Can we critique With Love, Meghan, without unfairly critiquing Meghan Markle?
Meghan Markle has just released her latest venture: a lifestyle talk show for Netflix titled With Love, Meghan.
Although the series debuts today, there's already been a ton of backlash from viewers and internet onlookers alike about the quality of the program. But is the negative response earned, or is it reminiscent of the media firestorm the Duchess of Sussex endured in her early years of royal life?
Today on Commotion, Etalk senior correspondent Lainey Lui and royal reporter Ellie Hall join host Elamin Abdelmahmoud to explain why some people are so mad about the program — and whether any of their anger is warranted.
We've included some highlights below, edited for length and clarity. For the full discussion, listen and follow Commotion with Elamin Abdelmahmoud on your favourite podcast player.
WATCH | Today's episode on YouTube:
Elamin: I take the point that Lainey was making, that there's only so many tropes, there's only so many ways you can pose in a kitchen, only so many titles you can give your lifestyle show, and there's bound to be some overlaps…. What do you make of that criticism of, we could have done a little bit more to distinguish this from what Pamela Anderson put out?
Ellie: Well, I'm going to reveal myself as someone who reads Lainey, because this is a throwback. But when Meghan guest-edited Vogue — I think about this all the time — you wrote something that said that it's so hard to talk about rational criticism of Meghan because it gets drowned out by all of the irrationality and by the racism. And when you do want to criticize Meghan … it's hard to be rational because you have people who have an industry, who make money only criticizing Meghan Markle and only attacking her, and that's what gets them the views….
There is so much hatred that people, from the very beginning, were and are looking for reasons to hate this show. People were going to go looking for things to compare it to, and I think Pamela Anderson's show just happened to be there. I'm not a lifestyle show viewer. They all kind of look alike to me…. There's only so many ways that you can do a show about cooking and hosting and gardening, in my opinion. You're going to see some of the same shots…. But with all the Pamela Anderson criticism, you really need to understand that the loudest voices here are people who have made an industry out of hating Meghan. And you need to accept these YouTubers, these people on Twitter, all of this crazy mad criticism — you need to look at it in that context.
Elamin: Okay. I take your point, which I suppose is Lainey's point — this is a bit of an attribution circle happening here … that the criticisms of Meghan Markle are landing within a context and landing within a history of really vicious racism. And so under all this context, Lainey, when we watch a show like this one, what are the avenues of criticism that are available to us, that don't feel like they are retreading that racism that made them leave the royal family in the first place?
Lainey: I think that it is fair to criticize Meghan, and Harry too, based on their work. I think what Ellie was referring to is when Meghan Markle guest-edited British Vogue and she wrote an editor's letter. I think what I criticized was her writing. You know, if you're going to write an editorial letter, I think it's fair for me to criticize the writing and what she was trying to say. I didn't care for her writing. I thought it was too flowery, and she did that whole thing where it was too much alliteration…. And so to me, that's a fair criticism, criticizing her writing. So to go back to your question, when is it fair? I mean, it's always going to get lumped in with the unfairness. But I do think it would be fair to criticize this TV show, the way I criticized Harry's show Polo….
So if we're criticizing Meghan's show, then you have to consider it in the context of its library, which is Barefoot Contessa, Martha Stewart, Pamela Anderson. And, is it well produced? Are the recipes and the ideas being presented in a way that's fresh? Is there chemistry between the players? Meghan seems to do better when she's with experts. There's chemistry there because she's presenting herself as a novice, or at least someone who's learning. The chemistry with her friends, if it's not landing for whatever reason with the audience, it must mean that there's something to the way it's filmed, how these friendships are being performed, that doesn't quite capture the viewers' expectation, interest, whatever. I think those are things that are fair to criticize. However, all of that criticism ends up getting into the bigger pot of hate against Meghan, and so it's hard to separate what's true, valid and legitimate criticism.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Geek Dad
2 days ago
- Geek Dad
Umbrella Academy: Plan B # 1— The Sparrow Academy
It is a rare occasion when we witness a superb adaptation finish a line before the story is fully drawn, and I am thrilled to know that things in comic form will be as weird and different as a set of timelines set off by Number 1. Six years later, we pick up where we left off. After the mass release of The City's greatest foes and the chaos that was to be known as Hotel Oblivion, Umbrella learns that other brothers and sisters exist : The Sparrow Academy. Mom is alive and well, and the Sparrows are dubbed by her as the best ones. They tell their siblings (as only siblings can do) the Umbrellas were the failures. No one knows how to hurt each other more than family, and this will be an all-out battle for the upper hand, a bloody one. This adaptation invites you to reread the cult classic and remember how things ended up, because we will tend to mix it up with the TV series (and things are very different). I have to say that in 2019, I was wondering about how they were going to film Hotel Oblivion, and the wedding party at the end of the world surpassed my expectations. It is one of my favorite screen scenes of all time, as it reminds me of my very weird and wonderful family (we are six siblings). Having said that, this will be blood and mayhem all around, and I can′t wait! ′Umbrella Academy: Plan B # 1′ is on sale since June 11th, 2025. Genre: Superhero, Science-Fiction, Action/Adventure Format: FC, 32 pages; Miniseries Price: $4.99 UPC: 7 61568 01420 4 00151
Vancouver Sun
3 days ago
- Vancouver Sun
What's streaming June 2025: New on Netflix, Prime Video and more
Reviews and recommendations are unbiased and products are independently selected. Postmedia may earn an affiliate commission from purchases made through links on this page. As summer kicks into full gear, the slate of new movies and TV shows is looking as promising as ever, catering to different genres and moviegoers. For those who want a good dose of romance, there's the YA novel adaptation, We Were Liars , streaming on Prime Video. There's also the third season of Ginny & Georgia streaming on Netflix, which serves more drama and heart this season. For action (and eye candy), Ben Affleck and Jon Bernthal star in The Accountant 2 on Prime Video, while Arnold Schwarzenegger returns for the season of FUBAR on Netflix. Get top headlines and gossip from the world of celebrity and entertainment. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sun Spots will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. For those looking for a solid film, we recommend Alex Garland's Warfare on Prime Video, which is a bit dark but worth watching. There's no better time than the present to grab your popcorn, settle in and prepare to be transported to worlds both familiar and spellbinding. That's why we've compiled a list of the top films and series to watch in Canada this month on Netflix, Prime Video and Disney+. To gain access to Prime Video, you need to have an Amazon Prime account . If you're new to Prime, you're eligible for a 30-day free trial. Air date: June 5 Synopsis: Ben Affleck stars as Christian Wolff (Ben Affleck), who is tasked with solving a case when an old acquaintance is murdered, and a cryptic message is left behind to 'find the accountant.' Realizing more extreme measures are necessary, Wolff recruits his estranged and highly lethal brother, Brax (Jon Bernthal), to help, along with the help of U.S. Treasury Deputy Director Marybeth Medina (Cynthia Addai-Robinson), as they uncover a deadly conspiracy. Why watch: It's the bromance between Ben Affleck and Jon Bernthal that makes this action film a compelling watch. Come for the action and stay for these two who bring their signature sense of humour to the table. Air date: June 18 Synopsis: The series follows Cadence Sinclair Eastman (Emily Alyn Lind) and her tight-knit inner circle, nicknamed the Liars, during their summer escapades on her grandfather's New England private island. A mysterious accident changes Cadence's life forever as she can't remember the events that happened the summer months leading up to her accident. And everyone, including her beloved Liars, seems to have something to hide. Based on: Best-selling novel by E. Lockhart Why watch: If you're into The Summer I Turned Pretty but want a tad mystery, then this one is right up your alley. It's based on the YA novel and is well-adapted, not just focusing on the young teens but also the adults and their lives, appealing to every demographic. Air date: June 15 Synopsis: The movie follows a platoon of Navy SEALs embarking on a dangerous mission in Ramadi, Iraq and the events of that traumatic day, searing together the brotherhood of war retold through their memories. Why watch: Alex Garland's movie is incredibly compelling, and it will linger in your mind long after watching the film. The score is also one that's deeply moving and haunting. Air date: June 12 Synopsis: This action comedy stars Bryce Dallas Howard as Kat, an improv comedy teacher beginning to question if she's missed her shot at success. When an undercover cop (Sean Bean) offers her the role of a lifetime, she recruits two of her students (Orlando Bloom and Nick Mohammed) to infiltrate London's gangland by impersonating two dangerous criminals. Why watch: Who wouldn't want to watch Bryce Dallas Howard and Orlando Bloom exercise their comedic skills in this action comedy? If you haven't signed up for Netflix, visit and choose the plan that's right for you. You can downgrade or upgrade at any time. Air date: June 5 Synopsis: The season picks up after the events of season two, after Georgia was arrested for murder during her wedding. Ginny has to deal with the aftermath, trying to figure out who she is without Georgia at the centre of everything. Why watch: This season deals with more drama and heart, but also touches on important topics like abortion and self-harm that are dealt with quite sensitively. Air date: June 11 Synopsis: This documentary looks at the Titan submersible's doomed 2023 journey to the wreckage of the Titanic and shows the ambitious OceanGate CEO behind the endeavour. Why watch: This tragic story rocked the world, and everyone will want to tune in to know what really went down behind the scenes that led to the tragedy. Air date: June 12 Synopsis: Luke (Arnold Schwarzenegger), Emma (Monica Barbaro) and the crew have to put their feelings aside and work together when a mysterious terrorist threatens to unleash worldwide chaos. Why watch: Not only is the series well-written when it comes to family drama and action, but it's fun to watch Arnold in his first TV series as he continues to do action-heavy sequences with his comedic edge. Also, the fact that this was shot in Toronto is an added bonus. Air date: June 27 Synopsis: The third and final season of Squid Game follows Gi-hun (Lee Jung-jae) after losing his best friend in the game and being driven to utter despair by The Front Man (Lee Byung-hun). He realizes the games are even more sinister than before, but is forced to return for more brutal, psychologically twisted challenges. Why watch: Fans all over the world are counting the days until the finale is revealed. Given the success and storyline of seasons one and two, this one is definitely going to be worth tuning in for. If you don't have a Disney+ subscription yet, go to and sign up. Air date: June 24 Synopsis: Picking up after the events of Black Panther: Wakanda Forever , this series follows Riri Williams (Dominique Thorne)—a young, genius inventor determined to make her mark on the world— who returns to Chicago to pursue her ambitions, but soon finds herself wrapped up with the charming Parker Robbins (Anthony Ramos). Why watch: Ryan Coogler is the EP on this, and given the success of Black Panther and his recent Sinners, this one should be on your radar as his fingerprints are all over this. Air date: June 25 Synopsis: Season four finds the team pushing forward, determined not only to survive but also to take The Bear to the next level. With new challenges around every corner, the team must adapt, adjust and overcome. Why watch: Each season seems to be a step up, and fans are loving Jeremy Allen White as head chef Carmy, a role that has won him two consecutive Emmys, and Ayo Edebiri returns as Sydney. Air date: June 11 Synopsis: The live-action retelling of Disney's Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs is a thrilling new cinematic adventure, one that also offers a charming stroll down memory lane. Why watch: Today's viewers can marvel at the stunning visual effects that bring nature and fantasy vividly to life. Shopping Essentials , a category written by research-obsessed shopping fanatics, is now on . Explore in-depth product reviews, expert recommendations and exciting collaborations — plus get behind-the-scenes info on your favourite brands and trending products — learn more here or sign up for our newsletter
Style Blueprint
3 days ago
- Style Blueprint
Cool Adult Clubs in Memphis: Find Your People in the 901
Share with your friends! Pinterest LinkedIn Email Flipboard Reddit New to town or looking to expand your circle? Whether you are an introvert, an extrovert, or something in between, finding like-minded people who share your passions is easier than you might think. From stimulating book chats and competitive runs to gardening workshops and game nights, Memphis offers an array of groups you can join to connect with new friends through shared interests! For Book Lovers A Novel Book Club More Info: Tucked inside the beloved East Memphis indie bookstore, this club hosts monthly discussions that go deep. Expect a mix of genres, themed reads, and the occasional guest author. Anyone is welcome — no registration required — and members help choose future reading selections. Bonus: You can grab coffee and browse for more books while you're there! Memphis Public Library Book Clubs More Info: Several local library branches run themed clubs open to the public, covering topics ranging from mystery to memoir. Many also offer virtual options, host speakers, and hold special events tied to each book's theme. Memphis Girls Book Club More Info: Founded in 2023 to foster literacy and community among girls who share a passion for reading, this fun, intimate book club hosts monthly meetings and mini-meets at spots around town. The goal is to provide a haven for women to explore new books, find new friends, and give back to the community. The group even has an online platform for members to connect and engage. Pin The New Romantics Book Club More Info: Instagram Run by spunky twin sisters, Stacey and Steph, this club is perfect for hopeless romantics, avid chick-flick watchers, and readers who love stories that end in a kiss. The group shares its monthly book picks via Instagram and hosts live reading sprints each weekend on its YouTube channel, along with a live book discussion at the end of each month. Pin Silent Book Club – Memphis Chapter More Info: Not a fan of structured discussions? The Silent Book Club is for you. The club, dubbed the 'Introvert Happy Hour,' is a no-pressure way to enjoy reading together — quietly. Meet at a cozy venue with your book of choice, read in silence, and chat afterward (or not). No assigned reading or small talk required! For the Movers & Shakers Memphis Runners Track Club More Info: One of the largest and most active running clubs in the South, the nonprofit MRTC promotes health and fitness through amateur road racing, cross-country, and track — all in the spirit of fun and competition. This club isn't just for marathoners; all levels are welcome! Join weekly group runs, training programs, fun events like 'Brew Runs,' and the club's annual Road Race Series. Pin Grind City Cycling More Info: Instagram Love biking? Whether you're into scenic city rides or off-road adventures, this club offers organized routes, trail exploration, and social rides across Memphis and the Mid-South with other cycling enthusiasts. It even sponsors charity events like the annual Paint The Streets Pink ride, which raises money for breast cancer research and awareness. Outdoor Adventures Meetup More Info: Want to get out of the city and into nature? This outdoor-centric meetup group has a calendar full of adventures you can sign up for, from kayaking and canoeing to hiking, camping, and backpacking. Get to know other nature buffs and explore natural treasures in Memphis and the surrounding area. For Green Thumbs & Creatives Memphis Area Master Gardeners More Info: Backed by the University of Tennessee Extension, the group allows gardeners (and aspiring gardeners) to take workshops, join community projects, and swap tips with fellow gardeners. You can train to become a certified master gardener — or just learn how to keep your succulents from wilting. Pin Memphis Herb Society More Info: Instagram For those intrigued by culinary, medicinal, or decorative herbs, this club dives into everything herbal: cooking, medicine, landscaping, and crafts. Meetings, which take plaoccur at the Memphis Botanic Garden, include hands-on demos, tastings, and talks by expert herbalists. MidSouth Makers More Info: Part hackerspace, part creative collective, MidSouthMakers in East Memphis is a hub for DIYers, hosting regular classes, workshops, and open studio nights. The collaborative space caters to diverse interests, from 3D printing and electronics to woodworking and stained glass, to bring builders, tinkerers, artists, and makers together under one roof. Pin For the Quirky & Curious Memphis Chess Club More Info: Founded in 1877, this downtown club has been reinvented into a café, social club, and tournament space all in one, bringing new life to a classic game. You don't need to be the next Bobby Fischer to join — it's open to all skill levels. Drop in to play casually or competitively, take lessons, or just sip coffee (or cocktails) while watching others strategize. If chess isn't your thing, the club is stocked with loads of other board games, including Monopoly and checkers. Pin Memphis Board Game Group More Info: Facebook Hosted at rotating bars, cafes, and game stores throughout Memphis, this casual group welcomes tabletop gamers of all experience levels. Expect to find everything from blackjack to Dungeons & Dragons. Play new games, meet fellow gamers, and learn from seasoned players in a relaxed setting. Toastmasters Memphis More Info: Are you looking to polish your public speaking or leadership skills? Multiple Toastmasters groups meet weekly across the city, offering a supportive environment to practice and build confidence. Ready to join? Most clubs are open to newcomers and host events year-round. Check out their websites or social media for current meet-ups and sign-up details. Here's to meeting new people! ********** To stay in the know on the best of the South, subscribe to our daily emails! About the Author Emily McMackin Emily McMackin Dye is an Alabama native and Tennessee transplant, who recently moved to Memphis from Nashville. A freelance writer, she enjoys exploring history, culture, and the lifestyle scene surrounding her new home in The Bluff City.
