How Switzerland's Birch glacier collapsed

A cascade of events in the Swiss Alps led to the dramatic collapse of the Birch glacier, wiping out Blatten village in the valley below, glaciologists and geoscientists said on Friday.
Experts knew days ahead of Wednesday's landslide that the glacier was likely to suffer a catastrophic failure. But the reasons why date back much further.
There are strong theories on the causes, and to what degree the disaster is linked to climate change — but these are yet to be confirmed by scientific analysis.
"This can be considered as a cascading event, because we have different processes involved," explained Christophe Lambiel, senior lecturer at the University of Lausanne's Institute of Earth Surface Dynamics.
Mountain above the glacier
The 3,342-meter Kleines Nesthorn mountain above the glacier was already somewhat unstable, and rockfalls accelerated dramatically around 10 days beforehand.
Experts feared a total collapse within hours, but instead there were successive rockfalls over several days, which was actually the best-case scenario.
Rockfall onto glacier
Some 3 million cubic meters of rock were deposited on the glacier.
"If you put a lot of weight on an unstable foundation, it can just slip away. And this is what actually happened," Matthias Huss, the director of Glacier Monitoring Switzerland (GLAMOS), said.
"The glacier accelerated strongly in response to this additional loading, and then the disaster struck."
The Birch glacier
The Birch glacier was a special case: the only Swiss glacier that was advancing rather than shrinking. However, this was not because of extra snowfall.
Its advance "was quite likely due to the pre-loading with rockfalls from this mountain, which has finally collapsed. So the landslide didn't start from nothing," said Huss.
A helicopter removes pieces of wood obstructing the river Lonza after the Birch glacier collapsed and a massive landslide destroyed the village of Blatten, on Saturday. |
AFP-JIJI
The glacier was on a steep slope, and even steeper at the front, worsening the dynamics.
Smaller-scale falls from the front of the glacier Tuesday were expected to continue, with Wednesday's sudden total collapse considered a less-probable scenario.
How the glacier collapsed
The rockfalls altered the stress equation between the weight of the glacier and the slope, which governs its forward speed, Lambiel said.
Like pushing a car, it takes a lot of force to initiate movement, but less once it is on the move, he explained.
Huss said the 1,000 meters of elevation between the glacier and the Lotschental valley floor added a "huge amount of potential energy," which through friction melts part of the ice, making the fall "much more dynamic than if it was just rock."
Role of melting permafrost
Permafrost conditions are degrading throughout the Alps. Ice inside the cracks in the rocks has been thawing to ever-deeper levels over the last decade, especially after the summer 2022 heat wave.
"Ice is considered as the cement of the mountains. Decreasing the quality of the cement decreases the stability of the mountain," said Lambiel.
Huss added, "At the moment, we can't say it's because of permafrost thaw that this mountain collapsed — but it is at least a very probable explanation, or one factor, that has triggered or accelerated this process of the mountain falling apart."
Role of climate change
Jakob Steiner, a geoscientist at the Lotschental valley floor, said, "There is no clear evidence as of yet, for this specific case, that this was caused by climate change."
Huss said making such a direct link was "complicated."
"If it was just because of climate change that this mountain collapsed, all mountains in the Alps could collapse — and they don't," he said.
"It's a combination of the long-term changes in the geology of the mountain.
"The failing of the glacier as such — this is not related to climate change. It's more the permafrost processes, which are very complex, long-term changes."
Lambiel said of a link between climate change and the glacier moving forward over time, "Honestly, we don't know.
"But the increasing rockfalls on the glacier during the last 10 years — this can be linked with climate change."
Other glaciers
Modern monitoring techniques detect acceleration in the ice with high precision — and therefore allow for early warning.
Lambiel said around 80 glaciers in the same region of Switzerland were considered dangerous, and under monitoring.
"The big challenge is to recognise where to direct the detailed monitoring," said Huss.
Lambiel said sites with glacier-permafrost interactions above 3,000 meters would now need more research. But they are difficult to reach and monitor.
Steiner said, "Probably the rapidly changing permafrost can play some kind of role.
"This is concerning because this means that mountains are becoming a lot more unstable."

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Japan Times

4 days ago

• Japan Times

Marine heat waves are spreading around the world

In recent decades, the oceans have warmed. Marine heat waves, once rare events, have become more common. One particularly intense event known as "the Blob' lasted years and devastated plankton populations, starving millions of fish and seabirds and damaging commercial fishing. Recently, high temperatures have persisted. In January 2024, the share of the ocean surface experiencing a heat wave topped 40%. Unusual heat waves have occurred in all of the major ocean basins around the planet in recent years. And some of these events have become so intense that scientists have coined a new term: super marine heat waves. "The marine ecosystems where the super marine heat waves occur have never experienced such a high sea surface temperature in the past,' Boyin Huang, an oceanographer at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, said in an email. The seas off the coasts of the United Kingdom and Ireland experienced an unusually intense marine heat wave, one of the longest on record, starting in April, and the temperature rise happened much earlier in the year than usual. Australia and its iconic coral reefs were recently struck by heat waves on two coasts. Scientists define marine heat waves in different ways. But it's clear that as the planet's climate changes, the oceans are being fundamentally altered as they absorb excess heat trapped in the atmosphere from greenhouse gases, which are emitted when fossil fuels are burned. Hotter oceans are causing drastic changes to marine life, sea levels and weather patterns. Some of the most visible casualties of ocean warming have been coral reefs. When ocean temperatures rise too much, corals can bleach and die. About 84% of reefs worldwide experienced bleaching-level heat stress at some point between January 2023 and March 2025, according to a recent report. Last year, the warmest on record, sea levels rose faster than scientists expected. Research showed that most of that rise in sea levels came from ocean water expanding as it warms, which is known as thermal expansion, not from melting glaciers and ice sheets, which in past years were the biggest contributors to rising seas. In a photo from the National Park Service, a humpback whale named Festus that was found dead just outside the mouth of Glacier Bay, Alaska, June 2016. A report on this whale revealed numerous health conditions, including poor nutrition and elevated levels of harmful algal toxins. | Craig Murdoch / National Park Service, NOAA permit #18786 / via The New York Times Excess heat in the oceans can also affect weather patterns, making hurricanes more likely to rapidly intensify and become more destructive. In the southwest Pacific, last year's ocean heat contributed to a record-breaking streak of tropical cyclones hitting the Philippines. "If we understand how global warming is affecting extreme events, that is essential information to try to anticipate what's going on, what's next,' said Marta Marcos, a physicist at the University of the Balearic Islands in Spain. Marcos was the lead author of a recent study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences that found that climate change has been responsible for the overwhelming majority of marine heat waves in recent decades. The losses Some of the earliest research on mass die-offs associated with marine heat waves, before there was a name for them, came from the Mediterranean, which has been warming three to five times faster than the ocean at large. Joaquim Garrabou, a marine conservation ecologist at the Institut de Ciencies del Mar in Barcelona, Spain, started studying these events after witnessing a die-off of sponges and coral in 1999. He and other scientists believed that with climate change, these die-offs would reoccur. "The reality is moving even faster than what we thought,' he said. "Having these mass mortality events is the new normal, instead of something infrequent, which it should be.' In 2012, a marine heat wave in the Gulf of Maine highlighted the risk these events pose to fisheries. The Northern shrimp population went from an estimated 27.25 billion in 2010 to 2.8 billion two years later, according to modeling by the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission. "This disappearance of the shrimp was just shocking,' said Anne Richards, a retired research fisheries biologist who worked at NOAA's Northeast Fisheries Science Center at the time. In a photo from Jemina Stuart-Smith, University of Tasmania, a red handfish is collected in the waters off the coast of Tasmania. In a heatwave that began in 2023, researchers in Tasmania transferred 25 red handfish to an aquarium until the temperatures fell. | Jemina Stuart-Smith, University of Tasmania / via The New York Times Her research pointed to a significant culprit: Longfin squid drawn north by warmer water were eating the shrimp. The fishery has not yet reopened. By 2023, the Northern shrimp population was estimated to have dropped to around 200 million. Commercial fishing has always been difficult, but now, "climate change is taking that to another level,' said Kathy Mills, a senior scientist at the Gulf of Maine Research Institute. Complicating matters is the fact that much of the research on marine heat waves comes from just a few countries, including Australia, the United States, China, Canada, Spain and the United Kingdom. "There are lots of regions around the world where monitoring isn't as good as other places, and so we don't really know what's happening,' said Dan Smale, a community ecologist at the United Kingdom's Marine Biological Association. Rising ocean temperatures can also set off a domino effect through the marine food web, starting at the bottom with plankton. In a photo from the Coastal Observation and Seabird Survey Team, emaciated Cassin's auklets found during a single survey on an Oregon beach, on Jan. 8, 2015. During the ocean heat event in the North Pacific known as 'the Blob,' hundreds of thousands of birds died of starvation. | Coastal Observation and Seabird Survey Team / via The New York Times Since the end of most commercial whaling in the 1970s and '80s, humpback whales in the North Pacific had been recovering, reaching a peak population of about 33,000 in 2012. But then came the heat event known as "the Blob' that blanketed much of region from 2014 to 2017. The heat wave diminished wind and waves, limiting the nutrients that typically get churned up to the sea surface. Fewer nutrients meant fewer phytoplankton, fewer zooplankton, fewer fish and fewer of everything else that eats them. How 'the blob' took a toll After the Blob dissipated, researchers learned that the effects of a severe marine heat wave could endure long after the event itself has passed. Ted Cheeseman, a doctoral candidate at Southern Cross University, had co-founded Happywhale, a database of tens of thousands of marine mammals built on photos submitted by researchers and whale watchers around the world. Cheeseman found a sharp drop in humpback whale sightings by 2021. The decrease was so significant, at first he thought the Happywhale team was doing the math wrong. The team members spent several years checking and last year published a study that concluded the humpback whale population in the North Pacific had fallen by 20% from 2012 to 2021. They attributed the decline to the loss of food like krill during and after the Blob. With "an estimate of 7,000 whales having disappeared and not showing up anywhere else,' Cheeseman said, "there's really no other explanation.' Looking ahead Eventually, parts of the ocean might enter a constant state of marine heat wave, at least by today's common definition. Some scientists see today's shorter-term spikes as practice for this future. Alistair Hobday, a biological oceanographer at Australia's Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, has been conducting public briefings with marine heat wave forecasts months ahead of time. People are tuning in — and responding. In a photo from Jemina Stuart-Smith, University of Tasmania, a red handfish in the waters off the coast of Tasmania. | Jemina Stuart-Smith, University of Tasmania / via The New York Times The critically endangered red handfish lives off the coast of Tasmania, crawling along the seafloor on fins shaped like hands. These unusual fish have only been found within two small patches of rocky reef and sea grass meadow. In late 2023, Hobday's forecast predicted potentially deadly marine heat waves. Researchers from the University of Tasmania's Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies, with support from the Australian Department of Climate Change, took a drastic step. They transferred 25 red handfish to an aquarium until the temperatures fell. Jemina Stuart-Smith, an ecologist at the University of Tasmania, described those weeks as the most stressful time of her life. "If it all went wrong,' she said, "you're talking about the potential extinction of an entire species.' After three months, 18 fish were returned to the ocean. Three had died, and four were enrolled in a captive breeding program. Scientists recognize that temporary fixes can only do so much in the face of long-term warming. "It's kind of putting a Band-Aid on a broken leg,' said Kathryn Smith, a marine ecologist and postdoctoral researcher at the Marine Biological Association. But those studying today's extreme events still hope their work gives people some visibility into the future of the world's oceans, Hobday said. "Clever people, if you tell them about the future,' he said, "can think of all kinds of things to do differently.' This article originally appeared in The New York Times © 2025 The New York Times Company

Japan Times

13-06-2025

• Japan Times

Natural disasters may be shaping babies' brains

Climate disasters are known for damaging homes, disrupting power and displacing residents. But even after the lights come back on and people return to their homes, their effects can linger — including in the brains of children born afterwards, a new study suggests. Climate stressors, and the effect they have on pregnant people, appear to affect the brain development of their babies, according to the study published in PLOS One on Wednesday, which relied on brain imaging conducted years after 2012's Superstorm Sandy hit the New York City metro area. The study evaluated a sample of 34 children, 11 whose parents were pregnant during Superstorm Sandy. By the time of assessment, the kids were roughly eight years old. Those who had been exposed to Sandy in utero had a significant enlargement in a part of the brain known as the basal ganglia. Parts of the basal ganglia were as much as 6% larger than in unexposed children, a change that could have negative implications for the children's behavior. The parents living through the disruptions from a storm that displaced more than 23,000 people and suspended electric services in the area for days to weeks may have affected their offspring's neurodevelopment, the researchers say. The findings signal how new generations of children may be marked by climate crises that occur before they were born, and speak to a need to better evaluate and educate pregnant people about climate risks, the researchers say. They contribute to a growing consensus about pregnant people's vulnerability to climate change, with extreme heat, air pollution and natural disasters posing risks like preterm births. "This is something which people who are going to get pregnant should know and be prepared,' says Yoko Nomura, an author of the PLOS One research and a professor at Queens College at the City University of New York. "Society as a whole has to have a strategy to protect those pregnant people.' Non-climate-related stress can affect pregnancies and influence fetal brain development. But studies typically haven't examined how natural disasters may work in the same way. Project Ice Storm, a project examining the aftermath of a devastating 1998 storm in Canada, found that stress had an effect on everything from kids' temperament to their IQ. Superstorm Sandy, which hit New York and New Jersey in October 2012, devastated coastal areas, leading to around 120 deaths and billions in damages. Queens College, in Flushing, New York, served as a shelter. Nomura, who was already on the faculty there at the time, observed how distressed storm evacuees in the on-campus gym were. Many of them were pregnant, and facing stressors like losing power and being displaced from their homes. That inspired Nomura to look into how the experience might affect their unborn babies. While the team hasn't yet determined how the changes they observed in the basal ganglia may affect participating children in the day-to-day, that part of the brain is involved in functions including emotional regulation. Other studies have linked the basal ganglia to conditions like depression and autism. Demonstrators, including mothers and babies, take part in a protest in London in October 2019. | Reuters "We do think that those changes we're seeing could lead to negative outcomes for the children's behavior,' says Donato DeIngeniis, the study's lead author and a doctoral student in clinical neuropsychology at the CUNY Graduate Center. For a subset of seven children whose parents had been exposed to Sandy and separately, over the course of their parent's pregnancy, extreme heat, the brain differences were more pronounced. Researchers observed that one portion of the basal ganglia was enlarged while another was reduced. "That might mean one area is impaired, which might lead the other to have to work harder to compensate,' DeIngeniis says, which is common in the brain in instances of brain damage or injury. The cohort of children examined in the study is small, reflecting the cost of brain imaging and the fact that the study's recruitment was interrupted by the COVID-19 crisis. Even after recruitment resumed in 2021, participants were reluctant to visit for in-person imaging. Burcin Ikiz, chair of the Neuro Climate Working Group, part of Columbia University's Global Consortium on Climate and Health Education, calls the study "small but mighty.' It's increasingly important to understand how different climate stressors may together affect human health, she says. For instance, children in New Delhi are experiencing both air pollution and extreme heat. "And this is one of the first studies — that's why it's a trailblazing study — that looks at these joint things,' she says. But she added that additional work still needs to be done to address limitations of the study such as the small sample size, and to examine the effect of heat with more depth. While the researchers used statistical methods to ensure the accuracy of their findings, it's still possible that other factors could explain the differences seen in the kids' brains, like genetic variability or socioeconomic status. The research team is now in the process of conducting a similar, larger study, with around 80 participants so far. But rather than wait to release those results, Nomura says the team felt it was important to release earlier findings more quickly to raise awareness among the public.

Japan Times

04-06-2025

• Japan Times

Swiss glacier collapse is a lesson on climate disaster management

A Swiss mountain slope bursting and unleashing a cascade of rocks and ice over an idyllic Alpine village last week was a chilling image, but also the symbol of a well-managed climate crisis. The collapse of the Birch glacier in the Swiss Alps was an expected disaster. Authorities and scientists had been monitoring the area closely and when the first signs of instability started to appear, over a week before the event, they evacuated the town of Blatten, on the valley below the glacier. The landslide obliterated about 90% of the village and one person is missing, according to Swiss authorities. "It was the least worst scenario — any loss of property or homes is a tragedy, but they were prepared for it,' said Rachel Carr, a glaciologist at the University of Newcastle in the U.K. "We can at least manage the threat of the loss of life, we need to at least do that.' Yet not all countries are able to respond as effectively to such disasters. Billions of people globally live downstream from glaciers and at least 15 million are directly exposed to floods from glacial lakes bursting, according to a 2023 research paper co-authored by Carr. Glaciers have melted at the fastest pace on record this decade, leading to an increase of lakes that can burst any time, unleashing hundreds of tons of rocks and ice, together with landslides and floods that destroy everything on their path. "We see the highest risk in the Himalayas and the Andes, where people have a strong dependence on subsistence agriculture,' said Carr, speaking on the phone from Bhutan. A lake outburst or a glacier collapsing can "take out their yaks, their grazing land and their capacity to generate food and money for years to come.' Police control the entry to the village where a crumbling glacier partially collapsed and tumbled in Blatten, Switzerland on Monday. | REUTERS Human settlements in many high mountain areas are days away from the nearest road, so bringing in materials to rebuild can take years, said Carr, whose current research focuses on helping set up sensors to monitor glaciers in Bhutan, one of the world's few carbon negative countries, which also has some of the fastest-retreating glaciers in the world. Glaciers are a thick layer of ice that has eroded the mountain for centuries. They often act like a containment wall, holding rocks and mud together. When the glacier melts, it becomes thinner until eventually it can't hold the mountain anymore and it collapses. At the same time, permafrost, the frozen ground present in high mountain environments, is thawing fast, making terrains more unstable. These events are made worse by climate change, and they played a role in the collapse of the Birch glacier, said Jean-Baptiste Bosson, a glaciologist and the director of nature preservation non-profit Marge Sauvage. Establishing a direct link between the event and climate change is difficult, if not impossible, but it seems likely that it played a role in the event, Swiss researchers said in a note. When Birch collapsed, Bosson was in Dushanbe, Tajikistan, attending the first-ever United Nations-sponsored glacier conference. Suddenly, glaciologists there saw their field of study become front page news and felt like the calls for action they had been repeating for decades would be listened to. Debris and the rest of the village of Blatten, now submerged by the obstructed river Lonza, after the huge Birch Glacier collapsed and a massive landslide in the Swiss Alps on Saturday. | AFP-JIJI The conference ended with a final declaration highlighting the need to protect glaciers as climate change advances, and to monitor them to prepare for hazards. It also called on governments and finance institutions to fund these efforts and contribute to a glacier preservation fund coordinated by the U.N. Tajikistan made an initial contribution of $100,000 and no additional funding has been announced, although several countries have expressed interest, according to a spokesperson from the U.N.'s World Meteorological Organization. "I'm a bit disappointed — there are no heads of state here' beyond Tajikistan's, Bosson said. "Glaciers are melting and we have to do something, but no one put on the table real, effective solutions.' Wealthy countries including France or Switzerland have their own programs and are watching dozens of glaciers with drones, satellites, sensors and measurements on the ground. Even with these advanced methods it's impossible to predict which glacier will collapse next, said Daniel Farinotti, a glaciologist at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich. "I would pay a lot of money in order to be able to answer this question,' Farinotti said. "We don't know why this particular glacier happened to fall down at that particular moment in time.' The vast amounts of data and images from the collapse of the Birch glacier will allow researchers to reconstruct the event, he said. "But we are not able to predict one of these the same way we can predict meteorological conditions three days ahead because the conditions are so complex. We try hard, though.' Authorities can do more than monitoring. In France, the Tete-Rousse glacier is under watch since scientists discovered the equivalent of twenty Olympic swimming pools of water were held underneath the ice. Between 2,000 and 3,000 people in the Haute Savoie region could be affected if that glacier collapses, according to local media. Over the past 15 years, some water has been pumped from underneath the glacier, an alarm system has been set up across the valley and construction in vulnerable areas has been restricted. Swiss authorities were already thinking about next steps just hours after Blatten was engulfed in ice and rock. At a press conference with emergency authorities in the area last Wednesday, the mayor of Blatten, Matthias Bellwald, appeared moved as he addressed journalists and the community. "The village is under rubble, but we will rebuild it,' Bellwald said. "This will take a long, long time, we will require help and support, but the glacier can't collapse twice.'