Paris Saint-Germain 0 Botafogo 1 – Are Europe's struggles good for the Club World Cup?
Europe's teams lost twice in one day at the Club World Cup as Botafogo shocked Champions League winners Paris Saint-Germain to take control of group B.
The Copa Libertadores holders took a first-half lead when Marlon Freitas released Igor Jesus who got the better of PSG centre-backs Willian Pacho and Lucas Beraldo before getting a shot away that deflected off Pacho and past Gianluigi Donnarumma.
Advertisement
Early in the second half, Botafogo goalkeeper John blocked a close-range header from Goncalo Ramos and Luis Enrique sent on Joao Neves, Bradley Barcola, Nuno Mendes and Fabian Ruiz as the start of a series of substitutions to try and equalise but the John Textor-owned team from Brazil held on to beat his rival Nasser Al-Khelaifi's Qatar-backed PSG.
Botafogo's win at a raucous Rose Bowl in Pasadena leaves them three points clear at the top of group B with four of the eight pools now led by teams from South America.
Here The Athletic's Jack Lang, Jordan Campbell and Austin Green analyse the game's key talking points.
For the first six days of the tournament it did not happen, but then two European teams lost in the space of eight hours.
It is a healthy development for the competition as there were fears the gulf between Europe and the other continents would be so pronounced that the group stage was uncompetitive.
Inter Miami beating Porto was the first real dent in the idea of Europe invincibility but Botafogo beating the reigning UEFA Champions League holders PSG was the sort of upset that can change the entire dynamics of a tournament.
The Brazilian side defended resolutely and were able to regularly counter on the French champions.
European sides have found it difficult to cope with the speed of PSG's moves but Botafogo matched them physically for most of the game.
South American teams have now won five, drawn three and lost none of their games against opposition from other continents.
The conditions may be more natural to some of the South American sides, who are also mid-season, but the European sides are finding that this is not the walkover they may have been expecting.
Jordan Campbell
Pacho and Beraldo seemed to have the situation well under control. Botafogo had nicked the ball in midfield but the PSG centre backs were well placed. There was a gap between them, but it was tiny, no more than three metres. No one was going to get through that.
Then along came Igor Jesus.
The Botafogo striker is not one of those subtle strikers. He doesn't paint pictures with his feet. He can look ungainly, a little imprecise. Tell him to run onto something, though, and he'll do it all day, then come back the morning after and ask for more.
He saw the gap, laughed at it, barrelled into it like a wild horse. The pass came from Jefferson Savarino, as he knew it would. From there, it was just about maintaining the momentum. A second and a couple of touches later, the ball was in the net and Igor Jesus was in the crowd, being smothered in hugs.
It's been a funny 12 months for the 24-year-old. Not so long ago, he was leading the line for the Brazil national team, the main individual beneficiary of Botafogo's all-conquering 2024 season. He has found the going much harder since the turn of the year. It was, in truth, a slight surprise when Nottingham Forest agreed to make a Premier League player of him in June.
Advertisement
Here, though, he showed his true potential. This may be his goodbye tour, but there is still a chance for him to make a few more memories in black and white yet.
Jack Lang
For PSG's first match of this tournament against a non-European side, Luis Enrique opted to sit several of his usual first-choice starters.
Gonçalo Ramos started at centre-forward for the injured Ousmane Dembelet. Senny Mayulu and Warren Zaire-Emery flanked Vitinha in the midfield. Lucas Hernandez and Beraldo started on the back line over Mendes and Marquinhos.
The results were mixed. PSG dominated possession but struggled to finish chances. They largely went away from Khvicha Kvaratskhelia after the winger created two superb opportunities for himself in the opening 15 minutes. Ramos was a non-factor and missed a chance at a tap-in goal because he failed to make a run at a Desire Doue cross into the box in the first half. Beraldo and Pacho had their moments in central defence but were also responsible for giving up Igor Jesus' goal.
It didn't take long after half-time — and another superb Botafogo chance on the counter — for Luis Enrique to determine he had seen enough. In came Barcola, Ruiz, Neves and Mendes in the 55th minute.
The result was a livelier, more balanced PSG attack and one that negated Botafogo's counterattacking threat. But it was too little, too late. It's not just that PSG didn't find an equalizer, they barely had a quality chance until late in the second half. Credit Botafogo for superb positioning as the Brazilian side's back line grew more comfortable as the game went on.
But given those early chances and PSG's early-scoring prowess throughout their run through the Champions League, it's hard not to second-guess Enrique's decision to sit so many first-choice players and not press for an early goal to then allow for some earlier-than-usual substitutions on the back end.
Austin Green
Monday, June 23: Seattle Sounders, Club World Cup group stage (Seattle), 3pm ET, 8pm UK
Monday, June 23: Atletico Madrid, Club World Cup group stage (Pasadena), 3pm ET, 8pm UK
You can sign up to DAZN to watch every FIFA Club World Cup game free.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
9 minutes ago
- Forbes
FC Barcelona Dream Still Chased By Premier League Ace Despite Williams
A Premier League star is still determined to fulfil his dream and play for FC Barcelona despite its increased interest in Nico Williams according to Mundo Deportivo, which cited anonymous sources. After Barca paid the former Espanyol goalkeeper Joan Garcia's €25 million release clause, and announced his capture on Wednesday, Barca has moved on to trying to land the Euro 2024 winner Williams, who is also a close friend of Lamine Yamal. Doing so will require the triggering of another release clause, though this one is a lot more expensive at €58 million and won't be as straightforward for a club still recovering from a financial crisis that pushed it to the brink of oblivion earlier this decade to raise. In the meantime, while Nico has reportedly agreed to join Barca, Marcus Rashford is still pushing for transfer from Manchester United to Catalonia according to Mundo Deportivo. Before interest was sparked in Williams again, he was believed to be Barca's top target for the left wing alongside Luis Diaz. With Rashford rated at around €40 million, he would be the cheapest of these forwards while Diaz is the most expensive at something close to €85 million. Rashford and his corner don't believe that signing Williams will be an obstacle that puts the kibosh on the England international's Camp Nou dream. His input on the pitch isn't only limited to the left wing, as, unlike Williams, he can play all three positions across the front line while providing a good alternative to the aging Robert Lewandowski. The Pole is entering the last year of his contract signed when joining from Bayern Munich in the 'economic levers' summer of 2022, and Barca as of yet has no natural heir for him other than winger Ferran Torres or Dani Olmo playing as a false 9. The newspaper also writes that Rashford is willing to lower his salary demands, while United would want a reduced fee of €30 million. Even at a cut fee for Rashford, FC Barcelona might struggle to afford both him and Williams. Across those two potential deals, we're talking about more than $100 million in cash, which is still a push for Barca despite its improved financial health under President Joan Laporta.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Football transfer rumours: Liverpool move for Guéhi? Rashford to Newcastle?
Marcus Rashford's future is very much in the 'up in the air' category. The chances of him ever playing for Manchester United look slim-to-none as he will not be given a boarding pass for the club's US tour, while a dream move to Barcelona is going up in smoke. A few Serie A clubs have had a sniff but his wages might be a stumbling block. What he really needs is a Champions League club with plenty of cash. Step in … Newcastle. The Magpies are back in the bigger time next season, will be eager to make a statement signing or two, and Rashford fits the bill. Liam Delap chose Chelsea over Newcastle and Eddie Howe likes to have the best English talent at his disposal, so Rashford would be an ideal candidate as an extra attacking option. It takes a brave man to move from Liverpool to Everton (and vice versa). Nick Barmby, Abel Xavier and Gary Ablett did the Merseyside double in their time and the next potential candidate is Ben Doak. The Scottish teenager impressed on loan in the Championship last season at Middlesbrough and is ready to step up to the Premier League but there is no obvious role he can play under Arne Slot. It means Doak might need to find an alternative and at least this one means he will not have to move house. Advertisement Related: Men's transfer window summer 2025: all deals from Europe's top five leagues Another potential Liverpool exitee is Jarell Quansah. He is currently playing for England at the European Under-21 Championships but that is not stopping talking going on in the background with Bayer Leverkusen over a summer move. The Germans are not short of cash having sold Jeremie Frimpong and – imminently – Florian Wirtz to Anfield. Said cash splashing is not coming to an end for Slot, who also wants Crystal Palace skipper Marc Guéhi to bolster his centre-back options. A year ago the defender was subject to bids from Newcastle but £65m was deemed insufficient and the Eagles are unlikely to have dropped their price. Burnley are seeking some extra quality now they are back in the promised land. One potential incoming is the Lazio winger Loum Tchaouna who could head from Rome to Turf Moor in a deal worth in the vicinity of £12m. Advertisement Igor Thiago has endured a difficult time at Brentford through a mixture of injury and the form of Bryan Mbeumo and Yoane Wissa. Despite the fact at least one those forwards will depart this summer, the Brazilian could also be allowed to leave with Besiktas contemplating a move for the former Club Brugge man. Speaking of those who could swap London for Istanbul, José Mourinho is eager to bring Thomas Partey to Fenerbahce for absolutely nothing. The midfielder's contract is days away from expiring and the club and player have failed to agree a new one, leaving him free to leave. Napoli are eager to add to Kevin De Bruyne in midfield and are targeting Brighton's Matt O'Riley. The Danish international has been the subject of a £26m bid from the Italian champions.
New York Times
an hour ago
- New York Times
Manchester City have been busy this summer, but still aren't favoured for any trophies next season
The 2024/25 campaign offered a rare sight from Pep Guardiola — a sign that his teams are not bulletproof. Not in the slightest. After winning four Premier League titles on the trot, City went from looking immortal to looking like imposters as they went through a turbulent period of 11 games without a win and plummeted down the table. Advertisement They did manage to recover mid-way through the campaign and added signings like Omar Marmoush and Nico Gonzalez as they rallied to secure a third-placed finish — despite fears they could miss out on Champions League football altogether. It was only the second trophyless season of Guardiola's managerial career and now it's up to the Spaniard to build up City's fear factor again, starting with the Club World Cup. The Sky Blues are currently 5/1 with Betfair to win the tournament. City can lay down a real marker in the United States by showing the rest of the world they mean business — and they're already on the way to doing just that with a comfortable 2-0 win over Wydad. The game saw Phil Foden impress with a goal and assist after having a difficult last campaign. Two of their new signings started the game — midfielders Rayan Cherki and Tijjani Reijnders. Cherki scored 12 and assisted 20 times for Lyon last season and is seen as the long-term successor to the outgoing Kevin De Bruyne. He could be the difference for City this season. With Cherki pulling the strings and providing for forwards like Erling Haaland, Marmoush and Savinho, City have a great chance of toppling champions Liverpool this time around. Meanwhile, Reijnders joined for £43million from AC Milan and Guardiola admitted he was happy with how both players looked on the pitch after the game — but it was the return of Ballon d'Or winner Rodri that really boosted them. 'Of course, Rodri will be important,' the coach said after the game. 'We have to adjust to many things, but step by step.' Rodri managed to play half an hour and suddenly a huge hole from last season has been filled. With his presence in midfield alongside the likes of Reijnders, Gonzalez and Mateo Kovacic, City can really dominate games again and play the way the manager wants them to. Another problem that has been solved is at left-back. Guardiola started last season without many recognised options in the position and was forced to play youngster Nico O'Reilly there at times. Now they have Wolves star Rayan Ait-Nouri to call upon, providing more solidity at the back — though he did not feature against Wydad. Advertisement So all of a sudden, you start to think City could become a global force again. They've got a superb midfield — with Rodri at the heart of it — and an attacking frontline that any team in world football would love to have. Perhaps only more defensive reinforcements are necessary. With no recognisable right-back present and Kyle Walker on his way out, a new man in that role would complete the set. Of course, going toe-to-toe with Liverpool will be a challenge, given that Arne Slot's side are set to sign Bayer Leverkusen playmaker Florian Wirtz — who is rated as one of the best players in the game right now — for an English record fee of £116.5m. The Reds have also added Jeremie Frimpong and fellow full-back Milos Kerkez is about to join from Bournemouth. With Chelsea still looking like a work in progress under Enzo Maresca and Arsenal lacking the star forward they need to challenge for the title, you can't look beyond Liverpool and City as the favourites for the Premier League title. Betfair have Liverpool as 15/8 favourites to retain their crown, but City's position as the nearest challengers is reflected with odds of 9/4, making them second favourites ahead of Arsenal (5/2). As for the Champions League, City look like outsiders to become champions again, with odds of 8/1. Liverpool are the favourites to become champions of Europe for the first time since 2019 at 11/2, with Real Madrid (13/2) and Arsenal (7/1) the next best-backed teams. Reigning champions PSG are also at 7/1, with City the fifth-favourites. Betting/odds links in this article are provided by partners of The Athletic. Restrictions may apply. The Athletic maintains full editorial independence. Partners have no control over or input into the reporting or editing process and do not review stories before publication. (Photo of Tijjani Reijnders: David Ramos / Getty Images)
