Letters, May 20
Opinion
Re: Carberry residents not convinced of province's highway safety plan (May 16)
This delay of improved safety at the intersection of Hwy. 5 and the Trans-Canada Highway is atrocious! The tragic accident took place almost two years ago and we still have ditherers arguing how to improve the site. It's all well and good that Premier Wab Kinew wants to hear from residents, but I suspect most have no apparent traffic design qualifications under their belts.
This is not rocket science! Does the highways department have no road design engineers, nor any external consultants, who have actually driven outside of North America and recognized the safety and efficiency of roundabouts as used all over the globe? As Ms. Steen mentioned in the article, with the RCUT design, there will be still be a need to have vehicles queuing to make a U-turn involving crossing the route of other vehicles. Bonkers, I say.
As an internationally experienced driver, I do know that because of the geometry of a roundabout, drivers are forced to slow down (unless they're asleep or impaired) plus any unfortunate collisions tend to be slower speed glancing blows rather than high speed t-bones.
Just build a 100- to 200-metre diameter roundabout with correctly angled approach and exit lanes that large vehicles can safely navigate without fear of crossing traffic or causing anything more than a glancing blow in an altercation. We have ample space in Manitoba to accommodate them. Manitobans deserve no less.
Bob Sales
Winnipeg
It is not only Winnipeggers who are in for a property tax shock. Many homeowners throughout Manitoba are similarly affected and will see huge increases in property and education taxes.
It is indeed caused by current NDP policy that affects both assessments, education tax levy and education tax credits.
The NDP has removed spending cap for school divisions, they have also fixed the Manitoba School Tax Rebate at $1,500 instead of a percentage calculation, and have skewed property tax assessments by some odd market value calculation for 2025. I cannot determine if the property tax credit advance of $350 is still in place, but for the moment I will assume it has not changed. The municipality has done its job in holding the budget and calculating the required mil rate.
For my rural subdivision, with no property improvements and no municipal improvements, the assessment has gone up 29 per cent, municipal taxes have gone up 13 per cent, and the Manitoba school tax has gone up a whopping 50 per cent for an overall increase of 25 per cent which equates to about a $1,000 on 35-year-old properties.
Note that because there were no changes to the property and the assessment increase was solely due to 'market value,' there was no ability to appeal. Further, the assessment was done six months prior to the establishment of the mil rates for property and education tax, so the impact of the assessment increase was totally unknown until now when the municipality established the mil rates.
This is tough to deal with and is exacerbated by a 30 per cent increase in home insurance, a 10 per cent increase in auto insurance, and an ever-escalating increase in electricity, gas and water utilities.
Never mind how hard it is to afford a first home, it is equally hard to afford the one you are currently living in.
Something needs to change, and the current provincial government is at the root these unfair increases. They broke it, they have to fix it. Maybe read the 1994 Norrie Report on schools for starters.
Gerry Shuster
Selkirk
Re: 'International example' (Letters, May 16)
Kudos to the writer who praised Finland's success in eliminating homelessness. It's refreshing — and frustrating — to see this kind of admiration expressed, once again, in a letter to the editor. Why does it always stop there? When are we going to wake up?
Scandinavian countries continue to offer Canada clear, proven alternatives: comprehensive health care that includes vision, dental, and hearing; high-quality elder care; tuition-free post-secondary education; and a robust network of social supports that foster both security and opportunity. These aren't Utopian fantasies — they are functioning, successful systems.
Yes, critics will point to high tax rates. But let's be honest: the return on that public investment is staggering. In exchange, citizens enjoy stability, equity, and peace of mind — something far too many Canadians now lack. The benefits of a well-funded, well-planned public sector are simply too great to ignore.
It's time for Canadian governments — federal, provincial, and municipal — to actively pursue closer ties with our Nordic counterparts. Learn from them. Adapt their ideas. Build a better, fairer future.
There is much to gain, and even more to lose by staying the course.
Robert Milan
Victoria, B.C.
Re: Treating heart failure to help heal health system (Think Tank, May 13)
The article written by Dr. Shelley Zieroth, I swear, was written for me.
Unfortunately, I am a Manitoban living with heart failure. I have recently been diagnosed with heart failure. My initial journey, with a concern that something was wrong with my heart, began in February at my family physician's office.
My wonderful doctor put me on heart medication and started the ball rolling with referrals for cardiac testing and a referral to a cardiologist. Unfortunately, a few days later, my wife called 911 as I knew I was in trouble.
Firefighters and paramedics arrived and took me to St. Boniface Hospital's emergency department on Feb. 22, as I was in AFIB and atrial flutter. I described this as 28 hours of hell. I was discharged the same way I came in, with the exception of a referral to a cardiologist. Countless calls and visits to the family physician adjusted my medications to keep me afloat until I could be seen by a cardiologist.
On March 5, I collapsed, and my wife called 911. I refused to go to St. Boniface because of my previous experience; I said I'd rather die at home. On March 6, I collapsed again, and my wife called 911.
They took me to Concordia Urgent Care, where I was stabilized and kept for three days. A consult was made with internal medicine and a cardiologist while I was in the hospital. I was discharged from Urgent Care with no mention of getting a Holter monitor or an echocardiogram, which are essential for properly diagnosing heart failure and the ejection fraction of my heart.
Finally, on March 12, I visited the Asper Institute to meet with a nurse practitioner. I asked for a Holter monitor, only to be told, 'We know you are in AFIB.'
Finally, on April 12, I was seen by a cardiologist who ordered an echocardiogram and Holter monitoring. A month passed between my visit with the nurse practitioner and the time I was seen by the cardiologist for diagnostic testing. No echocardiograms or Holter monitoring were done by two hospitals or the Asper Institute. Ironically, I was sent to the Asper Institute for 24-hour Holter monitoring. A miscommunication regarding when to start a blood thinner and antiarrhythmic again delayed my treatment.
Finally, on April 22, my body had enough, and I was taken back to St. Boniface emergency, where treatment was given, and I spent a week in the hospital. I will say the care was excellent.
Thousands of dollars' worth of diagnostic testing was done on me, with the exception of the initial essential echocardiogram and Holter Monitoring.
On May 9, I received a referral to MyCardia for a Treadmill Stress Test on July 17, with a followup on Sept. 3; clearly, I cancelled this appointment.
So, I am pleading with Premier Wab Kinew and Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara to listen very carefully to what Dr. Zieroth is telling our government about establishing a provincewide cardiac hub.
Bill Worthington
Winnipeg
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Toronto Sun
20 hours ago
- Toronto Sun
Letters to the Editor, June 21, 2025
Saturday letters Photo by Illustration / Toronto Sun STILL IN BUSINESS This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS ONLY Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. SUBSCRIBE TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. Enjoy additional articles per month. Get email updates from your favourite authors. THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments Enjoy additional articles per month Get email updates from your favourite authors Don't have an account? Create Account Re Editorial cartoon, May 30: Provinces where the NDP is in power or official opposition: B.C., Manitoba, Alberta, Saskatchewan, N.S. and Ontario. Hardly obsolete! Roger Middlemiss Mississauga (Federally the NDP is pretty much obsolete) CANNOT FIX ANYTHING Re 'Tories urge Grits to pull plug on gas engine ban' (Bryan Passifiume, June 18): I received an email recently that says it all. 'We can't fight homelessness, hunger or poverty but we are going to fight 'climate change.'' Just let that sink in for a moment. Karen Shorter (The Liberals warped priorities will do absolutely nothing to address any of these issues) BAIL REFORM Doug Ford rants and raves about the bail system but he should understand that the system is a shared responsibility between the federal and provincial governments. He would be smart, therefore, to ask Prime Minister Mark Carney for support for bail reform. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. Frank Cain North York (It's exactly what Ford needs to do) SPEED AND SAFETY Re 'Speed camera knocked down again' (May 24): If the intention (vociferously denied by Toronto City Hall) of the speed camera on Parkside Drive is to raise revenue, then hire security personnel to be stationed near the camera to monitor, record and report any vandalism of the speed camera. If such personnel were to be paid $40/hour for an average of 10 hours/day (for the dark hours of the day) 365 days a year, that would be an expense of about $438,000 for three years. This would reduce the three-year revenue (as reported for the three-year period April 2022 to April 2025 as $7,253,102) to about $6,815,000 — however, that would be increased for fines levied when the camera would not be down. However, if the often-cited objective of safety is the real objective, relatively high speed bumps about every 100 metres apart would do a much better job. Paul Maginn Toronto (They claim it's for safety, but it's not. Sipped cameras have always been a cash cow) Toronto & GTA World Columnists Toronto & GTA Toronto Blue Jays
Winnipeg Free Press
a day ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Manitoba experiencing growth spurt and we're a long way from ready
Opinion You may have missed it, but Manitoba quietly hit a milestone recently. According to Statistics Canada, the province's population surpassed 1.5 million people earlier this year. Not that anyone noticed. No ribbon cuttings. No speeches at the legislature. Not even a government news release. Manitoba's population hit 1,507,330 on Jan. 1. By April 1, the province tacked on another 3,307 people. From April 1, 2024 to April 1, 2025, Manitoba's population grew by 21,375 people, or 1.44 per cent. It's the fifth-largest growth rate since 1973, according to the Manitoba Bureau of Statistics. Manitoba even attracted more people from other provinces than it lost in the first quarter of 2025 — the first time that's happened since 2004. But hitting 1.5 million isn't just about bragging rights or demographic trivia. It's a turning point. Because growing by tens of thousands of people every year comes with consequences. And the big question is: are we ready for it? Right now, the answer is no. Let's start with the most obvious problem: housing. Ask anyone under 40 trying to buy a home in Winnipeg or Brandon, or a newcomer looking for rental space, and they'll tell you the housing crunch is real. Rents are up, vacancy rates are low, and home prices are climbing faster than incomes. Premier Wab Kinew's government has promised to build more affordable housing, and there are some encouraging signs. But the pace of construction still lags behind demand. Immigration — the biggest driver of our population growth — is outpacing our ability to house people affordably. And while high immigration helps the labour market and tax base, it also increases pressure on housing stock, especially in Winnipeg where most new arrivals settle. Then there's health care. We already have one of the worst physician shortages in the country. Emergency room overcrowding is the worst it's been in recent history and wait times for orthopedic, cataract and other surgeries continue to grow. More people means more demand for primary care, diagnostics and surgeries — services health authorities are already struggling to deliver. Until the province finds a way to recruit and retain more doctors, nurses and health professionals, Manitoba's growing population will only deepen those cracks. Education is another area where population growth is stretching capacity. Portable classrooms are becoming permanent fixtures and school divisions are scrambling to find land and funding for new schools. In rural Manitoba, growth in places such as Niverville and Winkler means schools are filling up fast. At the same time, First Nations communities still face persistent underfunding and infrastructure deficits. Government is playing catch-up in too many places at once. Then there's justice and public safety. Adult inmate counts in Manitoba increased by more than 12 per cent in 2022-23. Worse, incarceration rates have outpaced population growth for the past decade. As Manitoba's population grows, so too does the strain on the justice system. Policing resources in Winnipeg and other urban centres are also stretched thin, particularly in dealing with mental-health crises, addiction-related crime, and public safety in the downtown core. The root causes — poverty, trauma, homelessness — aren't going away. If anything, they're intensifying. Meanwhile, the Winnipeg police complement is smaller today than it was a decade ago. Manitoba's population boom is also putting new demands on infrastructure — roads, water and transit. Brandon, Portage la Prairie and Steinbach are growing fast, but they're still waiting on key infrastructure upgrades. Even in Winnipeg, the pace of investment in things such as rapid transit or road renewal hasn't kept up with the population curve. That doesn't mean population growth is a bad thing. Far from it. Growth brings opportunity — more economic activity, more innovation, a bigger tax base. It's a sign that people want to come here and build a future. But growth without planning is a recipe for disaster. It's not enough to simply welcome people in — we need to make sure the infrastructure and services are there to support them. And that requires forward-thinking policy, not just reactionary measures. It also means the province can't just rely on Ottawa to fix everything. While federal immigration targets drive much of the population growth, it's provincial governments — and by extension, municipalities — that have to deliver the services. Ottawa doesn't build your local ER or pave your street. The NDP government has talked a lot about restoring public services. That's admirable. But restoring what we had in the past won't be enough. Manitoba has to plan for what's coming: a province that will likely hit 1.6 million people within a few short years. What's needed is a comprehensive provincial growth strategy — not just immigration plans or housing announcements in isolation, but a co-ordinated vision for where Manitoba is headed and how we get there. That means aligning immigration targets with housing starts, investing in training for health professionals and tradespeople, and rethinking how we deliver education and justice in a rapidly changing province. Reaching 1.5 million is a milestone. But it's not a finish line. It's the start of a new chapter in Manitoba's history. And whether that chapter is a story of prosperity or strain depends entirely on how our leaders respond now. The numbers are clear. The question is whether the vision will follow. Tom BrodbeckColumnist Tom Brodbeck is a columnist with the Free Press and has over 30 years experience in print media. He joined the Free Press in 2019. Born and raised in Montreal, Tom graduated from the University of Manitoba in 1993 with a Bachelor of Arts degree in economics and commerce. Read more about Tom. Tom provides commentary and analysis on political and related issues at the municipal, provincial and federal level. His columns are built on research and coverage of local events. The Free Press's editing team reviews Tom's columns before they are posted online or published in print – part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
It doesn't have to be politics as usual
Opinion It usually takes a while for a new administration to slide into political gamesmanship. At first, it's all hearts and flowers and fair play — such as Prime Minister Mark Carney's pledge to call a byelection as quickly as possible to let Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre try to win his way back into Parliament. The byelection in question hasn't been called yet, primarily because there are rules and timelines that have to be followed for a newly elected Conservative to resign to create a space for a byelection. Battle River-Crowfoot MP Damien Kurek officially resigned on Tuesday. Kurek had to wait 30 days after his election was posted in the Canada Gazette before he could resign, the Speaker of the House of Commons has to inform Elections Canada of the vacancy and the earliest a byelection call could come is 11 days after that. JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESs fileS Premier Wab Kinew The Governor General sets the byelection day chosen by Carney, who can pick a date as far as 180 days after Kurek's resignation. If Carney lives up to his word, Poilievre can quickly either be back in Parliament after a win, or leave the Opposition leader's official Ottawa residence and no longer be the Stornoway stowaway. But byelections don't always move that quickly — and a case in point is happening here in Manitoba. Back in late March, Progressive Conservative MLA Grant Jackson resigned his Spruce Woods seat to run in the federal election under the Conservative banner. Ever since then, his seat has sat vacant — meaning that, for 88 days now, his former constituents haven't had a representative in the Legislature. That's a point that's been made directly to Premier Wab Kinew in a letter from PC Leader Obby Khan: 'Summer is an important time in rural constituencies full of fairs, festivals and events and whomever should be elected to represent Spruce Woods deserves this opportunity to engage with their constituents,' Khan wrote. Likewise, constituents deserve the opportunity to make their concerns known to their elected representative. There's not much drama involved with a byelection in Spruce Woods. It's a reliably PC seat — since its creation in 2011, it has always elected Progressive Conservatives — and the governing NDP is comfortably in a majority position and doesn't have to pull out all the stops to try to win there. Kinew has moved more quickly on two other byelections — to fill the seats left vacant by the resignation of former PC premier Heather Stefanson and the death of NDP cabinet member Nello Altomare. Both of those seats — Tuxedo and Transcona and were seen as likely to elect NDP candidates and both did. And that brings the political gamesmanship back into play. Wednesdays Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture. Kinew could choose to delay the Spruce Woods byelection until as late as Sept. 24 — and it's entirely within his purview to do exactly that. But just because you can do something, doesn't always mean that you should. The only real questions are who benefits by delaying the byelection, and who loses out? If, in any way, it's voters who are losing out, the answer is a simple one. Set a byelection date as quickly as possible and leave the political strategy by the wayside. A significant portion of the public already believes that politicians don't have their best interests at heart and petty politics just strengthens the impression that politicians put their parties and their own futures ahead of the public good. Why fuel voter apathy and mistrust — especially in the case of Spruce Woods, where the prospective gains seem so small — when there's a chance to take the high road instead?
