Don't mix business with tourist visas, affirms tax tribunal ruling

Live Events
Mumbai: The perils of travelling on a tourist visa for business purposes may not be confined to run-ins with foreign authorities. Sometimes it could even spell trouble with the local taxman.Indian businessmen who spend months abroad to look after overseas interests and carefully preserve their NRI status , may even find themselves in a spot if the tax authorities question their 'residency' status due to the type of visas approved by countries they travelled to.Recently, a tribunal has upheld the Income Tax (I-T) department's decision to tax the 'global income' of the bakery chain Hot Breads founder M.Mahadevan who, according to the tax office was a 'resident' for certain years, and not an NRI as claimed by the Chennai-based entrepreneur.The relaxation on the period of stay given to someone who was abroad for employment or business was denied to Mahadevan as he had travelled on tourist visas. His argument that the visits were purely in connection with his businesses in multiple countries was rejected by the Chennai bench of the I-T Appellate Authority, a quasi-judicial authority.(Join our ETNRI WhatsApp channel for all the latest updates)When contacted, a family member speaking on behalf of Mahadevan, said, "We are currently reviewing the order of the Hon'ble ITAT in detail. While we are disappointed with the outcome, we believe we have a strong case on merits and are considering all available legal options. We remain committed to full compliance with all applicable laws and regulations and will continue to cooperate with the authorities as required."The residency status of an individual is determined by the rules on the number of days spent. If someone stays for 182 days or more in India, he is considered as a resident whose global income (along with local earnings) for that year may be taxed in India. Alternatively, if a person spends at least 60 days in a year and a total of 365 days in the previous four years, he too is treated as a tax resident.However, the second rule extends a partial exemption to those travelling overseas for jobs or self-employment. For them, the minimum period of stay is 182 days instead of 60. This relief was not given to Mahadevan.The number of days are typically counted on the basis of the timing-stamp on passports. The tax office, however, obtained the information from the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO)-a practice that was upheld by the Tribunal. Based on the FRRO data, the I-T department claimed that Mahadevan had spent 182 days or more in the assessment years 2013-14, 2014-15, and 2019-20.Even if the duration of stay were less than 182 days, Mahadevan's overseas travels would not have been considered to treat him as a resident-thanks to his tourist visas and despite his argument that a person would not travel a country frequently for tourism. The tribunal held that every country restricts visas for specific purposes."The decision underscores the importance of holding the correct visa category, as an inappropriate visa can jeopardize an individual's residential status and complicate the taxation of the global income in India. Nevertheless, if it can be factually established that the individual left India for the purpose of conducting business and genuine business activities were indeed undertaken abroad (though under an inappropriate visa), then the benefit of extending the 60-day period to 182 days under Explanation 1(a) to Section 6(1) of the I-T Act should be granted. However, it is important to note that such a benefit is available only when the individual 'leaves' India for the purpose of employment or business and not 'visiting' abroad in connection with business," said Ashish Karundia, founder of the CA firm Ashish Karundia.According to Rajesh Shah, partner of Jayantilal Thakkar & Co, "A resident Indian becomes non-resident only if they go abroad for employment, including self-employment. Simply staying outside India for 182 days does not make anyone a non-resident. The type of visa is equally important. But this is ignored-either due to ignorance or for convenience." The ruing implied that an assessee cannot avoid tax on global earnings merely because he runs businesses abroad.Countering ITAT's decision to disregard the tax residency certificate issued by the UAE to Mahadevan, Harshal Bhuta, partner at the CA firm PR Bhuta & Co, said "An individual staying in the UAE for over 183 days in a calendar year qualifies as a resident of UAE under the India-UAE DTAA (tax treaty), irrespective of the purpose of stay. In cases of dual residency, the treaty's tie-breaker rules must apply and the treaty-based residency cannot be summarily disregarded."

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Business Standard

33 minutes ago

• Business Standard

Apple eyes Perplexity acquisition? What's at stake for Google, Samsung

Apple is reportedly exploring a potential acquisition of Perplexity AI, the US-based AI start-up. According to a recent Bloomberg report, Apple executives, including mergers and acquisitions head Adrian Perica, services chief Eddy Cue, and key decision-makers in AI, have held internal discussions about making a bid for the company. While there has been no confirmation from Apple, Perplexity told Bloomberg, 'We have no knowledge of any current or future M&A discussions involving Perplexity.' If Apple proceeds, the deal could give it a much-needed boost in AI talent, an established brand in the generative AI space, and a consumer-facing product. However, ongoing deals between Perplexity and other tech companies, notably Samsung and Motorola, could complicate the process. Bloomberg also reported that Meta attempted to buy Perplexity earlier this year. Here's a breakdown of what an Apple-Perplexity deal could mean for the companies involved: What Apple stands to gain from the Perplexity AI acquisition? A Perplexity acquisition would support Apple's efforts to develop its own AI-based search engine, a strategic move amid growing uncertainty around its lucrative deal with Google. Bloomberg reported that Apple currently earns an estimated $20 billion a year by making Google the default search engine in Safari, but that agreement is under scrutiny from US antitrust regulators. The potential acquisition also reflects Apple's wider push to catch up in the generative AI race. Despite unveiling its Apple Intelligence platform at WWDC 2024, the company remains behind competitors in core features. Siri's planned upgrade was even delayed earlier this year, with a revised rollout now targeted for next spring. By bringing Perplexity in-house, Apple would not only gain a robust AI product but also absorb a skilled team already working at the forefront of AI-powered search. The acquisition could further accelerate the development of next-gen Apple Intelligence capabilities. Samsung and Motorola partnerships at risk? Bloomberg previously reported that Samsung Electronics is close to finalising a major partnership with Perplexity. This would include preloading Perplexity's assistant and app onto Samsung devices and integrating its search technology into Samsung's native web browser. Talks have also involved incorporating Perplexity into Samsung's own voice assistant, Bixby. Samsung is reportedly aiming to announce these integrations as early as this year, potentially making Perplexity a default assistant option on its upcoming Galaxy S26 series. The South Korean giant is also expected to be a major participant in Perplexity's next funding round. Motorola already has an active partnership with Perplexity. On select Motorola smartphones, including the Edge 60 Pro, users can choose between Perplexity AI, Google Gemini, and Microsoft Copilot as their default assistant. While there is no indication yet that these partnerships are under threat, they could present a hurdle if Apple moves ahead with an acquisition. Bloomberg also noted that Apple is weighing an alternative: partnering with Perplexity rather than acquiring it outright. Such a deal would involve integrating Perplexity's AI search into Safari and possibly into Siri as an additional intelligence layer. What Apple Perplexity AI Deal could mean for Google An Apple-Perplexity alliance, whether through acquisition or partnership, would be a clear challenge to Google's dominance on iOS devices. For now, Google Search remains the default on Safari, but a Perplexity-powered alternative could alter the balance of power, particularly if antitrust regulators force changes to the current arrangement. Separately, Perplexity's growing relationship with Samsung is another potential concern for Google. Although Google's Gemini AI is already integrated into Samsung's Galaxy devices, including being set as the default assistant, Samsung's collaboration with Perplexity suggests a shift toward diversifying its AI offerings. If Samsung deepens its partnership with Perplexity, it could mark a strategic move away from sole reliance on Google and toward supporting a broader AI ecosystem.

Mint

37 minutes ago

• Mint

How to track your days in India—and why it matters more than ever for your tax status

Renowned entrepreneur M. Mahadevan, popularly known as 'Hot Breads Mahadevan' for his international bakery and restaurant chain, has run into tax trouble back home. A recent Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) ruling declared Mahadevan a tax resident of India for financial years 2012-13, 2013-14, and 2018-19, thereby making his global income taxable in India—despite his claim of being a non-resident. Mahadevan, who operates restaurants and bakeries both in India and abroad, declared himself a non-resident in his income tax filings for the aforementioned years. He based this status on his interpretation of passport stamps, asserting that he had stayed less than 182 days in India in each relevant year. As a non-resident, he only paid tax on Indian-sourced income, leaving his overseas earnings out of the tax net. Also read: NRI taxation: How to claim special tax concessions However, a detailed review by the tax department—using passport records, visa copies, and data from the Foreigner Regional Registration Office (FRRO)—suggested otherwise. The officer concluded that Mahadevan exceeded the 182-day threshold in FY13 and FY14, and also met the 60-day-plus-365-days condition for FY19, thereby qualifying him as a tax resident under India's Income-tax Act, 1961 (ITA). Importantly, Mahadevan's travel was under 'social' or 'visitor' visa categories, not business or employment—further undermining his claim of leaving India for professional reasons. Mahadevan challenged the tax officer's ruling at the first appellate level, where he found relief. The appellate authority ruled in his favour, interpreting his overseas trips as business-related despite the visa types. It accepted his stay in India to be under the threshold and upheld his non-resident status, exempting his foreign income from taxation. On further appeal, the ITAT clubbed the cases and overturned the appellate ruling. It agreed with the tax department, affirming that Mahadevan was a resident for those years and his foreign income was liable to Indian tax. Still, the Tribunal offered some relief: if Mahadevan could furnish proof of foreign taxes paid, foreign tax credit would be allowed. Why the tribunal ruled against Mahadevan FRRO data as credible proof: The Tribunal trusted FRRO records as reliable government data for determining days of stay. Visa purpose matters: Frequent travel abroad did not equate to business if the visa stated otherwise. Since Mahadevan's visas were for social visits, he could not claim the 182-day exception allowed for business departures. UAE Tax Residency Certificate (TRC): Mahadevan produced a UAE TRC issued in 2021 for earlier years. The Tribunal held that under the India-UAE tax treaty, treaty benefits cannot apply if a person qualifies as a tax resident of India under domestic law. Also read: Decoding dual taxation: What NRIs need to know for better tax efficiency Key lessons for global Indians Residential status is pivotal in determining tax liability and must be backed by appropriate records. Count days with care An individual's residential status determines their tax liability in India and is primarily based on days spent in the country. While passport stamps are usually relied on, it's advisable to cross-check stay records with FRRO data to avoid mismatches that may affect tax residency. Involuntary stays (e.g., passport seizures) are excluded. For land entries from Nepal or Bhutan, where passports/visas aren't required, documents like hotel receipts can help establish duration of stay. Who is a resident? A person is considered a resident in India if they: The 60-day threshold is relaxed to 120 or 182 days for: Visa type matters Residency status can also depend on the visa category used for travel. A person leaving India for work should not use tourist or social visas, as these may not support claims of business-related travel abroad under tax laws. Dual residency & tie-breaker If you're classified as a resident in both India and another country, tax treaties apply a tie-breaker test. This considers: This helps decide which country can tax your global income. Also read: Golden tax window for NRIs: What RNOR means and how to use itAshish Karundia, founder, Ashish Karundia & Co., Chartered Accountants

Time of India

40 minutes ago

• Time of India

Adani commissions India's first off-grid 5 MW green hydrogen plant in Gujarat

The Adani Group has announced the successful commissioning of India's first off-grid 5 megawatt green hydrogen pilot plant in Kutch, Gujarat. Developed by Adani New Industries Limited (ANIL), the clean energy arm of Adani Enterprises Ltd. , the plant represents a significant advancement in the country's pursuit of clean and self-reliant energy solutions. An off-grid green hydrogen plant generates hydrogen through electrolysis powered solely by renewable energy—such as solar or wind—without any connection to the conventional power grid. This means the plant operates independently, relying fully on its own renewable energy infrastructure. Describing the development as a key milestone supporting India's National Green Hydrogen Mission, the Adani Group said the project establishes technical feasibility and sets new standards for off-grid, renewable-powered applications of green hydrogen in high-emission sectors. "The state-of-the-art plant is 100 per cent green-powered by solar energy and integrated with a Battery Energy Storage System (BESS), enabling it to operate completely off-grid. This represents a new paradigm in decentralised, renewable-powered hydrogen production," the company said in a statement. Hydrogen, the most abundant element in the universe, is also one of the cleanest fuels—emitting only water vapour when used. Its environmental impact varies based on production methods. Hydrogen made from fossil fuels is classified as grey, while green hydrogen is produced using electricity from renewable sources to split water molecules into hydrogen and oxygen. Live Events ANIL is building an end-to-end ecosystem for large-scale green hydrogen production and its derivatives. This includes green ammonia, green methanol, sustainable aviation fuel, as well as the manufacturing of solar cells, ingots and wafers, solar modules, wind turbine generators, and electrolysers at its facility in Mundra, Gujarat, aimed at meeting both domestic and global demand. The Kutch-based pilot facility is also India's first of its kind to feature a fully automated, closed-loop electrolyser system that adjusts dynamically to real-time renewable energy inputs. This allows for enhanced operational flexibility to address the inherent variability in solar power generation while ensuring safety, efficiency, and high performance. "This breakthrough reinforces the Adani Group's commitment to innovation, sustainability, and leadership in the emerging green hydrogen economy . It supports India's ambition to become a global hub for green hydrogen production and sets a benchmark for renewable-powered industrial applications across hard-to-abate sectors," the statement added. The pilot plant also acts as a proof of concept for ANIL's upcoming Green Hydrogen Hub in Mundra—an ambitious project expected to significantly contribute to India's low-carbon transition. Green hydrogen is seen as a critical tool for decarbonising challenging sectors such as fertilisers, oil refining, and heavy transport, and plays a central role in achieving global net-zero targets.