Transformation Fund draft document lacks clear, outcome-driven goals, BLSA says
Business Leadership South Africa has criticised the recently launched Transformation Fund as being flawed because it was structured around input-based targets instead of clear, outcome-driven goals..(John McCann/M&G)
Business Leadership South Africa (BLSA) has criticised the recently launched Transformation Fund as being flawed because it was structured around input-based targets instead of clear, outcome-driven goals. It said effective efforts should be anchored in measurable objectives that justified the financial commitment required.
According to a
In
'The fund should use an outcome-based approach by specifying the expected transformation impact in tangible terms, such as the number of businesses it aims to grow, employment targets, or improvements in SME (small and medium enterprises) survival rates,' it said.
'For example, a goal of supporting 5 000 black-owned businesses with a 30% annual growth rate over five years would provide a more practical framework for assessing effectiveness.'
Trade and Industry Minister Parks Tau published the fund's concept document — which envisages raising R20 billion annually for black enterprise development — in March, with a 28 May deadline for comments.
Scrutiny of the draft comes amid tension over the government's
Communications and Digital Technologies Minister Solly Malatsi, a DA cabinet member, recently
President Cyril Ramaphosa has
BLSA acknowledged the importance of redressing the structural economic imbalances created by apartheid, and commended the government for establishing the Transformation Fund, but bemoaned the lack of analysis about why previous state-led initiatives such as the National Empowerment Fund and the Small Business Fund had underperformed.
'The paper does not provide a comprehensive overview of these existing funding mechanisms, nor does it justify why a new R100 billion structure is necessary instead of enhancing existing models,' it said in its submission.
It also expressed concern about institutional inflation, where new entities are created for the same purpose instead of supporting ongoing programmes, adding that access to funding alone would not resolve the systemic challenges and insufficient mentorship capacity had hampered black empowerment initiatives.
'Without targeted investment in mentorship infrastructure even significant financial allocations may fail to yield desired development outcomes,' it said.
Labour union Solidarity and the Free Market Foundation estimate that black empowerment laws have incurred R145 billion to R290 billion in compliance costs since their inception, equivalent to between 2% and 4% of GDP.
A report by the two organisations on the cost of broad-based black economic empowerment says the programme has imposed a substantial economic burden on high-intensity sectors such as mining and finance, attributing low employment numbers to racially motivated policies.
'While B-BBEE may have contributed to an increase in black ownership and supported some skills and SME development, those gains are overshadowed by elite capture, limited grassroots impact and persistent inequality,' the report said.
BLSA said transformation efforts would improve with more private sector participation in the fund's financial disbursement and oversight.
It argued that transformation is already happening in companies' enterprise and supplier development programmes, which have proved to be commercially viable in integrating small businesses.
A joint fund management team between government and the private sector would allow businesses to share and 'codify lessons and best practices for the fund's design', the organisation added.
'We recommend that the Transformation Fund be designed with sufficient flexibility to align with existing industry master plans and accommodate the requirements of the fast-growing priority sectors,' it submitted.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
2 hours ago
- The Herald
Exciting new release from one of the best vintages in recent memory
There's always something new in the world of wine, be it the latest vintage release of a well-known favourite or a new wine from an established winery exploring new territory or different wine styles. Exploring some interesting new releases this week, Delheim Grand Reserve 2021, one of the granddaddies of the Bordeaux-style red blends that SA wine lovers love and our winemakers have proved really good at, is a grand place to start. A new vintage of Delheim Grand Reserve is always something to look forward to, as it is only made in years when the fruit harvested from selected premium vineyards on the Stellenbosch estate's Simonsberg slopes is considered worthy of making a wine of the icon status it has gathered over the past four decades. The recently released 2021 Grand Reserve (±R550) comes from a vintage considered one of the best for Stellenbosch reds in recent memory, and Delheim cellarmaster Roelof Lotriet — who gets to taste through the 'vintage library' regularly — believes this is one of the best renditions they have ever made. Led by cabernet sauvignon (70%), with cab franc, merlot and petit verdot each making their own contribution to the wine's elegantly unfolding layers of flavour and complexity, firm texture and built-to-last structure; the four components are vinified separately and each matured for 18 months in oak before blending. The blend then spends another 18 months in bottle before release, allowing the components to mesh into familiarity. The resulting wine drinks beautifully now, with dark sour cherries and classic cassis, pencil shavings and mintiness woven around fynbos woody-herbal aromas. There's an enticing succulence of chalky tannins and acidity that enlivens the fruit, leaving a mouthwatering 'want more', but also suggesting for collectors that letting this one hang around in your cellar will reap rewards in the next decade or more. Meanwhile, Fairview Altesse 2024 is the first white wine released in the estate's Regional Revival range, which aims to reimagine and put an SA stamp on the classic Old World wines of Italy, Spain and France. In Altesse (R190), they've created a classic Bordeaux-style white blend of sauvignon blanc and sémillon from cool west coast vineyards above Darling, where the influences of altitude and sea breezes meet and 'shape a white blend rooted in tradition, yet alive with a refreshing Cape influence,' Fairview owner Charles Back says. Those influences make for longer, slower ripening, allowing grapes to retain acidity while developing complex aromas and flavours. The maritime theme is captured in a striking blue and silver label, reminiscent of a vintage postage stamp, featuring a lighthouse standing watch over rolling vineyards and ocean waves. The 45% sémillon component is fermented and aged in oak for nine months, bringing complexity and texture to the wine, a fine balance of freshness and richness. The wine is vibrant and zesty — fragrant with citrus blossoms, white peaches, green figs, leading into a mouthful that seamlessly integrates sauvignon's freshness with the light waxy touch and depth of the sémillon. Soft yellow fruit blending with bright lime and citrus, with a lingering saline minerality finish. Made 'for those who appreciate a little adventure in their glass', says Back, this is a journey well worth taking. The Herald
The Herald
2 hours ago
- The Herald
'Floyd was a big problem in the EFF': Mgcini Tshwaku responds to 'cult' claims
EFF member Mgcini Tshwaku has dismissed claims made by former EFF deputy leader Floyd Shivambu that the party is a cult. Shivambu made the remarks during a media briefing on Thursday, saying: 'There are those who said don't rejoin the EFF because it's a cult, and I agree with them.' Shivambu left the EFF last year to join Jacob Zuma's MK Party. In an interview with Newzroom Afrika, Tshwaku defended the EFF. 'I'm not deployed by a cult, I'm in a perfect organisation. I know the EFF is not a cult, it's a democratic organisation and all you have to do in the party is to work and be accountable.' He criticised Shivambu's leadership while he was still in the EFF, saying he was ineffective. 'Floyd was a big problem in the EFF. Many of us are injured because of him.' He said Shivambu would often rely on others to do the groundwork, only to appear and request reports. 'I know Floyd was a lazy person. He says he has criss-crossed the country everywhere, but we used to do the work for him and report to him. We were the ones doing door-to-door work, building structures around the country, and he would just come in, want reports and then disappear. When you told him your issues, such as not having petrol or a place to sleep, he would laugh at you.' Shivambu's exit from the EFF was reportedly due to disagreements with the leadership, particularly regarding coalition talks. Tshwaku labelled Shivambu a 'coward' for not raising his concerns in the party. 'He's a coward. He could've raised whatever he wanted to raise in the EFF.' Shivambu has been making headlines recently after being fired as MK Party secretary-general. While he remains in the party, he announced plans to form a new political party, which he said will be shaped by public consultation. TimesLIVE
eNCA
3 hours ago
- eNCA
Ramaphosa calls for diplomatic resolution
JOHANNESBURG - President Cyril Ramaphosa says the Israel-Iran conflict should be resolved through dialogue. He's concerned about the uncertainty around an increase in global fuel prices. "We want to continue calling on all actors that dialogue, peace-making is the only way in which to solve problems," Ramaphosa said.
