What became of M'sia's proposed social work law?
LETTER | The social work agenda is integral to the Asean agenda as it addresses critical social issues such as poverty alleviation, community development, and social inclusion.
By promoting social welfare and protection, Asean aims to enhance the quality of life for its citizens and foster regional stability. This agenda falls under the Asean Socio-Cultural Community (ASCC), which focuses on cooperation in education, health, and social welfare.
The ASCC aims to promote sustainable development and inclusive growth, ensuring that all members benefit from regional integration.
Several Asean countries, such as Singapore, Thailand, the Philippines, Indonesia, and Vietnam, have successfully implemented legislation related to social work.
They have made significant strides in formalising social work as a recognised profession, enhancing the quality of services provided to their communities.
Historical background
What happened to the enactment of the Social Work Act in Malaysia? The long-awaited Act, which has been pending in Parliament since 2010, remains unpassed, hindering the professionalisation of social work in Malaysia.
Historically, Malaysia has pioneered the establishment of social services for underprivileged populations within Asean, beginning during the British colonial period.
We acknowledge the foundational infrastructure laid by Britain, which has significantly contributed to our social services today.
In the 1950s, Malaysia recognised the need for trained social workers when the National University of Singapore (then Universiti Malaya) could not meet our training needs.
A collaboration between the Women, Family and Community Development Ministry, Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM), and the government saw the launch of the first formal social work training in 1975 at USM after the NUS was unable to accommodate trainees in social work from Malaysia.
Since then, seven other universities and several colleges have provided trained, qualified social workers.
Can't get hired
Despite training thousands of social workers since 1975, many trained social workers were unable to secure employment in their field.
The Public Service Department's criteria for becoming a social worker were not specifically tailored to those who were trained in social work, but were open to others from other disciplines.
Many trained professionals pursue alternative careers, often in education.
While Malaysia is committed to becoming the leading nation in Asean for addressing biopsychosocial issues, we fail to employ qualified social workers.
The roles of social workers within the Social Welfare Department have become increasingly indistinguishable, with many untrained individuals filling positions meant for qualified social workers.
Lacking proper training
USM and seven other universities have been producing professionally trained social workers. However, only 20 percent of social workers possess formal training, leading to gaps in knowledge and practice.
This situation is exacerbated when individuals leading social welfare departments and other related fields lack appropriate qualifications.
Medical social workers, governed by the Health and Education Ministries, face similar challenges. Many are hired from unrelated fields, leading to a lack of credibility within healthcare teams.
The perception of social work has diminished, resulting in an unnecessary reliance on counsellors for tasks traditionally performed by social workers.
Medical social workers in Malaysia are trained under a common curriculum developed by USM, which adheres to the International Association of Schools of Social Work (IASSW) standards.
It is unclear why there is a push for a separate association for medical social work when they receive the same training as their peers.
Legislative delay factors
It appears that the legislative delays for the Social Work Act in Malaysia, compared to other Asean countries, can be attributed to several factors.
The legislative process in Malaysia is slow, involving multiple layers of approval and extensive consultations. Differences in opinions among stakeholders, government agencies, and NGOs toward social issues hinder the law's progress.
Limited financial and human resources dedicated to social work also slow down the development and implementation of the Act. There is insufficient public awareness and advocacy for social work issues, leading to lower priority on the legislative agenda.
Cultural attitudes towards social work and welfare over the years have impacted the momentum for legislative changes, with varying levels of acceptance and understanding of the profession.
Malaysia appears to prioritise other legislative or economic issues, pushing social work legislation on the back burner.
The Women, Family and Community Development Ministry - which is working on the Act - the higher education minister along with relevant ministries that require trained social workers and the Malaysian Association of Social Workers must collaborate to push for the Act for the betterment of the quality of social services in Malaysia.
The social work agenda for Malaysia falls under the ASCC, has been discussed many times, and we have yet to see the positive results.
The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Barnama
12 hours ago
- Barnama
Original Structure Of Kota Melaka Fortress Unearthed At Taman Larangan
MELAKA, June 18 (Bernama) -- The legendary Kota Melayu Melaka, long celebrated in historical accounts and Malay-Nusantara chronicles as a grand and formidable Malay fort city, has once again come to light following the discovery of the original alignment of the Bastion Hendrica Louisa wall at Bukit Melaka. Registered archaeologist from the Department of National Heritage, Drs Mohd Nasruddin Rahman, said the discovery was made during an excavation at the base of the Taman Larangan stairs, located in front of the Melaka Sultanate Palace in Banda Hilir. The uncovered structure is believed to be part of the original fort, which was later buried beneath new fortifications built by the Portuguese and later upgraded by the Dutch and British during the colonial period. 'This discovery is significant as it confirms the existence of the original Melaka Fort and helps trace the early layout of its walls. The remains include part of the Bastion Hendrica Louisa, which once served as a key southern defence point against attacks from both land and sea. 'Interestingly, the fort was also protected by a moat surrounding the outer wall, estimated to be about five metres wide and deep,' he told Bernama. The excavation, carried out from May 22 to 30, also revealed structural features consistent with bastion designs found in 18th-century Dutch maps. Drs Mohd Nasruddin stressed the importance of protecting the site from being lost to modern development, especially in the Banda Hilir area. He called for strong cooperation from the state government, the Melaka Museum Corporation (Perzim), the Department of National Heritage (JWN), and local authorities. 'This effort aligns with the vision of Chief Minister Datuk Seri Ab Rauf Yusoh, who is committed to ensuring that Melaka's historical legacy is properly documented, preserved, and shared with the public to highlight the glory of the Melaka Sultanate before colonisation,' he said. He also recommended further archaeological work to fully uncover the oval-shaped bastion wall and suggested partially reconstructing a section of the fort wall, similar to what was done at Middlesbrough Bastion.
The Star
5 days ago
- The Star
Sacred book survives plane crash
Compiled by JUNAID IBRAHIM, C. ARUNO and R. ARAVINTHAN A COPY of the Bhagavad Gita, which was found almost intact among the wreckage of the Air India plane crash, has become a talking point among Indian netizens. Videos of one of the rescue workers finding the Hindu holy scriptures with minimal damage on its cover went viral online, Makkal Osai reported. The discovery was even reported on TV. Some people called it a 'miracle' that the book was found in good condition although the entire plane went up in flames. Last Thursday, Air India Flight AI171, which was bound for London, crashed shortly after take-off in the Indian state of Gujarat. There was only one survivor among the 242 people onboard – a 40-year-old British man. Apparently, there has been a constant stream of people trying to access or get near the crash area to take selfies of the air disaster. This has led to many netizens voicing their displeasure over such behaviour. The above articles are compiled from the vernacular newspapers (Bahasa Malaysia, Chinese and Tamil dailies). As such, stories are grouped according to the respective language/medium. Where a paragraph begins with a, it denotes a separate news item.
The Star
5 days ago
- The Star
Indian tribes visit UK museum to bring home ancestors' remains
Naga artefacts on display at the Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford, Britain, June 13, 2025. REUTERS/Marissa Davison OXFORD, England (Reuters) -Tribes from the Indian state of Nagaland have held talks at a museum in Britain to secure the return of ancestral remains taken during the colonial era and put on display for decades. Skulls and other body parts were often brought from Asia, Africa and elsewhere to Britain and to other former colonial powers, as "trophies", to be traded, displayed or studied. There are growing calls worldwide for such remains, as well as stolen art, to be returned to their communities as part of a centuries-old movement demanding reparations for colonialism and slavery. Just last month, skulls of 19 African Americans were returned to New Orleans from Germany to where they were sent for examination by phrenology - the now discredited belief that the shape and size of a head shows mental ability and character, especially when applied to different ethnic groups. Historians say some of the remains were taken by colonial officers from burial sites and battlefields in Nagaland, where for centuries headhunting was common practice. Others were looted in acts of violence. The Pitt Rivers Museum, which displays collections from Oxford University, holds the world's largest Naga collection, including thousands of artefacts, 41 human remains, primarily skulls, and 178 objects that contain or may contain human hair. It removed all remains from public display in 2020, including ancestors of Dolly Kikon, an anthropologist from Nagaland's Lotha-Naga tribe, who teaches at the University of California and who travelled to Oxford last week. "For the first time, there is a Naga delegation (at the museum) to connect and to reclaim our history, our culture and our belongings," Kikon, 49, told Reuters. Museum director Laura Van Broekhoven said the timing of the return of the remains was still uncertain due to the bureaucracy involved. The museum is also in talks with other groups to facilitate more items being returned. The 23 Naga representatives, including elders of several tribes, repeated calls by British lawmakers and campaigners for the government to legislate to protect ancestral remains. Some European countries, such as the Netherlands, have national policies for the repatriation of human remains. Opponents of reparations argue that contemporary states and institutions should not be held responsible for their past. Advocates say action is needed to address the legacies, such as systemic and structural racism. "One way to confront the colonial legacy is for indigenous people to be able to tell our own stories," Kikon said. (Reporting by Catarina Demony and Marissa Davison; Editing by Kate Holton and Alison Williams)
