'Utterly shameful': Irish MEPs slam EU offer to assist Israel in replacing Gaza aid agencies
AN OFFER MADE by the European Union's top diplomat to assist Israel in replacing aid agencies in Gaza has been described as 'utterly shameful' and 'against what we stand for' by two Irish MEPs.
On Wednesday evening, the EU's High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Kaja Kallas said she had offered Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar EU assistance with his government's proposal to take over the distribution of aid in the besieged Palestinian territory, where Israel has imposed a complete blockade since early March.
Since then, no food, water or medical supplies have entered Gaza and Taoiseach Micheál Martin has said the siege is 'clearly a war crime' and that Israel's war 'has lost any moral compass'.
'I offered also help by the European Union to distribute the humanitarian aid if they don't trust the other actors there,' Kallas
told journalists at a meeting
of EU foreign ministers in Warsaw.
Kallas apparently contradicted
her own statement issued on Wednesday
, which raised concerns about the Israeli proposal, saying it 'runs counter to humanitarian principles, as underlined by UN agencies and humanitarian partners'.
The Journal
understands that Kallas made the offer without consulting her colleagues and that her remarks do not reflect the EU's official position.
Irish MEPs spoke to
The Journal
and expressed concern about Kallas' offer of EU assistance.
'Rather than offering to assist in their plan to ethnically cleanse Gaza, the EU should be imposing the most severe sanctions on Israel, and leading calls for a permanent ceasefire,' said Sinn Féin MEP Lynn Boylan.
Fianna Fáil MEP Barry Andrews said: 'Israel's current proposal to bypass and undermine established humanitarian actors and take direct control of aid distribution is deeply alarming.'
Both MEPs said assisting Israel in taking over aid distribution would go against core humanitarian principles and undermine the work of the United Nations.
Kallas made her comments on the same day that UN agencies condemned Israel's plan to take over aid distribution.
Displaced Palestinians by makeshift tents outside an UNRWA-run clinic west of Gaza City
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
A spokesperson for the UN's aid coordination office, OCHA, said it 'appears to be a deliberate attempt to weaponise the aid and we have warned against that for a very long time'.
Amnesty International told
The Journal
'the EU must unequivocally reject' the plan and ensure the bloc 'is not complicit in Israel's genocide, whether directly or indirectly'.
There are 15 UN agencies operating in Gaza – including the likes of UNRWA, UNICEF and the World Food Programme – alongside roughly 200 NGOs.
Palestinians struggle to get donated food at a community kitchen in Khan Younis, Gaza Strip
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
Advertisement
'Beyond belief'
According to Lynn Boylan, Kallas' offer of EU participation in the Israeli plan undermines the United Nations agencies working in Gaza.
'Kaja Kallas' comments around finding an 'alternative' to UNRWA are utterly shameful and a complete betrayal of international law,' Boylan told
The Journal
.
'Instead of undermining the work of UNRWA, Ms Kallas should focus on who is responsible for blocking humanitarian aid from entering Gaza at every opportunity,' Boylan said.
It is truly beyond belief to make this offer mere days after Israel announced their intention to indefinitely occupy Gaza.
Fianna Fáil MEP Barry Andrews told
The Journal
that the EU has a duty to ensure that aid is delivered 'according to the core humanitarian principles of neutrality, impartiality, independence, and humanity'.
Aligning with Israel's proposed model would not only go against what we stand for, it would also set a dangerous global precedent.
'It is of the utmost importance that aid remains separate from politicisation, militarisation and weaponisation.'
MEPs Lynn Boylan and Barry Andrews
Alamy
Alamy
He also said that normalising 'the politicisation and instrumentalisation' of humanitarian aid would blur the lines between civilian and military roles.
'Fragmenting the humanitarian response system not only risks the lives of those on the ground, but also severely damages the legitimacy and effectiveness of aid delivery.'
Boylan said that Israel has 'forced supplies to rot at the border, attacked aid vessels in international waters and tried to cover up their murder of aid workers'.
'Offering to assist Israel in taking over 'the distribution of aid' in the Gaza Strip is handing them total power to weaponise starvation and deprivation.'
Ireland and a number of other EU member states have consistently voiced support for UN agencies working in Gaza, particularly UNRWA, while the Israeli government has levelled attacks at the UN throughout the conflict.
The Israeli parliament voted to ban UNRWA from operating in Israel in January of this year after accusing the organisation of being staffed by members of Hamas.
Israel's Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu told the General Assembly last year that the UN was an 'antisemitic swamp' while Israeli officials have also taken aim at the UN's International Court of Justice, where the country stands accused of committing genocide against the people of Gaza.
Netanyahu himself is wanted by the International Criminal Court for alleged war crimes, including the use of starvation as a weapon of war.
Earlier this week, a group of more than 20 UN experts said countries were at a moral crossroads over their response to Israel's escalation of hostilities and ongoing siege of Gaza.
States face a choice between acting to halt the violence and looking on at 'the annihilation of the Palestinian population' in the territory, the experts said.
'The decision is stark: remain passive and witness the slaughter of innocents or take part in crafting a just resolution,' they said in a statement, urging the world to avert the 'moral abyss we are descending into'.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
‘Very volatile conflict', says Harris as evacuation of 15 Irish citizens from Israel underway amid US strikes on Iran
EFFORTS are under way to evacuate 15 Irish citizens from Israel, Tanaiste Simon Harris has said. The Foreign Affairs Minister confirmed that an operation was ongoing to evacuate 15 Advertisement 2 US strikes on Iran had made a 'volatile situation even more dangerous' Credit: AFP or licensors 2 Simon Harris confirmed that the evacuation of Irish citizens from Israel is currently underway Credit: � 2025 PA Media, All Rights Reserved He said they were working with a smaller number of citizens in Around 29 Irish citizens in Iran had registered with the Irish embassy and around 200 in Mr Harris said he spoke to Iran's deputy foreign minister on Sunday, at their request, who was 'full of anger'. Talking to the reporters at Government Buildings, he said: 'He did say to me that it was the view of Iran that the aggressors would have to learn lessons and pay a price. Advertisement READ MORE ON ISRAEL-IRAN 'Of course I articulated in the strongest possible terms that Ireland and the Mr Harris said the Taoiseach They said they are in close contact with their European counterparts before a meeting of EU foreign leaders on Monday and of EU leaders later in the week. Advertisement Most read in Irish News Exclusive The 'Iran should commit not to develop nuclear weapons and disavow its nuclear and uranium enrichment programme. The Sun reports from inside as Israel as tensions flare following US air strikes ' BREACH OF INTERNATIONAL LAWS Martin added that the escalation on Sunday should not draw attention away from the Advertisement He said: 'We shouldn't lose sight of the catastrophe that is still unfolding in Gaza while the war between Iran and Israel continues. 'What is happening in Staff from Ireland's embassy in Harris said there were no plans to withdraw Irish troops and that 'decisions are being made constantly' to ensure their safety. Advertisement 'VOLATILE CONFLICT' When asked whether he supported US President 'We're now entering a moment of particular danger, because I think the chances now of a spiral of escalation are more likely than ever before, and there is a real prospect now of the international community losing all control of this very, very volatile conflict.' He said there was only a 'very small' number of Irish citizens, many dual nationals, seeking an evacuation, and they were working with European counterparts. He said a significant update on this would be available in the hours ahead. Advertisement 'EXTRAORDINARILY DANGEROUS TIME' Speaking on 'But imagine if we were waking up this morning to a situation where radiation levels were extraordinarily high, and the health and human danger that that would have presented far beyond Iran as well. So this is an extraordinarily dangerous time.' He said that it was 'sadly true' that international legal norms are not being adhered to, citing the He said there was a diplomatic process in train and his understanding from readouts was 'there was a commitment from the Iranian side to further talks'. Advertisement POSSESSION OF NUCLEAR WEAPONS Harris said 'The way to address this was always through a negotiated solution. Any alternative to that is simply too dangerous for civilians, for the 'Together with my EU counterparts, we will in the coming hours and days discuss and review the latest developments and consider the next steps Europe can usefully play to support de-escalation.' Minister for Culture Patrick O'Donovan said people woke up on Sunday 'terrified, really, to be quite honest, about the prospect of what's unfolding'. Advertisement 'TERRIFYING' He told RTE's The Week In Politics it is 'terrifying' for citizens in Iran and Israel. He said: 'It does take great people to make leaps of faith in particular places in time to come forward, whether it was in relation to (Anwar el-Sadat) in Egypt, and later on in relation to 'Because, ultimately, as the Taoiseach said, this is terrifying – not only for the innocent communities that are living in both countries, but as well as that for the neighbouring countries in the Middle East, who we obviously all hope are not drawn into a much bigger conflict.'
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
RTÉ coverage of Pope Francis's funeral and election of Pope Leo cost €150k
RTÉ's coverage of the death of Pope Francis and the subsequent election of Pope Leo cost the broadcaster €150,000. Figures released under Freedom of Information show that the broadcaster's extensive coverage of the death of the pontiff included €4,200 in venue hire and over €1,200 in subsistence costs for management grade staff from Radio 1, with the overall costs of travel, hotels, and subsistence coming in at around €150,000 in total. RTÉ provided hours of coverage across its platforms upon the death of Pope Francis in April, including his funeral and the election of American cardinal Robert Francis Prevost as the 267th leader of the Catholic Church and the successor to Francis as Pope Leo. The station's output included a special broadcast of its flagship Prime Time programme with records showing that staff airfares and hotels for that show cost around €3,600. While the cost of flights was one of the larger outlays, some airfares came in at as little as €13. The world's media and thousands of pilgrims descended on the Vatican City upon the death of Pope Francis, with mourners standing in line for hours to pay their final respects while his body lay in state in St Peter's Basilica ahead of his funeral. That was followed by coverage ahead of the papal conclave which lasted just over a day and a half and resulted in the election of the first American pope. In response to the FOI request, RTÉ said: "In relation to hotels, it is not possible to extract a precise spend on this alone so we have included 'staff subsistence' which would cover this and other costs. "Similar to civil and public servants, RTÉ personnel were paid to a set 'day rate' which would cover the cost of accommodation as well as food etc. "[T]he costs incurred were necessary to allow RTÉ fulfil its obligations to provide comprehensive coverage of two major global events across radio, television and online in both Irish and English. "Those who travelled provided many hours of coverage for all radio and television news and current affairs programming as well as online content spanning the days between the death of Pope Francis to the election of Pope Leo." Read More Pope Leo XIV calls for aid to reach Gaza in first general audience
The Journal
2 hours ago
- The Journal
Remains of three Israeli hostages recovered from Gaza
THE ISRAELI MILITARY has said it has recovered the remains of three hostages held in the Gaza Strip. The military identified the remains as those of Yonatan Samerano, 21; Ofra Keidar, 70; and Shay Levinson, 19. All three were killed during Hamas's October 7, 2023, attack into Israel. The militant group is still holding 50 hostages, with less than half of them believed to be alive. The military did not provide any details about the recovery operation, and it is unclear if an air strike which killed four Palestinians was related to it. 'The campaign to return the hostages continues consistently and is happening alongside the campaign against Iran,' Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said in a statement. Kobi Samerano said in a Facebook post that his son's remains were returned on what would have been Yonatan's 23rd birthday. Hamas-led militants killed some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducted 251 people in the October 7 attack. More than half the hostages have been returned in ceasefire agreements or other deals, eight have been rescued alive and Israeli forces have recovered dozens of bodies. Advertisement Israel's retaliatory offensive has killed more than 55,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza's Health Ministry, which has said women and children make up more than half of the dead. It does not distinguish between civilians and combatants. Four people were killed on Sunday in an air strike in the built-up Nuseirat refugee camp in central Gaza, according to Al-Awda Hospital, where the bodies were brought. It said another 22 people were injured while waiting for aid trucks. Palestinian witnesses and health officials say Israeli forces have repeatedly opened fire on crowds seeking desperately needed food, killing hundreds of people in recent weeks. The military says it has fired warning shots at people it said approached its forces in a suspicious manner. The Hostages Families Forum, the main organisation representing families of the hostages, has repeatedly called for a deal to release the remaining captives. 'Particularly against the backdrop of current military developments and the significant achievements in Iran, we want to emphasise that bringing back the remaining 50 hostages is the key to achieving any sort of victory,' it said in a statement on Sunday. Hamas has said it will only release the remaining hostages in return for more Palestinian prisoners, a lasting ceasefire and an Israeli withdrawal from Gaza. Netanyahu has rejected those terms, saying Israel will continue the war until all the hostages are returned and Hamas is defeated or disarmed and sent into exile. Even then, he has said Israel will maintain lasting control over Gaza and facilitate what he refers to as the voluntary emigration of much of its population, plans the Palestinians and others view as forcible expulsion. Separately, World Central Kitchen, the charity run by celebrity chef Jose Andres, said it had resumed the distribution of hot meals in Gaza for the first time in six weeks after shutting down because of Israel's blockade, which was loosened last month amid fears of famine.
