Why were so many Thai farmers among the hostages held by Hamas?

Israel says it has retrieved the body of a 35-year-old Thai hostage who was abducted into Gaza during the Oct. 7, 2023, attack that sparked the war.
Nattapong Pinta was among 31 Thais taken by the Hamas militant group. Thailand's foreign ministry in a statement Saturday confirmed that Pinta, the last Thai hostage in Gaza, was confirmed dead. It said the bodies of two others have yet to be retrieved.
The ministry has said 46 Thais have been killed during the war. Thais were the largest group of foreigners held captive by Hamas. They were among tens of thousands of Thai workers in Israel. Here's a look at what they were doing.
Why are there so many Thais in Israel?
Israel once relied heavily on Palestinian workers, but it started bringing in large numbers of migrant workers after the 1987-93 Palestinian revolt, known as the first Intifada.
Most came from Thailand, and Thais remain the largest group of foreign agricultural laborers in Israel today, earning considerably more than they can at home.
Thailand and Israel implemented a bilateral agreement a decade ago to ease the way for workers in the agriculture sector.
Israel has come under criticism for the conditions under which the Thai farm laborers work. A Human Rights Watch report in 2015 said they often were housed in makeshift and inadequate accommodation and 'were paid salaries significantly below the legal minimum wage, forced to work long hours in excess of the legal maximum, subjected to unsafe working conditions and denied their right to change employers.'
A watchdog group found more recently that most were still paid below the legal minimum wage.
How many Thai nationals work in Israel?
There were about 30,000 Thai workers, primarily working on farms, in Israel prior to the attack by Hamas.
In the wake of the attack, some 7,000 returned home, primarily on government evacuation flights, but higher wages than those available at home have continued to attract new arrivals.
The Thai ambassador to Israel, Pannabha Chandraramya, recently said there are now more than 38,000 Thai workers in the country.
What happened after some left?
Faced with a labor shortage in the wake of the exodus, Israel's Agriculture Ministry announced incentives to try to attract foreign workers back to evacuated areas.
Among other things, it offered to extend work visas and to pay bonuses of about $500 a month.
Thailand's Labor Ministry granted 3,966 Thai workers permission to work in Israel in 2024, keeping Israel in the top four destinations for Thais working abroad last year.
Thai migrant workers generally come from poorer regions of the country, especially the northeast, and even before the bonuses, the jobs in Israel paid many times what they could make at home.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Sun

25 minutes ago

• The Sun

Trump has taken a big step toward restoring the US deterrent after Joe Biden's dismal presidency

Striking a blow for a safe world FOR all its sabre-rattling, Iran's Islamist regime is utterly reeling from US President Donald Trump's strikes on its nuclear sites. Thanks to the US and Israel, Tehran had already seen its terror proxies Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis severely weakened. 1 Iran no longer holds any influence in Syria and doesn't even control its own airspace. Meanwhile, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei's grip on power at home is slipping. The battering from President Trump — pummelling Iran's three main sites for enriching uranium — may well have completely knocked out its nuclear threat, too. The only card the mad mullahs have left to play is a threat to close the Strait of Hormuz — a vital shipping lane for the world's energy. Those accusing President Trump of war-mongering assert this could drive up oil prices and send shockwaves through the global economy. But such a gamble would severely hurt China — Iran's biggest oil client — and may also provoke further US strikes. Trump rightly ignored those who urged him to keep negotiating and let the fundamentalists keep their nuclear ambitions intact. Instead, Operation Midnight Hammer delivered a stinging message to the world's tyrants that he is prepared to act when necessary. It also signalled that there is far more to come should Iran now refuse to co-operate. Trump has taken a big step toward restoring the US deterrent after the dismal Joe Biden Presidency. Watch Trump hail 'very successful' bombing on Iran's nuke bases That is very good news for the world. Sir Keir Starmer has struggled to show firm leadership since Israel first decided to strike against Iran and the US said it might join the fight. In the days leading up to the US strikes, he was urging 'cool heads' and 'de-escalation'. That is the standard position of a UK Foreign Office which has entirely lost its way, and whose default position is passivity. Nevertheless, the Prime Minister did yesterday back the US military action, saying Iran's nuclear programme was a 'grave threat to international security'. Trump spared Starmer from having to give permission to use our Diego Garcia airbase on the Chagos Islands. Instead, seven B-2s flew an incredible 13,600-mile non-stop return trip from Whiteman Air Force Base in Missouri to Iran to deliver their huge payload. What the Prime Minister needs to do now is stand squarely behind the US and Israel, allowing UK forces to help strike down any retaliatory efforts by the Iranians if necessary. By hugely degrading the threat posed by the hate-filled mullahs of Iran, Trump and the US have done us all a great favour.

The Sun

an hour ago

• The Sun

Starmer's Iran errors have humiliated UK & isolated us from key allies… it's shameful US & Israel had to go it alone

GOODBYE 'TACO', hello to 14 30,000lb Massive Ordnance Penetrators raining down from B-2 stealth bombers with deadly precision. The US President's critics' favourite line — that Trump Always Chickens Out — lasted about as long as an Iranian intelligence chief popping down the shops. 3 In just eight days, Israel and the US have dismantled the Mad Mullahs' military hierarchy and reduced their terrifying nuclear ambition to dust. Mossad has clearly filleted the inner workings of the Iranian state, able to assassinate its evil henchmen and their instant replacements at will. History will regard the sickening October 7 attack by Iran -backed Hamas as one of the biggest strategic cock-ups by a warmongering nation in history. Pretty pathetic Since that day in 2023, when 1,200 Israelis were killed with Iranian-funded weapons, fired by Iranian-trained militants, a snowballing retaliation has ripped through Iran's entire standing in the Middle East. First through the terrorist tunnels of Gaza, then the extraordinary exploding pagers literally decapitating Iran-backed Hezbollah in Lebanon. As Iran's proxy network unraveled at the sharp end of Israel's canny might, it has looked increasingly isolated from old chums China and Russia, who have not rushed to its aid. Now there are questions over the future of the regime in Tehran, as Israel's missiles and drones force them to cower in bunkers rather than stop the 92million citizens of the rogue state casting off the shackles of 46 years of Islamic tyranny. It was one helluva audacious strike by a tiny democracy on the menacing nearby dictatorship, ten times its size, that has spent decades vowing to wipe Israel off the map. It sparked a week of international hand-wringing, mind games, false flags, misdirection, social media diplomacy and shattered reputations. And then Saturday night's piece de resistance from the air, which saw President Trump come good on his long-standing pledge that Iran must never have a nuke. Warnings that Tehran was hell-bent on building a bomb have kept countless Presidents awake at night, but despite a wall of diplomatic bedwetting, finally one has taken action. And the mullahs only have themselves to blame. Trump gave Tehran 60 days to come to the table, but instead they continued to enrich uranium, stall for talks and attempt to continue their pernicious proxy war against Israel and the wider West. Given the implications for us all, it is shameful the US and Israel had to not only go it alone at this historic moment, but act in the face of public warnings to de-escalate from fellow world leaders such as Sir Keir Starmer. His watery Foreign Office drivel about the need to step back and return to a table — aka repeat the mistakes of the last 20 years — have left the UK isolated from, and distrusted by, two of its most important allies. Whether driven by naivety, misinformation or a slavish love of his Attorney General Lord Hermer, who decreed we may break the rules by helping out friends, Starmer's insistence 'that we need to de-escalate this' looks pretty pathetic as the world woke up safer yesterday morning to a nuclear-free Iran. And it was a misstep to declare publicly, on camera, having sat next to President Trump at dinner at the G7 in Canada last week, that there was 'nothing the President said that suggests he's about to get involved in this conflict'. Pushed that all signs were pointing to a US strike, the PM even doubled down, telling reporters: 'On the contrary, throughout the dinner, I was sitting right next to President Trump, so I've no doubt, in my mind, the level of agreement there was.' So either Trump misled him, or Starmer missed the art of the deal with the President playing mind games with the mullahs. Either way, it was a humiliation for Britain to be so out of the loop. Rough few days The UK has publicly hectored the US not to get involved, and appears to have made American bombers take the 40-hour long way round to Iran, rather than offer our support and services at our base in Diego Garcia in the Indian Ocean that could have shortened that trip dramatically. The Government insists no request for support was made, but it should have been offered before even needing to be asked. How naive Labour's arms embargoes on Israel and petty sanctions on its politicians also look now, however well it went down with their MPs scared of losing their seats to Gaza independents. For a PM who clearly enjoys the lure of the international stage far more than his unpopularity back home, it's been a rough few days. And as he gets back in his jet for the Nato summit tonight, he better be planning how to mend those bridges with the United States and Israel — and quick. It's one thing to lose friends at home, but unforgivable to lose them in such a weak manner abroad. A public 'well done and thank you' to our allies would not go amiss either. SWITCH over to the BBC and you would think they were covering a state funeral yesterday, with the sombre reporting of the destruction of three Iranian nuclear facilities. The attack came just days after limp-as-a-lettuce TV chef Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall took to the Beeb to demand Israel and the US leave poor Iran alone. Over on Sky News, you would have thought there was a moral equivalence to the democratically elected leader of the free world and the evil Ayatollah Khamenei. But the prize for clown coverage has to go to LBC's Lewis Goodall, who argued the Iranian dictatorship had the right to build the Bomb because Israel (a democracy) has one and those nice men in Tehran were actually the ones obeying all the international nuclear rules. Is there some pundit madrasah where they are brainwashing these jokers?

Reuters

3 hours ago

• Reuters

Israel rejects critical EU report ahead of ministers' meeting

BRUSSELS, June 22 (Reuters) - Israel has rejected a European Union report saying it may be breaching human rights obligations in Gaza and the West Bank as a 'moral and methodological failure,' according to a document seen by Reuters on Sunday. The note, sent to EU officials ahead of a foreign ministers' meeting on Monday, said the report by the bloc's diplomatic service failed to consider Israel's challenges and was based on inaccurate information. "The Foreign Ministry of the State of Israel rejects the document ... and finds it to be a complete moral and methodological failure," the note said, adding that it should be dismissed entirely. European nations have been increasingly critical of the massive civilian toll of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's military campaign against Palestinian militant group Hamas since its October 7, 2023 attack on Israeli communities.