McGregor whiskey case not going ahead after 'fundamental' change to original plea
The High Court hearing of a dispute over a claim by a former sparring partner of Conor McGregor for a share in a whiskey brand founded by the MMA fighter is not going ahead as planned next week after the case was "fundamentally changed" to what was originally pleaded.
The case by Russian Artem Lobov, claiming he had an oral agreement for a 5% share made with Mr McGregor in a gym in September 2017, was due to begin next Tuesday, with eight days set aside for the hearing.
The case concerns Mr Lobov's claim for a share in creating the idea for and working on setting up the Proper No Twelve Irish whiskey brand.
It was sold in 2021 to Proximo Spirits for a reported sum of up to US$600m and Mr McGregor was reported to have received US€130m from the sale.
Proximo cut ties with Mr McGregor and the brand following last year's separate High Court action in which a civil jury found he should pay almost €250,000 for assaulting a woman, Nikita Hand, in a Dublin hotel in December 2018. That decision is being appealed.
On Thursday, a judge said he was reluctantly going to allow the case to proceed next week after he expressed concerns about whether or not it was ready.
The court heard Mr Lobov's side was late in lodging pre-trial legal submissions. This meant Mr McGregor's side was unable to have its submissions in before the case was due to begin.
On Friday, Mr Justice Brian Cregan was told Mr Lobov's submissions had been received after Thursday's court hearing and they contained a proposal that the date of the alleged oral agreement was not as first claimed to be, in September 2017, but October 2017.
Shelley Horan BL, for Mr McGregor, said her side had prepared the case on the basis it was a September date that the alleged oral agreement was made and they had interviewed four people who were supposed to be present when it occurred in a gym.
As a result, it had significant implications for the case, which counsel had described as being primarily evidence-based. Her side was prejudiced by this amendment to the case and would now need time to prepare for what would be a new claim.
Ms Horan also said no specific date had been given for the September claim, which had created challenges for the defendant in preparing the case. The defence denied there was any oral agreement.
Andrew Walker SC, for Mr Lobov, accepted what had happened was wholly unacceptable but he was seeking leave to bring a motion to amend the case next week with an affidavit setting out the rationale as to why this had happened.
Asked by Mr Justice Cregan why, when the court set the hearing date for next Tuesday, the fact the case had "changed fundamentally" had not been brought to the judge's attention, Mr Walker said he would like to have that put on affidavit.
The new date is a month later, not months later or a different year, he said. New information was discovered by Mr Lobov on an old phone which gave him clarity about the date, he said.
After the case was put back to later in the morning for Mr Walker to get instructions, counsel said he was agreeing to an adjournment of next week's hearing.
The judge vacated the hearing date but said he would hear Mr Walker's application next week to amend the statement of claim to put in the new October date.
Read More
Judge reluctantly allows McGregor whiskey brand dispute to go ahead next week
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
41 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Sligo's new whiskey very much influenced by the River that runs through the town
A bottle of Garavogue will set you back €199 Sligo Champion Today at 12:08 A Sligo distillery located on the shores of Lough Gill has produced its first whiskey which draws on the influence of the water all around it. latest whiskey was The Sazerac Company celebrated the release of its inaugural Irish whiskey from Hawk's Rock Distillery, Hazelwood, Sligo on Wednesday last, June 18.
Irish Examiner
42 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Cork-based services company Org Group acquires Brussels-based firm
Cork-based services firm Org Group has announced it has acquired Brussels-based European workforce solutions firm Enterprise Digital Resources (EDR). Org Group said the acquisition strengthened and expanded its access to a 'network of high-skilled consultants at a time when businesses are accelerating digital transformation and facing heightened talent demands'. Financial details of the acquisition have not been disclosed. EDR provides specialised tech staff to clients in countries across Europe including France, Belgium, UK, and Ireland. It focuses on areas such as enterprise resource planning, human capital management, enterprise performance management, as well as customer relationship management. Org Group chief executive Seb O'Connell said EDR's deep domain expertise was a 'natural fit for Org Group'. 'This complements our capacity to deliver impactful digital and organisational transformation through the right mix of strategy, systems, and people.' Org Group is the holding company for Irish-owned recruitment firm Morgan McKinley, business process services company Abtran, and advisory firm Org. The group employs 3,000 people in 10 countries. EDR director James Parker said Org Group 'shares our belief that skills and talent are the engine behind successful transformation'. 'Joining the group enables us to scale our impact and support more organisations in navigating the future of enterprise technology.' Last month, the company also acquired global technology recruiting business Venturi. Venturi is headquartered in Manchester, with offices in New York, USA and Düsseldorf, Germany. Its clients include Red Kite, Bet 365, and Money Supermarket. The company has annual revenues of about £40m (€47.5m).
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Asylum seeker, 34, died from stab wound to chest during violent incident on Dublin city street, inquest told
AN ASYLUM seeker died from a stab wound to the chest during a violent incident in Dublin city centre, an inquest heard today. Quham Babatunde - an ex-footballer who came originally from 2 Faith Akpobome gave evidence of formally identifying her friend's body to gardai Credit: The 34-year-old, who was living in an accommodation centre for international protection applicants in Ballyogan in south Dublin while his request for asylum was being processed, was rushed by ambulance to At the opening of an inquest into Mr Babatunde's death at Dublin District Coroner's Court, a friend of the deceased, Faith Akpobome, gave evidence of formally identifying his body to Ms Akpobome said she had known Mr Babatunde since May 2024 and had spoken to his uncle in Nigeria, Adeola Olayokun, to confirm that she could assist gardaí for the purpose of identifying his nephew's body. The inquest heard that fingerprint evidence was also used to confirm his identity with officials from Forensic Science Ireland matching the fingerprints of the deceased with those provided by Mr Babatunde to the International Protection Office when he was applying for READ MORE ON NEWS The coroner, Clare Keane, said the results of a postmortem conducted by State pathologist, Sally Anne Collis, showed Mr Babatunde died from a stab wound to the chest. Detective Inspector Katharina Joyce applied for an adjournment of the inquest under Section 25 (2) of the Coroners Act on the basis that A total of nine individuals have already been arrested and charged in relation to the fatal incident as part of the investigation into Mr Babatunde's death. Ryan Ndede, 23, of Boroimhe Birches, Swords, Co most read in the irish sun David Oloo Omee, 19, of The Lawn, St Marnock's Bay, Dublin 13, is charged with engaging in violent disorder with others at Anne Street South and assault causing harm to Adetola Adetuilehim, a friend of the deceased. Rory Carr, 21, of Ard na Greine, Seapoint Lane, Balbriggan, is accused of assault causing harm to Mr Babatunde and Mr Adetuilehim on Anne Street South and Jeffrey Bangu, 21, of Cardy Rock Crescent, Balbriggan, is charged with assault causing harm to Mr Babatunde at Duke Lane and to Adetuilehim at Anne Street South. He is also accused of violent disorder and the production of a knife during the incident. Sean Forde, 23, of Bath Road, Balbriggan, Co Dublin, is charged with violent disorder at Anne Street South. John Eghomwanre, 23, of Dun Emer Glade, Lusk, Co. Dublin, is accused of assault causing harm to Mr Babatunde on Anne Street South and Mr Adetuilehim at Duke Lane, as well as violent disorder. Bakuani Diavisi, 25, of Cardy Rock, Balbriggan, Co Dublin, is charged with assault causing harm to another named male at Dawson Street, Dublin 2, on the same date. Bruno Tache, 20, of Trimleston, Balbriggan, Co Dublin is charged with violent disorder and assault causing harm to Mr Babatunde and another man, Angel Ahgaria. Faraj Odukoya, 19, of Hamlet Lane, Balbriggan, Dublin, is accused of assault causing harm to Mr Babatunde at Anne Street South and to Mr Adetuilehim at Duke Lane, and violent disorder. The coroner granted the application and adjourned the hearing of Mr Babatunde's inquest until a date to be fixed on conclusion of any related criminal proceedings. Dr Keane also offered her condolences to Mr Babatunde's family on what she described as his 'tragic death.' 2 Quham Babatunde, 34, who was stabbed to death in Dublin city centre Credit: Supplied
