A tale of 2 Gujarat plane crashes, a common ‘emergency worker', and haunting memories from BJ Medical College

Ahmedabad MLA Dr. Hasmukh Patel, then a second-year MBBS student, played a role in the aftermath of the 1988 Indian Airlines Flight 113 crash in Kotarpur. He assisted at Civil Hospital, tagging body bags amidst staff shortages following the tragic event that killed 133.
AHMEDABAD: Dr Hasmukh Patel, an MLA for the Amraiwadi constituency in Ahmedabad, has a history of providing service during two tragic plane crashes in the city. Back in 1988, while still a second-year MBBS student at B J Medical College, Patel was thrust into the aftermath of the Indian Airlines Flight 113 disaster.
The flight, en route from Mumbai, tragically crashed in Kotarpur, claiming the lives of 133 passengers and crew members.
Patel said, "I was a second-year MBBS student at BJ Medical College at that time. I remember we rushed to the postmortem room since they were grappling with staff shortage. Dr Deshmukh was the head of the forensic department and we served in whatever capacity we could. There was very little space in the postmortem room, and the casualties were very high."
"On June 12, when we got the news of the plane crash, I rushed to Civil Hospital. Around seven bodies arrived when I arrived. I helped the staff put tags on the body bags. Both the air tragedies were heart-wrenching," he said.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Time of India

2 hours ago

• Time of India

From a husband who hasn't cried to a father who won't go home

Ahmedabad: Eleven days after AI 171 crashed into the BJ Medical College hostel in Meghaninagar, families of the victims continue to struggle with processing their overwhelming grief, with many displaying unexpected reactions to trauma that have left counsellors concerned. Among the most heartbreaking cases is that of a 27-year-old man who lost his wife in the crash and has been unable to cry even once. The couple married in 2024, their future stretching ahead like an open road filled with possibilities. He flew ahead of her to set up their new home in London while her papers were being processed. "I should have been with her," the guilt-ridden widower has been telling himself repeatedly, too traumatised to come to terms with the loss. During their last conversation, she told him repeatedly not to get delayed and keep her waiting at London Gatwick airport. "So, when he received the news of the crash, he took the first available flight and reached the city, rebuking himself for getting late," said a Civil Hospital counsellor who has been speaking to the family in their time of grief. "He visited the campus for three days to complete the procedures and take home her mortal remains for the last rites. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free P2,000 GCash eGift UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo He did not cry, could not cry rather, even once." Considering the nature of the incident, Civil Hospital authorities have appointed counsellors – primarily experienced psychiatrists – to help families cope with the deaths of multiple family members. Dr Urvika Parekh, one of the counsellors, described her most difficult moments in the past 11 days: breaking news of death to a seven-year-old girl. "She came to give DNA sample for identification of the mortal remains. The family could not break the news to her," she said. "Some families have lost multiple family members. The void is hard to fill." The counsellors have encountered several instances where families have been unable to return to their normal lives. A senior citizen, who lost four family members in the crash, has not gone back home. "The emptiness of the house is overwhelming for him, so he has been staying with a close relative for the time being. The same is true for several families as they have just held the last rites of their dear ones and are now finding it difficult to envision life without them," said the counsellor. Dr Parekh explains that there are seven stages of grief – shock and denial, pain and guilt, anger and bargaining, depression, the upward turn, reconstruction, and acceptance and hope. "The nature of the reaction of the relatives has changed over the past 11 days. Earlier, they had some hope that their loved ones may have escaped the crash. But then news came in that there was only one survivor. The next stage is disbelief and denial. We had to deter several grieving parents from seeing their children one last time due to the condition of the mortal remains," she said. Dr Disha Vasavada, another psychiatrist and counsellor, noted the particular difficulty of losing children. "It is tougher to cope with the death of a child than the death of a parent, and one can only imagine the pain of the senior citizens who have lost their children in the crash. In several instances, it may take days or even weeks to process the trauma and grieve for the departed relative," she said. The team will stay in touch with the families, who also have been given the numbers of the counsellors. "In several instances, the relatives gained their composure but could not hold themselves back once the coffins were handed over to them," said Dr Vasavada. "The initial few days of the incident were spent arranging logistics, but when the loss hits hard, handholding is necessary." The psychiatrists draw parallels with early Covid deaths, where the relatives were not allowed to see the deceased "one last time". Not seeing the departed often caused dissonance for the close relatives in search of closure, they add. Dr Rakesh Joshi, medical superintendent of Civil Hospital, said that a team of 10 dedicated counsellors was deployed from day one to assist relatives in going through procedures ranging from providing DNA samples to victim identification to handing over the mortal remains. "The counsellors are stationed at the hospital round the clock. They will be there till all the bodies are handed over," he said.

Business Standard

4 hours ago

• Business Standard

AI-171 plane crash: 245 bodies handed over to families, 251 identified

The DNA samples of 251 victims in the Air India plane crash have been identified, and the mortal remains of 245 victims have been handed over to the concerned families as of Sunday evening. Speaking to mediapersons, Ahmedabad Civil Hospital Superintendent Rakesh Joshi said, "DNA samples of 251 dead bodies of the plane crash have been matched. So far, a total of 245 bodies have been handed over to the families, while six families, who are from the UK, will receive the bodies of their relatives in the near future." "The 245 dead include 176 Indian citizens, 7 Portuguese, 49 British citizens, one Canadian and 12 non-passengers. Dr Rakesh Joshi gave details of the bodies handed over," he added. On June 12, a London-bound Air India Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner crashed into a hostel complex of BJ Medical College in the Meghani Nagar area of Gujarat's Ahmedabad shortly after takeoff from Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport. Former Gujarat Chief Minister Vijay Rupani was among the passengers who died in the plane crash Two days ago, Air India CEO and Managing Director Campbell Wilson reassured the public and employees that the airline's fleet--particularly its Boeing 787 aircraft--remains safe to operate following comprehensive checks and that the carrier is exercising maximum caution in the wake of the AI171 tragedy. In an official communication, Campbell said, "Have our aircraft been deemed safe? Yes. We have completed the additional precautionary checks on our operating Boeing 787 fleet as requested by the DGCA, who have publicly declared that they meet required standards." "We have also, as a matter of abundant precaution, voluntarily decided to continue additional pre-flight checks for the time being. Where there is any doubt, we will not release aircraft - of any type - for service," said the CEO. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

Indian Express

20 hours ago

• Indian Express

History Headline: 37 years earlier, another air crash in Ahmedabad

Ushaben Patel had just finished helping her son Mileen, 8, with his homework before school on October 19, 1988, when the driver she had sent to Ahmedabad airport to pick up her husband returned to their Naranpura residence without him. Sharadbhai Patel, 35, a finance director at Rexroth, a hydraulic and electrical systems firm, was flying back a day before their elder son Jaysheel's birthday. 'As soon as the driver told me that my husband's plane had crashed, I left for the airport. At the site, I saw bodies on fire. I said a quick prayer for them before fainting,' Ushaben, 75, who lives in Canada now, tells The Indian Express over telephone. At 6.53 am on October 19, 1988, an Indian Airlines flight (a Boeing-737) from Bombay to Ahmedabad with 135 passengers, including six crew members, crashed into a paddy field around 2.5 km from runway 23 of Ahmedabad's Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport. While 130 died on impact, three succumbed to their injuries during treatment. Two men who survived the crash sustained grievous injuries. On June 12 this year — nearly 37 years later — Air India's Boeing-787 Dreamliner departed from runway 23 of the airport with 242 passengers, including 12 crew members, for London. Minutes later, the plane went down, its tail striking the first-floor mess at B J Medical College and Hospital, located a kilometre from the airport. While 241 persons onboard and several others on the ground were killed, one passenger survived the crash. A report dated October 20, 1988, in The Indian Express states that the Boeing, 'acquired in 1971…apparently lost height before landing and went shearing through branches of babul trees, hit a neem tree and also snapped a high tension power line before crashing'. Initially, five persons had survived the 1988 crash — Vinod Tripathi, Parag Vasavada, Jaikrishna Kaushik Rav, Ashok Agarwal and Rajiv. News reports say that these survivors, seated in the tail portion of the plane, were 'thrown out' after the aircraft broke into three parts on impact. At 13, Jaikrishna was the youngest survivor, but he lost his parents and brother in the crash. Residents of Sabarkantha district's Idar, the family had come to Gujarat nearly a decade after shifting to Zambia. In 1988, Dr M F Shaikh, then 30, was an assistant professor in the General Surgery and Plastic Surgery Department of BJ Medical College, which is affiliated with and located on the Civil Hospital campus. 'Jaikrishna had fractured his right femur (the strongest bone in the human body) and had burn injuries. A week after his treatment at the hospital, he was airlifted to Mumbai's Hinduja Hospital. However, he succumbed to his injuries within two days,' says Dr Shaikh, who retired as the Head of the Plastic Surgery Department. Besides Jaikrishna, Parag Vasavada and Rajiv too died during the course of treatment. Of the two survivors, Tripathi, then Gujarat Vidyapith Registrar, passed away in 2003, while Agrawal, a textile businessman, died in March 2020. The first to treat the Registrar, Dr Shaikh says Tripathi 'ran from the blazing plane despite burns in both legs'. Tripathi, who retired as Vice-Chancellor, was carrying 170 degrees to get them signed by then Chancellor Morarji Desai. The Vidyapith reissued these degrees. Agarwal's family, which has moved to another area in Ahmedabad, declined requests by The Indian Express to talk about the incident. One of his old neighbours says, 'He lost his wife Abha, 22, and their daughter Ruhi, 11 months, in the crash. He never recovered from the loss of his family.' Dr Drupad Chhatrapati, 92, then medical superintendent at the Civil Hospital, recalls, 'Within 48 hours of the post-mortem, we emptied out a ward at the hospital. The bodies, covered in white sheets, were lined up there for identification. Since there was no DNA testing then, families were asked to identify the remains.' According to reports, bodies, luggage and plane debris were found strewn over a radius of half a kilometre near the Kotarpur Water Works, under construction then. Pinakin Dikshit, then Deputy Commissioner, Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation, says, 'It was a foggy morning. Construction lights were on at the water works compound. The pilot could have mistaken those for landing lights.' Today, a memorial — a concrete airplane on a 10×10 platform — stands at the crash site, located inside the compound. Since 1990, victims' families have been visiting the site annually on October 19 to pay their respects. A rusted board near the memorial, with the words 'Smriti Van' painted in white, leads to a 'mini forest', where the families had planted 133 saplings in 1991. Anil Pathak, 75, a reporter who had done stories on the crash, recalls, 'Among the belongings recovered was a potli (cloth bundle) of gold. I remember the parents of a Mumbai-based cabin crew member wandering around the site in search of their daughter for months. They were convinced that she had survived the crash.' The crash posed many challenges, says ex-Chief Secretary P K Laheri, then Principal Secretary to CM Amarsinh Chaudhary. 'There were no mobile phones then. The police control room called me 20 minutes after the crash. Limited resources meant we had to call the fire brigade from Vadodara (around 100 km away). There were no rescue teams then. All rescue work was undertaken by the fire department,' he says. US resident Pankesh Patel, 64, lost his brother Rakesh and sister-in-law Bhavnaben, both 24, in the crash. He says, 'The June 12 crash revived memories of the 1988 incident— the shock and how my parents were left devastated. Like us, these families too will go through the same trauma.' Though the authorities had announced a compensation of Rs 2 lakh per victim of the 1988 crash, their families have been fighting a legal battle for 'fair' compensation based on a victim's age and income . The writer is an Assistant Editor, The Indian Express