German court to rule on Peruvian farmer versus RWE climate case
Peruvian farmer Saul Luciano Lliuya, who is suing German energy utility RWE, arguing that the company's emissions have contributed to the melting of Andean glaciers, poses for a photo in front of Lake Palcacocha, before the verdict of the high regional German court in Hamm, in Huaraz, Peru May 27, 2025. REUTERS/Angela Ponce
(Reuters) -A German court is due to decide on Wednesday whether a lawsuit brought by a Peruvian farmer against German energy giant RWE can continue, in a landmark case that is setting a precedent for future climate change litigation.
In a case that began a decade ago, farmer Saul Luciano Lliuya argues that RWE's emissions have contributed to the melting of Andean glaciers, increasing the flood risk to his home.
Using data from the Carbon Majors database, which tracks historic emissions from major fossil fuel producers, Lliuya says RWE is responsible for nearly 0.5% of global man-made emissions since the industrial revolution and must pay a proportional share of the costs needed to adapt to climate change.
For a $3.5 million flood defence project needed in his region, RWE's share would be around $17,500, according to Lliuya's calculations.
The 44-year-old farmer, whose family grows corn, wheat, barley and potatoes in a hilly region outside Huaraz, says he has chosen to sue RWE because it is one of the biggest polluters in Europe - rather than any particular company projects near his home.
RWE, which is phasing out its coal-fired power plants, says a single emitter of carbon dioxide cannot be held responsible for global warming.
In two days of hearing in March, the Higher Regional Court of Hamm examined a 200-page report by experts it had appointed to determine whether melting glaciers were raising the water levels in Lake Palcacocha and posing a direct risk to Lliuya's home in Huaraz over the next three decades.
Lliuya's lawyer Roda Verheyen in March raised concerns about the assessment of risks by the court experts, who found a 3% flood risk, and said she was ready to challenge their findings.
The verdict was originally due in April, but the court had to postpone it because Verheyen filed a motion to disqualify one of the court's experts.
Verheyen said the arguments were clear.
"In my view, we cannot lose," she told a media briefing last Thursday.
The amount that industrialised countries should contribute to mitigating the effects of global warming, including rising sea levels, extreme storms and heatwaves, has been fiercely debated at successive U.N. climate summits.
If the court on Wednesday finds a specific flooding risk to Lliuya's home, it will then examine the impact of climate change and greenhouse gas emissions on Andean glaciers melting and increasing the risk.
Whatever the outcome on Wednesday, climate academics said the case was a game-changer as the court's legal reasoning would be used by future cases.
"Even if the case is dismissed, we expect to get this legal precedent, which would be a massive step forward," Noah Walker-Crawford, a researcher at London School of Economics Grantham Research Institute, said.
($1 = 0.8809 euros)
(Reporting by Riham Alkousaa; editing by Barbara Lewis)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Barnama
an hour ago
- Barnama
Singapore PM Undertakes Introductory Visit To China, Attends Summer Davos
Singapore's Prime Minister Lawrence Wong speaks during a swearing-in ceremony of Singapore's new Cabinet ministers at the Istana, in Singapore, May 23, 2025. REUTERS/Edgar Su By Nur Ashikin Abdul Aziz SINGAPORE, June 22 (Bernama) -- Singapore Prime Minister Lawrence Wong will make a five-day official visit to China from Sunday at the invitation of Premier Li Qiang, according to the Prime Minister's Office (PMO). PMO said Wong's introductory visit will see both sides commemorate the 35th anniversary of the establishment of Singapore-China diplomatic relations and reaffirm mutual commitment to strengthen bilateral ties. bootstrap slideshow 'It is also an opportunity for leaders on both sides to exchange views on bilateral issues as well as regional and international developments,' PMO said in a statement on Sunday. In Beijing, Wong, who is also the Finance Minister, will meet President Xi Jinping, Premier Li, and Chairman of the National People's Congress Zhao Leji. Wong will also travel to Tianjin to attend the World Economic Forum's (WEF) Annual Meeting of the New Champions (Summer Davos) and participate in a dialogue session with WEF President Børge Brende. The prime minister's delegation includes Foreign Minister Dr Vivian Balakrishnan, Sustainability and Environment Minister and Minister-in-charge of Trade Relations Grace Fu, Acting Minister for Transport and Senior Minister of State for Finance Jeffrey Siow, Senior Minister of State for Foreign Affairs and for Home Affairs Sim Ann, and Member of Parliament Dr Syed Harun Alhabsyi. -- BERNAMA
New Straits Times
2 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Gulf states prepare for possible Iran attack after US strikes
DUBAI/ RIYADH: Gulf states, home to multiple United States' military bases, were on high alert on Sunday after US strikes on Iran raised the possibility of a widening conflict in the region. US forces "obliterated" Iran's main nuclear sites with massive bunker-busting bombs in the early hours of Sunday in the region, President Donald Trump said, warning Tehran it would face more devastating attacks if it does not agree to peace. Saudi Arabia, the world's largest oil exporter, was on a high security alert after the US strikes, two sources with knowledge of the matter told Reuters on Sunday, while Bahrain urged drivers to avoid main roads and Kuwait set up shelters in a ministries complex. Tehran has previously warned that if it was attacked by the United States, it could target American assets in the region, including US military bases. Bahrain is home to the headquarters of the US Navy's 5th Fleet and there are US bases in Saudi Arabia and Kuwait, as well as in neighbouring Qatar and the United Arab Emirates. Nuclear authorities in Saudi Arabia and the UAE said they had not detected signs of nuclear contamination following the strikes in Iran. "While the war has so far been contained in direct hostilities between Israel and Iran, direct US involvement is a critical threshold that risks dragging the Gulf states, notably Bahrain, Kuwait and Qatar, which host large US military facilities, into the conflict," said Hasan Al Hasan, a senior fellow for Middle East Policy at the International Institute for Strategic studies. He said the risk of an open conflict between the US and Iran could plunge the region into a devastating and potentially protracted conflict. "In light of recent developments in the regional security situation, we urge citizens and residents to use main roads only when necessary to maintain public safety and to allow the relevant authorities to use the roads efficiently," Bahrain's interior ministry said in a post on X. Bahrain also told 70 per cent of its government employees to work from home on Sunday until further notice, citing escalating tensions, according the Civil Service Bureau. The country's authorities earlier this week said they had activated a national plan to prepare for emergencies, set up an emergency centre and tested warning sirens. Local media also reported that Bahrain had set up 33 shelters.
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
Cheerleaders to critics: German machinery makers call for EU action on China
Germany's iconic machine makers used to be among the loudest cheerleaders for ever-closer economic ties between China and Europe. Now, as exports dwindle and facing 'increasingly strong [Chinese] competitors' beefed up by 'unfair state subsidies', the industry is demanding that Brussels put in place trade barriers to protect it. A new position paper published on Thursday by the Mechanical Engineering Industry Association (VDMA), representing medium-sized manufacturers that help constitute Germany's famed Mittelstand group of businesses, marks a dramatic reversal for an industry that until recently lauded the Sino-German economic miracle. 'The EU should impose countervailing duties on imports from third countries if they violate EU anti-dumping or anti-subsidy rules. China is a particular focus here with its aggressive export policy,' read the VDMA's paper. The industry group – whose 3,600 members make everything from power transmission systems and machine tools to semiconductor machines and precision tools – made clear that it was ready to compete with Chinese rivals on a level playing field. However, it was also unequivocal that it feels those conditions do not exist and that it wants governments to intervene. 'Chinese companies are heavily subsidised by the government. And they supply products to Europe that sometimes disregard our technical regulations. China is not playing fair, and politicians must respond to this,' said Bertram Kawlath, VDMA's president. The paper marks a break from decades in which German industry grew rich from selling machines made for powering the workshop of the world. Since the Covid-19 pandemic, the VDMA has turned sharp critic of a harsh new reality in Germany's economic ties with China. It has spoken of being out-competed by fierce rivals in China, Europe and third markets. It will provide an early challenge for new Chancellor Friedrich Merz, who has taken a tougher rhetorical line on China than predecessor Olaf Scholz, but who will also have to deal with the country's powerful automotive lobby, whose views are unrecognisable from those of the VDMA. While Scholz backed the EU's de-risking strategy, research has shown that this support did little to unpick Germany's dependencies on China for critical goods. 'Compared to the previous year, there has been little change in Germany's potentially critical import dependency on China,' wrote Juergen Matthes of the German Economic Institute in an assessment published last week. The VDMA's statistics showed a substantial loss of market share in China for its companies. German machinery went from holding a 20.4 per cent share in China's import market in 2015 to 15.1 per cent in 2024. The shipments were down 12.2 per cent over the first quarter of 2025 year-on-year, German government stats showed, exacerbating a trend of declines in five of the last six years. 'Supported by the 'Made in China 2025' strategy, Chinese mechanical engineering companies have become increasingly strong competitors on the global market. Unfair state subsidies for Chinese companies play a major role in international business,' the paper said. The figures chime with broader German and EU trends: over the first five months of 2025, EU exports to China fell 7.3 per cent compared with a year earlier, while Germany's shipments fell 5.9 per cent. At the same time, China's shipments to Germany and Europe are booming. In May alone, exports to Germany – the EU's largest economy – soared 21.5 per cent, following 20.3 per cent growth in April. To France, shipments were up 24.1 per cent in May, stoking fears that Europe will become a 'dumping ground' for Chinese products that are effectively blocked from the United States due to sky-high tariffs. Soapbox, a newsletter focused on Chinese trade, forecast that for 2025 as a whole, Switzerland will import more from the EU than China, the world's second largest economy. The VDMA's intervention comes amid a clamorous debate over the direction of the EU's China policy and ahead of a crunch summit in July, where leaders will meet in Beijing to discuss thorny issues from trade gripes to China's ties with Russia. With the return of US President Donald Trump to the White House and his swift abandonment of the transatlantic alliance, many expected Europe and China to patch up their many differences. A growing body of evidence is emerging, however, to suggest that this will be more difficult than anticipated. While China's commerce ministry has talked up the prospect of a blockbuster deal on electric vehicles – which would see EU tariffs imposed last year replaced with a minimum import price – EU officials and diplomats said that was highly unlikely in the short term. Briefing ambassadors from the bloc's 27 member states on Wednesday, meanwhile, the European Commission gave no hint that a deal was close, diplomatic sources said. - South China Morning Post
