Keezhadi row: Expert transferred again, CM Stalin says: ‘How many hurdles before Tamil race?'
K Amarnath Ramakrishna, the archaeologist known for his excavation work at Keezhadi, has been transferred from his post of Director of Antiquity at the National Mission on Monuments and Antiquities (NMMA) to Director of the NMMA's Greater Noida office.
The transfer comes less than a month after Ramakrishna declined to revise his 982-page 'final' report on Keezhadi, submitted to the ASI in January 2023. It is Ramakrishna's third transfer in nine months.
Hitting out at the Centre over the transfer, Chief Minister M K Stalin said people should gather in large numbers for the protest organised by the DMK youth wing against the Centre's move to 'sabotage' the Keezhadi excavations and findings.
In a statement Tuesday, he said: 'How many hurdles have been placed before our Tamil race? And yet, for thousands and thousands of years, we have resisted them, fought back, and established the antiquity of our people with the support of science! Still, there are some minds that refuse to accept it. It is not the reports that need correction – it is those minds!'
Su Venkatesan, the CPI(M) MP from Madurai, said: 'Amarnath Ramakrishna is being relentlessly hunted down for the truth he uncovered… The people of Tamil Nadu will give an appropriate response to the deceitful actions of the Union government.' The CPI(M) is an ally of the DMK government in Tamil Nadu.
The Stalin government, which has made 'Dravidian' pride the centrepiece of its politics, considers the Keezhadi findings a key part of this – as they date the settlement to around the same time as the Indus Valley Civilization.
Stalin and his ministers had reacted sharply to the letter written by ASI Director (Exploration & Excavation) Hemasagar A Naik on May 21 asking Ramakrishna to revise his findings, citing feedback from two unnamed experts.
Stalin accused the BJP of 'selectively' accepting historical narratives. 'Even when confronted with carbon-dated artefacts and AMS (Accelerator Mass Spectrometry) reports from international laboratories on the Keezhadi excavations, they continue to demand 'more proof',' he said. 'They do so without credible evidence, while dismissing the rigorously proven antiquity of Tamil culture… We fought for centuries to unearth our history. They fight every day to erase it.'
Tamil Nadu Finance and Archaeology Minister Thangam Thennarasu said: 'First, they said there was nothing in Keezhadi. Then the archaeologist was transferred. Later, they refused to allocate funds. Finally, they shelved the report for two years. Now they demand more proof.'
During a recent visit to Chennai, Union Culture Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat backed the questions raised over Ramakrishna's report, saying 'it was not technically well-supported and established yet'. 'Let them come up with more results, more data, evidence, and proof. One finding cannot change the discourse of history.'
He added: 'People in positions are trying to flare up regional sentiments, but we need to be cautious. This is a subject not to be decided by politicians but by archaeologists with sound technical expertise.'
Ramakrishna has stood by his findings, citing 'documentary evidence' and scientific dating methods such as AMS to show that the Sangam-era urban settlement in Keezhadi goes back to 585 BCE. This puts it contemporaneous to Indus Valley, and potentially contradicts the Sangh's theory of who the original settlers of the Indian region were.
The letter by ASI Director Naik, asking Ramakrishna to revise the report, said the dating of the earliest cultural phase – between the 8th and 5th centuries BCE – required 'concrete justification', and suggested that 'in the present state of our knowledge', it could be no earlier than 300 BCE.
In a written reply two days later, Ramakrishna said: 'The period of the site was reconstructed as per the stratigraphical sequence, cultural deposit available with material culture and with the AMS date found during the excavation… The outcome of the observation of the excavator was incorporated in the final report with all documentary evidence.'
Ramakrishna added that relevant nomenclature changes had already been accepted and communicated in 2023. 'The view expressed by you for further examination of sequence is against the well-reasoned conclusive finding of the excavator of the site,' he wrote to Naik.
Earlier, in 2017, Ramakrishna had been transferred to Assam just months after his preliminary findings from Keezhadi became known. His successor at the site dismissed the third phase of excavations as yielding 'no significant findings'. The Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court eventually allowed the Tamil Nadu State Department of Archaeology to take over the dig, which is now entering its 11th phase, with over 20,000 artefacts unearthed.
In September 2024, Ramakrishna was transferred after promotion to Director (Excavation & Exploration), only to be moved to Director (Antiquity) three months later.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
44 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Government appoints Special Officer to administer Pennington Public Library in Srivilliputtur
A Government Order has been issued appointing an officer in the rank of Deputy Registrar of Societies as the Special Officer of the 150-year-old Pennington Public Library in Srivilliputtur on Monday. The District Registrar (Administration), Sivaganga, V.P. Kavinilavu, has been appointed as the Special Officer. However, the present administrative committee, led by the vice-president, V. Muthu Battar and secretary, A.M.M. Radha Sankar, did not allow the Special Officer to take charge of the library. 'When the officer came here with an order to take charge, we refused to permit her as the present administrative committee has not received any such order to hand over the charge,' said Mr. Muthu Battar. The committee has sought 10 days to hand over the charge, he added. However, Srivilliputtur Tahsildar, V. Balamurugan, who had accompanied the Special Officer, said that she had assumed office immediately. 'The committee has sought time only to hand over the charge,' he added. The district administration said that simmering differences between two groups had led to the interference of the Government, Mr. Muthu Battar claimed that no such tug of war existed. The previous administrative committee that was in charge for six long years as against the by-law that stipulated only three-year term had vacated the office. 'We assumed office only six months back,' he said. The committee had got a stay order against the Collector, who is also the ex-officio president of the library committee, in interfering with the administration. However, Collector V.P. Jeyaseelan had demanded various details like properties under the administration of the library and the revenue generated through them and the expenses incurred for running the library. 'We got a stay against the Collector's letter seeking these details,' he added. Menawhile, the G.O. said that in view of the prevailing confusion as both rival factions were competing with each other to take over the administrative panel, the Special Officer had been appointed to set right the administration. The library started in the British era in 1875 was celebrating its 150 years in 2025. It has got a rich collection of over 69,000 books in Tamil and English along with over 4,000 rare books in both languages.
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Priyanka Chopra shares how John Cena, Idris Elba pranked her during Heads of State
Priyanka Chopra gets pranked by John Cena and Idris Elba. India Today Entertainment Desk Priyanka Chopra Jonas shared a hilarious behind-the-scenes moment from the sets of 'Heads of State' The actor said that she was pranked by her co-stars on the first day of the shoot The film will be premiered July 2 on Prime Video in multiple Indian languages Actor Priyanka Chopra Jonas is set to return to action in the upcoming film 'Heads of State', alongside Hollywood actors John Cena and Idris Elba. But her first day on set wasn't all smooth. In fact, it started with a hilarious prank from her co-stars. Sharing a funny behind-the-scenes story from the film's shoot, Priyanka shared how she walked into an unexpected trap while trying to make a friendly first impression on John Cena. "The first scene we were doing together, I literally went in just because I was like, 'I'll break the ice. I'll just go in and be like, I don't see you'. I think they were in on it or whatever when I went, and John and Idris were standing with each other. I was like, now I've offended him, he hates that. That's what Idris said. He's like, 'don't say that. He hates when people do that' and then they were obviously taking the piss. So that cracked the ice,' she said in a statement. In 'Heads of State', Priyanka plays Noel Bisset, a top-level MI6 agent tasked with guarding two of the world's most powerful leaders - US President Will Derringer (John Cena) and UK Prime Minister Sam Clarke (Idris Elba). The film features high-stakes political drama with fast-paced action and comedy. Directed by Ilya Naishuller, the movie also features Paddy Considine, Stephen Root, Carla Gugino, Jack Quaid, and Sarah Niles in supporting roles. 'Heads of State' will premiere on July 2 exclusively on Prime Video, and will be available in English, Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, and Kannada. Actor Priyanka Chopra Jonas is set to return to action in the upcoming film 'Heads of State', alongside Hollywood actors John Cena and Idris Elba. But her first day on set wasn't all smooth. In fact, it started with a hilarious prank from her co-stars. Sharing a funny behind-the-scenes story from the film's shoot, Priyanka shared how she walked into an unexpected trap while trying to make a friendly first impression on John Cena. "The first scene we were doing together, I literally went in just because I was like, 'I'll break the ice. I'll just go in and be like, I don't see you'. I think they were in on it or whatever when I went, and John and Idris were standing with each other. I was like, now I've offended him, he hates that. That's what Idris said. He's like, 'don't say that. He hates when people do that' and then they were obviously taking the piss. So that cracked the ice,' she said in a statement. In 'Heads of State', Priyanka plays Noel Bisset, a top-level MI6 agent tasked with guarding two of the world's most powerful leaders - US President Will Derringer (John Cena) and UK Prime Minister Sam Clarke (Idris Elba). The film features high-stakes political drama with fast-paced action and comedy. Directed by Ilya Naishuller, the movie also features Paddy Considine, Stephen Root, Carla Gugino, Jack Quaid, and Sarah Niles in supporting roles. 'Heads of State' will premiere on July 2 exclusively on Prime Video, and will be available in English, Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, and Kannada. Join our WhatsApp Channel
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
SC stays further coercive action against man facing multiple FIRs for social media posts
'Hate speech will not take us anywhere,' the Supreme Court said Monday as it stayed further arrest of Wazahat Khan, accused of allegedly hurting religious sentiments through his social media posts and on whose complaint West Bengal police arrested law student Sharmishta Panoli on similar charges. Issuing notice on his plea seeking consolidation of FIRs registered against Khan in Assam, Maharashtra, Delhi and Haryana over his social media posts, a bench of Justices K V Viswanathan and N K Singh directed against any coercive action in the other FIRs or any other FIR that may be registered in future over the same allegations. The bench noted that Khan was undergoing police custody in an FIR registered at the Golf Link police station in Kolkata, and was also remanded to judicial custody in another FIR lodged in Bengal. During the hearing, Justice Viswanathan remarked orally 'these hate speeches get us nowhere'. Citing a Tamil saying, he added '…a wound inflicted by fire may heal, but one inflicted by tongue will not'. Justice Viswanathan said, 'I have been thinking, someday we will get into it…incitement to violence is a test for the speech — should it be physical violence? Need not be. It can also be verbal.' Senior Advocate Dama Seshadri Naidu appearing for Khan said the FIRs were registered in retaliation to the complaint he had made against Panoli. The bench asked why he had not attached the allegedly offensive tweets. Naidu said he had deleted those tweets and apologised before the FIRs were lodged. Apparently conveying his disapproval of the social media posts by Khan, Naidu said he is 'reaping what he has sown' but had 'learnt the lesson the hard way'. He said he was only praying to consolidate the different FIRs so that trial can happen in one place. The bench said that the alleged social media posts were 'all hate mongering' and would not fall within the ambit of free speech.
