Legacy body 'lacks powers of a public inquiry to examine Sean Brown murder'
The head of a legacy body has conceded it does not have the same array of powers that a public inquiry would to examine the murder of GAA official Sean Brown.
The Irish Government is among those who have backed his family's long campaign for such an investigation.
Earlier this month, the Court of Appeal in Belfast affirmed a previous court ruling, compelling the UK government to hold a public inquiry into his killing.
Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn has appealed the decision to the Supreme Court.
Mr Brown, 61, then chairman of Wolfe Tones GAA Club in the Co Derry town of Bellaghy, was ambushed, kidnapped and murdered by loyalist paramilitaries as he locked the gates of the club in May 1997.
No-one has been convicted of his killing.
Preliminary inquest proceedings last year heard that in excess of 25 people had been linked by intelligence to the murder, including several state agents.
It was also alleged in court that surveillance of a suspect in the murder was temporarily stopped on the evening of the killing, only to resume the following morning.
Mr Brown's widow, Bridie, said that she does not know why her husband was killed and reiterated her call for a public inquiry into his death to answer the questions her family has.
"I don't know why they chose Sean, I just do not know because he was the same with everybody," the 87-year-old said during an interview on BBC's The GAA Social podcast.
"He treated everybody alike, he walked with both sides of the community."
She also paid tribute to the thousands of people who turned out in Bellaghy last Friday to support her family's campaign for a public inquiry.
"It was emotional. Never in my wildest dreams had I thought about so big a turnout," Mrs Brown said.
Last month, Mr Benn said he was taking steps to ensure that the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery (ICRIR) was capable of carrying out an independent and rigorous investigation into Mr Brown's murder.
During an appearance at the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee, ICRIR Chief Commissioner Declan Morgan was pressed by SDLP leader Claire Hanna on the case.
Mr Morgan said that if it came to the ICRIR, investigators would carry out a cold case review, a scoping exercise and would treat the case as a criminal investigation and gather the evidence.
"But I agree that we could not do the next step which is subsequent to that, once the terms of reference have been set, and up to that point, we're definitely Article 2 compliant," he told MPs.
"But the next bit is having identified what the issues are to then organise a hearing with proper representation by lawyers in relation to that, and also understanding that the sensitive information arrangements, in my view, need to be reviewed and the commission needs to be able to exercise proper challenge in relation to those."
Speaking outside the meeting, Ms Hanna said the ICRIR in its current form "cannot fully meet the needs of the family of Sean Brown".
"Today's comments from Sir Declan Morgan are welcome and shine a light on where the ICRIR falls short," Ms Hanna said.
"Any further delay to the resuming and restarting of inquests alongside the continued denial of a public inquiry to the Brown family is the British government delaying truth and justice.
"The SDLP is committed to the delivery of legacy structures that families can buy into. Sir Declan's comments underline our key concerns about deficiencies relating to participation by families in proceedings and the continued existence of a veto on information by the secretary of state".
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
14 hours ago
- Irish Times
Palestine GAA club's planned tour of Ireland ‘under serious threat' due to visa delays
A West Bank GAA club's planned trip to Ireland 'is now under serious threat due to visa delays', representatives have said. At least 33 young Palestinian players are to arrive in Ireland in July to play a series of competitive matches against GAA clubs around the country and to take part in a cultural exchange. GAA Palestine, the organisation behind the tour, said it faced 'new requirements introduced during the [application] process', such as English-language birth certificates for Palestinian players and for coaches born in the West Bank. It further said the Irish embassy in Tel Aviv had closed its public office since Iranian missiles hit the Israeli capital and it was 'not prioritising visa applications ... halting all progress'. READ MORE A total of 46 people, including players, coaches, officials and one doctor, were due to arrive in Dublin on July 18th as part of planned trip by Ramallah-based Moataz Sarsour GAA club. GAA Palestine chairman Stephen Redmond said the new requirements in the visa application process had increased the expected processing time from four weeks to eight after, he said, it was given a 10 week pre-departure time frame to submit all necessary paperwork. It had officially submitted the visa applications on May 19th. Co-founder of GAA Palestine Claire Liddy said 'the embassy responded three weeks later, on Monday, June 9th, with a list of additional required documents'. She said the Irish Representative Office in Ramallah 'refused to accept the original documents' on June 13th. She said as local team members were Palestinian, they were 'banned from travelling to Tel Aviv', so club officials outside the region 'had to scan and send the original documents digitally on Monday, June 16th'. A spokesperson for the Department of Foreign Affairs said: 'The department cannot comment on individual visa applications, but all visa applications are processed in line with established procedures for consideration by the Department of Justice.' The spokesperson said the Irish embassy's public office in Tel Aviv and representative office in Ramallah 'are presently closed due to the security situation and staff are working remotely. The public offices will reopen when circumstances permit'. Mr Redmond criticised what he labelled 'bureaucratic nonsense' and he called 'for common sense to prevail so these young people can step on to a GAA pitch'. He said the group had requested an expedited processing of their application, but that this had not taken place. 'With co-operation from the Department of Foreign Affairs, there is still a chance to issue these visas in time,' he said.
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Vision for a united Ireland cannot be ‘annexation of six more counties', Leo Varadkar says
Mr Varadkar also said he hopes the current Irish Government takes the decision to establish a forum to lead discussions on unity, and also appeared to dismiss concerns of potential loyalist violence in reaction to a united Ireland. Mr Varadkar, who stood down as taoiseach in April last year, said he believes he will see a united Ireland in his lifetime but warned it is not inevitable. He said that he has had no regrets so far since leaving elected politics, and is enjoying both 'a lot of personal and intellectual freedom to say what I think'. He was speaking at an In Conversation event with Rev Karen Sethuraman at St Mary's University college in west Belfast, hosted by Féile an Phobail and Ireland's Future. Former Sinn Féin president and West Belfast MP Gerry Adams was among those in the audience for the event. Mr Varadkar stressed that a united Ireland 'has to be a new Ireland that is better for everyone'. 'That includes a bill of rights, guarantees civil protections and liberties,' he said. 'Unification, in my view, is not the annexation of six more counties by the Republic of Ireland. It's a new state and one that can be better for all of us, an opportunity that only comes around every 100 years, which is to design your state and design your constitution.' In terms of what the current Irish Government is doing, Mr Varadkar described the Shared Island Unit, which was set up when he was taoiseach, as really positive. But he said he would like to see the Irish Government lead a forum ahead of unity. ADVERTISEMENT He said there was the New Ireland Forum in the 1980s, and the Forum for Peace and Reconciliation in the 1990s. 'I think there is a strong case now for us to convene the parties that are interested in talking about this – unions, business groups, civil society – in a forum to have that discussion, but I don't see how that can happen if that isn't led by the Irish Government, and I hope at some point during the course of this five-year government, a decision will be taken to do that,' he said. Meanwhile, asked how he felt potential violent opposition to a united Ireland could be handled, Mr Varadkar suggested he felt 'only a very small minority may turn to violence'. 'I know there are people south of the border who, when I talk to them about reunification, express to me concerns that there might be a very small minority within unionism who may turn to violence,' he said. 'I don't think we should dismiss that as a possibility. I don't think it will happen, to be honest. 'I n two referendums, both north and south, people would be very clearly giving their preference as to what should happen, it would be quite a different situation to when partition happened 100 years ago and it wasn't voted for.' Meanwhile, deputy first minister Emma Little-Pengelly suggested Mr Varadkar was 'wrong in terms of the trajectory' towards a united Ireland, insisting the number of people voting for nationalist parties, around 40pc, 'hasn't moved since 1998'.
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Scotch Broth – Frank McNally on Michael Cusack's frustrated hope for a pan-Celtic sports alliance
Soon after he helped set up the GAA in 1884, Michael Cusack was also involved in a campaign for a pan-Celtic alliance to link the cultural and sporting traditions of Ireland, Scotland, and Wales. One of his confederates in this enterprise was a Dublin-based Scot of socialist leanings, A Morrison-Miller, whose Caledonian Games exhibitions had already been a spark for the GAA. Together, in 1887, he and Cusack founded a newspaper to promote their joint cause: The Celtic Times. Alas, as it is in Ireland, the first item on the agenda in Scottish politics is the split. Thus in May 1887, to Cusack's disgust, Morrison-Miller was expelled from his own Caledonian Games Society by a Presbyterian faction opposed to the Irish outreach programme. Apart from having a stand in Croke Park named after him, Cusack went on to be immortalised by his portrayal as 'the Citizen' in James Joyce's Ulysses. Or at least by the perception that he is the Citizen. READ MORE In fact, like others in the book, the character was a composite of different people. And insofar as Joyce led readers to believe that the bigoted, anti-Semitic Citizen was him alone, Cusack might have had a case for libel had he lived to see Ulysses published. But as Luke Gibbons pointed out to me during the Bloomsday Festival, the same Cusack may also hold the key to one of the continuing mysteries of Joyce's masterpiece: the anonymous postcard with the message, as interpreted by Mrs Breen, wife of the agitated recipient: 'U.P.: Up.' The simplest interpretation is a slang phrase of the time, equivalent to kaput . If a person or thing was 'U.P.: Up', they were finished. Which might indeed be considered offensive, but hardly the basis for the £10,000 libel suit on which Denis Breen is seeking advice. Cusack, meanwhile, offers a different explanation, as Gibbons found out some years ago when tracking down a full set of the original Celtic Times print run. For there, in Cusack's gossip column of 18th June 1887, is the headline: 'U.P. Up'. Underneath it, Cusack reported the 'extraordinary treble-whip meeting' of the CGS that had 'unceremoniously deposed' Morrison-Miller. The piece includes reference to a 'United Presbyterian' faction, punning on their desire to keep up appearances, and ends by declaring: 'The CGS has died a sudden and unprovided for death. R.I.P.' Elsewhere in his newspaper, Cusack detected a part played in the coup by a shadowy organisation called The Irish Times. He suggested it was trying to wrestle control of the CGS in the same way (as he alleged) that the Freeman's Journal had tried to do with the GAA: 'Is the staff of The Irish Times trying to grab the work of Mr Miller's hands, much as the Freeman tried to grab the work of my hands? Answer at once, Mr James Carlyle, manager of The Irish Times. You signed the circular calling the meeting. Read Carleton's 'Rody the Rover,' and you will find that we ought to be very careful to avoid those practices which little by little qualify us to out-Judas Judas.' We don't know if Carlyle took up the suggestion to read William Carleton's novel about double-dealing among Ribbonmen – a militant Catholic movement of the early 19th century. We do know that the same Irish Times manager also was later namechecked in Ulysses, perhaps with mischievous intent. Even as he ponders the 'U.P. Up' mystery, guessing that Alf Bergan or Richie Goulding 'wrote it for a lark in the Scotch House', Leopold Bloom passes The Irish Times, and admiring the success of its small ads operation, credits 'James Carlisle' (sic), the 'cunning old Scotch hunks'. An effect of the internal coup in the CGS was the cancelation of the Caledonian Games planned for 1887 and their replacement by a 'picnic'. According to Cusack, this caused such an outpouring of letters to The Irish Times that the paper could carry only one tenth of them. Among those that made it in was a satirical proposal that the CGS be renamed the 'Scotch Anti-Irish Bun and Lemonade Society'. In his book Joyce's Ghosts: Ireland, Modernism, and Memory (2015), Gibbons suggests a link between the anonymous postcard and the sectarian commercial wars being fought in Dublin in the early years of the 20th century. Those included the setting up of an undercover Catholic Association, to counter Protestant dominance in business. The Denis Breen of Ulysses was a proudly devout Catholic, said to be related to a senior Vatican clergyman. This is a cause for ridicule in Barney Kiernan's pub. When Bloom sympathises with Mrs Breen's plight, the narrator sneers: 'Begob I saw there was trouble coming. And Bloom explaining he meant on account of it being cruel for the wife having to go round after the old stuttering fool. Cruelty to animals so it is to let that bloody povertystricken Breen out on grass…And she with her nose cockahoop after she married him because a cousin of his old fellow's was pew opener to the pope.' If the 'U.P.: Up' postcard was hinting that the pious Breen had secretly joined the United Presbyterians, that might indeed be grounds for a libel case. At the very least, it would explain why his goat was so much – as the expression puts it – up.
