Mathieu Darche has Mat Barzal decision to make — and it could impact Islanders' entire offseason plan

One of Mathieu Darche's most important decisions this summer isn't a decision at all, but a question that could prompt multiple: When the Islanders' general manager pulls up his team's depth chart, is Mat Barzal slotted as a right wing or a centerman?
Surely, no matter what the answer is, Barzal likely will play both positions at various points during the season depending on need.
Advertisement
That's not the point.
The point is that where the Islanders want Barzal playing has a cascading effect on their offseason.
It's the hinge point as to whether they view themselves as having enough depth to trade a center, or need to go get one instead.
If the perfect-world scenario for Darche is to keep Barzal on Bo Horvat's right wing — out of his natural position but a spot where the eye test and advanced numbers alike show both players accessing the best versions of themselves over the past two seasons — then the Islanders find themselves with four bottom-six centers, and needing someone who can play on their second line.
Advertisement
3 Mat Barzal moves the puck during an Islanders' game against the Penguins in December 2024.
Corey Sipkin for the NY Post
Jean-Gabriel Pageau, who stepped into the 2C spot out of need after the Islanders dealt away Brock Nelson at the trade deadline, never looked like a fit there.
Granted, by that point in the season, the Islanders were banged-up and nearly everyone was playing up a line higher than would have been ideal, so you can put a caveat on the data.
Still, Pageau was rolling along pre-trade deadline with a superb 55.76 expected goals percentage, 54.51 corsi for percentage and 56.01 goals for percentage at five-on-five, per Evolving Hockey.
Advertisement
Post-deadline, his numbers fell off a cliff: 50.15 expected goals percentage, 49.83 goals for percentage, 46.29 corsi for percentage.
When you go further down the depth chart, similar issues abound.
Casey Cizikas, Kyle MacLean and Calum Ritchie — assuming the 20-year-old Ritchie starts next season in the NHL and not the AHL — would all be well-suited to center the fourth line.
Advertisement
3 Mathieu Darche addresses reporters during a press conference May 29, 2025.
Corey Sipkin for the NY Post
Cizikas' numbers improved post-deadline last year when he became the 3C, but that had as much to do with finally getting to play down the middle as anything else — needing to play wing for most of the year was a misadventure the Islanders would do well not to repeat
And, whether Barzal is at center or not, at least one of those three would need to be moved out of position as things stand right now.
Cizikas' 2024-25 season shows the risk inherent there.
3 Mat Barzal scores a goal during the Islanders' loss to the Flyers on Jan. 16, 2025.
Robert Sabo for the NY Post
It's true, and a cliché that it's easier to move a center to wing than vice versa.
Still, the Islanders have simultaneous problems here: too many centers and no way of slotting everyone in their ideal positions.
One potential shortcut could be trading Pageau, whose name has biannually popped up in the rumor mill for the past few years.
Advertisement
With one year left on his deal at $5 million and a 16-team no-trade clause, Pageau — who proved last season he still has a lot left in his tank and can help a team immensely in the right role — would have some value if made available.
Darche has seemed reluctant to undergo a huge roster makeover in his first summer in the job, but whether or not dealing a 32-year-old player on an expiring deal who would be a prime candidate to get moved at the trade deadline anyway constitutes a major swing is in the eye of the beholder.
It's a safe guess, however, that the Islanders are not comfortable playing any of Cizikas, Ritchie or MacLean on the second line to start the season.
Advertisement
So if they're moving Pageau, it means there's a level of comfort splitting up Horvat and Barzal to start the season, even with the success they've achieved together.
That, or Darche believes an extra $5 million could buy him someone to solve the problem on July 1.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

New York Post

3 hours ago

• New York Post

Trent Grisham details how he escaped ‘bad place' to become breakout Yankees star

Yankees center fielder Trent Grisham catches up with Steve Serby for some Q&A during a breakout season. Q: Center field is a prestigious position at Yankee Stadium. A: I don't think there's really any position that's not prestigious for the Yankees, but yes, it is. Access the Yankees beat like never before Join Post Sports+ for exciting subscriber-only features, including real-time texting with Greg Joyce about the inside buzz on the Yankees. Try it free Q: How would you describe what it's like being a Yankee? A: I love it because it kind of simplifies everything. Sometimes the big leagues gets a little bit more about everything but baseball. Here it's very simple — it's we're here to win. It's very business mentality, very straight cut, there's no ifs, ands or buts about it, we're here to win every night, and you can either get on that page or you can go somewhere else. Q: What is it like playing on the New York stage? A: It's the pinnacle of sports and media in the world, so there's a lot of pressure, but that's also what makes it a lot of fun. Q: Your baseball dream started at age 3. What do you remember about those early first days? A: (Chuckle) What my mom tells me. First word was 'ball,' and wanted to play T-Ball starting at the age of 3, and really didn't stop wanting to do that any day after that. Q: What drives you? A: I love the game. That drives me. I would say my childhood dream drives me. And obviously, I honestly just want to see what I'm capable of. I've been told since I was young that I had ability and potential and all those other things that people say, but at the end of the day, I want to see where I stand in the league at the end of my career, just to see what I can get out of my capabilities. Q: How would you sum up your major league career to this point? A: Unfinished. Q: What has been the emotional low point for you in the major leagues? A: It had to be probably middle of '23 in San Diego, maybe early to the middle of the season. I just got into a bad place where I was thinking negatively a lot more often than I want to admit, and it just kind of spiraled into a bad place. … Meaning I was playing very fearfully on the field. Was thinking, 'Don't do this, don't do that,' as opposed to just playing the game and having fun, and treating it as a game. Q: Did it turn out to be a valuable lesson for you? Or is it something you battle all the time? A: I wouldn't say I battle it all the time anymore, it was something I had to work out of. It's a very fearful mentality, worry about what was going to happen instead of staying in the present moment, let my ability come out. I would say it's something that I have to constantly work at to stay in the right frame of mind, just because this game is hard. … You're playing against the best players in the world for 180 straight days. 9 Yankees outfielder Trent Grisham reacts after he hits a double during the seventh inning in the Bronx, New York, Thursday, June 19, 2025 JASON SZENES/NY POST Q: What is the importance of sports psychologists for you? A: I've always kind of been in love with the mind, the role it plays in sports, and baseball in particular. And I kind of fell in love with it at a young age — when I was 18 I just kind of saw it as a separator. Physically, I wasn't the biggest guy, I wasn't the fastest guy, was always a good player but I always felt that what set me apart was I just wanted it more, and I was willing to think differently than other people, and I think that that gave me my edge. I kind of took it to the first couple of years of the minor leagues, maybe the first year, year-and-a-half, and then kind of forgot about my love for it. I didn't really pay much mind to it, maybe kind of got involved with more of what everybody else talks about — the swing and what pitchers are trying to do and all the different metrics. But kind of re-fell in love with it, got back to it, reminded myself of how important it was to me. Q: Describe the 2022 National League wild card series at Citi Field while with the Padres — when you went 4-for-8 with two homers over three games. A: I was in a bad place mentally throughout the year. They came to me about a week left in the season, we'd already clinched, so I played the final three days of the season. I got benched in September. I kind of treated it like I did in 2019 and said, I'm just going to go try to free myself up mentally and do what I've always done, as opposed to what mechanical change or anything that I was doing that kind of got me into a bad place. So I just kind of freed myself going into that and ended up having a great three days, played well, had some big hits, some big homers. … It was a lot of fun. CHECK OUT THE LATEST MLB STANDINGS AND YANKEES STATS Q; How did you free yourself up? A: By telling myself I'm going to hit the way that I taught myself how to hit when I was younger as opposed to trying whatever I was trying that year. Q: What do you remember about the Joe Musgrove sticky substance controversy in Game 3? A: I don't really remember much about it other than the ['Hold My Ear'] T-shirts that they had made (laugh). Had something to do with his ear, that was really about it. Q: Then beating the Dodgers in the NLDS? A: Well, we got beat up pretty bad the entire time I was there during the regular season. Then they beat us in '20 in the postseason, so it felt like we were always kind of the Dodgers' little brother in San Diego at the time. To beat them and send them home when it mattered meant a lot to us, and to the city, too. 9 Trent Grisham #2 of the San Diego Padres reacts after hitting a home run against the Los Angeles Dodgers during the fourth inning in game three of the National League Division Series at PETCO Park on October 14, 2022. Getty Images Q: Describe the time you ran headfirst into the outfield wall in your second game in the minors. A: I was going back on a ball, tripped, and instead of kind of going down, I tripped probably a couple of steps before the warning track. … I kind of held myself up, thinking that I could like regain my balance and make the play, but I kind of ran into the wall first. I think I stood up, passed back out, got taken out on a stretcher, ambulance came onto the field and everything. Scared everybody but ended up being just 14 days on the concussion IL and then right back at it. Q: Did you think you might be done as a baseball player? A: The thought crossed my mind, but it turned out it was just a concussion. Q: You said at the time, 'They thought my neck might be broken.' A: The key word 'they' — I didn't think my neck was broken. I thought I was fine. I was trying to stay in the game. Go beyond the box score with the Bombers Sign up for Inside the Yankees by Greg Joyce, exclusively on Sports+. Thank you Enter your email address Please provide a valid email address. By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Enjoy this Post Sports+ exclusive newsletter! Check out more newsletters Q: They strapped you to a stretcher, right? A: I got up and then passed out probably 10 minutes later and don't remember much. This is all from the coaches' and teammates' recollection. I don't remember that 10 minutes. … It wasn't even 10 minutes, it was five minutes that I was petitioning. Q: You were unconscious for how long? A: It was anywhere from 10 to 20 minutes, and then the first thing I remember vaguely is being put on the stretcher and someone over me, like a paramedic over me. Q: Your head was swollen for a long time. A: I couldn't wear a hat for, like, probably a week-and-a-half. Q: How did it feel to be back on the field? A: I was 18, bright-eyed, bushy-tailed, ready to play pro ball. I only got to play one game, so … 9 Yankees outfielder Trent Grisham #12 is greeted by his teammates in the dugout after he scores on his two-run homer. Charles Wenzelberg / New York Post Q: Describe your on-field mentality. A: Try to be as relaxed as possible. Try to play as freed up as I can. And I just try to play aggressively on both sides of the ball. A defensive coach in San Diego once told me he used to tell his infielders he liked them to play offense on defense, like attacking balls, and I always liked that, it kind of resonated with me. Q: What does it take to be a Gold Glove outfielder? A: I think that mentality. You got to love it, you got to want to do it. I remember when I was younger, in the minor leagues, I just didn't want to play outfield defense, it was boring, there's nobody out there. But once I kind of took that mentality later in my minor league career of caring about it and wanting to attack it, it just became a lot more fun for me to get myself in that headspace. Q: Best baseball moment? A: First hit was pretty cool … seventh inning in the Dodgers-Padres, I think it was Game 5 in San Diego for the [Division Series] in '22, that was a lot of fun. That was like the loudest environment that I'd been in. … Getting drafted. … There's a lot of really good ones. Q: Worst baseball moment? A: 2019 wild-card game [Padres against the Nationals]. I made the error to send us home and lose it, so that was pretty tough on me at the time. 9 Yankees outfielder Trent Grisham reacts after a single. Charles Wenzelberg / New York Post Q: How's fatherhood? A: A lot of fun. I've always wanted to be a dad. I always knew that growing up, so for it to come to fruition it's really more taking care of Mama right now than anything. I get to do all the fun stuff like hold the baby, try to make him smile. Q: Ezekiel was born April 21. Does he have your personality yet? A: Yeah. Stone pan face all the time, doesn't smile a lot. Not a lot of facial expressions yet. Q: How's your diaper game? A: Pretty good. They blow out still, but I get them in there nice and tight. 9 Trent Grisham (r) hit a pivotal home run to help the Padres eliminate the Mets. Corey Sipkin for the NY POST Q: Tell me about your wife, Megan. A: She's a sweetheart. Very down-to-earth, really, really good person. Very kind, very caring, very empathetic. … She's just the best. Q: Do you remember where you took her on your first date? A: I don't remember the first date, I remember the first day I asked her to go out with me. We were 13 or 14, and we were at one of our friend's pools. I was kind of scared my other three buddies that were at the party would make fun of me, so I kind of snuck around a tree and asked her to go out with me. I wanted it to be private with us. Q: Where did you take her? A: The first one I really remember was taking her to Saltgrass Steakhouse. Q: Tell me about your mother, Michelle. A: One of the toughest women I know … loyal … caring … she basically raised me and my brother kind of alone with a little help. She's awesome. Q: She drove your truck across the country? A: (Laugh) Yeah, she heard about how expensive it was to ship my truck, and she said, 'There's no point in doing that. I want to come see Opening Day anyway. I'll just come out every spring and drive it to wherever you go.' She drove it from Arizona spring training to Appleton, Wis. 9 Trent Grisham hits a two-run homer for the Yankees. JASON SZENES/NY POST Q: Did you know your father growing up? A: Yeah, I knew him growing up. He just wasn't around much. Q: Did that bother you? A: I'm sure it bothers any kid, yeah. You want to know your dad, and I didn't really know him. Q: Does your wife remind you of your mother? A: Not really. My wife is sweet-natured, my mom is more direct, more hard-nosed, more straightforward. Q: Explain her reaction when she found out you wanted to change your last name from Clark to Grisham. A: She was … honored, I think is kind of the best way to describe it. She was very emotional and excited. Q: Three dinner guests? A: Stan Musial, Jackie Robinson, Larry Doby. Q: Why Musial? A: Kind of my favorite player. Obviously an unbelievable great player, played for over 20 years. But when you read anything about him or hear anything about him, no one could say anything bad about the man, the way he lived his life, the kind of person he was, the man he was off the field. Q: Why Doby? A: Because Larry Doby went through the same thing that Jackie went through right around the same time, and was going to a lot more southern cities, so it wasn't getting much press. Which means you can probably assume that it was probably worse for him. 9 Yankees outfielder Trent Grisham (12) catches a hit by Texas Rangers’ Sam Haggerty (0) in the fifth inning at Yankee Stadium, Wednesday, May 21, 2025. Corey Sipkin for the NY POST Q: Favorite movie? A: 'About Time.' Me and my wife watched it for the first time together and we both loved it. Q: Favorite singer/entertainer? A: Hudson Westbrook. Q: Favorite meal? A: Since being in New York, it's 4 Charles' burger. Q: How did you get in to that place? A: Through a guy on the team, helped us out. 9 Trent Grisham celebrates a win. Getty Images Q: Favorite golfer? A: Scottie Scheffler. Q: Favorite golf course? A: Peachtree in Atlanta. Q: What's your handicap? A: Right now, it's a six. Q: Favorite Dallas Cowboy? A: Dak [Prescott]. Q: How about growing up? A: Jason Witten. Q: Favorite New York City things? A: Central Park. I love walking around Central Park. Q: Whatever comes to mind: Aaron Judge. A: Captain, every sense of the word. Q: When you watch him in the batter's box, what sticks out to you? A: He's bigger than everybody. … There's so many things trying to distract him, pulling him away from baseball, and he's able to lock in every night, and that's really fun to watch. 9 Trent Grisham homers for the Yankees. JASON SZENES/NY POST Q: Max Fried. A: Very businesslike, I'd say like very Yankee-like kind of without being a Yankee before. Q: Devin Williams. A: Quiet, goes about his business, kind of loud, emphatic on the mound, but quiet off the mound. Q: Is this a World Series team? A: Yes. Q: Why? A: Because we're really good.

Yahoo

19 hours ago

• Yahoo

Red Wings Could Be Circling Islanders' Noah Dobson in Trade Talks

New York Islanders exploring options for defenceman Noah Dobson with Detroit being a potential destination Image The Red Wings head into the offseason looking to upgrade several areas of their lineup, with help on the blueline high on their list as a deep pool of talent is available in this year's free agent market. Advertisement Luckily for Detroit, another big name looks like they will be joining the picture as Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman explained on his podcast 32 Thoughts that the New York Islanders are testing the market on restricted free agent Noah Dobson. The 25-year-old Summerside native has stood out in recent seasons, peaking with 10 goals and 60 assists for 70 points just a year ago. However, he experienced a significant drop this past season, posting only 39 points, his lowest total in four years. A change of scenery may be the right move for the former 12th overall pick back in 2018, and the Islanders could command a strong return in a trade. More NHL: Should Detroit Go All-In For Canucks' Brock Boeser? That said, time is a factor as if the team waits too long, rival clubs could present offer sheets for Dobson, potentially reducing the return to draft pick compensation based on the value of the contract offered. New York is currently testing the market for the young defenceman to see what more they can get besides draft picks and this could open the door for Detroit to make a move. Advertisement The Islanders were middle of the pack defensively last season but their offence looks to be the team's biggest problem as they finished bottom five in goals per game. The Red Wings have plenty of players that would be able to slide into a middle-six role for the Islanders as well as a very deep prospect pool and draft capital with four first-round picks over the next three seasons. A potential trade package featuring forward J.T. Compher, typically a 30-50 point producer, along with 24-year-old NHL-ready prospect Jonatan Berggren and additional draft picks, should be enough to land the Red Wings a defenceman for the future. More Red Wings: Red Wings' Potential Buyout Targets Ahead of Key Offseason Window

New York Post

20 hours ago

• New York Post

Yankees navigating a different Luke Weaver-Devin Williams closer call after early demotion debacle

Access the Yankees beat like never before Join Post Sports+ for exciting subscriber-only features, including real-time texting with Greg Joyce about the inside buzz on the Yankees. Try it free Luke Weaver is healthy, and Devin Williams is pitching as well as he has since becoming a Yankee. Now it's up to the team to determine how to best use the right-handed relievers at the back end of their bullpen, and Aaron Boone said Friday he planned to use both, although he highlighted Weaver's versatility. Advertisement Weaver returned from the IL on Friday after being sidelined for nearly three weeks with a left hamstring strain, and Boone said Weaver and Williams would each be asked to close games. But the manager added Weaver would be asked to pitch more than one inning at times, as well as occasionally in a 'fireman' role earlier in the game, if need be. 3 Luke Weaver throws a pitch during the Yankees' May 22 game. Robert Sabo for the NY Post 3 Devin Williams throws a pitch during the Yankees' June 19 game. Jason Szenes for the NY Post Advertisement The Yankees liked Weaver in that role when he emerged in The Bronx last season before Clay Holmes' difficulties in the closer role forced them to put Weaver there, where he excelled. Again in the early part of this season, when Williams faltered badly after arriving in a trade from Milwaukee in the offseason, Weaver was shifted back to the closer role. Williams began to pitch better setting up Weaver and also has thrived of late closing in Weaver's absence. Advertisement Boone said Williams' improvement began when he still was in a setup role and he would be unafraid to use either in any spot. 'On nights when both are available and we're in the eighth inning in a save situation, then I'll probably match it up with who we think they line up best [against] coming up,' Boone said. And he's confident Williams will pitch well whenever asked. Advertisement When it was noted Williams has performed well as the closer, entering Friday having allowed six baserunners in his previous six outings covering 5 ²/₃ innings, Boone responded that Williams' rebound goes back longer than that. His fastball/changeup pitch mix has worked better since early May, and Williams has excelled over a 17-outing stretch. 3 Austin Wells (l.) and Devin Williams (r.) react after the Yankees' June 19 win. Charles Wenzelberg 'This has been over a month now of some excellence,' Boone said. '[Williams] is gonna close a lot of games. That's the reality.' He added: 'We want to put him and [Weaver] and the rest of the guys in the best situations possible. There will be those given nights where we'll probably use [Williams] in the eighth.' CHECK OUT THE LATEST MLB STANDINGS AND YANKEES STATS Still, Williams hasn't been as dominant as Weaver, who entered Friday having given up just three earned runs in 25 ²/₃ innings, with a minuscule WHIP of 0.701. Advertisement Whichever direction Boone and the Yankees go for now might not last the rest of the way, as was proven in 2024. 'Last year was very unknown,' Weaver said of his first season with the Yankees, when he began as a multi-inning reliever, graduated to a high-leverage role, then ended up closing the final month of the regular season and throughout the playoffs. The acquisition of Williams pushed Weaver back to a setup role, but he's proven to be adaptable to just about anything the Yankees ask him to do.