Report calls for minimum income guarantee pilot in Scotland

A minimum income guarantee could be piloted in Scotland following next year's Holyrood elections.The policy would establish an income level below which nobody is allowed to fall, via reform to social security, work and services.A new report for the Scottish government said the guarantee would help provide a dignified quality of life, deliver financial security, and unlock opportunities for everyone in the country.The group of charities, campaigners and academics also recommended doubling the Scottish child payment to £55 per week by 2031 while also effectively ending sanctions in the welfare system.
An interim minimum income payment could be established by 2036, in line with the relative poverty level, according to the group - commissioned by ministers and chaired by Russell Gunson from the Robertson Trust grant-maker. Social justice secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville said the Scottish government would consider the group's report and respond in due course.
Some of the group's welfare changes would cost £671m per year by 2030/31, in today's prices.However the group said these would require just over £300m of additional spending if the UK government scraps the two-child limit and ends the five-week wait for universal credit.The Scottish Conservatives described the policy as "bizarre and unaffordable" due to the costs.But Mr Gunson said the guarantee could be transformative if it was implemented. He added: "Given the levels of poverty and inequality we see, we must act urgently."With technological change and an ageing population, we need to build security for all to make sure we can take the economic opportunities in front of Scotland."A minimum income guarantee could future-proof Scotland."He stated that the first step in the report were affordable with immediate effect.
Conservative finance spokesman Craig Hoy said the proposal would see Scottish workers saddling the cost.He said: "The SNP have made no serious attempt to rein in wasteful public spending and a soaring welfare bill. "Now this report shows that a minimum income guarantee would cost billions - when Scottish taxpayers are already footing the bill for spending that is simply unsustainable and unaffordable."Shirley-Anne Somerville said the Scottish government were already trying to take action in a number of areas highlighted by the group's report, citing plans to end the universal credit two-child limit next year. However she added there would be no change to tax policy to help finance any guarantee. She stated: "The Scottish government is of course committed to ensuring that finances remain on a sustainable trajectory."We will continue to take forward our programme of work for doing this, which will be updated in the next Medium-Term Financial Strategy to be published later this month, alongside our fiscal sustainability delivery plan."We have no plans to change tax policy in Scotland to finance a minimum income guarantee."

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Scottish Sun

24 minutes ago

• Scottish Sun

Thousands of Scots struggling to save for first home secretly barred from government's help to buy scheme

Dawn Ramsay, a Dundee-based mortgage broker, said the rule change was a 'kick in the teeth' for first time buyers 'kick in the teeth' Thousands of Scots struggling to save for first home secretly barred from government's help to buy scheme Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) MOST first-time buyers have been quietly banned from an SNP government scheme to help people get on the housing ladder. The Open Market Shared Equity scheme allows people to pay for as little as 60 per cent of a sale price, with the state buying the rest. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 1 Most first-time buyers have been quietly banned from the SNP help to buy scheme Credit: Alamy It had mostly been used by first-time buyers on lower incomes. But now first-time buyers have been locked out of the scheme unless they fit into a 'priority' group such as social renters or people with disabilities. Data obtained by the BBC shows that the majority of the scheme's past users did not belong to any of the priority groups. Dawn Ramsay, a Dundee-based mortgage broker, said the rule change was a 'kick in the teeth' for first time buyers. She said: 'It pushes the house price up because there could be five or six people looking at a property, and some of them may well have financial backing where they can pay over the asking price for that property. 'It's not a level playing field. These are the people that will keep our housing market moving.' And Scottish Tory shadow housing secretary Meghan Gallacher said: 'This is typical of the sleekit SNP. No wonder they didn't people knowing they had quietly ditched this flagship scheme during a housing emergency that has spiralled on their watch. 'SNP ministers appear hellbent on turning their noses up at those with aspirations of getting on the property ladder with short-sighted decisions like this.' Last year, 182 out of 210 successful OMSE purchases were made by first-time buyers with just six per cent in the priority groups. The scheme does not allow househunters to bid over the asking price so low-income buyers are frequently outbid by those that can afford to pay over the odds for property, particularly investors. Homeowners blast 'tone-deaf' plan by billionaire to build massive resort & rename town as they insist it'll 'destroy' it The scheme opened in 2007 and was mostly used by low-income first-time buyers seeking a way out of private lets or family homes. The Scottish Government declared a national housing emergency in May last year pledging to increase housing supply and tackle homelessness, with more than four in 10 Scots struggling to meet housing costs. A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'Supporting social renters to make the transition to affordable home ownership will help free up social rented accommodation, which in turn could help families move out of temporary accommodation.'

Telegraph

24 minutes ago

• Telegraph

Starmer defended protester who sabotaged military aircraft

Sir Keir Starmer defended a protester who sabotaged US bombers when he was a human rights barrister. Details of the case emerged hours after pro- Palestinian activists allegedly damaged military aircraft at RAF Brize Norton in Oxfordshire. Footage posted online by Palestine Action on Friday morning showed two people inside the air base, with one riding an electric scooter up to an Airbus Voyager air-to-air refuelling tanker and appearing to spray paint into its jet engine. It has now emerged that the Prime Minister represented a defendant in a similar case in 2003. A group of anti-war protesters had broken into RAF Fairford in Gloucestershire to sabotage US bombers before they flew to Iraq. Sir Keir argued that while the actions were against the law, they were justified because they were trying to stop the planes from committing war crimes. Josh Richards, who was represented by Sir Keir, was cleared after a jury failed to reach a verdict. The revelation was first made by the Politico email newsletter. Tory leader Kemi Badenoch tweeted: 'Worth noting that Keir Starmer defended an activist who broke into an RAF base to set fire to aircraft. Starmer claimed his client was legally justified because it might stop a war crime. 'If he'd won that argument in 2004, what happened at Brize Norton would be perfectly legal.' Downing Street declined to comment, except to point out the 'cab rank' rule - under which barristers have no choice but to take the next case in the queue. There were six trials into the 'Fairford Five' who broke into the airbase in the build-up to the invasion of Iraq. Two were found guilty of causing criminal damage to American vehicles at the base. Two others were acquitted, while Mr Richards - defended by Sir Keir - was cleared after two juries failed to reach a verdict. On Friday morning, Sir Keir described the 'act of vandalism' by Palestine Action as 'disgraceful'. 'The act of vandalism committed at RAF Brize Norton is disgraceful,' he said. 'Our Armed Forces represent the very best of Britain and put their lives on the line for us every day. 'It is our responsibility to support those who defend us.'

BBC News

27 minutes ago

• BBC News

Librarians set to be removed from every Glasgow secondary school

Librarians will be removed from all of Glasgow's 30 secondary schools next year if council budget cuts are plans would see the school service headed up by a principal librarian along with three area-based assistant would then be placed in each of the city's high Life, which manages the service on behalf of Glasgow City Council, says it would take 16 librarians out of the school system. In February 2024, the council approved a review of the school library service, with a target saving of £100, Life and the council's education department concluded the greatest savings could be made through changes to staffing they insist their plans would increase access to school libraries citywide by 27% by raising the number of hours when facilities have some form of staffing.A Glasgow Life spokesperson said: "Additionally, the funding available to provide school library books and other resources going forward will remain above the Scottish average."The plans have now been communicated to staff and trade unions, with consultations expected to spokesperson added: "Glasgow Life is bound by Glasgow City Council's commitment to no compulsory redundancies."Should the proposal be approved, affected staff will have the opportunity to apply for promoted positions or be redeployed into available vacant roles commensurate with their existing pay and grade."