‘Lies:' A UWA professor accuses the WA Government of lying about the impact of industrial emissions on Aboriginal rock art
The Western Australian government has been accused of lying in the summary of a report about the impact of industrial pollution on Aboriginal rock art in the Pilbara to support an extension to Woodside's North West Shelf gas plant.
UWA professor of archaeology Benjamin Smith said he had blown the whistle on the summary of an 800 page report released by the WA government late last week examining the impact of industrial emissions on Murujuga rock art.
The Cook government has denied the allegation.
The report was produced by the Murujuga Aboriginal Corporation, Department of Water and Environmental Regulation and scientists from Curtin University, which the professor claims were gagged from commenting on its findings.
Professor Smith has studied the impact of pollutants on rock art for the past six years and claims the WA government covered up evidence that industrial pollutants have degraded rock art and misrepresented findings in the report.
'This report contains very serious evidence that industrial emissions are currently damaging the rock art of Murujuga,' he said.
Professor Smith said experiments showed rocks at Murujuga were damaged by industrial pollutants at accelerating elevated porosity, which meant they looked liked Swiss cheese under a microscope, rather than hard, even surfaces.
He said the government tried to blame elevated porosity on a Dampier power plant that operated in the 1970s and 1980s that produced 4000 tonnes of pollution, but current emissions from industry were now five times higher.
'That means current emissions are five times more serious, we have five times the level of destruction of Murujuga rock art than we had in the 1970s and 80s, according to the Murujuga rock art report,' he said.
A state government spokesman denied the allegations saying the claims were offensive and factually incorrect.
The premier told media at a press conference the science has said that modern industrial developments do not have a long-term impact in terms of the quality of the rock art.
'There was one incident back in the 1970s associated with an old generation power plant, that is what people have pointed to as being the most damaging period during the age of the rock art.'
Professor Smith tore up a copy of the summary at a press conference telling media the document was a disgrace and not worth the paper it was written on.
'The minister cannot make a decision on the expansion of the North West Shelf on the basis of this propaganda document,' he said.
Woodside has operated the facility for 40 years and have environmental approval to operate the gas plant until 2030, but need government approval to extend operations beyond next decade.
The WA government approved Woodside's expansion in December, but the project needs environmental approval from the federal government before it can continue past 2030.
Federal Environment Minister Murray Watt is due to make a decision by the end of the month on whether to grant Woodside an extension to continue operating the North West Shelf gas plant until 2070.
The North West Shelf is one of the world's biggest producers of liquefied natural gas, environmentalists argue it is one of the biggest polluters of greenhouse gas emissions in the Southern Hemisphere.
WA Greens spokesman Sophie McNeil called on Minister Watt to delay making a decision on the North West Shelf extension in the wake of these 'shocking revelations.'
'There is a clear discrepancy between the findings of the 800 page report and of the summary, which we know was written by department officials,' she said.
'We have serious concerns about the ability of the minister to make this decision in this short period of time, because that report is incredibly technical reading.'
Mr Watt declined to comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Herald Sun
an hour ago
- Herald Sun
Australian Army chief identifies problems with troop training in leaked letter
Don't miss out on the headlines from SA News. Followed categories will be added to My News. Australian Army recruits are 'not up to scratch' and lack the mental strength to take on criticism or be 'yelled at', a unit commander has claimed. The criticism comes as a leaked letter – written in December by Deputy Chief of the Army Major General Christopher Smith – identified a range of deficiencies in the force's troop training. Support units were particularly affected, with the letter claiming personnel lacked 'competency in foundational soldiering skills [including] navigation, digging pits, putting up wire, patrolling and air sentry duties'. The result: 'non-arms corp units are finding it necessary to expend valuable time teaching foundational skills rather than on collective training, inhibiting the value troops draw from exercises'. Major Smith's letter urged commanders to shift their priorities and focus on improving the physical, psychological and social conditioning (or group cohesion) of troops, representing a broader philosophical change in the army's approach to training – to ensure the army can meet the nation's 'changing situation'. A defence spokesman confirmed General Smith wrote the letter to all army commanders in December, saying it was 'intended to reflect on the force's posture changes and strategic circumstances as outlined in the 2024 National Defence Strategy'. But one commander, speaking under anonymity, suggests the letter speaks to his own deeper concerns about troop standards claiming some were simply 'not up to scratch'. They claim cadets lacked the mental fortitude expected of a soldier, being unable to take on criticism or withstand 'being yelled at'. The letter also flagged remote training as a problem, being at odds with the army's philosophical shift, stating in-person experiences were preferable as they built 'camaraderie, resilience, and readiness in ways that remote learning cannot replicate'. The letter emphasised on multiple occasions the need to change immediately, with General Smith explaining that he took 'the unusual step' of issuing the letter to all commanders rather than following a standard top-down process, 'because the requirement to adapt is urgent'. 'Army Headquarters is leading the development of doctrine for the essential physical, psychological, and social conditioning we seek to instil across the force,' the letter says. 'That work is important however, action cannot wait for top-down directives. 'In the interim, I encourage you to take immediate steps to reflect this change in the bias of our training to the extent you are able and to the extent resources and staffing allows. 'Time is the critical resource for conditioning our soldiers and officers. Exploit it fully.' Defence would not clarify why General Smith's letter reiterated a sense of urgency, but a spokeswoman said there have already been changes within the army over the last six months since the letter was sent – including an increase in the number of weeks troops spent going through basic training. Minister for Defence Richard Marles declined to comment. Originally published as Deputy Chief of the Army instructs commanders to fix 'deficiencies' with troop training as some units lack basic soldier skills
The Advertiser
a day ago
- The Advertiser
State Budget 2025: $21.5 million for Stockton beach renourishment
Next week's state budget will include $21.5 million for vital sand renourishment works at Stockton beach as part of the largest beach repair project in the state's history. The funding will help ensure the beach's long-term future and protect the area's Aboriginal heritage and recreational and economic assets. The government has worked with the City of Newcastle to deliver 130,000 cubic metres of sand to nourish Stockton beach to date. The new funding will ensure the government can deliver the next phase of the Stockton beach Repair Blueprint. Actions include finalising environmental approvals, creating and implementing an environmental monitoring plan, securing licences, planning the approach to procurement, and delivering beach nourishment. "I have been fighting for Stockton beach alongside the community since I was first elected as the Member for Newcastle. I secured $21.5 million for mass sand nourishment, and I am so pleased to be delivering on that commitment," Stockton Special Advisory Panel Chairman and Member for Newcastle Tim Crakanthorp said. "It's one thing to have a blueprint - it's another to have the funding confirmed in this year's budget and to be moving onto the next steps of getting sand back on the beach." The Newcastle Herald reported in March that public assets at the northern end of the beach were under "immediate threat" due to the impact of relentless coastal erosion. The warning, contained in the draft Extended Stockton Coastal Management Plan, proposed a medium to long-term plan to manage ongoing sand movement between Little beach and the Port Stephens local government boundary. However, the recent storms stripped even more sand from the beach. City of Newcastle brought in heavy machinery on low tide this week to recontour the beach to slow further sand loss. The work involves scraping sand from the lower part of the beach and depositing it close to land to support and accelerate the natural processes of sand accumulation, to increase dune resilience ahead of mass sand nourishment. The government's new investment over five years is in addition to the $6.3 million stage one project administered by the state government and jointly funded by the federal government and the City of Newcastle Council. The government will continue to involve the community and seek their input on the restoration process. The Stockton Special Advisory Panel will continue to provide important stakeholder perspectives. "Locals have fought for action on Stockton beach for years, and now, the Minns Labor Government is delivering," Minister for the Hunter Yasmin Catley said. "We've already seen the first signs of recovery with sand returned to the beach. This next round of funding means we can keep that momentum going, push ahead with planning and approvals, and deliver the long-term solution Stockton needs. "This is about protecting a place that means so much to locals - for lifestyle, for culture, and for the economy." Next week's state budget will include $21.5 million for vital sand renourishment works at Stockton beach as part of the largest beach repair project in the state's history. The funding will help ensure the beach's long-term future and protect the area's Aboriginal heritage and recreational and economic assets. The government has worked with the City of Newcastle to deliver 130,000 cubic metres of sand to nourish Stockton beach to date. The new funding will ensure the government can deliver the next phase of the Stockton beach Repair Blueprint. Actions include finalising environmental approvals, creating and implementing an environmental monitoring plan, securing licences, planning the approach to procurement, and delivering beach nourishment. "I have been fighting for Stockton beach alongside the community since I was first elected as the Member for Newcastle. I secured $21.5 million for mass sand nourishment, and I am so pleased to be delivering on that commitment," Stockton Special Advisory Panel Chairman and Member for Newcastle Tim Crakanthorp said. "It's one thing to have a blueprint - it's another to have the funding confirmed in this year's budget and to be moving onto the next steps of getting sand back on the beach." The Newcastle Herald reported in March that public assets at the northern end of the beach were under "immediate threat" due to the impact of relentless coastal erosion. The warning, contained in the draft Extended Stockton Coastal Management Plan, proposed a medium to long-term plan to manage ongoing sand movement between Little beach and the Port Stephens local government boundary. However, the recent storms stripped even more sand from the beach. City of Newcastle brought in heavy machinery on low tide this week to recontour the beach to slow further sand loss. The work involves scraping sand from the lower part of the beach and depositing it close to land to support and accelerate the natural processes of sand accumulation, to increase dune resilience ahead of mass sand nourishment. The government's new investment over five years is in addition to the $6.3 million stage one project administered by the state government and jointly funded by the federal government and the City of Newcastle Council. The government will continue to involve the community and seek their input on the restoration process. The Stockton Special Advisory Panel will continue to provide important stakeholder perspectives. "Locals have fought for action on Stockton beach for years, and now, the Minns Labor Government is delivering," Minister for the Hunter Yasmin Catley said. "We've already seen the first signs of recovery with sand returned to the beach. This next round of funding means we can keep that momentum going, push ahead with planning and approvals, and deliver the long-term solution Stockton needs. "This is about protecting a place that means so much to locals - for lifestyle, for culture, and for the economy." Next week's state budget will include $21.5 million for vital sand renourishment works at Stockton beach as part of the largest beach repair project in the state's history. The funding will help ensure the beach's long-term future and protect the area's Aboriginal heritage and recreational and economic assets. The government has worked with the City of Newcastle to deliver 130,000 cubic metres of sand to nourish Stockton beach to date. The new funding will ensure the government can deliver the next phase of the Stockton beach Repair Blueprint. Actions include finalising environmental approvals, creating and implementing an environmental monitoring plan, securing licences, planning the approach to procurement, and delivering beach nourishment. "I have been fighting for Stockton beach alongside the community since I was first elected as the Member for Newcastle. I secured $21.5 million for mass sand nourishment, and I am so pleased to be delivering on that commitment," Stockton Special Advisory Panel Chairman and Member for Newcastle Tim Crakanthorp said. "It's one thing to have a blueprint - it's another to have the funding confirmed in this year's budget and to be moving onto the next steps of getting sand back on the beach." The Newcastle Herald reported in March that public assets at the northern end of the beach were under "immediate threat" due to the impact of relentless coastal erosion. The warning, contained in the draft Extended Stockton Coastal Management Plan, proposed a medium to long-term plan to manage ongoing sand movement between Little beach and the Port Stephens local government boundary. However, the recent storms stripped even more sand from the beach. City of Newcastle brought in heavy machinery on low tide this week to recontour the beach to slow further sand loss. The work involves scraping sand from the lower part of the beach and depositing it close to land to support and accelerate the natural processes of sand accumulation, to increase dune resilience ahead of mass sand nourishment. The government's new investment over five years is in addition to the $6.3 million stage one project administered by the state government and jointly funded by the federal government and the City of Newcastle Council. The government will continue to involve the community and seek their input on the restoration process. The Stockton Special Advisory Panel will continue to provide important stakeholder perspectives. "Locals have fought for action on Stockton beach for years, and now, the Minns Labor Government is delivering," Minister for the Hunter Yasmin Catley said. "We've already seen the first signs of recovery with sand returned to the beach. This next round of funding means we can keep that momentum going, push ahead with planning and approvals, and deliver the long-term solution Stockton needs. "This is about protecting a place that means so much to locals - for lifestyle, for culture, and for the economy." Next week's state budget will include $21.5 million for vital sand renourishment works at Stockton beach as part of the largest beach repair project in the state's history. The funding will help ensure the beach's long-term future and protect the area's Aboriginal heritage and recreational and economic assets. The government has worked with the City of Newcastle to deliver 130,000 cubic metres of sand to nourish Stockton beach to date. The new funding will ensure the government can deliver the next phase of the Stockton beach Repair Blueprint. Actions include finalising environmental approvals, creating and implementing an environmental monitoring plan, securing licences, planning the approach to procurement, and delivering beach nourishment. "I have been fighting for Stockton beach alongside the community since I was first elected as the Member for Newcastle. I secured $21.5 million for mass sand nourishment, and I am so pleased to be delivering on that commitment," Stockton Special Advisory Panel Chairman and Member for Newcastle Tim Crakanthorp said. "It's one thing to have a blueprint - it's another to have the funding confirmed in this year's budget and to be moving onto the next steps of getting sand back on the beach." The Newcastle Herald reported in March that public assets at the northern end of the beach were under "immediate threat" due to the impact of relentless coastal erosion. The warning, contained in the draft Extended Stockton Coastal Management Plan, proposed a medium to long-term plan to manage ongoing sand movement between Little beach and the Port Stephens local government boundary. However, the recent storms stripped even more sand from the beach. City of Newcastle brought in heavy machinery on low tide this week to recontour the beach to slow further sand loss. The work involves scraping sand from the lower part of the beach and depositing it close to land to support and accelerate the natural processes of sand accumulation, to increase dune resilience ahead of mass sand nourishment. The government's new investment over five years is in addition to the $6.3 million stage one project administered by the state government and jointly funded by the federal government and the City of Newcastle Council. The government will continue to involve the community and seek their input on the restoration process. The Stockton Special Advisory Panel will continue to provide important stakeholder perspectives. "Locals have fought for action on Stockton beach for years, and now, the Minns Labor Government is delivering," Minister for the Hunter Yasmin Catley said. "We've already seen the first signs of recovery with sand returned to the beach. This next round of funding means we can keep that momentum going, push ahead with planning and approvals, and deliver the long-term solution Stockton needs. "This is about protecting a place that means so much to locals - for lifestyle, for culture, and for the economy."
Perth Now
a day ago
- Perth Now
Lidia flips off King Charles in new stunt
Senator Lidia Thorpe has sparked controversy after sharing photos of herself standing outside Buckingham Palace making a rude gesture. The independent senator, who made international headlines after gatecrashing an event during King Charles III's visit to Australia and yelling 'you are not my king', was in London this week to attend a conference. During her trip she donned a 'blak sovereign movement' shirt and was pictured outside the gates of Buckingham Palace holding an Aboriginal flag, making a rude gesture with her middle finger and standing with her hands on her hips. She shared the three images to social media with the caption: 'Dropped by to collect all the stuff this lot stole, but Charlie wasn't in.' The post sparked division among her followers. On Instagram, the reception was largely positive, with multiple users calling Senator Thorpe 'the only Queen I'll recognise' or 'our Queen'. 'This made my day,' one follower wrote, while another said it was 'great to see you delivering your middle finger for his bday in person!' The King's birthday was celebrated on June 14 in the UK. On Facebook, where comments on the post were blocked, others shared the post with less enthusiastic commentary. 'What a shock she did not get an invite into the palace,' one user wrote. 'What a bloody embarrassment,' another said. While the Senator's actions sparked debate online, they were less disruptive than her shock protest during the King's visit to Australia last year. Senator Thorpe made international headlines after disrupting a speech from King Charles III at Parliament House in Canberra on October 21. NewsWire / POOL / Lukas Coch Credit: News Corp Australia The Indigenous MP sparked international outrage after screaming out 'f**k the colony' in the Great Hall at Parliament House in Canberra shortly after the King had given a speech praising Australia. 'You are not our king. You are not sovereign,' she yelled at the monarch, 'You committed genocide against our people. Give us our land back. 'Give us what you stole from us: our bones, our skulls, our babies, our people. 'You destroyed our land. Give us a Treaty. We want a Treaty in this country. You are a genocidalist. This is not your land. This is not your land. You are not my king. You are not our king. F. k the colony, f. k the colony, f. k the colony.' She was evicted by security guards who had been watching her throughout the proceedings, continuing to yell as she was removed from the room. She continued to yell at the King as she was removed from the room by security. NewsWire / David Beach Credit: NewsWire
