. They already felt it could be different to the 'tit-for-tat' strikes in past months. 'I remember I turned to her and said, 'when will this end? How much longer does this have to go on?'.'
The Guardian
2 days ago
- The Guardian
Guardian Australia's In the Box investigation wins award at Walkley Foundation's Mid-Year Media Prizes
A groundbreaking Guardian Australia investigation into incarcerated teenagers born with severe intellectual disabilities has been awarded the Media Diversity Australia prize at the Walkley Foundation's Mid-Year Media Prizes. In the box: how children with FASD end up in police cells, by Queensland correspondent Ben Smee and medical editor Melissa Davey, uncovered the stories of children who, branded repeat offenders, spend their days locked in adult watch houses despite living with the effects of foetal alcohol spectrum disorder. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email The series of three articles, published in July last year, was recognised by the judges at Thursday evening's awards ceremony in Sydney. Guardian Australia was also a finalist in the young Australian journalist of the year's coverage of community and regional affairs and innovative storytelling categories, and the Our Watch award for excellence in reporting on violence against women. The ABC journalist April McLennan was announced as the John B Fairfax Family young journalist of the year, with her coverage of unwanted medical intervention in childbirth and the accusations against former Launceston mayor Danny Gibson singled out by the Walkley judging board. She won the public service journalism and coverage of community and regional affairs prizes in the young journalist category for her reporting in Launceston. Freelance journalist of the year prize went to Prue Lewarne for her coverage of Latin America for SBS, and the women's leadership in media award was won by SBS's Calliste Weitenberg. The awards are held separately from November's Walkley awards for excellence in journalism. The Walkley Foundation chief executive, Shona Martyn, said the 'judges remarked on the high quality of entries across the categories, an encouraging reminder that Australia's best journalism is of the highest standard.'
The Guardian
4 days ago
- The Guardian
Sydney tram drivers say they fear more pedestrian deaths without urgent safety fixes
Sydney tram drivers say the city's light rail infrastructure needs to be made safer after a second fatal incident involving a pedestrian in two years. The drivers, who spoke to Guardian Australia on the condition of anonymity because they were afraid of losing their jobs, said they had been banned from sharing information about the deaths with colleagues. Drivers said they decided to risk speaking out because they wanted safety changes and had concerns about the current set-up, including that it was too easy for someone to fall into the gap between a crowded platform and a tram. They raised concerns that existing safety measures were not adequate, saying the trams' camera system was too slow to switch on and an emergency sensor underneath the carriages did not activate during the two recent fatal incidents. One driver said they were discouraged even from sharing articles about safety issues, such as one published by Guardian Australia on 7 June, two days after a pedestrian was hit and killed by a tram in Surry Hills. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email A driver raised concerns that they were being silenced by Transdev, the light rail's private operator. Guardian Australia has obtained a leaked internal communique from 8 June warning staff not to talk among themselves about the deaths. 'Sharing content or discussing distressing details – whether through employee or unofficial channels – is disrespectful and potentially in breach of the code of conduct,' Transdev warned drivers in the note. 'They always put out things like that, trying to not let us really talk about incidents that have happened,' a driver said. 'My gut feeling is they just don't want the driver group as a whole to know too much about things that happen.' But a Transdev spokesperson said the note was 'aimed at reminding all employees of their obligations to wider staff wellbeing and not designed to curb discussion about the related news coverage'. 'Formal and informal mechanisms for safety conversations between employees and employer representatives, and additionally with unions are part of regular engagements held monthly to discuss diverse ranges of safety issues,' they said. On Sydney's L2 and L3 routes, two 33m-long trams are coupled together to form 66-metre-long vehicles. On 5 June, a man died at the light rail stop in Surry Hills. Police said they believed he was trying to cross between the first and second carriage. In 2023, a teenage girl died after becoming trapped underneath a tram while attempting to cross a street in the CBD. Police told the ABC at the time that she had been trying to climb between the two tram carriages. The drivers who spoke to Guardian Australia said Sydney's trams had been fitted with a metal barrier underneath the carriages, which was attached to a sensor that would be triggered if it ran over something and bring the tram to a halt. 'Occasionally they're triggered at the front when you've gone over a cardboard box or something,' one driver said. 'In the [2023] incident in Chinatown, we knew the tram had gone 100 metres without stopping and it didn't work because it [was] meant to trigger an alarm and stop the tram.' Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion David Babineau, NSW division secretary at the Rail, Tram and Bus Union, said anecdotal evidence from members was that the system did not engage the way it was supposed to. 'Whether that means it was switched off, or not operating, we would expect [the Office of the National Rail Safety Regulator] to get to the bottom of it,' Babineau said. 'When the coupled trams were introduced, we were explicitly promised it was impossible for someone to get run over at the beginning. Why now are two people dead in two years?' Drivers told Guardian Australia the trams had been fitted with cameras after the 2023 death that allowed them to see some blind spots around the trams whenever they were stopped at a platform, but there could be a delay in these activating. 'It sometimes does take a few seconds longer than it should to appear,' one driver said. They said drivers were 'under the pump to make trips on time' and so might not wait for the camera feed to appear on the dashboard. 'There is a delay of a few seconds of the camera coming up,' another driver said. 'The phase of the signals are telling you you have to go, your doors are closed and you're ready.' One driver said the yellow line at the light rail stops should be moved further back, as it was right at the edge of the platform and commuters were confused about where to stand, reinforcing concerns raised by a woman who witnessed the death on 5 June. Annalise Gasparre, 27, who said she was at the light rail stop when the pedestrian was hit, said 'you could fit two people' between the platform and the coupling joining the two trams. 'To be honest, I think the light rail design needs to be changed,' she told Guardian Australia last week. 'The danger gap is so big.' Transdev and Transport for New South Wales declined to comment on the record when asked about the sensors, cameras, or yellow safety lines at platforms. Transdev suggested the sensors installed on light rail vehicles were not disabled for any reason, but would not clarify when asked if this included the second carriages or if they had ever been disabled. The company suggested the yellow safety line visually marked the edge of the platform, helping to prevent slips on to the track, as light rail platforms were closer to street level than train platforms. The drivers who spoke to Guardian Australia echoed calls from experts who suggested that the gap between the tram carriages be blocked off with netting or another sort of barrier, to prevent people from trying to cross between them. They said the coupling area was dangerous and the existing warning signs weren't enough of a deterrent. 'Further deaths are inevitable, really,' one driver said. 'The only way to stop that is to restrict access to it.' A Transdev spokesperson said an investigation into the Surry Hills death would review what controls were in place. 'We cannot speculate further on any controls or conditions at this time,' they said. 'While the matter is investigated, we are unable to comment further.'
