Letters to the Editor: GAA has lost the hearts and minds of the country
For two years now I have been saying the GAA's 'split season' is an absolute disaster and to tell the truth, I've often felt like I was wasting my time and energy, so I'm glad that at least one former Inter County manager has come around to my way of thinking.
Let me repeat again, the split season has been an unmitigated disaster for the GAA.
But let's examine the reasons why the split season was introduced in the first place.
Undoubtedly, ordinary GAA Club players weren't getting fair play under the old system, where the Inter County Championships ran from May until September. A club championship game was fixed, then the County team were involved on a draw and replay, and the Club game went off.
This happened repeatedly — first rounds of Club championships were often played in May and it could be September before the next game.
Certainly there was no certainty for the Club players who make up around 92% of all hurlers and footballers — they couldn't plan holidays, weddings, honeymoons or other social occasions.
There was a major problem and as a Club Officer for decades, I am well aware of what pertained. The so-called solution — the Utopia, the panacea — the much-lauded split season has solved one problem but caused many others far more serious than the old postponement of fixtures.
Has the GAA ever commissioned a cost-benefit analysis of the split season? Maybe secretly, but I never heard of it anyway. I don't simply mean cost-benefit in terms of finance, but in terms of developing our games and promotion.
Our promotion in the GAA is woeful. Take the Munster Final next week. After great games in the early round, we now play our top game at 6 o'clock of a Saturday evening — have we a curtain raiser? Have we a band? Have we a price hike for tickets?
The club championships in every county are the 'bread and butter', the lifeblood of the GAA in every parish. Our Inter County games then should be our shop window, our Champions League, our premiership, something to attract youngsters to Gaelic Games and foster a love of our native pastimes.
Here we are at the end of May and over 60% of all our Inter County Hurling teams are 'wrapped up' for 2025. Promotion — how are ya!
Fair play to one of the Munster rugby bosses who lately commented on the 'promotional value' to rugby of big games in Croke Park and Páirc Uí Chaoimh.
Fair play to the GAA, we truly are sportingly ecumenical, but it isn't it time we saw after our own?
Losing the absolute grasp we had on the minds and hearts of the country every September has been an unmitigated disaster.
Is the GAA too proud to admit 'We made a mistake' and admit the same in regards the decoupling of minor and senior inter-county games.
Ad nauseam I have proposed a dual 'side-by-side' Club and Inter County games programme running from April until September — like the song says 'When will they ever learn?'
John Arnold, Bartlemy, Co Cork
Time to honour our Defence Forces heroes
Commandant (retired) Ray Cawley once again draws attention (Letters, Irish Examiner) to continuing 'failure' of various Irish governments to ensure the heroic actions of the members of the Irish Defence Forces and the brilliant leadership displayed in the defence of Jadotville are properly acknowledged.
Cmdt Cawley, in my opinion, correctly criticises our Government, senior civil servants, and military hierarchy for their continuing failure in this regard.
I can confirm that during my time with the United Nations peacekeeping operations, I met several civilian and military personnel who were in the Congo at the time of the siege of Jadotville. All spoke in glowing terms of the performance of Irish military personnel.
Several military officers from various nations confirmed to me that the defence of Jadotville is used in their training academies as an example of outstanding defensive actions.
Yet successive Irish governments in the past 60 years have failed to properly recognise the actions of those brave men.
Shame on them all, government ministers and ministers for defence — beginning with Micheál Martin, former minister for defence, and Simon Harris, current minister for defence.
Recently, Fergus Finlay wrote: 'Our leaders are running a 'do-nothing' parliament and it's offensive.' Any wonder that Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael between them could not form a government after the last general election?
The people of Ireland deserve better. Over to you, Micheál and Simon.
Michael Moriarty, Rochestown, Cork
Trump deserves praise for keeping cool head
The editorial on May 27 adopted a rather belligerent attitude towards US president Donald Trump for, apparently, not plunging Europe, including Ireland, into a devastating world war since his return to the presidential office in the US.
Looked at a little more objectively, it would appear that Mr Trump is behaving in a somewhat restrained manner for the sake of the American people, and for all our sakes, by not allowing himself to be dragged or pushed by belligerent people into a world war scenario.
The Irish Examiner's editorial attack on Mr Trump is quite personal.
The extract reads 'Trump's narcissistic streak' and 'Trump needs to up his game'.
Instead of such negative personalised comments, the Irish Examiner should be thanking Mr Trump, profusely, for keeping a cool head — and avoiding, so far, a major world war — unlike certain other European leaders.
In the Financial Times, in an editorial under the heading 'Europe needs smart rearmament', on May 15, Ursula von der Leyen, European Commission president, is quoted as follows: 'If Europe wants to avoid war, Europe must get ready for war.'
I think this is ill-conceived advice from the European Commission president — it is myopic; it ignores the underlying causes of the two horrific wars in Europe in the last century, namely the First World War and Second World War.
Is this lady readying the scene for another world war? For instance, regarding the Second World War, the construction by France in the 1930s of the heavily fortified and armed Maginot Line along its border with Germany didn't avoid that war.
It would appear that Ms Von der Leyen, along with others in Europe and elsewhere, are unaware of the dire recent warnings by an eminent US organisation, the Science and Security Board, of the imminent nuclear threat facing the people of Europe, including Ireland.
For instance, since the beginning of the year, the Doomsday Clock (Albert Einstein et al) has moved closer than it has ever been to predicting a major global disaster — the clock now stands at 89 seconds to midnight.
The Doomsday Clock's Science and Security Board Bulletin of Atomic Scientists warned on January 28, 2025, with regard, for example, to the increasing possibility of nuclear war, that: 'The war in Ukraine, now in its third year, looms over the world; the conflict could become nuclear at any moment because of a rash decision or through accident or miscalculation.'
Micheál O'Cathail, Dún Laoghaire, Co Dublin
We must stand up for victims of Gaza now
In the years to come, a global generation of young people will confront their parents with simple questions: What did you do to oppose the catastrophic genocide of innocent civilians in Gaza? What did you do to resist the deliberately induced Israeli famine in Gaza?
If that question is met with a variation of, 'What could we do? We were only observers/bystanders with no direct ability to challenge the slaughter,' it will be treated with the same contemptuous response that consumed the first generation of post-Second World War German children in the 1960s, when they demanded of their parents, 'What did you know or not do about the persecution of Jews that culminated in the Holocaust?
The overwhelming response to that question was a variation of personal innocence, ignorance, and/or helplessness. This led to the scathing term 'mitläufer', a label depicting an individual, who through a lack of courage, didn't confront the obvious evilness of the evolving Holocaust.
What's your view on this issue?
You can tell us here
We witness in real time on a daily basis the mass starvation and daily bombardment of 2m defenceless Palestinians. Will our children and grandchildren in the years to come not also challenge us with a simple question: What did you demand of your government?
The very least we should be able to answer is that we demanded of our TDs an immediate implementation of the occupied territories bill — a piece of legislation which is a totally inadequate resort to the incremental displacement of Palestinians in the West Bank.
Yet consecutive Irish governments have found multiple excuses to not apply even this deficient response.
If we do not mobilise as a national collective to demand/force our representatives to act on Israeli genocide, we too will have to bare the guilt of the morally outraged yet, at the same time, otherwise engaged citizen.
Kevin McCarthy, Clonfadda, Killaloe, Clare
Cruel impact of Catholic Church's negative labels
The Irish Catholic Catechism of 2014 states homosexual acts are 'intrinsically disordered' and 'contrary to the natural law'.
Sadly, this teaching can unfairly put gay people off having any gay friendships, and it can also prevent normal friendships forming between gay people and straight people.
In turn, Catholic straight people also get to hear false biology teaching from their own Church — a false type of lesson that is easily apt to mischievously get under their skin and make Catholic straight people feel uncomfortable to be in social settings with gay people.
This can cruelly be the case, I feel, no matter how talented and nice gay people may strive to appear to be.
The Catholic Church often says gay people should be loved by everyone else in society.
But this will, I fear, never fully make up for the harm such an offensive and divisive term as 'unnatural' can cause this significant minority.
Many acts committed against the law of our land are not considered unnatural and so may soon enough be forgiven and forgotten.
But, I believe, unfortunately, when some people are labelled as being unnatural, then this negative label may unhappily never leave them at all.
Seán O'Brien, Carnanes South, Kilrush, Co Clare
Read More
Irish Examiner view: Trump tariff plan in disarray just as his biggest cheerleader exits
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
27 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Joe Brolly pinpoints what ‘happiness is' from a GAA fan's perspective – though some argue he's totally wrong
JOE Brolly surmised "Happiness Shane Walsh play football" on Sunday - though not everyone was in agreement. Clearly Brolly was bowled over by the Galway talisman's display as they 3 Brolly loves watching the Kilmacud Crokes forward in full flight 3 He scored a brilliant goal from play to set the Tribe on their way 3 Not all of those 29 replies shared Brolly's sentiment though Credit: @JoeBrolly1993 The mercurial ace wound up with 1-7 though Those contrasting views from two men who clearly know what they're talking about sums up how Walsh splits opinion that like few other players across Gaelic football. He can pull off a majestic strike like Among the more glass half-empty replies, Donal asked: "Do you not think he's underachieved considering his talent?" Read More On GAA While another more gruff follower added: "Is it aye? Shut the f*** up Joe." Finally another sceptic posted: "Not really. But overall, a few of the Down players are making this an interesting fixture." Against that, there were plenty of others who hailed the 32-year-old for playing through a shoulder injury that saw him subbed off late on. One person (loudly) pondered: "How does Shane Walsh not get MAN OF THE MATCH for Galway against Down scoring 1-7 for Galway with shoulder injury Shane Walsh was SUPERMAN IN NEWRY today." Most read in GAA Football While Jonathan simply chimed in with: "Some baller isn't he." Walsh won't have long to rest that shoulder as Padraic Joyce's charges will be back out this weekend as they take on Meath in the All-Ireland quarter-finals. Tomas O'Se calls out GAA's mid-season rule change but fellow Sunday Game pundit disagrees All four match-ups will be played out at Croke Park across June 28/29 with the CCCC to confirm throw-in times later today. The various bumps and bruises sustained by the second/third seeds who came through the preliminary quarter-finals should mean the rested panels of Meath, Monaghan, Armagh and Tyrone automatically have an edge.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
After years of illuminating the championship, Limerick couldn't find the light switch against Dublin
In the build-up to the Munster final John Kiely gave a group interview to GAA reporters that lasted about 40 minutes. In answer to a wide range of questions, Kiely was thoughtful and expansive, with one pointed exception. He was asked about last year's All-Ireland semi-final defeat to Cork and suggestions at the time that this Limerick team had reached some kind of end. 'Maybe that narrative was out there,' he said. 'I think that narrative has been debunked now.' It seemed like he wanted to say something else on the subject, but he checked himself and stopped. In the entire interview it was the only short answer he gave. In his post-match interview on Saturday Kiely wasn't asked that question. All over the country, people had made up their own minds. Dublin had just produced a staggering performance to cause probably the greatest shock of the last 50 years, but Limerick's performance was indistinguishable from the outcome and the story. READ MORE In the modern game, where the ball is managed with digital precision, nobody expects an elite team to lose against 14 players. During their years of dominance Limerick were masters at making it seem like they had an extra man. By meticulous design, they created overloads and pockets of space, and the ball always moved along expected lines. One of their greatest powers was to make other teams chase with their tongues hanging out. On Saturday, they couldn't inflict that torment on 14 Dublin players. After Limerick lost a league semi-final to Kilkenny at Páirc Uí Chaoimh 15 months ago, Kiely said it was their worst performance since his first season as manager. Everything in the league, though, is biodegradable. What Limerick produced on Saturday was their weakest performance in a consequential match since they were beaten in the qualifiers by Kilkenny in 2017; on that evening they hit just 17 scores and committed 17 wides. Paul Kinnerk's work with the team, though, still hadn't reached the launch phase. On Saturday, there were no mitigating circumstances. Limerick manager John Kiely during the quarter-final against Dublin. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho For Limerick this was a systems failure. In his post-match press conference Kiely kept referring to the difficulty they experienced on their own puck-out, especially in the first half. For one puck-out Nickie Quaid gestured urgently with his hands, begging for movement in the landing zone. Eventually he spread his arms wide in exasperation. When have you ever seen that? Quaid is the epitome of cool detachment. Making connections between the goalie and the puck-out receiver has been one of Limerick's superpowers. Quaid and Cian Lynch are their creative pulse. In the first half Limerick won just 15 of their 24 puck-outs, even though they had an extra man for 20 minutes. By the end of the game their return on long puck-outs was 11 out of 21. Dublin's aggression on Limerick's restarts was a massive source of energy. One of the other metrics that Limerick swear by is having more shots than the opposition. On Saturday Dublin had 39 shots from play and Limerick had just 35. In the Munster final, in normal time, Cork had eight more shots from play. When Cork beat them in the round-robin last season, it was the first time that any team had more shots than Limerick since 2017. Their overall shooting efficiency in the Munster final was 59 per cent; against Dublin it was 58 per cent. When the numbers fall as they did on Saturday, Limerick know they're in trouble; for half a dozen seasons, this was exactly how they caused trouble for all-comers. The only variable was their efficiency; the bombardment came as standard. On Saturday, it didn't materialise. How Limerick reacted to not winning the five-in-row was always going to be one of the compelling storylines of the summer. When they eviscerated Cork in their second-last game in the Munster round-robin, the wondering stopped. They simplified the group think for everyone. It was clear that Limerick made a conscious stab at renewal. During the close season there was more boardroom turnover in the Limerick set-up than at any other time during Kiely's eight years in charge. Limerick's Nickie Quaid and Adam English after Saturday's game. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho They appointed a new strength and conditioning coach, a new performance coach, a new goalkeeping coach and a new nutritionist. Their lead analyst Seán O'Donnell had a team of three; they all stepped away and needed to be replaced. Kiely also came back with two new coach/selectors and a different captain. On the field, they used 36 different players in the league, which was more than any of the other Munster counties, and one more than Galway, a team in the early stages of a massive rebuild. For the first round of the championship against Tipperary, Limerick fielded five players who had not started in the All-Ireland semi-final against Cork last July. This was exactly how Kilkenny had responded to not winning the five-in-a-row: they swapped out a third of their starting team for the following year's championship. In Limerick's case, though, they couldn't sustain it. Barry Murphy and Colin Coughlan returned to the bench and were surprisingly joined by Shane O'Brien for the Munster final. O'Brien fell so far out of favour that he wasn't named in their original 26 for last weekend's game. Of the players who made a big impression in the league, only Adam English held his form and kept his place; he was sensational. Among their vastly experienced players, Declan Hannon, Darragh O'Donovan and Séamus Flanagan couldn't break back into the team. William O'Donoghue was taken off on Saturday, just as he had been against Waterford and in the Munster final. Peter Casey recovered from a serious, long-term injury but was only used as an impact player. Diarmaid Byrnes was in-and-out of form; so was Seán Finn. For years, their brilliance had illuminated the championship. There might only be a couple of retirements, or there might be none, but the process of renewal will be accelerated now. One of the recurring themes in the post-match reaction over the weekend was that Limerick had been 'great champions'. Nobody would have meant to be patronising but this is the second year they have been exposed to that guff, and you can imagine how it will grate on them. The team that won five All-Irelands in six years, though, perished in Croke Park on Saturday. The next Limerick team to win the All-Ireland won't be the same.
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
'The Damien Duff era at Shelbourne FC has ended - today's a new chapter' Shels defiant despite bombshell
Shelbourne insist there's no hard feelings with Damien Duff over his shock exit and they will continue to thrive in his absence. Irish football was rocked on Sunday when – as first revealed by the Irish Examiner – the Ireland legend informed his players at training of his intention to immediately quit. A degree of tension had arisen following his cutting remarks about a lack of preparation and motivation in the aftermath of Friday's 1-0 defeat to Derry City but to the extent a parting was anticipated. The champions might be 15 points off leaders Shamrock Rovers but are within touching distance of a top-four slot to guarantee a third year of European qualification. Champions League football will be returning to Tolka Park for the first time in 18 years on Wednesday fortnight when Island rivals Linfield visit, but Duff wasn't waiting around. His three-and-a-half year spell will be fondly remembered for it provided as much to him as a first-time boss as it did in revving the fortunes of a club that had descended into yo-yo status since the heady noughties days led by Ollie Byrne and Pat Fenlon. Tolka may look the same but the organisation is a world apart. Read More Watch: Trailer for Saipan film has dropped and they might just have pulled it off with Roy Keane Mickey O'Rourke and the Doyle brothers, Cathal and Neil, hold the majority shares, with the latter brother intrinsically involved in the day-to-day operations of an outfit they began investing in 14 months ago. Former All-Ireland GAA winner Mossy Quinn recently joined as chief executive. Stressing everybody at their club 'did their best' to keep Duff as chief, Doyle assured the Reds fanbase that the objective is to continue strengthening the club. He was adamant the development created 'no recriminations, no hard feelings', describing it 'just a parting of the ways for great friends at the end of a journey'. It remains to be seen if the caretaker spells of Duff's assistant Joey O'Brien, flanked by other staff members David McAllister and Paul Skinner, will continue beyond this week for their Champions League debut. One win over two legs against the Irish League champions would treble the guaranteed €1m of prize-money, going a long way to replenishing the trading losses of the club over the past three years. Shels, sixth in the table, have trips to Waterford on Monday and Galway United on Friday (both 7.45pm). 'Yesterday was a tough day, I'm sure every one of you felt the same,' began the statement directed to the club's fans who revelled in last year's unlikely title triumph. 'The Damien Duff era at Shelbourne FC has come to an end. 'It is a great privilege we hold to represent you as we navigate through a day like yesterday. I knew in every word I spoke, to Damien, to the players, to the staff you were all right there with me. 'I have no doubts in saying to you, everybody from staff to players did their best yesterday – I have no regrets.' Doyle referenced the naysayers predicting the regression of a club synonymous with the league's leading light. 'Every single comment I see about us being reliant on one man, how we're nothing without a single individual and tolling the death knell of Shelbourne FC will spur us all on to greater things,' he said. 'Our foundations are stronger than they've ever been and we will continue to strengthen this amazing club. 'Regardless of how you're feeling about Damien's departure, we need you now more than ever. 'Your support is not just for those that take to the pitch, or the staff in the dugout. 'It is for the generations of people to come behind us who will hear of the great triumphs we are yet to have. How we overcame adversity, how we got behind our club and how we proved everybody wrong. Again. 'From the first to the last-minute let's show the rest of the League of Ireland, and the world, what it means to be a Shels supporter. I will be right there with you. 'Today is the beginning of a new chapter.'
