Ottawa Battery Project Down But Not Out After Failed Committee Vote
A proposed 250-megawatt battery storage project in Ottawa's rural west is down but not out, after the city's Agriculture and Rural Affairs Committee (ARAC) voted unanimously last week to reject the plan.
The Energy Mix has learned that supporters of the Marchurst Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) expect a closer margin when the full city council meets June 11-with the possibility that at least two ARAC members will change their votes.
The 10-hour meeting last Thursday heard 68 public delegations before denying official backing for the project, CBC reports. Gatineau, Quebec-based Evolugen, a subsidiary of Brookfield Asset Management, already has a contract from Ontario's Independent Electricity System Operator to build the project on a 4.5-hectare site, about 30 kilometres west of downtown Ottawa. But it's conditional on a municipal support resolution (MSR) from the city.
"The technology is a key part of the Ford government's plan to solve a looming energy supply crunch, as demand in the province is expected to increase by 75% by 2050," CBC writes. "But for many residents, the location of this particular battery trumped any broader provincial picture."
Still, while the ARAC vote "was unanimous at face value," some committee members were "very conflicted", a committee observer told The Mix , with one councillor comparing the introduction of battery storage to the arrival of the motor car in a horse and buggy community.
View our latest digests
"I believe that BESS is a good technology, and this, on its merits, may actually be a good project," said Councillor Matthew Luloff (Orleans East-Cumberland), according to a segment of an unofficial meeting transcript viewed by The Energy Mix . While Luloff said his committee vote followed the wishes of councillor Clarke Kelly (West Carleton-March), who vehemently opposes the project in his ward, "I reserve the right to make my own decision at Council, where this matter will come forward again for further discussion."
Luloff added: "I will be taking the lessons I learned here today at that vote. Let this also be a lesson on consultation, it is not a box to be checked but a fundamental part of decision-making. Community education is incredibly important, and we must continue to do better... in how we inform."
Angela Keller-Herzog, executive director of Community Action for Environmental Sustainability (CAFES), said the community adjacent to the Marchurst site "needs to come together" in order to negotiate with Evolugen for local benefits from the project. But at the moment, "avowed opponents... distrust information offered up by the project proponent company," she wrote in an email. "The anti-BESS group is talking about 'raising pitchforks' and the local Facebook group ejects anyone who has positive things to say about the project."
[Disclosure: CAFES is a partner of the Green Resilience Project, a joint community listening effort hosted by Energy Mix Productions and the Basic Income Canada Network.]
The Energy Mix could not verify the content of the private West Carleton BESS Facebook group. Courtney Argue, a leading project opponent who lives about 400 metres from the site, said "it really depends" how visitors are treated when they join the group.
"People get deleted if they are being disruptive or we have a suspicion that they have ties to Evolugen or their potential or confirmed partners," she told The Mix in an email. "You try your best. Sometimes you get it right and sometimes you get it wrong."
As for the comment about pitchforks, "we hold our pitchforks in our hearts when it comes to protecting our land, wildlife, and way of life," Argue wrote. "Rural folk are not violent folk. We handle things together. We show up in the masses at town halls, we help neighbours. In this fight, we cannot leave any stone unturned."
While the group is meeting neighbours who support sustainable energy solutions-Argue said she'd "love to add solar to our farm to help sustain our operations"-she maintained that most of the people she's heard from oppose the BESS project. Keller-Herzog said the local community newspaper, West Carleton Online, which has covered the issue extensively over the last two years, recently estimated that "the community was pretty evenly split but that the anti-BESS voices consistently tried to present a picture as everybody against."
In spite of the furor and the "significant coverage" it has received, "there is probably a majority of busy working families that are not tuned in to the local news and have no engagement on the issue," she said.
"The real problem? Our community lacks a calm and credible space to talk things through," Keller-Herzog wrote in a mid-May opinion piece for West Carleton Online. "Many thoughtful West Carleton residents, who might offer balance or ask good questions, have simply gone silent, understandably reluctant to wade into a conversation that has become conflictive and dominated by a few loud voices."
Evolugen, meanwhile, "now appears hesitant to engage further, perhaps understandably, given how strident the misinformation has become," she said. Evolugen's Canadian head of development, Geoff Wright, had not responded to a request for comment as The Mix went to virtual press Monday evening.
But "there are other BESS conversations that affirm of course residents and businesses in Ottawa want the lights to stay on, want the grid to be stable, want power to be affordable, want the jobs, investment, taxes paid and local community benefits from a safe, non-polluting energy infrastructure solution," Keller-Herzog added.
Source: The Energy Mix
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
Peel Pub closes suddenly after 60 Years, leaving staff and performers in the dark
After more than 60 years, Montreal's Peel Pub abruptly closed due to bankruptcy, leaving staff unpaid and performers scrambling for new venues. After more than 60 years, Peel Pub in downtown Montreal has suddenly shut its doors. On June 20, a bankruptcy notice went up on the locked front door. Clients and staff were caught off guard by the news. Erik Intrevado has two sisters who worked at the downtown mainstay for more than a decade and were notified by text of the closure. Intrevado produced the weekly comedy night at the pub and had no idea an insolvency notice would be posted. 'Coming in without the permission of the trustee is guilty of an offense and basically breaking and entering,' says Intrevado, reading the notice on the locked front door of the pub. When he heard about the closure, he came to collect his gear, but he was out of luck. 'Maybe a few hundred dollars a year, a microphone, speakers, some cables, power bar.' Intrevado says comedy night was doing well, but Peel Pub was on the decline. Raby, who didn't want his family name used, has friends who worked at the pub. He came by to take a photo of the notice on the door. Raby also pointed out the terrasse wasn't installed for this summer season — a sign, he says, staff took as a sign the end was near. 'They don't get paid on time. He refused to pay them as well for their hours. And who clocked in for the Grand Prix weekend. So there's a lot of people who still have money, tips stuck in here. Completely dead silence from the owner. Just kind of disappointing,' says Raby. Ongoing construction also affected summer business, according to Dave Laanemets of McLean's Pub next door. 'Having the street closed at the intersection has been really bad for business. It hurts us. If no one's going up and down the street, no one's walking up or down the street. And it's not good. If the street was closed for a festival, that's a different story — then people have a reason to be here.' CTV News contacted Peel Pub owner Sami Jmaiel several times and did not get a response. Meanwhile, Intrevado says he's looking for a new venue to host comedy night — but lots of people, like his sisters, are looking for backpay and a job. 'I think that's where the real problem is, is what is going to be the process for everyone who's affected by this.'
Winnipeg Free Press
14 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Fred Smith, FedEx founder who revolutionized the package delivery business, dies at 80
MEMPHIS, Tenn. (AP) — Fred Smith, the FedEx Corp. founder who revolutionized the express delivery industry, has died, the company said. He was 80. FedEx started operating in 1973, delivering small parcels and documents more quickly than the post office could. Over the next half-century, Smith, a Marine Corp. veteran, oversaw the growth of a company that combined air and ground service and became something of an economic bellwether because so many other companies rely on it. Memphis, Tennessee-based FedEx grew into a global transportation and logistics company that averages 17 million shipments per business day. Smith stepped down as CEO in 2022 but remained executive chairman. Smith, a 1966 graduate of Yale University, used a business theory he came up with in college to create a delivery system based on coordinated air cargo flights centered on a main hub, a 'hub and spokes' system, as it became known. The company also played a major role in the shift by American business and industry to a greater use of time-sensitive deliveries and less dependence on large inventories and warehouses. Smith once told The Associated Press that he came up with the name Federal Express because he wanted the company to sound big and important when in fact it was a start-up operation with a future far from assured. At the time, Smith was trying to land a major shipping contract with the Federal Reserve Bank that didn't work out. In the beginning, Federal Express had 14 small aircraft operating out of the Memphis International Airport flying packages to 25 U.S. cities. Smith's father, also named Frederick, built a small fortune in Memphis with a regional bus line and other business ventures. Following college, Smith joined the U.S. Marines and was commissioned a second lieutenant. He left the military as a captain in 1969 after two tours in Vietnam where he was decorated for bravery and wounds received in combat. He told The Associated Press in a 2023 interview that everything he did running FedEx came from his experience in the Marines, not what he learned at Yale. Getting Federal Express started was no easy task. Overnight shipments were new to American business and the company had to have a fleet of planes and a system of interconnecting air routes in place from the get-go. Though one of Memphis' best-known and most prominent citizens, Smith generally avoided the public spotlight, devoting his energies to work and family. Despite his low profile, Smith made a cameo appearance in the 2000 movie 'Castaway' starring Tom Hanks. The movie was about a FedEx employee stranded on an island. Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. 'Memphis has lost its most important citizen, Fred Smith,' said U.S. Rep. Steve Cohen of Tennessee, citing Smith's support for everything from the University of Memphis to the city's zoo. 'FedEx is the engine of our economy, and Fred Smith was its visionary founder. But more than that, he was a dedicated citizen who cared deeply about our city.' Smith rarely publicized the donations he and his family made, but he agreed to speak with AP in 2023 about a gift to the Marine Corps Scholarship Foundation to endow a new scholarship fund for the children of Navy service members pursuing studies in STEM. 'The thing that's interested me are the institutions and the causes not the naming or the recognition,' Smith said at the time. Asked what it means to contribute to the public good, he replied: 'America is the most generous country in the world. It's amazing the charitable contributions that Americans make every year. Everything from the smallest things to these massive health care initiatives and the Gates Foundation and everything in between,' he said. 'I think if you've done well in this country, it's pretty churlish for you not to at least be willing to give a pretty good portion of that back to the public interest. And all this is in the great tradition of American philanthropy.'
Vancouver Sun
a day ago
- Vancouver Sun
Anthony Gismondi: Canadian wine has never been better as national awards mark 25th year
As you read this, I will be embarking on my 25th year at the WineAlign National Wine Awards of Canada in Penticton. Toronto-based writer and critic David Lawrason and I established the original awards to reliably assess the quality of Canadian wines on an annual basis. Over the last quarter century, the awards have produced a moment-in-time snapshot of the state of Canadian wine. Most of the first two decades mirrored the growth of wine and wine quality across Canada, while the last five have been marked by the chaos of a global pandemic and a variety of climate events, ranging from wildfire smoke and deep freezes to heat domes and drought, interspersed with some exceptional vintages and vigneron resilience lit amid the chaos. Our vision for a national competition encompassed participation from across the country, both by wine producers and judges and aimed to provide consumers with valuable insights regardless of their location. As we celebrate our 25th anniversary, we are proud to have achieved widespread industry participation despite the provinces' continuing restrictions on the free movement of wine within Canada. Discover the best of B.C.'s recipes, restaurants and wine. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of West Coast Table will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. British Columbia and Ontario dominate the entries, supplemented by increasing contributions from Quebec, Nova Scotia and other regions, creating a comprehensive picture of Canadian wine. The credibility of the awards is bolstered by the participation of virtually all of the country's most significant wineries. That does not happen anywhere else. We should note that mead and cider producers have also joined the show, albeit in modest numbers. This year's judging panel consists of 25 experts, slightly more women than men, hailing from several cities across Canada, as well as from San Francisco and London, England. We have introduced a mentorship program for young professionals over the years, providing apprentice judges with valuable experience alongside the nation's top sommeliers, retailers, buyers and wine critics. So, what can we say about Canadian wine after two and a half decades? It has never been better. The most significant gains have occurred in the last five years, as significantly improved viticulture has finally provided us with the raw material that reflects our wealth of unique terroir and climate. When we began The Nationals, Icewine ruled the day. Like Sauternes, it is somewhat out of fashion today, as Syrah, Chardonnay, Cabernet Franc and Pinot Noir dominate the stage. Syrah has been a mainstay category for quality at The Nationals. Still, since 2023, the complex grape has suffered significant damage in B.C. from two major freeze events, and its future looks uncertain as owners assess the risks and rewards of growing it again in the future. In the same vein, there is an opportunity for Grüner Veltliner, Semillon, Chenin Blanc and, as we warm up, even Cabernet Sauvignon. Nothing stays the same. Our best wines are turning heads, but sadly, we have yet to find our feet in the export markets, mainly because we sell everything we make in Canada. There is plenty to celebrate, and we suggest you do so with Traditional Method sparkling wines made in Canada, now showing up at celebrations across the nation. They are the perfect example of a true cool-climate wine, offering the ideal balance of acidity while allowing for an appropriate level of ripeness to produce outstanding sparklers from Nova Scotia to British Columbia. It should be a great week. Look for our report when the results are out in mid-July. $16.99 | 89/100 UPC: 3760040420127 The Paul Mas Viognier originates in Languedoc, France, a region known for the concept of 'Luxe Rural,' or rural luxury. The wine style is influenced by the warmth of the south, offering aromas of ripe apricots and peaches with a hint of florals. On the palate, it presents rich stone fruits complemented by hints of honeysuckle and spice. It is a versatile table wine that pairs well with grilled shrimp, roast chicken, vegetarian stir-fries, mild curries or soft cheeses like Brie or Camembert. $31.39 I 91/100 UPC: 808755006236 Severe winter temperatures resulted in notably reduced Chardonnay yields in 2023. Despite the limited crop, the quality is exceptional, characterized by excellent flavours and acidity balance. The warmer-than-usual conditions have contributed to this Naramata Chardonnay displaying a slightly richer texture that matches its complexity. Orange, tangerine, peach and hazelnuts combine to complement the oak, resulting in a well-balanced, delicious Next World Chardonnay that is somewhat reminiscent of a Western Australian Leeuwin Estate. The price remains a rare Okanagan bargain — winery direct or private wine shops. Price: $32 | 90/100 UPC: 776545502315 The 2024 Red Barn pink is the first replacement wine released by winemaker Kaylee Barrs. Fittingly, to fill the 'gap' left by the damage wreaked at Jagged Rock Vineyard, which, by the way, is well on its way to recovery, is a Pinot Noir from the Petaluma Gap, a large 200,000-acre AVA that stretches from San Pablo Bay to Bodega Bay. The styling is Red Barn, from its barely there colour to its subtle mix of dry red fruits and acidity. Sleek and pure, it fits the gap to a T. Impressive. $29.99 I 90/100 UPC: 628055147107 Bartier's '22 Franc is a mix of fruit from Cerqueira Vinyard (Black Sage Bench) and Blind Creek Vineyard (Similkameen), with minor additions of Syrah and petit verdot. The colour, nose and palate are rich and deep, with scents of black fruits, baking spices and minerals. There is a modicum of light tannin that will dissipate over the next year, leaving a mostly warm, friendly, lush south Okanagan red you can confidently serve with grilled vegetables, pork or beef. $34.99 I Score 90/100 UPC: 818201022161 Le Volte dell'Ornellaia is designed for earlier consumption compared to the flagship Ornellaia due to its softer tannins and brighter fruit. The 2022 blend comprises 51 per cent Cabernet Sauvignon, 44 per cent Merlot, and 5 per cent Petit Verdot, with an alcohol content of 13 per cent. It has floral and light toast aromas and a palate that includes blackberries, red plums, dried herbs, and black olives. This wine can be consumed now or stored for future use. • If you are planning to visit Vancouver Island this summer and want to catch up on the wine scene, Blue Grouse Vineyards has a spectacular venue in the Cowichan Valley and a wide assortment of offerings for you, including a sit-down, in-depth guided tasting of five wines, pack a picnic or on-site food offerings when you book a table and buy a bottle of wine. Neapolitan Pizzas and a bottle make for a fun afternoon looking over the vineyards. All and more are available by reservation at Visit Blue Grouse . Experience prices vary, starting at $15.99 per person. • The Fairmont Waterfront Garden Dinner Series has upcoming evenings scheduled for July 24 and Aug. 21. Enjoy a multi-course menu by executive chef Harris Sakalis, paired with wines from Burrowing Owl Estate Winery (July 24) and Quails' Gate Estate Winery (Aug. 21). The event features vintage cellar selections, insights from collaborators such as Chief Beekeeper Julia Common and Dave Wayward of Wayward Distillery, and dishes with rooftop honey and signature gin-based cocktails. Book your seat at the Garden Dinner Series – Fairmont Waterfront . $24.99 I 90/100 UPC: 776545993069 What can I say? This wine is as good as it was when tasted last year, if not better. The MHFE Reserve Rosé originates from southern estate vineyards in Osoyoos and Oliver. In 2022, it has a clean, crisp, fresh and bright profile. It features a blend of red fruit, including watermelon, strawberry and rhubarb, with subtle sweetness and no detectable sugar. Suitable for pairing with prawns, crab cakes, olives, and more, this style of rosé is easily comparable to those produced in Provence. $20.99 I 88/100 UPC: 8011204007650 This 85 per cent Glera and 15 per cent Pinot Noir blend is grown in light, stony soils. The two varieties are fermented separately and left on their fine lees until the second fermentation, which ends just off-dry, with approximately 11 grams of sugar per litre. The mix spends 60 days in a pressurized tank at 12°C, producing a persistent and creamy foam. Orchard fruits with a hint of vegetal notes provide balance, making this Prosecco the perfect late-afternoon aperitif. Organically certified and suitable for vegan diets, this Prosecco hits all the right notes for its price and the packaging.
