From Gaza to South Sudan, private firms deliver aid and face questions
Workers load food aid in a cago plane for delivery within Ulang and Nasir counties in Upper Nile State ravaged by fighting between local militiamen and the army, in an operation run by Fogbow, a U.S. company organising the airdrops with funding from the South Sudanese government, at the Juba International airport in Juba, South Sudan June 9, 2025. REUTERS/Thomas Mukoya
Workers prepare to release food aid from a cargo plane within Nasir town airspace, ravaged by fighting between local militiamen and the army, in an operation run by Fogbow, a U.S. company organising the airdrops with funding from the South Sudanese government, in Nasir County of Upper Nile State, South Sudan June 10, 2025. REUTERS/Thomas Mukoya
Workers load food aid in a cargo plane for delivery within Ulang and Nasir counties in Upper Nile State ravaged by fighting between local militiamen and the army, in an operation run by Fogbow, a U.S. company organising the airdrops with funding from the South Sudanese government, at the Juba International airport in Juba, South Sudan June 9, 2025. REUTERS/Thomas Mukoya
A pilot flies a cargo plane with food aid for delivery within the Torbar airspace, ravaged by fighting?between local militiamen and the army, in an operation run by Fogbow, a U.S. company organising the airdrops with funding from the South Sudanese government, in Torbar within Ulang county of Upper Nile State, South Sudan June 9, 2025. REUTERS/Thomas Mukoya
A worker prepares to release food aid from a cargo plane within Nasir town airspace, ravaged by fighting between local militiamen and the army, in an operation run by Fogbow, a U.S. company organising the airdrops with funding from the South Sudanese government, in Nasir County of Upper Nile State, South Sudan June 10, 2025. REUTERS/Thomas Mukoya
JUBA - Fifty-kilo sacks of food hurtled out the open hatch of the cargo plane, scattering in the wind on their 1,000-foot descent to the northeastern flatlands of South Sudan.
For the past three weeks, an American company run by former U.S. soldiers and officials has airdropped hundreds of tonnes of maize flour, beans and salt into one of the world's most desperate pockets of hunger.
The campaign, which South Sudan's government says it is funding, has brought lifesaving aid to areas ravaged since February by fighting between the military and local militiamen.
It also offers a window into a debate about the future of humanitarian aid in the wake of U.S. President Donald Trump's dismantling of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) and cuts to aid budgets around the world.
The South Sudan contract is one of a growing list of business opportunities for Fogbow, an outfit of about a dozen people that first distributed food last year in Gaza and Sudan. Fogbow president Mick Mulroy said the company - which is owned by a former U.S. diplomat, a Marine Corps veteran and an American businessman - now has five project requests in conflict zones in Africa and the Middle East.
Mulroy attributed the rising demand to donors looking to support humanitarian projects but increasingly hard-pressed to find implementing partners due to aid cuts.
"There's a substantial and growing need from people around the world at a time when we decided collectively to reduce the support," said Mulroy, who was a deputy assistant secretary of defence during Trump's first term.
For some aid sector veterans, the demand for Fogbow's services points to a worrying shift toward a more politicised aid model that they say sacrifices humanitarian principles like neutrality and, by extension, its credibility with beneficiaries.
In Gaza, a U.S.-backed outfit that Israel has authorised to distribute food in the Palestinian enclave, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), has bypassed the U.N.-led aid system and been accused by some critics of weaponising aid in service of Israel's war aims.
Asked for comment, GHF said it had found a "better model" to ensure food was delivered in Gaza. "Bottom line, our aid is getting in and feeding people while aid from other groups is getting looted and not being delivered," it said in an email.
Fogbow says it has no connection to GHF. But its operation in South Sudan is raising some of the same questions because it is working directly on behalf of a party to an active conflict.
The campaign has been complicated by its association with the government: the aid comes in sacks marked "South Sudan Humanitarian Relief" and emblazoned with the national flag. Some people have refused the food because they don't trust the government, whose forces are bombarding parts of Upper Nile, according to two residents, opposition politicians and a U.N. source.
"They expect people to take the food but we say 'no' to our people," said Manpiny Pal, a senior local government official in Ulang County, one of two in Upper Nile targeted by the airdrops.
"We need the food of the U.N. How do we know if that food dropped has something in it?" said Pal, who is from the opposition SPLM-IO party.
The United Nations' World Food Programme (WFP), which plans to distribute over 160,000 tonnes of food in South Sudan this year, said last month that no humanitarian aid was getting to the two counties by the usual river route due to the fighting.
Asked if WFP had considered airdropping food there, a spokesperson said airdrops were a last resort because they cost up to 17 times more than deliveries by road or river.
HUMANITARIAN PRINCIPLES
Some veteran humanitarians have deep misgivings about Fogbow's model.
Martin Griffiths, who served as the top humanitarian official at the United Nations from 2021 to 2024, urged against trying to reinvent the wheel.
"The humanitarian community is large and amorphous. It is also careful. And finally it is experienced. This is a well to draw on and I wish this was done by Fogbow," Griffiths told Reuters.
Michael VanRooyen, the director of the Harvard Humanitarian Initiative, which researches humanitarian issues, said Fogbow and GHF were undermining an evidence and needs-based approach to aid.
"These organisations are not humanitarian. They are agents of a government, intended to fulfill political and in some cases military purposes," he said.
Fogbow officials say they are a logistics provider rather than a humanitarian organisation but try to align their projects with humanitarian principles.
Chris Hyslop, Fogbow's humanitarian lead and a veteran of the U.N. system, said he had near-daily contacts with WFP to discuss drop locations and ask for input.
He acknowledged complications from working directly with the government but said such concerns had to be weighed against the benefits of national authorities taking responsibility for their own people.
The WFP spokesperson said that while the agency receives a daily update from Fogbow on drop locations to deconflict airspace, it has no involvement in the operation.
South Sudan's government said it asked Fogbow, rather than WFP, to do the drops in order to expedite the rollout and show it was taking responsibility for its citizens.
"Here is a government taking up responsibility as a core mandate of that government," said Chol Ajongo, the minister of presidential affairs.
The government declined to say how much it was spending to distribute the 600 tonnes of food.
Fifty-seven percent of South Sudan's more than 13 million people suffer acute food insecurity, according to the U.N., but the country has only received pledges covering 20% of its $1.69 billion in estimated humanitarian needs for 2025.
'WE'RE GONNA TRY SOMETHING DIFFERENT'
Fogbow's leaders express respect for the U.N. and traditional non-governmental organisations and say they would be happy to work as contractors within the existing system.
But they also think they can do better.
Fogbow CEO and co-owner Brook Jerue said the company's previous work had shown the advantages of its military background and willingness to innovate.
In Gaza, Fogbow advocated for sending food on barges across the Mediterranean from Cyprus to avoid bottlenecks at land crossings. Many humanitarians opposed the idea, arguing it would ease political pressure on Israel to open land routes.
"The humanitarian community was super upset with us because they were all pushing for land crossings, and we were just like, 'hey, we're gonna try something different'," said Jerue, a former U.S. Marine Corps pilot.
Fogbow dropped its barges plan when then-U.S. President Joe Biden decided in March 2024 to deliver aid through a U.S. military-built floating pier.
Fogbow went on to deliver 1,100 tonnes of flour through the U.S. pier and an Israeli port with funding from Qatar, Jerue said.
Later last year, it used profits from the Gaza operation to finance airdrops into Sudan's remote South Kordofan state before USAID offered to provide funding, Jerue said.
The State Department declined to comment on that operation. A spokesperson said the U.S. was not involved in the aidrops in South Sudan but voiced support for "burden-sharing among capable nations".
WAR AND SUSPICION
Fogbow's model is facing its sternest test in Upper Nile's Ulang and Nasir Counties, which the U.N. on Thursday said are at risk of famine in the coming months after fighting this year forced more than 100,000 people to flee their homes.
Each morning and afternoon, a cargo plane carrying 16 tonnes of food leaves the capital Juba for one of two drop sites. The food is collected by workers from an independent local NGO and then distributed.
While the aid has reached around 30,000 people, the government-led campaign has faced resistance rooted in accusations of abuses by the military, including allegations made by local residents - and supported by Human Rights Watch - that government planes have dropped incendiary weapons.
The government denies this and says it does everything possible to minimise harm to civilians.
The SPLM-IO has accused the military of coercing displaced civilians to return home to collect the food.
Local residents have also questioned the decision to drop food into Nasir, a military garrison town largely deserted by civilians after heavy fighting in March, as opposed to areas with high concentrations of displaced people.
The government denied any coercion but acknowledged the drops into Nasir were intended to encourage people to return and show it could provide for them.
"For you to claim the legitimacy and the representation of the people of South Sudan, you must have presence in all those places," said Ajongo. REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
a day ago
- Straits Times
Gaza faces a man-made drought as water systems collapse, Unicef says
Unicef said just 40 per cent of drinking water production facilities in Gaza remain functional. PHOTO: REUTERS GENEVA - Gaza is facing a man-made drought as its water systems collapse, the United Nations' children agency said on June 20. "Children will begin to die of thirst... Just 40 per cent of drinking water production facilities remain functional," Unicef spokesman James Elder told reporters in Geneva. "We are way below emergency standards in terms of drinking water for people in Gaza," he added. Unicef also reported a 50 per cent increase in children aged six months to 5 years admitted for treatment of malnutrition from April to May in Gaza, and half a million people going hungry. It said the US-backed aid distribution system run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) was "making a desperate situation worse." On June 20, at least 25 people awaiting aid trucks or seeking aid were killed by Israeli fire south of Netzarim in central Gaza Strip, according to local health authorities. On June 19, at least 51 people were killed by Israeli gunfire and military strikes, including 12 people who tried to approach a site operated by the GHF in the central Gaza Strip. Mr Elder, who was recently in Gaza, said he had many testimonials of women and children injured while trying to receive food aid, including a young boy who was wounded by a tank shell and later died of his injuries. He said a lack of public clarity on when the sites, some of which are in combat zones, were open was causing mass casualty events. "There have been instances where information (was) shared that a site is open, but then it's communicated on social media that they're closed, but that information was shared when Gaza's internet was down and people had no access to it," he said. On June 18, the GHF said in a statement it had distributed three million meals across three of its aid sites without an incident. On June 20, at least 12 people were killed in an airstrike on a house belonging to the Ayyash family in Deir Al-Balah, taking the day's death toll to 37. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
2 days ago
- Straits Times
Arab town in Israel weeps for four family members killed in Iranian strike
FILE PHOTO: A man reacts as relatives and friends attend the funeral of four members of a family who were killed during a missile attack from Iran on Israel, in Tamra, north Israel June 17, 2025 REUTERS/Ammar Awad/File Photo FILE PHOTO: Relatives and friends attend the funeral of four members of a family who were killed during a missile attack from Iran on Israel, in Tamra, north Israel June 17, 2025 REUTERS/Ammar Awad/File Photo Arab town in Israel weeps for four family members killed in Iranian strike TAMRA, Israel - When a phone alert sounded on Saturday night to warn of Iranian missiles flying towards his town of Tamra in northern Israel, Nidal Abu Al Heija called his sister to tell her to take shelter with her daughters, but no one answered. After the alert, he rushed to the area where she lived. The street was full of people and littered with debris. "I was asking people what happened, and someone, he just said to me 'oh, Nidal'. He didn't know what to say. And then the other one says, 'it's your own sister's house'," Abu Al Heija said, speaking to Reuters four days after the strike. The house had taken a direct hit. Part of the roof had collapsed, crushing the top floor. Windows and walls were blasted out and rubble tumbled down the side of the house. "Darkness, dust, smell of bomb, something I don't want to remember," said Abu Al Heija. "I was just going there shouting 'Noura! Noura! Shada! Hala!' And then unfortunately I saw her coming, people holding her, with no breath." Known to her family as Noura, Manar Abu Al Heija Katib, 45, and two of her daughters, Shada, 20, and Hala, 13, were killed, along with Manar's sister-in-law, Manar Diab Katib, 41. The only survivors were Manar Abu Al Heija Katib's husband, Raja Katib, and their third daughter, Razan. The dead were among those killed in the conflict with Iran since Israel launched air and missile attacks on Iran a week ago that have wiped out the top echelon of Iran's military command, damaged nuclear capabilities and killed hundreds of Iranians. Iran has aimed hundreds of retaliatory missiles at Israel and killed at least two dozen people. 'BURNING FIRE INSIDE' In Tamra, a small Arab town about 25 km (16 miles) east of the port city of Haifa, relatives and the wider community are in shock. "If I would have gone (died) with my wife and my two girls, it would have been easier because I have a burning fire inside," Manar's husband told reporters on Wednesday. The sisters-in-law were both teachers. Their husbands, Raja Katib and his brother Ihab Katib, have described them to local media as wonderful women. Pictures of the two daughters showed them smiling warmly. Nidal Abu Al Heija recalled telling people previously that the chances of being killed in the war with Iran were tiny. Now he said he was dealing with an unfathomable loss. "Noura was the thing that we loved. Noura was the thing that united the family," he said. The four had run to a protected room on the top level of the house, he said, but it could not withstand the Iranian missile. Tamra has been hit by rockets before, but smaller ones fired by militant group Hezbollah from southern Lebanon. Residents said that those who could afford it had protected rooms inside their homes, and there were a few public shelters, but not as many as in Jewish neighbourhoods. Arab citizens make up about 20% of Israel's population, and often complain of unequal treatment compared with the Jewish majority. Since Saturday's strike, many residents of Tamra have begun spending the night in public shelters inside schools. On Tuesday, four simple wooden coffins with wreaths of red and white flowers were carried through the narrow streets of Tamra, with crowds of men chanting as they walked alongside and people watching from every window and doorstep. At the town's cemetery, Muslim prayers rang out from a loudspeaker and a large number of men, mostly dressed in black, surrounded the gravediggers and relatives as the four were laid to rest. Afterwards, a group of women and girls paid their respects by the graves. They wept and embraced each other as they walked away. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
2 days ago
- Straits Times
Indian canteen worker's hopes dashed, no second miracle in air crash
AHMEDABAD, India - Ravi Thakor had been hoping his mother and two-year old daughter had escaped just before an Air India jet crashed into the building they were in. A week after one of the world's worst aviation disasters killed more than 270 people in the western Indian city of Ahmedabad, Thakor's hopes were dashed when doctors matched his DNA on Wednesday with the remains of his mother Sarla and daughter Aadhya. A canteen worker in a college hostel, Thakor and other family members had left the hostel around 30 minutes before Air India's Boeing 787 Dreamliner aircraft crashed into the building. Sarla had stayed back, cooking and looking after Aadhya, who was asleep. Thakor and his wife Lalita searched for them in hospitals and the morgue after the crash. After not finding them for days, they said they were hoping for a "second miracle", referring to the lone passenger aboard the plane who survived the disaster. On Thursday, the dead bodies were handed over to Thakor's family for the final rites. "We are going to cremate my mother and daughter. It is very difficult for me to say anything right now, but at least we know what happened to them," Thakor said, struggling to speak. At least 211 DNA samples had been matched, and 189 dead bodies handed over to families, Rakesh Joshi, the medical superintendent at the Ahmedabad Civil Hospital told reporters on Thursday. The dead included 241 people on board the plane and at least 30 on the ground. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
