Empty promises or real change?
Listen to article
ISLAMABAD:
The term "reforms" has been so misattributed and misused in Pakistan that any mention of reform sounds like an empty promise without any genuine strategy for change. A new report titled Pakistan Reforms Report (PRR) 2025 has been published recently. The report, published by Mishal Pakistan, applauds the government for instituting "more than 100 reforms" in 2024, citing a number that raises more questions than it answers. Furthermore, a closer look at the report suggests that most of these reforms are wrongly termed as such because they are either a mere continuation of previous plans or solely steps taken to track previous programs.
Surprisingly, the report mentions that the government privatised seven loss-making State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) in January 2025. While the names of those SOEs are not provided, this claim alone seriously weakens the credibility and authenticity of the report. While the case of the privatisation of Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) is no mystery to anyone, it is clear that the current government has not completed any privatisation transaction. The last successful transaction was closed in February 2024.
While the government is not hiring employees for vacant seats and has abolished 150,000 vacant positions to cut anticipated government expenditures (if these positions were to be filled), commercial SOEs are still functional and are incurring billions of rupees in losses to the country.
Most SOEs, including those in the transport and energy sectors, continue to suffer from financial burdens and management inefficiencies. Thus, it is essential to verify whether any liquidation or restructuring of these SOEs has taken place.
The World Economic Forum, for which Mishal serves as a country partner, publishes the Global Competitiveness Report, evaluating economies based on 12 key pillars, including innovation, business environment, efficiency of the labour market, and financial system of the country.
One would expect the section on the economic competitiveness of Pakistan to provide an analysis based on global rankings, focusing on ease of doing business, productivity, innovation, and economic efficiency. However, the section largely applauds the Special Investment Facilitation Council (SIFC) for its role in supporting economic recovery. While SIFC's efforts in attracting investment and addressing governance bottlenecks are debatable, the report lacks any reference to actual competitiveness indicators, making it more of a political endorsement rather than an analytical assessment.
According to the latest Global Competitiveness Report, Pakistan ranks 110 out of 140 countries, underlining the fact that the country is far from being a globally competitive nation. This ranking indicates persistent barriers in innovation, regulatory inefficiencies, and weak infrastructure. While the government touts progress in ease of doing business, the reality is that Pakistan still faces systemic challenges in fostering a business-friendly environment, reducing red tape, and encouraging advanced technological adoption. Without structural reforms in key areas such as tax policy for businesses, research and development, and institutional efficiency, Pakistan's competitiveness is not expected to make a stark shift in the rankings.
On the fiscal management front, the Pakistan Reforms Report highlights that pension reforms could potentially save Rs1.7 trillion over the next decade through the contribution fund scheme introduced in 2024. However, this scheme applies only to new entrants in government services, meaning its impact on reducing pension expenditures will take considerable time. Meanwhile, pension expenditure for existing beneficiaries in FY24 alone stood at Rs1.2 trillion, and with a 15% increase announced in the FY24-25 budget, the financial burden remains substantial. Pakistan can look to successful pension reform models in countries like Chile and India, which have implemented structured transitions to reduce long-term liabilities.
On the fiscal side, the most significant reform area pertains to tax policy rates and the complexity of the tax system. The report, as well as the Economic Transformation Agenda, remains silent on this issue. While technology can help, in the absence of real policy reforms, it cannot fix the deep-rooted problems.
While the country is at a crossroadsas alwaysand is in dire need of actual economic and governance reforms, it is important that only implemented reforms are recognised as such. Announcing policies and making administrative changes don't constitute actual reforms unless concrete execution and measurable outcomes are produced.
The Pakistan Reforms Report highlights several initiatives taken by the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) government, some of which are potentially viable and can pave the way for long-term progress. Some of these reported reforms should be acknowledgedsuch as allowing Pakistani IT companies to retain foreign exchange earnings in dollars.
Most of them, however, should not even be called reforms. For example, the creation of new regulatory authorities cannot be classified as reforms. Also, enforcement of limitations on government-sponsored trips cannot be considered a reform, though it can be appreciated as a step to reduce public spending.
As a rule, policy debate should be based on quantifiable and achievable actions rather than aspirational claims, or else political claims in the long term can lose their essence and trust. The future of the country depends not merely on announcing reforms but on real, transformative actions that bring structural changes and unleash sources of economic prosperity for our people.
THE WRITERS ARE AFFILIATED WITH PRIME, AN INDEPENDENT ECONOMIC POLICY THINK TANK BASED IN ISLAMABAD
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
21 hours ago
- Business Recorder
PIA brings 121 nationals from Iran
KARACHI: Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) successfully completed its second special rescue flight on Friday, bringing 121 Pakistani nationals safely home from Iran via Azerbaijan's capital city Baku. According to PIA spokesman, the special flight PK-7160 landed at Lahore airport at 3:40 PM, carrying passengers who had been stranded in Iran due to recent airspace restrictions that affected normal flight operations. Due to the closure of Iranian airspace, the stranded Pakistani citizens were required to travel overland to Baku, Azerbaijan, where they boarded the PIA rescue flight for their journey home to Pakistan. The complex evacuation operation was made possible through the coordinated efforts of Pakistani diplomatic missions in both Iran and Azerbaijan, who played crucial roles in facilitating the safe passage of citizens to the departure point in Baku. The special flight was dispatched on direct instructions from the Government of Pakistan, demonstrating the state's commitment to ensuring the welfare of its citizens abroad during challenging circumstances, he said. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
PIA special flight repatriates 121 stranded Pakistanis from Iran via Baku
A second special repatriation flight operated by Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) safely brought home 121 Pakistani nationals stranded in Iran, the national flag carrier said in a statement on Friday. Flight PK-7160 arrived in Lahore from Baku, Azerbaijan, at 3:40 PM, concluding a coordinated evacuation effort in response to the closure of Iranian airspace. 268 Pakistanis repatriated from Basra successfully: FO With direct air travel suspended, the stranded passengers had travelled overland from Iran to Baku, where arrangements were made for their return to Pakistan. The Pakistani embassies in Tehran and Baku played a pivotal role in facilitating the cross-border movement and coordination required for the repatriation process. Evacuation of Pakistanis in Iran, Iraq: Dar directs PIA to coordinate closely with MOFA The special flight was operated on the directives of the Government of Pakistan. PIA stated that, even in challenging circumstances, it remained committed to national service by prioritizing the safe return of citizens, a reflection of its longstanding tradition of operating in the national interest.
Express Tribune
2 days ago
- Express Tribune
Ministry asked to get IMF nod for oil tax
Finance Minister Ishaq Dar said that the imposition of 17% general sales tax would increase the HOBC price by Rs45 per litre, therefore, he did not approve the proposal. photo: file Listen to article The Special Investment Facilitation Council (SIFC) has directed the Ministry of Finance to swiftly secure consent of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) for imposing sales tax on petroleum products as the matter has stalled investments of $6 billion in refinery upgrade projects. The government had earlier agreed to remove sales tax exemption on petroleum products to support struggling oil refineries and oil marketing companies. It committed to imposing 5% sales tax on petroleum, but did not include it in the Finance Bill 2025, sparking concerns in the oil industry. The Oil Companies Advisory Council (OCAC) – an industry lobby – had also raised the issue with the federal government for failing to meet the commitment and for continuing the tax exemption. The oil industry claims it has suffered Rs34 billion in losses during the ongoing financial year, which has prompted the government to allow loss recovery through the inland freight equalisation margin. "However, the main issue of GST removal from petroleum products remains in place," an industry official told The Express Tribune. Sources said that the issue landed in a recent meeting of the SIFC, which voiced concern over delay in resolving the matter. The finance ministry informed the SIFC that it had presented the proposal of levying GST on petroleum to the IMF and was awaiting its consent. The ministry expressed hope that the IMF's nod would be secured before the approval of budget by parliament. Industry officials pointed out that the government had additionally imposed carbon and petroleum levies on furnace oil, which would cause a halt to their furnace oil sales. Since the release of the Finance Bill 2024 in June last year, refineries have actively pursued the inclusion of high-speed diesel, motor spirit (petrol), kerosene oil and light diesel oil in the exemption regime under the Sales Tax Act, 1990 with the authorities concerned. Through consistent and collaborative efforts from June 2024 to May 2025, the government approved a mechanism for reimbursing the additional cost of sales tax inputs, resulting from the exemption status of petroleum products for fiscal year 2024-25. Regrettably, despite assurances and constructive engagement, the matter remains unresolved in the Finance Bill 2025. This undermines investor confidence, disrupts long-term planning and runs counter to objectives of Pakistan Oil Refining Policy for Upgradation of Existing/Brownfield Refineries, 2023 that seeks to attract investments of $6 billion. In case the dispute drags on, it will not only derail plant upgrade plans but will also pose financial and liquidity challenges to existing operations as refineries run under a regulatory pricing regime and are unable to recover this additional burden from product pricing. Separately, a summary is circulating on social media, suggesting that the Ministry of Energy (Petroleum Division) has proposed the imposition of petroleum levy on high sulphur fuel oil (HSFO) at Rs82,077 per metric ton. This is in addition to a carbon levy of Rs2,665/MT on HSFO, as proposed in the Finance Bill 2025. It is feared that the application of petroleum and carbon levies will result in an 80% increase in the end-user price of HSFO. This may lead to a further reduction in industrial activity and domestic demand. With lower local consumption, government revenues with respect to sales tax collection will go down markedly and refineries will be forced to export HSFO at a significant financial loss. In addition, the refineries that consume HSFO as fuel in their own operations will be burdened with a sharp rise in operating costs due to the inclusion of petroleum and carbon levies.
